1/265
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Contract
A promise or a set of promises for the breach of which the law gives a remedy, or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes as a duty
Plain English: Promises giving rise to legal obligations
Promise
A manifestation of intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, so made as to justify a promisee in understanding that a commitment has been made
Promisor
The person manifesting the intention
Promisee
The person to whom the manifestation is addressed
Beneficiary
A person, other than the promisee, who benefits from performance of a promise
Agreement
A manifestation of mutual assent on the part of two or more persons
Bargain
An agreement to exchange promises or to exchange a promise for a performance or to exchange performances
How a promise may be made
May be stated in words either written or oral, or may be inferred wholly or partly from conduct
Express warranties by the seller are created by any of the following, if part of the basis of the bargain
Affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods
Any affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods, if part of the basis of the bargain, creates an express warranty that the goods shall conform to the affirmation or promise
Description of the goods
Any description of the goods, if part of the basis of the bargain, creates an express warranty that the goods shall conform to the description
Sample or model of the goods
Any sample or model creates, if part of the basis of the bargain, creates an express warranty that the whole of the goods shall conform to the sample or model.
What is the overall contract analysis?
What is the applicable law?
Common law
UCC Article 2
Is the contract within the Statute of Frauds?
If yes → Are the requirements of the Statute satisfied?
If no → What are the effects?
Is there a legal relationship between the parties (i.e., are there grounds for recognizing obligations/giving remedies)? (Enforceability)
Did the parties form a contract? (Formation)
Did the parties agree on a bargain?
What is the content of their contract? (Construction)
What performance was required/did the parties breach? (Performance)
What remedies are available? (Remedies)
(If relevant) Are third parties’ rights and remedies affected? (Third Parties)
It is not necessary in the creation of an express warranty that the seller
Uses formal words like “warrant” or “guarantee”
Have specific intention to make a warranty
What does not create an express warranty?
An affirmation merely of the value of the goods or a statement purporting to be merely the seller’s opinion or commendation of the goods (i.e., puffery) does not create an express warranty
Promise vs. warranty
A promise is a commitment to do or refrain from doing something; a warranty is a commitment that a fact or condition is or will be as represented
Measure of expectation interest
Difference between the value promised and the value received, plus
Other losses caused by the breach (incidental or consequential damages), less
Costs saved by not having to perform
Purpose and direction of expectation damages
Forward looking
Purpose: Putting the plaintiff where they would have been if the contract had been performed
Measure of reliance interest
Expenses incurred in preparing to perform or performing the contract, less
Any losses the breaching party proves the injured party would have suffered even if the contract had been performed
Purpose and direction of reliance damages
Backward looking
Purpose: Putting the plaintiff where they would have been if contract had never been entered into
To what extent is a party entitled to restitution?
A party is entitled to restitution only to the extent that he has conferred a benefit on the other party by way of party performance or reliance
Measure of restitution
The value of the benefit the breaching party received, measured by either
What it reasonably would have cost breaching party to obtain the benefit from someone else, or
How much the benefit increased the breaching party’s property value or improved their interests
Purpose and direction of restitution
Backward looking
Purpose: Return any benefits that the plaintiff conferred upon the defendant
As a general rule
Default remedy is contract damages
Contract damages are compensatory
Damages awards are focused on the plaintiff’s position, not the defendant’s
We compensate for the value of the promised performance
Damages awards aim to approximate contract performance, rather than undoing breach
Calculation
Damages aren’t calculated with mathematical precision; there’s often some uncertainty involved
If you are in breach, you might have to accept imprecise forms of proof
Where there is uncertainty, courts will favor the non-breaching party
Which measures focus on the plaintiff’s position?
Expectation
Reliance
Which measures focus on the defendant’s position?
Restitution
Disgorgement
Requires breaching party to surrender profits obtained through breach
When might defendant’s gains be relevant to a contract damages calculation?
While on occasion the defendant’s profits are used as the measure of damages, this generally occurs when those profits tend to define the plaintiff’s loss.
When are punitive damages recoverable for breach of contract?
