1/82
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Speech motor control
Speech involves voluntary goal-directed movements (requires sensorimotor integration - feedforward and feedback)
Motor Speech Disorders (MSDs)
Speech disorders of neurological impairments affecting the motor control of speech
Apraxia of Speech (AOS)
planning level lesion; "Disconnection of motor programs for skilled movements from the mind"
AOS speech characteristics
1) segmental articulation errors (primarily on consonants, distortions, errors with coarticulation + increased complexity)
2) reduced fluency (repetitions of sounds/syllables, self correction, initiation difficulties accompanied by searching behaviors)
3) disruption in temporal prosody (slowed rate, syllables segregated by pauses, prolonged sounds)
4) errors increasing with increasing word length + phonetic complexity
5) more errors in novel/less practical utterances + nonsense words
Dysarthria
Execution level lesion; Abnormalities in strength, speed, range, steadiness, tone or accuracy of movement resulting in weakness, spasticity and incoordination
Knowledge we draw from
Duffy + DAB; Also, our understanding of and clinical approach to motor speech disorders must be grounded in knowledge and literature of typical/healthy speech motor control.
Broca's area
language motor planning
Basal ganglia (BG)
smooth and refine movement plans; net output: Primary inhibition function (inhibiting "doors" staying shut and letting motor programs in)
Cerebellum
coordination, aim, and spatial information
BG direct circuit
Important for initiation of movement; Lesion -> hypokinetic dysarthria
BG indirect circuit
Important for inhibition of extra movement; Lesion -> hyperkinetic dysarthria
MSD contemporary topics
1) units of control is not straightforward on which brain picks up
2) acoustic output of a given sound can be accomplished by variations in speech movements (and movement combinations)
3) speech is highly variable
4) motor speech is only 1 part of what client may be going through; considering disease course
5) speech happens across multiple levels/subsystems; movements impacting one another
speech motor equivalence
I can accomplish the same goal by using different movement combinations
Speech motor invariance
what is constant; speech sound identification
NO!
Is limb and/or non-speech oral apraxia always present with AOS or CAS?
contemporary view of motor programming
production of rapid, discrete movements involves unit of action (motor programs) that are retrieved from memory and adapted to the situation
motor program
memory representations that encode relations among various kinds of information, based on past experiences with producing similar actions; Does NOT apply to all movements
storage and novelty issue
have to have a way to generate new motor programs; brain cannot store infinite motor program possibilities
Generalized Motor Program (GMP)
addresses the issue of novelty with a set of generalized instructions and modifications to certain specific parameters (absolute timing, force, specific muscles) as needed
Mayo clinic classification
- key idea is speech impairment characteristics have localizing value (specifically for dysarthria types)
- clinically, don't stop at just confirmation of lesion site -> account for all of person's speech characteristics (There is some relation between neurological diagnosis and type of dysarthria, but it's not always 1:1)
- the same perceptual feature can have diff clinical presentations across dysarthria types
Flaccid dysarthria
- LMN lesion
- Perceptual features: monopitch, monoloudness, harsh/continuous breathy voice, slow rate, short phrases, hypernasality, nasal emission, imprecise consonants; "slurred" quality, audible inspiration
- Acoustics: reduced pause frequency + duration, slower rate, restricted F0 variation
- Clinical presentation: hypotonia (decreased tone, flaccid muscles, fasciculations (visible, fine, and fast contractions of fine muscle fibers that occur spontaneously + intermittently)
Spastic dysarthria
- bilateral UMN lesion
- Perceptual features: abnormally low pitch, pitch breaks, monopitch, harsh/continuous breathy voice, strained-strangled voice, monoloudness, hypernasality, slow rate, short phrases, reduced/excess+equal stress, reduced stress consonants,
- Acoustics: shorter breath groups/speech runs, reduced maximum vowel prolongation, slow rate, reduced F0, reduced vowel space
- Clinical presentation: hypertonia, weakness/paresis but not atrophy, pseudobulbar palsy
Ataxic dysarthria
- Bilateral Cerebellum lesion
- Perceptual features: monopitch, voice tremor, harsh voice, hyponasality, monoloudness, excess loudness variation, slow rate, prolonged intervals, excess/equal stress, imprecise consonants, prolonged phonemes, irregular breakdowns, distorted vowels, "scanning speech"
