1/14
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What was one of the major concerns of a female leader?
That she would be unable to control factions.
What is an example of when Mary had appeared unable to control factions?
Over her proposed marriage, two of her leading councillors supported different suitors.
What were the fears of the impact of a Spanish marriage on factions?
Would create factional strife between English courtiers, who they believed would dominate the court + be given positions within the administration.
Is there any evidence that the Spanish marriage had an impact on administrative efficiency?
No.
What sort of size was Mary’s Privy Council and why?
Large - she brought in her own supporters who had helped her gain the throne but also kept many experienced administrators.
Why did some argue Mary’s Privy Council was ineffective?
Because of it’s large size
Evidence to challenge the view that Mary’s Privy Council was ineffective due to it’s large size.
rare for all councillors to be present
average size of meetings similar to those held under Northumberland
committees established in 1554 which excluded casual councillors
1555 - ‘inner circle’ established
Philip’s departure in 1555 + death of Gardiner in November 1555 allowed Paget to dominate and establish a conciliar from of government
Did Gardiner and Paget get along?
No, many clashes.
What were some examples of clashes between Gardiner and Paget?
Mary’s marriage
The revival of the heresy laws
When did parliament reject and agree to the heresy laws
Rejected in April 1554.
Agreed when they had guarantees that monastic lands would not be restored to the Catholic Church.
What does the initial rejection of the heresy laws suggest and what is a counter argument for this?
That Mary’s religious policies were unpopular.
The struggle to reintroduce them was part of the factional struggle between Paget and Gardiner, because the same legislation that had initially been rejected was passed once Paget and his supporters backed out.
Were Gardiner and Paget problematic for Mary?
Not majorly, despite the delay in introducing the legislation and the desire of Gardiner and Paget to persuade the queen to support their policies, they were able to put aside their differences for much of the reign
What was the impact of the arrival of Cardinal Pole?
Can be argued arrival of Cardinal Pole as papal legate changed nature of court politics.
What has it been suggested Mary did because she distrusted her councillor’s advice?
Mary was aware of the divisions among her councillors, and therefore had everything referred to Cardinal Pole or to the Spanish ambassador, Simon Renard.
Was faction a bad thing?
No - debates over policy in the Privy Council were usually constructive. Elizabeth was able to use it to great effect to control government by playing one group against each other. In Edward’s reign no evidence to suggest that the struggles created inefficiency / prevented the government + administration from working.