Punitive damages are not recoverable for a breach of contract unless the conduct constituting breach is also a tort for which punitive damages are recoverable
Equitable principles
Equity will not suffer a wrong without a remedy
He who comes into equity must come with clean hands
Equity aids the vigilant, not those who slumber on their rights
Equity acts in personam
Equity regards substance rather than form
Nominal Damages
A small, symbolic sum awarded when a breach occurred, but substantial actual damages were not established
Injunctive relief
A court order requiring a party to act or refrain from acting
Specific performance
A court order requiring a party to perform their contractual obligations
Replevin
A remedy used to recover possession of specific personal property (chattel).
Efficient breach
A breach that produces a greater economic benefit to the breaching party than performance would, even after compensating the nonbreaching party for its losses
Requirements for injunctive relief
Plaintiff has suffered legal injury
The injury is irreparable by other means
The injunction is warranted upon consideration of the balance of hardships between defendant and plaintiff
Granting the injunction would not harm public interest
What are the sources of contract law?
U.S. Constitution and federal statute
State law
Common law (Restatement)
Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
International law
CISG
UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts
How are promises enforced?
With compensatory damages aimed at putting the plaintiff in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed
In exceptional circumstances:
Nominal damages
Punitive damages
Injunctive relief (usually specific performance)
By giving effect to remedial clauses
Law of obligations
Legal relationship arising out of interpersonal interaction
Three categories of legal obligations
Wrongdoing (torts)
Bargains (contracts)
Unjustified enrichment (restitution)
Consideration
A bargained for change in legal position
Feinberg v. Pfeiffer — What is the consideration rule?
An act done before a promise is made cannot serve as consideration because the promisor cannot bargain for services already rendered (Feinberg v. Pfeifer)
Past services cannot constitute consideration because they were not bargained for in exchange for the promise.
Bilateral contract
Promise exchanged for promise
Consideration: Return promise
Contract forms with return promise is made or received
Unilateral contract
Promise exchanged for performance
Consideration: Performance
Contract forms when performance is completed
Gratuitous promise
Promise to make a gift without consideration
Kirksey v. Kirksey — What is the rule for conditions on a gift?
May include certain conditions or stipulations that the promisee must fulfill simply to receive or collect the gift (Kirksey v. Kirksey)
Even if promisee changes their position or performs a required act, if that performance was not bargained for, the promise remains unenforceable as a standard contract (Kirksey v. Kirksey)
A conditional gift promise is an unenforceable gratuitous promise, not a contract, unless the condition was bargained for as consideration rather than just a necessary step to receive the gift
What are the tests for a gratuitous promise?
Is promisor shopping for anything in the world?
Was promise made as part of a bargain?
Did promisor make this promise because they sought something in return?
To constitute consideration, what must a performance or return promise be?
To constitute consideration, a performance or return promise must be bargained for
When is a performance or return promise bargained for?
A performance or return promise is bargained for if it is sought by the promisor in exchange for his promise and given by the promise in exchange for that promise
The performance may consist of
An act other than a promise
A forbearance
The creation, modification, or destruction of a legal relation
Who may give or receive performance or a return promise?
The performance or return promise may be given to the promisor or to some other person and may be given by the promise or by some other person
Illusory promise rule
A promise that leaves performance entirely to the discretion or desire of the promisor is illusory and cannot serve as valid consideration.
Test for illusory promises
Test: Can you easily imagine what non-performance looks like? If the promisor can say, "I'll perform unless I change my mind," it is illusory.
A promise is not consideration if promisor reserves a choice of alternative performance, unless
Each of the alternative performances would have been consideration if it alone had been bargained for; or
One of the choices counts as consideration, and there's a substantial chance that something will happen to remove the choice that does not count as consideration before the promisor has to decide
If requirement of consideration is met, there is no additional requirement of
A gain, advantage, or benefit to the promisor or a loss, disadvantage, or detriment to the promisee (Hamer v. Sidway); or
Equivalence in the values exchanged; or
Mutuality of obligation (requirement that both parties be bound)
Sham exception
If both parties know the consideration is a mere pretense/sham, it will not enforce the contract
Satisfaction clause
A contract term that makes one party's obligation depend on whether something is satisfactory to them
Satisfaction clauses can be non-illusory and enforceable because
Reasonable professional standards may determine satisfaction.
Even without an objective standard, the implied duty of good faith limits the party's discretion.