- Acoustics: decreased rate
- Clinical presentation: ataxia, dysrhythmia (abnormal timing), dysmetria (abnormal trajectories -> hyper and hypo), intention tremor (tremor during uncoordinated movement), unsteady gait, dysdiadochokinesia, dysynergia (decomposition of movement)
- Moderate amount of cases from Friedrich's Ataxia (37%)
Hypokinetic dysarthria
- BG direct pathway lesion
- Perceptual features: abnormally low pitch, monopitch, harsh/continuous breathy voice, monoloudness, reduced overall loudness, fast rate, increased rate in segments/overall, reduced stress, variable rate, inappropriate silences, short rushes of speech, imprecise consonants, palilalia (repeated syllables), reduced stress contrasts
- Acoustics: irregular breath/pause patterns, reduced vowel working space, increased/abnormal nasalization
- Clinical presentation: bradykinesia (movement slowness and difficulty initiating movement), hypokinesia (reduced movement), akinesia, resting tremor, festination phenomenon, muscle rigidity, postural instability, shuffling gait
- Most cases from Parkinson's Disease (89%)
Hyperkinetic dysarthria
- BG indirect pathway lesion
- Perceptual features: inappropriate silences, voice stoppages, prolonged intervals, excessive loudness variations/alternating loudness, irregular articulatory breakdowns, vowel distortions, imprecise consonants, strained/harsh voice quality, transient breathiness, audible forced inspiration
- Clinical presentation: hyperkinetic, dyskinesia (abnormal, involuntary movement), myoclonus (involuntary body part "jerks"), tics, chorea, dystonia, tremor, athetosis (writhing movement), ballism
- Most cases undetermined (89%)
MSD general eval considerations
Age of onset
Cause (lesion/neurological diagnosis)
Pathophysiology
Speech subsystems involvement
Severity
Perceptual characteristics
Comprehensive MSD eval
General intake
Oral mechanism exam
Structures at rest + sustained postures: tone, other LMN signs, strength
AMRs + SMRs: rate, range, accuracy
Auditory-perceptual characteristics (+ intelligibility)
Contextual speech
Respiratory-laryngeal integrity
Prosody
Testing for AOS
Respiratory function eval testing
administer passage reading to evaluate phrase length (# of words per utterance) and breath pause pattern (Frequency of pauses and where)
Laryngeal function eval testing
include vowel prolongation to supplement conversational speech to assess stability in voice and voice quality with clinician perceptual rating
articulation eval testing
examine articulatory precision and contrast with the kent intelligibility word test (clinical judgment of distinctiveness between minimal word pairs and descriptions of productions and % word pairs accurately distinguished); considering precision, distortions, repetitions, and coordination
Velopharyngeal sufficiency eval testing
test sentences with nasals and high-pressure consonants to assess intro-oral pressure sufficiency and resonance (# occurrence of nasal emission, # nasals with insufficient nasality, # stops/fricatives/affricates with imprecision or distortion)
rate (prosody) eval testing
evaluate phrase length (# words per utterance), pause duration (silence in milliseconds), and rate of speech (syllables per second) in connected speech tasks of conversation and passage reading
stress/emphasis (prosody) eval testing
administer passage reading with the caterpillar passage and assess the use of pitch, loudness, and duration when stressing syllables and giving emphasis in speech (clinical perceptual judgment of sufficient/insufficent stress and emphasis)
speech participation eval testing
administer the communicative participation item bank (CPIB) to document patient reported social participation impact of speech
contextual speech
- "the most useful task for evaluating the integrated function of all aspects of speech"
- requires all speech subsystems to work together in functional speech tasks
- example tasks: Reading passage, picture description/narrative, conversation (free, prompts/topics, specific interactions such as with family member)
Frenchay Dysarthria Assessment-second edition (FDA-2)
- 8 sections: reflexes, respiration, lips, palate, laryngeal, tongue, intelligibility, influencing factors
- "relies heavily on patient reports and ratings of nonspeech oromotor activities, and it does not yield an adequate description of the specific deviant speech characteristics associated with each dysarthria type. For these reasons, it may be viewed most appropriately as a measure that distinguishes among patients with different lesion loci on the basis on nonspeech observations and a limited set of speech observations, rather than a differential diagnostic test of the auditory perceptual features of dysarthria per se."
