1/132
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the power dilemma
Effective government needs enough power to solve complex, large-scale problems and maintain order, but concentrated power threatens individual rights and invites tyranny.
How does separation of powers solve the power dilemma?
It divides government into three branches—legislative, executive, and judicial—with distinct functions and checks on each other.
What is the goal of separation of powers?
No single branch can dominate—power is used, but never unchecked.
What did Thomas Hobbes argue in Leviathan?
Humans in a lawless “state of nature” face chaos and violence, so a strong, near-absolute sovereign is needed for order and security.
Did Hobbes favor concentrated or divided power?
Concentrated power.
What did John Locke argue in the Second Treatise?
Government’s legitimacy rests on consent of the governed and protection of natural rights: life, liberty, and property.
What did Locke believe about dividing government power?
Power should be divided—legislative power supreme, but still checked—to prevent tyranny.
What basic conflict did Hobbes and Locke represent?
Order vs. liberty.
What is the key idea of Federalist No. 37?
Boundaries Are Blurry: some overlap between branches is unavoidable and necessary.
What is the key idea of Federalist No. 47?
Separation, Not Isolation: no branch should hold the WHOLE power of another; some shared function is fine.
What is the key idea of Federalist No. 48?
Parchment Barriers Aren’t Enough: written constitutional limits alone cannot restrain power-hungry branches.
Which branch did Madison see as the biggest threat in Federalist No. 48?
The Legislature.
What is the key idea of Federalist No. 51?
Ambition vs. Ambition: each branch needs tools and incentives to resist encroachment by the others.
What famous idea summarizes Federalist No. 51?
“Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”
How is the President formally chosen?
Through the Electoral College, not a direct national popular vote.
How many electors does each state receive?
Equal to its total congressional delegation: House + Senate.
How many electoral votes are needed to win?
270
What do National Popular Vote advocates argue?
It is more democratic and reflects the true nationwide will of voters.
What do Electoral College defenders argue?
It protects smaller/rural states, preserves federalism, and forces broad geographic coalitions.
What elections intensified the NPV vs. Electoral College debate?
2000 and 2016—the winner lost the popular vote but won the Electoral College.
What are the Article II, Section 4 grounds for impeachment?
“Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”
What does the House do in impeachment?
Impeaches by majority vote; this is a formal accusation, not removal.
What does the Senate do in impeachment?
Impeaches by majority vote; this is a formal accusation, not removal.
What does the Senate do in impeachment?
Holds the trial; a two-thirds vote is required to convict and remove.
Does House impeachment itself remove the President?
No. Senate conviction is what actually removes the President.
What are the major Article II presidential powers?
Commander-in-Chief, appointments, treaties, pardons, receiving ambassadors, vetoes, and recommending measures to Congress.
What check exists on presidential appointments?
Senate advice and consent.
What check exists on presidential treaties?
Senate ratification
What is Constitutional/Whig Theory?
President may exercise ONLY powers explicitly granted by the Constitution or delegated by Congress.
Who is associated with Constitutional/Whig Theory?
William Howard Taft.
Is Constitutional/Whig Theory broad or restrained?
Limited and restrained
What is Stewardship Theory?
President may act for the public interest in any way NOT explicitly forbidden by the Constitution or law.
Who is associated with Stewardship Theory?
Theodore Roosevelt.
Is Stewardship Theory broad or restrained?
Broad and proactive
What is Prerogative Theory?
In true necessity/emergency, the President may act outside—or even against—ordinary law for the public good, later seeking ratification.
What thinker is Prerogative Theory rooted in?
John Locke.
What President’s actions are associated with Prerogative Theory?
Abraham Lincoln’s Civil War actions.
How can the President be a legislative leader if Congress makes laws?
Congress makes laws, but the President shapes what Congress works on
What tools does the President use as legislative leader?
Proposing legislation, setting the agenda, bully pulpit, lobbying, vetoes, executive orders, and budget proposals.
What is the “bully pulpit”?
Using presidential public influence to build public pressure for legislation.
What does Article II, Section 3 require for the State of the Union?
President must give Congress information on the state of the union “from time to time.”
Does the Constitution require an annual State of the Union?
No
Must the State of the Union be delivered in person or on television?
No
How did early presidents commonly deliver the State of the Union?
Jefferson through Taft, roughly, mostly sent WRITTEN reports.
Who revived the in-person State of the Union in 1913?
Woodrow Wilson.
What does Article II, Section 2 say about presidential appointments?
President appoints ambassadors, judges, and officers “by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate.”
Who may appoint inferior officers?
Congress may vest appointment in the President alone, courts, or department heads.
Is presidential removal power explicitly stated in the Constitution?
No. It has been defined largely through case law.
What did the Tenure of Office Act of 1867 do?
Required Senate consent before the President could remove certain officials.
When was the Tenure of Office Act repealed?