What promises do not require new consideration under Restatement §§ 82–83?
Promises to fulfill an underlying legal relationship do not require consideration to be enforceable.
Examples under Restatement §§ 82–83
A promise to repay a debt after the statute of limitations has expired is enforceable without new consideration because consideration was already provided when the original debt was created.
A promise to repay a debt discharged in bankruptcy may still be enforceable without new consideration because of the preexisting legal relationship.
Hawkins v. McGee — What are the promise and damages rules?
A statement creates an enforceable promise when it manifests an intention to act in a specified way that reasonably justifies the promisee in understanding that a commitment has been made.
True measure of damages: The difference between the value of a perfect hand and the value of his hand in its present condition.
When may someone recover for professional services protecting another’s life or health?
A person who provides professional services to protect another's life or health may recover restitution to prevent unjust enrichment if circumstances justify intervention without a request
Recovery is measured by a reasonable charge for the services.
When may someone recover for protecting another’s property, and how is recovery measured?
A person who protects another's property from harm may recover restitution to prevent unjust enrichment if circumstances justify intervention without a request, and it is reasonable to assume the owner would want the action performed.
Recovery is measured by the lesser of:
The loss avoided; or
A reasonable charge for the services.
Statute of Frauds
Requires certain contracts to be in writing to be enforceable
Contracts subject to the Statute of Frauds
Marriage (i.e., contracts in consideration of marriage)
Year or more (i.e., contracts that cannot be performed within the space of one year)
Land (i.e., contracts conveying an interest in land)
Executor of estate (i.e., contracts making the executor of an estate liable for debts of the estate)
Goods valued at or above $500
Suretyship or guarantee contracts (i.e., contracts making someone liable for the debts of another)
When is a contract within the Statute of Frauds enforceable (Restatement)?
If it is evidenced by any writing, signed by or on behalf of the party to be charged, which:
Reasonably identifies the subject matter of the contract
Is sufficient to indicate that a contract has been made between the parties or offered by the signer to the other contract party
States with reasonable certainty the essential terms of the unperformed promises in the contract

Bayliner Marine Corp. v. Crow rule
An express warranty requires a factual affirmation or description that relates to the goods and becomes part of the basis of the bargain. Mere opinion or commendation does not create a warranty.
UCC Statute of Frauds
A contract for the sale of goods for the price of $500 or more is not enforceable unless there is writing sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made between the parties and signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought
A writing is not insufficient because it omits or incorrectly states a term agreed upon; but
The contract is not enforceable under this paragraph beyond the quantity of goods shown in such writing
Sullivan v. O’Connor — What is the rule?
Contract damages may include foreseeable pain and suffering resulting from breach, depending on the nature of the contract and circumstances.
When does/doesn’t Article 2 of the UCC apply?
Transactions in goods
Transaction: Transfer of title for a price
Goods: All things moveable at identification of contract for sale, including specially manufactured goods, unborn young animals, growing crops, and things attached to realty (to be severed, and excluding money, investment securities, real estate, and things in action.
Does not apply to security transactions
Security transaction: Securing a debt with property
Does not impair or repeal any statute regulating sales to consumers, farmers or other specified classes of buyers
Permits more precise regulatory frameworks
Hybrid transaction
A contract that merges the sale of goods and the provision of services into a single agreement
Which test applies to a hybrid transaction?
Predominant purpose test
How does the predominant purpose test apply?
Predominant purpose test
If sale of goods predominates→ UCC Article 2 applies
If sale of services predominates → Common law applies
2022 amendment to predominant purpose test
If sale of goods predominates → UCC Article 2 applies
If sale of goods does not predominate → UCC Article 2 still applies to sale of goods aspects
Basis for liability in restitution
Derives from the receipt of a benefit whose retention would result in the unjustified enrichment of the defendant at the expense of the claimant
Requirements for unjust enrichment
Benefit conveyed from P to D
Non-officiously conveyed
Officious: Marked by excessive eagerness in offering unwanted services or advice to others
Rationale: A person cannot force another into a legal obligation to pay for unsolicited or unwanted benefits through unjust enrichment
Non-gratuitously conveyed
If benefit was a gift, D had a license to keep the benefit
Measurable
Can someone who lacks contractual capacity be liable for restitution?
