1/58
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why do we need a standing army?
To provide for the Common Defense, deal with surprise attacks, maintain technical knowledge about arms and munitions, and protect commerce (The Military and the Constitution)
Schake makes the case that Washington deserves special credit for our healthy civil military relations. What is her argument?
Through maintaining a non-partisan military, with military figures not seeking presidential office this precedent was set by George Washington resigning military post before running for office.
Newburgh Conspiracy- military officials tried to convince Washington to take on a king like figure after revolutionary war but Washington refused, setting precedent for civilian control
Why might complex national security policy decisions be a tricky arena in which to maintain civilian control?
Civilians need military advice but are not always qualified to asses whether they are given complete or accurate information, military technical expertise about the use of violence is often much greater than civilians, the military is often caught in the political competition between Congress and the President.
What is civilian control in the American context?
Civilians must have the institutions and authority to issue orders, they must not be subject to undue influence in the formulation of the orders, civilians must be obeyed when they issues orders, and civilians have the right to be wrong when issuing orders.
How is civilian control maintained?
1) Civilians oversee the military and assert their authority. Ex) Civilian Commander in Chief, Civilian Secretary of Defense, and Congressional war in budgets, declaring war, budgets, ect. 2) The military maintains regulations and norms that support civilian control.
According to Schake: How should this work to maintain a strong military and civilian control in a democratic context?
Objective Control: Military identity is as professional soldiers. However the constructed meaning of being a professional solider includes being non-partisan and subject to civilian control. Therefore the more professional the officer corps is the safer the state from military takeover.
But civilian leaders must pay a price: Civilians set the policy goals without interference from the military and then, without civilian interference, the military determines how to achieve these goals.
What are the regulations and norms that maintain civilian control?
Oath of Enlistment/of Office- swearing to support and defend the Constitution.
Military as a non-political institution: Military members not being able to wear uniforms to rally, allowed to sign petitions and have opinions just not on behalf of the military
What dd The National Security Act of 1947 do?
Made the Air Force an independent Department
Merged the Department of Army Navy and Air Force into what would become the Department of Defense
Formalized the Joint Chiefs of Staff
Preserved independence of the Marines
The War in Vietnam was devastating to the American Miliary, particularly the Army. Why?
We failed to achieve our military goal of Communist control of the South despite vast founding and ground troops
Indiscipline undermined fighting and moral
Crime, abuse, racial tension, and drug use tainted the image of the Army in the eyes of Americans.
The trauma of the draft
Weinberg/Powell “Doctorine”: If we aren’t fighting in situations like Vietnam then what are we likely to do?
Either the United States or its close allies’ vital national interests have to be at risk
The war had to be fought “wholeheartedly, with the clear intention of winning”
We should employ decisive force in the pursuit of clearly defined political and military objectives
We must constantly reassess whether the use of force is necessary and appropriate
There must be a “reasonable assurance” of Congressional and public support
Force should be used only as a last resort
What was the motivation to the shift to “The Total Force Policy”?
Vietnam- Enlisted cannot deploy without the guard component. Increases political accountability for office holders not wanting to deploy people from their district out of fear of political repercussions from constituencies. This also increases ties to the citizenry in general which was important after bad public perceptions with Vietnam, and losing the tie with shifting to an AVF
What is the AirLand Battle Doctorine?
Emphasized maneuver warfare instead of a battle of attrition (attrition is where whoever has more power wins, continuing to fight through loses)
Synchronized ground and air power
Uses surprise, deception, and surveillance to maximize your effects
Requires excellent command control as it integrates all the arms- infantry, artillery, engineers, and airpower
Extends operations in space and time
What is TRADOC?
Stands for Training and Doctrine Command, for training soldiers during peacetime mainly through Joint Readiness Training Centers (JRTC)
Why did we shift to an All Volunteer Force (AVF)?
