Social Action Theory

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/6

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

7 Terms

1
New cards

What are the two levels of explanation that Max Weber (1864-1920) argued are necessary for an adequate sociological understanding of human behaviour?

→ Max Weber saw both structural and action approaches as necessary for a full understanding of human behaviour, arguing that an adequate sociological explanation involves two levels.

→ The level of cause involves explaining the objective structural factors that shape people's behaviour.

→ The level of meaning involves understanding the subjective meanings that individuals attach to their actions; unless both levels are accounted for, our explanation will be incomplete or false.

2
New cards

How does Weber's study The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1905) illustrate both the level of structural cause and the level of subjective meaning?

→ At the level of structural cause, the Protestant Reformation introduced a new belief system, Calvinism, which changed people's worldview and promoted a work ethic that brought about the rise of capitalism.

→ At the level of subjective meaning, work took on a religious meaning for the Calvinists as a calling by God to glorify his name through their labours.

→ This subjective meaning motivated Calvinists to work systematically, leading them to accumulate wealth and become the first modern capitalists.

3
New cards

What are instrumentally rational action and value-rational action according to Max Weber?

→ Instrumentally rational action is where the actor calculates the most efficient means of achieving a given goal, regardless of whether the goal itself is desirable (for example, a capitalist calculating that paying low wages is the most efficient way to maximise profit, or actions aimed at distributing charity or committing genocide).

→ Value-rational action involves action towards a goal that the actor regards as desirable for its own sake, such as a believer worshipping their god in order to get to heaven.

→ Unlike instrumental rationality, value-rational action offers no way of calculating whether the means of achieving the goal are effective, as a believer cannot know whether performing a particular ritual will gain them salvation.

4
New cards

What are traditional action and affectual action according to Max Weber, and where is affectual action particularly important?

→ Traditional action involves customary, routine, or habitual actions that Weber does not see as rational, because no conscious thought or choice has gone into them; rather, the actor does it because 'we have always done it'.

→ Affectual action is action that expresses emotion, such as weeping out of grief or violence sparked by anger.

→ Weber sees affectual action as important in religious and political movements with charismatic leaders who attract a following based on their emotional appeal.

5
New cards

What is the main value of Max Weber's social action theory, and how does Alfred Schutz (1972) criticise it?

→ Weber's ideas are a valuable corrective to the over-emphasis on structural factors seen in functionalism and some forms of Marxism, affirming that we must understand actors' subjective meanings to explain their actions adequately.

→ However, Schutz (1972) argues that Weber's view of action is too individualistic and cannot explain the shared nature of meanings.

→ For example, when a person at an auction raises their arm, they mean they are making a bid, but Weber does not explain how everyone else present also comes to give this gesture the same meaning.

6
New cards

Why is Weber's typology of action difficult to apply in practice, and what is the limitation of verstehen?

→ Weber's typology of action is difficult to apply because a single behaviour can fit multiple categories: for example, among the Trobriand Islanders, individuals exchange ritual gifts called 'kula' with others on neighbouring islands, which could be seen either as traditional action (practised the same way for generations) or as instrumentally rational action (a good way of cementing trading links between kula partners).

→ Furthermore, Weber advocated the use of verstehen, or empathetic understanding of the actor's subjective meaning, where we put ourselves in the actor's place to understand their motives and meanings.

→ However, because we cannot actually be that other person, we can never be sure we have truly understood their motives.

7
New cards