DX Everly Wisconsin

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/17

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

18 Terms

1
New cards

Please introduce yourself to the members of the jury.

Good (morning/afternoon), my name is Sage Everly.

2
New cards

What do you do for a living?

I am the owner and operator of Power Consulting, giving solutions to midlands biggest electrical concerns.

3
New cards

Can you walk us through your education and training?

Sure, first I graduated from Case Western University with a degree in mechanical engineering. From there I got a job at Big City Electric. It was a firm very similar to my own where I helped design electrical infrastructure for developing countries. I got a job in Midlands at the Midlands Department of Transportation, which working for the government taught me that I am able to do my job the best if I am the one in charge, which led me to starting my company Power Consulting. 


4
New cards

How'd you get involved in today's case?

I was retained by the defense to do what I do best, look at a problem and investigate possible solutions.

5
New cards

What was the focus of your investigation?

Firstly, I focused on whether MG&E's actions may have contributed to the Dip Fire, and secondly whether those actions were within the industry standards.

6
New cards

What facts and data did you review?

I reviewed Dr. Prescott's report, as well as the evidence she used to form the report independently. I also visited the area where the pole started in August of this year. As a major company in the industry I am also familiar with both MG&E's and the industry manual.

7
New cards

Were they sufficient in forming your conclusions?

Yes, they were

8
New cards

How did you analyze these materials?

I always use the TAB method, which is widely used by experts in my industry. It stands for Timeline, Actions, and Big Picture. It essentially means that I first build the timeline of what happened. Then I examine the actions that were taken and compare them to industry standards. Finally, I took a step back and looked at the big picture.

9
New cards

Did you reliably apply the TAB method in today's case?

Yes.

10
New cards

How did you start your investigation?

I first established that timeline, starting with the crash at 1:40, moving to the report at 2:10, and finishing with the call to MG&E reporting the fire.

11
New cards

Why do you start with the timeline?

It's vital for establishing context. We know what happened today, eleven months later, but what I'm interested in is what MG&E knew in the moment.

12
New cards

Where did you begin examining MG&E's actions?

I focused on whether MG&E took proper care of their equipment, specifically the utility pole in question, the one off of Dip Road.

13
New cards

Did you find that MG&E adequately maintained this pole?

Yes, and there are usually a few points that stick out to me. Firstly, the dimensions of the pole itself were all in industry standard. Then I analyzed maintenance records and found that the pole had no history of major electrical malfunctions.

14
New cards

Can you walk us through what happened that night?

Certainly, MG&E was first notified by police that a vehicle struck their pole at 2:10. Later, at 3:30, their environmental sensors started giving unusual readings, which were determined to be non-actionable according to standards.

15
New cards

Why were those alerts listed as "non-actionable?"

If the sensor has a documented history of false-positives within the previous 90 days, then it is within MG&E’s standard procedure to document that as a non-actionable alert. The UROC manual states that while past false positives alone is not reason enough for it to be non-actionable, it is weighed with other factors like weather and location of the potential damage. Which in this case was non-actionable.

16
New cards

What was the final action you reviewed?

MG&E's decision not to immediately de-energize their poles after the report. Doing something like that comes with major consequences, which should never be taken lightly. MG&E quickly investigated the situation and still de-energized promptly, which is within industry standards.

17
New cards

When you compare what MG&E actually did to its own manual and the industry standards you reviewed, what did you find?

I found that all of MG&E's actions on the morning of January 1st were compliant with both the manual and the standards.

18
New cards

When you step back and look at the entire timeline, what is your conclusion?

I see a lot of competing factors form an admittedly complicated picture. A holiday morning, a car crash, reliable sensors showing nothing wrong, and eventually a devastating fire. MG&E was not handed the full picture at 2:10 a.m.; they got one piece at a time. They made every decision in accordance with all of our industry's