Army lost confidence in draft discipline with problems in Vietnam
Public and political opposition due to Vietnam
Obtaining enough volunteers was reasonable given budget
Draft was no longer practical with the amount of men eligible and the needs of the military
Why do men still have to register for Selective Services
In case of emergency and because Congress cannot agree on what to do instead of the draft
What was the importance of The Gulf War (1991) Desert Storm?
marked a massive recovery effort from the aftermath of Vietnam
showed military innovation through: new doctrine, new weapons, rigorous approaches to training, and changes to organizations and tatics
What were the demographic characteristics of the AVF in 2024, and how are those a shift from past years/periods of history?
smaller force due to no longer being an AVF increase in women in the military with women no longer being forced into support roles, 77% of youth do not qualify by fitness standards to serve in the military due to higher rates of obesity, professionalization due to increased education, and increased diversity
In what ways is the military different from the US as a whole and why? How might this matter?
Disproportionate amount of women (under 20%), significant racial disparity in Officer role in the military (74% white), warrior caste with the “burden” of taking on military service falls to military families
Is it a problem that a declining percentage of the US population serves in the military or that a relatively small group of families provide the core of America’s military manpower?
Yes leads to the development of a warrior caste where military families feel like they have to carry the “burden” of military service. It also creates a feeling of otherness when the public lacks connection to the military. It can also foster a feeling of eliteness among the members of the armed forces.
What are the areas of excellence in the US Army?
Power projection: Forward deployed, US based Ready Force
Deterrence and Defense
Logistics: Lead role in joint force
Tactical Operations: Defined Objectives
Partnerships
Areas of Improvement for the US Army
Modernization: Character of war is rapidly changing, the Army is not. Ex) Need to leverage inexpensive weapon systems and update Warfighting doctrine.
End Strength: requirements of US Army are outpacing manpower resources
US Army Characteristics
Largest military service
High-Intensity Conflict: Major Operations, large scale combat
Multi-Domain: Combined Arms
Emphasis on Education: Professional Officer and NCO Education and Combat Training Centers
History, Tradition, Structure
Emphasis on the man, not the machine
Logistics!
Why do we need a Navy?
Because America is a Maritime nation and we need to protect our coasts, protect shipping and commerce abroad, need forward presence in ports abroad.
Characteristics of Navy Culture
Power Projection- maintaining presence in all international ports.
UNODIR (Unless Otherwise Directed): allows for crew autonomy, just given an objective and it’s up to crew to determine how to employ it.
Accountability: Officer dismissal upon mistake
Honor, Courage, Commitment
“Ask the Chief”- reliance on Command Structure and superiors
Gaps in the Navy
Need for development of remote and autonomous vehicles, innovation, faster innovation and not needing to balance innovation with maintaining current systems
What is the role of the Marines
To be the Nation’s crisis response (911) force. Conduct amphibious operations- help with the seizure/defense of naval bases, conduct land operations essential of a naval campaign, and protect embassy’s abroad
Principles of a Marine
Every Marine is a rifleman all receive basic combat training
Marines are forward deployed (always ready to deploy at a moments notice.)
Marines win
Marines are innovative and adaptable
“centralized planning, decentralized execution” autonomy and trust to change plan to execute principle
Tough, willingness to “live hard”
Why do the Marines have a more consistent, intense, and intentional culture than other services?
Smaller group, consistent training leading to shared experiences and backgrounds, and a learned and shared history of suffering.
Marine culture consists of a set of key elements. What are these? List as many as you can.
Effective
Frugal
Aggressive
Adaptable
Tough
Transformational
Innovative
Focused on the individual fighters
Exceptional (better than others mindset)
Why does the U.S. continue to have a Marine Corps?
Practically it is an amphibious crisis response force. But we continue to have them because of their culture of resilience, fighting tooth in nail for their existence with their willingness to adapt and continue to prove they are needed because they are willing to do what other service branches do not do.
What are four historic events experienced by the Marines that are deeply embedded in their service culture?
Belleau Woods (June 1918): first time Marines move from keeping order on a Naval ship to becoming a fighting force on land, hand to hand combat with Germany.
