1/96
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Elements of a contract
offer, acceptance, consideration, consent, capacity, legality
When evaluating a scenario, identify:
who is suing who and for what, bilateral or unilateral, comman law or UCC, does statute of frauds apply, apply 6 elements, if contract can be enforced and what remedy may apply
bilateral contracts
promise for promis, both parties make commitments, acceptance by promising
example of bilateral contracts
transactions/sale of goods
unilateral contracts
promises for performance, one party promises in exchange for act, acceptance by performing requested act
example of unilateral contract
lottery, games of chance
common law
services, land, real estate, stricter offer and acceptance, mirror image rule, requires new consideration for mods, more demandinga bout missing essential terms
UCC
sale of tangible goods, flexible formation rules, batle of the forms rules, doesnt require new consideration for good faith mods, can supply reasonable missing terms
valid
binding and enforceable
void
no legal effectvo
voidable
one party has right to cancel
unenforceable
agreement may exist but cannot be enforced due to legal barrier
implied-in-fact
agreement inferred from conduct
executed
contractual obligations completed
executory
performance remains outstanding
promissory estoppel
reasonably foreseeable promise induces detrimental reliance, and injustice would result without relief. can provide a remedy even without ordinary consideration
quasi contract (unfair enrichment)
a court can requre payment for benefits received to avoid unfair enrichment, often measured in quantum meruit
quantum meruit
reasonable value of services
consideration (bargained-for legal detriment)
a person agrees to do something they are not legally obligated to do, or refrains from something they have the legal right to do, in exchange for a promise (does not have to involve money)
bargained-for exchange
both parties must exchange promises, actions, or legal rights as part of their agreement
adequacy of consideration
courts do not examine whether the exchange was financially fair
exception to adequacy of consideration
disguised gifts, unconscionability, or improper pressure
where consideration fails
illusory promise, preexisting duty, past consideration
illusory promise
a supposed promise does not actually require the promisor to do anything (no enforceable commitment)
preexisting duty
promising to do something you are already legally requried to do
past consideration
a benefit supplied before a promise is made generally cannot support that later promise
common law modification
generally requires new consideration
common law with unforeseen difficulty
court may enforce modification when unexpected circustances make performance harder
UCC goods modification
no new consideration required, but must be in good faith
UCC modification involving coercion or fraud
can be invalid
UCC modification triggering statue of frauds
still must satisfy applicable writing requirements
liquidated debt
amount owed is undisputed, debtor already has a duty to pay full amount
unliquidated debt
dispute over existence or amount owed, good faith settlement can create an enforceable accord and satisfaction, resolution of dispute provides consideration
debt composition agreement
2+ creditors agree to accept an agreed percentage of their claims against the same debtor
other consideration exceptions
output contract, requirement contract, exclusive dealing, moral obligation, charitable subscribtion, time-barred or discharged debts
output contract
buyer agrees to purchase all production of a particular good from a producer
requirement contract
supplier agrees to provide all of a buyers actual requirements for a particular good
exclusive dealing
parties are obligated to use their best efforts, commitments are not automatically illusory
moral obligation
promise motivated solely by gratitude or moral duty lacks consideration
charitable subscription
may be enforceable through promissory estoppel when an org has relied on a promise
time-barred/discharged debts
some states recognize renewed promises to pay debts barred by limitation periods or bankruptcy discharge, subject to specific requirements
promissory estoppel components
a promise that should reasonably induce reliance, the promisee actually relies on it, injustice would result if the promise were not enforced or remedied
innocent misrepresentation
no fraudulent intent, injured party may rescind, scienter not required
fraud
knowingly false statement with scienter (intent to deceive), injured party may rescind and potentially sue for damages
for a misrepresentation claim, identify:
false assertion of fact, fact is material to the decision to contract, actual reliance of the assertion, justifiable reliance under the circumstances
mutual mistake
both parties mistaken, concerns a basic assumption, must materailly affect exchange, party seeking avoidance must not bear the risk
unilateral mistake
only one party mistake, generally more difficult to establish, look for other party causing/knowing of mistake and unconscionable enforcement
duress
improper threat or wrongful act that leaves someone no reasonable alternative but to agree
