1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Level of moral reasoning - Moral development
Moral development: Kohlberg (1967) applied concept of moral reasoning to offending behaviour
People’s decisions & judgements on issues of right/qrong summarised in a stage theory of moral reasoning
Higher stage = more sophisticated reasoning
Based theory on people’s responses to series of moral dilemmas (e.g. Heinz dilemma)
Studies suggest offenders show lower level of moral reasoning
Kohlberg et al (1973): moral dilemmas found that gorup of violent youths at a significantly lower level of moral dev than non-violent youths even after controlling for social background
Level of moral reaosning: link with criminality
Offenders = classified at pre-conventional stage of Kohlberg’s model (1 & 2)
Non-offenders progress to conventional level & beyond
Pre-conventional level: need to avoid punishment & gain rewards - childlike reasoning
Adults at PC level may commit crime if they can avoid punishment/gain rewards (e.g. money, respect, etc)
Supported by studies (e.g. Chandler 1973: offenders = egocentric & display poorer social perspective-taking skills than non-offending peers)
Cognitive distortions: Hostile attribution bias
Prosperity for violence associated with tendency to misinterpret others’ actions
Assume others are being confrontational
Read non aggressive cues → trigger disproportionate/violent response
Schonenberg & Jusyte (2014) presented 55 violent offenders with images of emotionally ambiguous facial expressions
compared to non-aggressive matched control group, offenders more likely to perceive images as hostile
Roots may be apparent in childhood
Dodge & Frame (1982): showed children clip of ambiguous provocation where intention wasnt hostile or accidental
aggressive & rejected children interpreted situation as more hostile than nonagressive/accepted
Cog distortions: minimalisation
Downplay seriousness of offence
“euphemistic label” for behaviour (Bandura 1973)
E.g. burglars describe themselves as “supporting my family£ to minimise seriousness of offences
Studis → indivdiuals who commit sexual offences prone to this
Barbaree (91): among 26 incarcerated rapists → 54% denied committing offence at all and 40% minimised harm caused
strenght: research support - MR
Link between level of moral reasoning & crime
Palmer & Hollin (1998): comapred moral reasoning in 332 non-offenders & 126 convicted offenders using SRM-SF containing 11 moral dilemmas
Offender group showed less mature mr than non offenders
consistent with kohlebrg
Type of offence - not generalisable - MR
moral reasoning depend on offence
Thomton & Reid (82): people who committed financial gain crimes more likely to show pre-conventional moral reasoning than impulse criminals
Pre-conventional moral reasoning associated with crimes where offenders think they can evade punishment
Not applicable to allc rimes
Real world application - CD
Application to therapy
CBT challenges irrational thinking
Offenders encouraged to face up to their actions & establish less distorted view
Harkins et al 2010 suggest reduced incidence of denail and minimilisartion in therapy highluy associated with less risk of reoffending
Accepting crime = aspect of rehabilittion
Practical value
LIm: type of offence not ceneraliabile - CG
CD depends on offence type
Howitt & Kerry Sheldon (07): gathered questionnaire responses from sexual offenders
Non contact sex offenders used more cognitive distorions than contact sex offenders
Previous history of offending more likely to distort as justifications
Not used in same way by all