Iwo Jima (1945): Marines took the island in hand to hand combat, lost 10,000, but was still able to raise the flag.
The Battle of Chosin Reservoir (Nov-Dec. 1950): Intervention of Chinese Communist resulted in absolute disaster, the task force was annihilated, the solders that fought and died in the frigid cold of the Chosin area, is one of the most tragic in the history of the military
Fallujah (2004): bloodiest combat Marines experienced since the world war.
Common theme: historical suffering, you will suffer because other people have suffered and survived so you will too OR other people have suffered and not survive so you will survive for hem.
What did the Goldwater-Nichols Department of Defense Reorganization Act of 1986 do?
In short, Goldwater–Nichols shifted operational authority away from the individual military services and toward the Secretary of Defense, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, and unified combatant commanders, while requiring the services to work more closely
together.
Established clear operational chain of Command (President → Secretary of Defense → combatant commanders)
Strengthened the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff: Made him principal military advisor to the President and Secretary of Defense
Clarified the role of the service chiefs: Department Chiefs remained responsible for organizing, training, and equipping their forces but no longer needed operational command over forces assigned to combatant commands.
Strengthened unified combatant commanders: Commanders of Geographic commands received greater authority over their forces.
What does it mean to “Command”?
Exercise authority over your troops, maintain responsibility for your troops actions, and hold accountability for when something goes wrong under your command, whether you knew it happened or not
FREEBIE
YIPPEE
What is the Command Climate?
the shared perception of how a unit’s command team exercises leadership and manages the organization. In the U.S. military, it generally refers to the attitudes, behaviors, and environment established by commanders and leaders.
Why was there such a heated debate when the Consituion was written around permitting a standing army?
High tax cuts where borne by the British when they produced a standing army, British standing Army was used to repress the citizenry, British standing army conducted offensive wars and made bad tactical decisions, we don’t need a standing army because we are protected by water.
But they also needed a standing army to quell rebellions, maintain technical expertise of warfighting, and protect commerce.
What is doctrine?
Set of standards that determine the most effective way of action for the future.
What are the pros and cons of the AVF?
Pros: Buy in (people want to be there), more easily trainable and willing to learn, more selectivity for members.
Cons: Alienation from average America, more time and effort put into recruiting, less diversity (same type of person being recruited)
What is CHOP?
Change in Operational Control, happens when Navy is passing through different combatant commands
UNODIR
Unless Otherwise Directed- ability to move forward with a plan or misison UNODIR
What is Special Forces?
Specialized training operational units, that often have time sensitive, clandestine, low visibility missions.
What are the origins of Special Forces?
The Office of Strategic Services: Teams of 3 people during World War 2 that would preform subversive missions during World War 2, was precursor to unconventional warfare.
What is Special Operation Forces culture?
Humans are more important than hardware
Quality is better than quantity
Autonomy in decision making
Unconventional problem solving
“Prima donna” effect
Over/misuse of SOF
Why study the U.S. military?
Becuase the U.S. public increasingly supports our military, and decreasingly understand what it does.
Freebie
YIPPEE
What checks does Congress have on the military?
Declare war, raise and support the services, make the legal framework (Uniform Code of Military Justice), and provide for organizing the military.
What powers does the president have over the military
Commander in Chief, make treaties, nominate officers
Tell me about the civil-military divide.
Rise of the “warrior caste”- trend where a large portion of people who choose to serve is from military. If the warrior caste continues it will be harder to sustain trust for healthy civil-military relations. Ex) General Cadwell being a 5th gen
Less than 1 percent of Americans serve in the armed forces today
Veterans report feeling a sense of “otherness” from civilians
This gap could also ”getting away” with more when the public does not understand what they do.