- diagnostic test, does not guide treatment decision
Apraxia Battery for Adults-second edition (ABA-2)
Subtests: diadochokinetic rate, increasing word length, limb+oral apraxia, latency time and utterance time for polysyllabic words, repeated trials test, inventory of articulation characteristics of apraxia
Dysarthria impact profile (DIP)
Looks at functional communication challenges
Apraxia of speech rating scale (ASRS)
Identifying and describing speech symptoms, mainly auditory-perceptual characteristics
Intelligiblity
- Directly related to acoustics (requires decoding of acoustic information)
- Sufficiency of speech signals
- Relative understandability of speech
- Prime candidate for indexing functional communication
Speech intelligibility test (SIT)
- randomization of stimuli that allow for test and re-test, inclusion of sentence-level stimuli being more functional than word-level only, and rate can be measured.
- When the timer function is used, the test can calculate overall speaking rates, rate of intelligible speech measured in words per minute, and a communication efficiency ratio
- vowel/consonant matrix can be generated from word test portion
- Word and sentence intelligibility by orthographic transcription
Percentage intelligibility measure by transcription on reading passage
good way to document and track intelligibility, although there is the risk of practice effects with just one passage.
% correct
Assessment of intelligibility of dysarthria speech (AIDS)
Word and sentence intelligibility by orthographic transcription
comprehensibility
- the message (takes into account contextual information and entails making sense of the message)
- Understanding entirety of message = speech (intelligibility) + everything else (gestures, context, facial expressions, body language, environmental cues, etc
- rely on this in functional communication
criteria for evaluative measures
1) demonstrated sensitivity to dysarthria... (severity + type differences)
2) relevance to functional speech communication
3) a direct measure of movement, or a measure that can be interpreted in terms of speech movement
4) ease and simplicity of application and interpretation
(acoustic measures fit these criteria)
acoustic measures
Bias within auditory-perceptual methods, these measures establish better reliability
recording speech considerations
1) Physical environment, including background noise level
2) Client's positioning
3) The recording device setup
- Computer and operating system
- Praat version
- Distance between client's mouth and internal microphone
Respiratory phrasing measures
- Number of pauses, average pause duration, standard deviation of pause duration, number of speech runs, average speech run duration, standard deviation of speech run durations
- Dysarthria types:
1) Flaccid: reduced pause frequency
2) Spastic: shorter breath groups/speech runs
3) Flaccid-spastic: increased frequency of pauses, reduced breath group/speech run length
4) Hypokinetic: irregular breath/pause patterns
Speech timing measures
- Speech rate for the selected segment, average articulation rate per speech run, standard deviation of articulation rate per speech run
- Dysarthria types:
1) Flaccid: slower rate
2) Spastic: slow rate
3) Flaccid-spastic: slow rate, reduced speed and range of articulatory movements
4) Ataxic: reduced rate
F1
How high or low tongue is in the oral cavity; relationship with vowel articulation NOT straightforward
F2
How front/forward or back in the oral cavity, increased means more forward in tract; relationship with vowel articulation NOT straightforward
Vowel Acoustics
- Vowel ranges correlate with increased intelligibility and distinction of each vowel; vowels closer together will have less distinction for the listener to differ.
- Speakers with dysarthria tend to have shorter vowel distances. Treatment may contain strategies meant to improve vowel distinction, thus improving intelligibility. Obtaining these measures can allow for documentation of baseline and the tracking of effectiveness of particular strategies.
Quadrilateral vowel space
- There are dialectal and individual variations
- shape has to do with the relationships and distances among the vowels
- constructed by F1 and F2 of vowels /i/, /æ/, /ɑ/, and /u/
- dysarthria types:
1) Spastic: reduced vowel space
2) Flaccid-spastic: reduced vowel space
3) Hypokinetic: reduced vowel working space
F2 slope
- well suited to make inferences to speech motion and to predict speech intelligibility; reflective of tongue movement in terms of speed and range
- A shallower/flatter or less extended slope may be expected for speakers with dysarthria
- This measure is widely used in PD and ALS to index articulation
Differential diagnosis
The nature of the problem should be established as clearly as possible because we usually treat more adequately what we understand than what we do not understand
Harsh voice
Voice is harsh, rough, and raspy.
Hoarse voice
There is wet, "liquid-sounding" hoarseness.
Strained-strangled voice
Voice quality sounds strained or strangled (an apparently effortful squeezing of voice through glottis).
Excess loudness variation
Voice shows sudden, uncontrolled alterations in loudness, sometimes becoming too loud, sometimes too quiet.