undue influence
improper persuasion arising from a relationship of trust, dependency, or vulnerability
consent defects (contracts effected are generally voidable)
fraud/misrepresentation, mutual/unilateral mistake, duress, undue influence
Statute of Frauds MYLEGS
marriage, year, land, executor, goods, surety. must be evidenced in writing to be enforceable
year
cannot possibly be performed within one year of formation
land
sale or transfer of an interest in real property
executor
personally promises to pay a deceased persons debt
goods
sale of goods worth $500+
surety
a third party guarantees someone elses debt
what satisfies SoF writing requirement
identification of parties, reasonably identified subject matter, signature of party against whom enforcement is saught, essential agreement terms, quantity (for goods contracts)
UCC exceptions
merchant confirmatory memandorum, partial payment/delivery, admission in court, specialyl manufactured goods
merchant confirmatory memorandum
between merchants, an appropriate written confirmation can satisfy sof rules
partial payment/delivery
can support enforcement for goods paid for/received and accepted
admission in court
party acknowledges a sales contract existed
specially manufactured goods
custom goods not suitable for ordinary resale may qualify for an exception
parol evidence rule
when parties intend in a written agreement to be the complete and final expression of their contract, prior or contemporaneous statements generally cannot contradict, add to, or change its terms
requirements for a valid offer
intent, definitiveness, communication
offer intent
objective manifestation of a present intention to be legally bound
offer definitiveness
terms must be sufficiently clear
offer communication
offer must be communicated to the offeree
offers vs invitations to negotiate
advertisements are not offers, ex. displaying a product and price or requesting a bid
how offers terminate
revocation, rejection, counteroffer, lapse of time, death or incapacity, destruction or illegality
revocation
offeror withdraws offer before acceptance, with communication to the offeree
counteroffer
offeree proposes materially different terms
lapse of time
deadline passes, or a reasonable period expires
death or incapacity
either party dies or becomes legally incapable before acceptance
destruction or illegality
subject matter is destroyed or proposed transaction becomes illegal
exceptions to revocation
option contract, UCC firm offer, unilateral performance, promissory estoppel
option contract
separate agreement supported by consideration to keep an offer open
UCC firm offer
qualifying merchants written commitment to keep a goods offer open
unilateral performance
beginning requested performance may limit revocation
valid acceptance
intends to accept the offer, agrees to its proposed terms under applicable legal rules, communicates acceptance in an unauthorized or reasonable manner
Common law mirror-image rule
acceptance must generally match the offer
UCC battle of the forms
a definite, timely acceptance can form a contract even if it contains additional or different terms
battle of the forms when both parties are merchants
additional terms generally become part of the contract unless: offer expressly limits acceptance to its own terms, additional terms materially change agreement, offeror objects within a reasonable time
mailbox rule
acceptance becomes effective when dispatched, not received
silence
not acceptance, unless previous dealings or circumstances may make it reasonable to expect the offeree to reject an offer expressively
acceptance through shipment
an order may be accepted by a prompt promise to ship or by shipment of goods
capacity
legal ability to incur contractual obligations and acquire rights
minors
generally has the right to disaffirm a contract. only minor or their guardian can invoke right to disaffirm, the minor can generally disaffirm while underage or for a reasonable time after reaching majority, necessaries are an important exception, an agreement may be ratified after the minor reaches majority through workds or conduct
necessaries
basic food, shelter, clothing, medical care, essential educational or vocational expenses
what happens if a minor disaffirms
parties generally must return what they received
mental incapacity
a persons mental condition prevents them from sufficiently understanding the nature and consequences of the contract. void if established before signing, voidable if established after execution
intoxication
impairment must be extreme enough to prevent understanding the nature of the bargaining process
illegal agreements
generally unenforceable, and courts ordinarily refuse to award remedies for breach
licensing laws to protect the public
unlicensed professionals contract is unenforceable
licensing law to raise government revenue
contract may still be enforceable
unconscionability
an agreement can be unconscionable if one party lacks meaningful choice and the terms are excessively one-sided
procedural unconscionability
problem in how the contract was formed, unequal bargaining power or improper bargaining process
substantive unconscionability
problem with the contracts terms, extremely oppressive, unfair, or harsh provisions