Army Service Culture
Emphasis on Education: Professional Officer and NCO Education and Combat Training Centers
History, Tradition, Structure
Emphasis on the man, not the machine
Teamwork
Coordination
Detailed Planning
Characteristics of Land Power
exercises control and security over a long period of time
the decisive domain of warfare
we play away games, we tend not to fight on our own territory
land power carries a higher risk for casualties and therefore a higher political risk
2 basic roles preformed by the Navy
Sea control: ability to use a specific area on the sea for a specific purpose at a specific point in time
Power projection- ability to transport U.S. military power and land it on distant shores.
List the Combatant Command Centers, what are the significance of these command centers?
USNORTHCOM (U.S Northern Command), USSOUTHCOM (U.S Southern Command), USAFRICOM (U.S Africa Command), USCENTCOM (U.S Central Command- Middle East), USEUCOM (U.S European Command), USINDOPACOM (U.S. Indo-Pacific Command)
Significance: maintaining unity of Command through dividing up the world, with only 1 Combatant Commander in a command at a time, and through the Goldwater-Nichols DOD Reorganization Act of 1986 promoted jointness through requiring officers to gain experience serving within other military service before being promoted to General and Flag Officer ranks.
What tools does a commander have to reconcile there comprehensive responsibility with the limits of what they can personally oversee?
Commander’s Intent: Give clear and concise expression of the purpose of operations and desired end state to help subordinates act to achieve commanders desired result with further orders.
Command Climate: Foster a positive climate through the leader’s attitude behavior and environment, so members have a positive shared perception of how a unit’s leadership manages the organization.
What does the structure of a Brigade Combat Team look like in the Army?
Three Combined Arms: 2 infantry companies and two armor companies, one scout (recon) platoon, and one mortar (indirect fire) platoon
One Cavalry Squadron with three cavalry companies
One Fires Battalion: with three field artillery batteries, and a target acquisition platoon
One Brigade Engineer Battalion: two combat engineer companies, a brigade signal company, and a military intelligence company
One Brigade Support Battalion (support combat elements): with a distribution (quartermaster/transportation) company, a field maintenance (ordnance) company, a medical company, and separate for ward support companies that are attached to each of the battalions to provide logistics support
The brigade and all battalions also each have headquarters companies that include not only the commander and his or her staff, but could also include soldiers with military police, chemical, civil affairs, chaplain, medical, and legal specialties
What is MAGTF?
Marne Air-Ground Task Forces. an integrated collection of personnel and equipment that operates under a single commander. It is designed to have everything needed to operate independently in any location. Accordingly, each MAGTF is composed of four elements: ground forces, aviation, logistics, and a command element. Four types of MAGTF
Marine Expeditionary Force (MEF)- the largest and most permanent Marine Corps warfighting organization. Each MEF is assigned a divi sion, wing, logistics group, and MEF command element for operations,
Marine Expeditionary Brigade (MEB), which is sig nificantly smaller than a MEF. Rather than having permanent forces assigned, a MEB’s air, ground and logistics elements come from within the wing, division, and logistics group of a MEF
MEU is a sea-based force designed to respond rapidly to crises
Special Purpose MAGTF. These emerged over the past decade to respond to unique situations requiring limited capabilities.
Name Navy Capabilities
Aircraft Carriers- Presence and power projection: applies visible pressure internationally, and has missile defense systems.
US Submarines- strategie deterrence through strategic missle systems
Surface Combatants- engage with enemy forces above the water.
Amphibious Ships- Get warfighters to the fight.
Combat Logistics Ships- helps replinish resources such as transferring oil
Why does the US need a Space Force?
Protect satellites, collect satellite imagery for surveillance, Manage space field (space debris), missile warnings, weather
Challenges to US space interests
Space is becoming more crowded, missiles being launched to destroy satalites, Cyber threats- RF jamming wires that communicate from Earth to Space, FOBs (Fractional Orbital Bombardments)- missiles designed to reorient in space to hit countries
What were the debates for and against the Space Force?
For: it makes sense to separate domains to provide more specialization
Against: Mostly people with the microphones, thought it wouldn’t be worth the time/resources, (now separate budgets)