1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What was milgrams interest into obedience sparked by?
Eichmann's trial for war crimes - in charge of Nazi death camps
His defence was that he was just following orders
Led Milgram to propose odedience to destructive authority occurs bc person doesn’t take resposibility
What is an agent?
acts for or in place of another
Not unfeeling -> they experience high anxiety when they realise what they are doing is wrong but feel powerless to disobey
What is an agentic state?
Mental state where we feel no personal responsibility for our behaviour → we believe ourselves to be acting for an authority figure - eg. as their agent
Frees us from the demands of our consciences & allows us to even obey destructive authority figures
What is autonomous state?
Opposite of agentic state
Person in autonomous state - free to behave according to their own principles & feels sense of responsibility for their actions
What is the angentic shift?
The shift from autonomy to agency
Milgram suggested that this occurs when a person perceives someone else as authority figure
Authority figure has greater power because higher position in social hierarchy.
In most social groups when one person in charge, others defer to legitimate authority of this person & shift from autonomy to agency
What are binding factors?
Migrams participants said they wanted to stop but seemed powerless & remained in agentic state
Binding factors → aspects of the situation that allows the person to ignore /minimise the damaging affect of their behaviour & thus reduce their moral strain
eg. shifting responsibility to victim/denying damage they were doing to victims
What is legitimacy of authority?
Explanation for obedience which suggests that we are more likely to obey people who we perceive to have authority over us
This authority is justified by the individuals position of power within a social hierarchy
Most people accept that authority figures have to be allowed social power over others -> allows society to function
What is a consequence of legitimacy of authority?
Some people granted power to punish others -> people have to be willing to give up independence & hand control of our behaviour to people we trust to exercise their authority properly
Where do we learn legitimacy of authority?
Acceptance of legitimacy of authority -> learned through socialisation from childhood - from parents initially & then teachers & adults generally
When do problems arise with legitimate authority?
When it become destructive authority
History often shown that charismatic & powerful leaders eg.Hitler can use their legitimate power for destructive purposes eg. ordering people to act in cruel / dangerous ways
How was destructive authority shown in Milgram’s study?
Experimenter used prods to order participants to behave in ways that went against their consciences
What is a strength of the agentic state?
Milgrams own studies support role of agentic state in obedience
Most of Milgrams participants resisted giving shocks at some point -> often asked the experimenter questions about the procedure
One was 'Who is responsible if the learner is harmed?’ & when Experimenter replied 'I'm responsible’ participants often went through procedure with no further objections
Shows that once participants perceived they weren't responsible for their behaviour -> acted more easily as Experimenters agent
What is a limitation of the agentic shift?
Doesn’t explain many research findings about obedience
Eg. Rank & Jacobson's study: 16 out of 18 hospital nurses disobeyed orders from doctor to administer excessive drug dose to patient
Doctor was an obvious authority figure but most nurses remained autonomous as well as many of Milgram's participants
Suggests at best the agentic shift can only account for some situations of obedience
What is an opposing view to Rank & Jacobson's study?
Kelman & Hamilton: argue that real world crimes of obedience such as the My Lai massacre can be understood in terms of power hierarchy of US army -> COs operate within clearer legitimate hierarchy than doctors & have greater power to punish
What was the obedience alibi & how does it challenge agentic state?
Situational variables dangerous -> Mandel - offers an excuse for evil behaviour
Mandel described an incident in Second World War involving German Reserve Police Battalion 101 -> these men shot civilians in a small town in Poland despite not having direct orders to do so -> challenges agentic sate → behaved autonomously
What is a strength of the legitimacy explanation?
Useful account of explaining cultural differences in obedience
Many studies show countries differ in degree of obedience to authority
Kilham & Mann: only 16% of female Australian participants went to 450 V in Milgram style study
HOWEVER Mantell: 85% of German participants reached 450V
Shows in some cultures -> authority more likely to be accepted as legitimate & entitled to demand obedience from individuals
Reflects ways different societies structured & how children raised to perceive authority figures
What is a limitation of the legitimacy explanation?
Can't explain disobedience in hierarchy where legitimacy of authority accepted
EG. nurses in Rank & Jacobson's study -> most disobedient despite working in rigid authority structure
Also significant minority of Milgrams participants disobeyed despite recognising Experimenters scientific authority -> suggest people just more /less obedient
Possible that innate tendencies to obey/disobey have greater influence on behaviour than legitimacy of authority figure