Alternating loudness
Alternating changes in loudness within an utterance.
Fast rate
rate of speech is abnormally rapid
Short rushes of speech
There are short, rapid rushes of speech separated by pauses.
reduced stress
Speech shows reduction of proper stress or emphasis patterns.
excess and equal stress
There is excess stress on usually unstressed syllables or parts of speech.
Imprecise consonants
1) Flaccid -> "slurred" quality, prominent weakness, resonance involvement = lack of precision
2) Spastic -> effortful, strained-strangeld voice
3) Ataxic -> irregular breakdowns, rhythm/timing component
4) Hypokinetic -> may be related to fast rate (accelerated rate, short rushes of speech), also: (bradykinesia and hypokinesia)
5) Hyperkinetic -> disruptions/interruptions bc of excessive/unwanted movements
Articulatory breakdowns
For AOS, increased task complexity will increase errors; for ataxic dysarthria, increased task complexity, errors will remain the same; Breakdown denotes an abnormality in subsystem
primary distinguishing features of AOS
1) Distorted sound substitutions
2) Distorted sound additions (not including intrusive schwa)
3) Increased sound distortions or distorted sound substitutions with increased utterance length or increased syllable/word articulatory complexity
4) Increased sound distortions or distorted sound substitutions with increased speech rate
5) Inaccurate (off-target in place or manner) speech AMR's
6) Reduced words per breath group relative to maximum vowel duration
AOS vs Aphasia
AOS:
- location/types of errors inconsistent from trial to trial
- Successive self-initiated trial to repair errors
- disruption in temporal prosody
- articulatory hesitancy and groping
- errors influenced by articulatory complexity
Aphasia:
- variable but typically normal interword intervals, movement + vowel durations
- Clear substitution errors/no distortions
- may be unaware of speech errors
AOS vs. Dysarthria
AOS:
- no abnormalities in speech subsystems
- Presence of articulatory searching/groping, distorted sound additions, and increased difficulty/errors with increased word length + complexity
Dysarthria:
- Presence of muscle paralysis/paresis and involuntary movement
- Speech subsystem deficits/abnormalities
CAS important diagnostic candidates
1) Inconsistent consonant + vowel errors
2) lengthened/disrupted coarticulation
3) Inappropriate prosody (especially stress)
Restorative approach
decrease impairment and increase physiologic support for speech
Compensatory approach
reducing limitations and restrictions
1) prosthetic compensation
2) behavioral compensation
3) social compensation
Respiratory TX approaches
1) respiratory muscle strength training
2) breath patterning
3) behavioral techniques, postural adjustments, preparatory inhalation, controlled inhalation/ exhalation
Laryngeal TX approaches
1) LVST loud / speak out
2) speechvive
3) vocal function exercises
4) effortful closure technique
5) velopharyngeal management
articulation TX approaches
1) clear speech / SPEAK OUT
2) phonetic placement techniques
3) articulatory-kinematic approach
4) emphatic/contrastive stress
rate TX approaches
1) slowed rate
2) pacing board
3) rhythmic cueing
prosody TX approaches
1) emotional prosody / MIT
2) contrastive/emphatic stress / SPEAK OUT
AAC TX approaches
1) alphabet cueing
2) topic cueing
3) gestural cueing
4) syntactic cueing
5) speech generating AAC
6) voice/message banking
MSD TX goal
maximizing use of functional speech (restorative tx) and develop approaches to facilitate communication (compensatory tx)
Severity considerations
- Severe: establish functional means of communication (Consider if there is any residual usable speech vs no intelligible/usable speech)
- Moderate: maximizing intelligibility via compensated intelligibility (ex using gestures or context clues)
- Mild: maximizing communication efficiency and speech naturalness while maintaining intelligibility → full participation in life situations
Etiology considerations
- Improving: Short term use of compensatory strategies with emphasis on remediating impairment)
- Degenerating: staging of compensatory strategies
- chronic/stable: long term use of compensatory strategies
Goal writing considerations
- Collaboration with client, family, caregiver... (as well as interprofessionally)
- Significance of understanding the mechanisms for improving functional communication (understand how a treatment works not just that it works... be able to motivate and justify)
- Combination and balance of restorative and compensatory approaches (maximize and optimize)
- Task considerations: meaningful and functional, doable but challenging, considering how to progress task
Goal components
specific, approach/strategy, desirable outcome, outcome measure, contextual considerations, cohesion