1887
What did Myers v. United States (1926) establish?
President has exclusive power to remove EXECUTIVE officials without Senate approval.
What did Humphrey’s Executor v. U.S. (1935) establish?
Congress CAN restrict removal of officials at independent regulatory agencies performing quasi-legislative/judicial duties
How did Humphrey’s Executor affect Myers?
It limited Myers by creating an exception for independent regulatory agencies.
What did NLRB v. SW General (2017) establish?
Limits use of “acting officers” nominated for permanent posts and reinforces the Senate’s advice-and-consent check.
What is the progression of the removal cases?
Tenure Act = restrict President → Myers = expand President → Humphrey’s = limit Myers → SW General = reinforce Senate check.
What is a recess appointment?
President temporarily fills vacancies without Senate confirmation “during the Recess of the Senate.”
Why are recess appointments controversial?
They can be used to bypass Senate opposition or gridlock.
What are pro-forma sessions used for?
To try to block recess appointments by preventing a genuine Senate recess.
What did NLRB v. Noel Canning (2014) establish?
The SENATE—not the President—decides when the Senate is truly in recess.
What does Article II, Section 2 say about pardons?
President may grant “Reprieves and Pardons for Offenses against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.”
What is the explicit constitutional limit on presidential pardons?
They cannot apply to impeachment cases.
What is the first explanation for pardon power?
Mercy or grace toward the individual.
What is the second explanation for pardon power?
Political reconciliation and public tranquility.
What is the third explanation for pardon power?
Checks and balances—tempering overly harsh justice
What did Schick v. Reed (1974) establish?
The pardon power is broad; the President may attach conditions to a pardon.
What must be determined about a condition attached to a pardon?
Whether the condition is independently constitutional.
What is a treaty?
A formal agreement with a foreign nation
What approval does a treaty require?
Two-thirds approval of the Senate.
What kind of commitment is a treaty?
A lasting, formal, binding national commitment.
What is an executive agreement?
An agreement with a foreign government made solely by the President.
Does an executive agreement require Senate ratification?
No
Treaty vs. executive agreement?
Treaty = 2/3 Senate approval and formal commitment; executive agreement = no Senate ratification
Why might a President choose an executive agreement?
Speed, flexibility, secrecy, and avoiding the difficulty of getting two-thirds Senate approval
Which is easier for a future President to reverse?
An executive agreement
Does the President need Congress/Senate approval to receive ambassadors?
No
What role is connected to receiving ambassadors?
Head of state and chief diplomat.
What substantive power is connected to receiving ambassadors?
Recognition of foreign governments and diplomatic representatives.
What can the President do as Commander-in-Chief?
Direct the military and respond to sudden attacks or emergencies.
Can the President formally declare war?
No. Congress alone has that power.
What war powers does Congress have?
Declare war and raise and fund the military.
How can Congress constrain presidential military action?
Funding controls and legislation.
Why is there ongoing tension over war powers?
Presidents have often committed troops without a formal declaration of war
What are inherent powers?
Powers not spelled out in the text but treated as necessary for effective presidential foreign-policy leadership.
What did Hamilton argue in Federalist No. 23?
National defense power must be essentially unlimited because threats cannot be fully anticipated.
What is the KEY case for inherent presidential foreign-affairs power?
U.S. v. Curtiss-Wright (1936).
What did U.S. v. Curtiss-Wright establish?
The President has broad inherent authority abroad as the nation’s “sole organ” in international relations.
According to Curtiss-Wright, how does presidential authority abroad compare with authority at home?
Presidential activities/power abroad are far broader than at home.
What did Justice Sutherland argue about foreign-affairs power?
It passed from the British Crown directly to the national government, not the states
What did FDR’s Executive Order 9066 authorize?
Forced relocation and internment of over 100,000 Japanese Americans
How was Executive Order 9066 justified?
As wartime/national-security necessity.
What did Korematsu v. United States (1944) do?
Upheld the policy.
Why is Japanese American internment important to presidential power?
It showed how far inherent wartime powers could stretch at the expense of individual rights.
Why was the War Powers Resolution of 1973 passed?
In response to the prolonged, undeclared conflict in Vietnam.
How did the War Powers Resolution become law?
Congress passed it OVER President Nixon’s veto
What is the War Powers Resolution’s 48-hour rule?
President must notify Congress within 48 hours of committing U.S. troops to conflict
How long can troops remain without congressional authorization or declaration of war?
60–90 days.
Why have Presidents objected to the War Powers Resolution?
They argue it unconstitutionally infringes on Commander-in-Chief power.
How do Presidents today generally view the War Powers Resolution?
As “advisory” or “symbolic” rather than strictly binding.
Why was the USA PATRIOT Act passed in 2001?
Passed after 9/11 to fight terrorism
What powers did the Patriot Act expand?
Government surveillance, wiretapping, and information-sharing.