A person who lacks contractual capacity (e.g., insanity) may still be liable in restitution for benefits conferred on them, even without capacity to bargain
Equitable estoppel (representations about legal rights)
Voluntary act, admission, or conduct
That induces someone else to foreseeably change their position (i.e., they reasonably rely on the content of that act, admission, or conduct)
For the worse
A natural person who manifests assent to a transaction has full legal capacity to incur contractual duties thereby unless he is
Under guardianship; or
An infant; or
Mentally ill or defective; or
Intoxicated
If a person is intoxicated he enters into a transaction
He incurs only voidable contractual duties if the other party has reason to know that by reason of the intoxication he is:
Unable to understand in a reasonable manner the nature and consequences of the transaction; or
Unable to act in a reasonable manner in relation to the transaction
There is no manifestation of mutual assent to an exchange if the parties attach materially different meanings to their manifestations and
Neither party knows or has reason to know the meaning attached by the other; or
Each party knows or each party has reason to know the meaning attached by the other
Four principles of assent
If the parties subjectively attach the same meaning to an expression, that meaning prevails even if it is unreasonable.
If the parties subjectively have different understandings, and neither party knows that the other has a different understanding, and the two meanings are not equally reasonable, the more reasonable meaning prevails
If parties attach different meanings, and party A knows that party B attaches a different meaning but B does not know that A attaches a different meaning, then B’s meaning prevails, even if it is less reasonable
If parties subjectively attach different meanings to an expression, and neither party knows that the other party attaches a different meaning, and the two meanings are equally reasonable, neither meaning prevails
Rationale of assent principles
We care about objective meaning, but there are some exceptions
We care about subjective meaning but there are some exceptions
We care about incentives
We care about fault
We care about who is the complainant before the court
US Naval Institute v. Charter Communications, Inc. — What is the rule?
Contract damages generally protect the plaintiff’s expectation interest—the value of the promised performance—not the defendant’s gains.
Damages need not be proven with mathematical precision. Once the fact of damage is established, reasonable uncertainty in calculating the amount is resolved against the breaching party.
Offer
A manifested willingness to enter into a bargain, so made as to justify another person in understanding that his assent to that bargain is invited and will conclude it (i.e., an act whereby one party confers upon another the power to create contractual relations between them)
A manifestation of willingness to enter into a bargain is not an offer if
The person to whom it is addressed knows or has reason to know that the person making it does not intend to conclude a bargain until he has made a further manifestation of assent
Even though a manifestation of intention is intended to be understood as an offer…
It cannot be accepted so as to form a contract unless the terms of the contract are reasonably certain.
The fact that one or more terms of a proposed bargain are left open or uncertain may show that…
A manifestation of intention is not intended to be understood as an offer or as an acceptance.
Open price terms
Parties can conclude a contract for sale if a price isn’t settled, but if the parties intend not to be bound unless the price is fixed or agreed, and the price is not fixed or agreed, there is no contract.
A contract for sale with one or more terms left open does not fail for indefiniteness if:
The parties have intended to make a contract; and
There is a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy.
If the contract doesn’t say otherwise, who gets to choose the shipping arrangements?
The seller
How are offers made?
Manifest willingness
Definite terms
Where the offer is clear, definite, and explicit, and leaves nothing open for negotiation, it constitutes an offer, acceptance of which will complete the contract (Lefkowitz).
How do offers terminate?
Lapse of time
Rejection
Death or incapacity of an offeror
Revocation (explicit or implicit)
Limits on the power to revoke:
Option contracts/firm offers
Start of performance
Reliance
Counteroffer
An offeree’s power of acceptance is terminated by his rejection of the offer, unless:
The offeror has manifested a contrary intention.
A manifestation of intent to not to accept an offer is a rejection unless
The offeree manifests an intention to take it under further advisement
When is the offeree’s power of acceptance terminated?
At the time specified in the offer or, if no time is specified, at the end of a reasonable time
What is a reasonable time for the purpose of terminating offers?
Depends on all the circumstances existing when the offer and attempted acceptance are made
What happens to an offer upon death or loss of legal capacity?
An offeree’s power of acceptance is terminated when the offeree or offeror dies or is deprived of legal capacity to enter into the proposed contract.