1/43
Looks like no tags are added yet.
open ended questions
questions that allow someone to explain an answer in their own words
close ended questions
questions that require short, specific answers, often yes/no or a particular detail
demands of an interview
mental effort required to remember an event, understand questions, and communicate information
difficulty of an interview
witnesses may be stressed, confused, traumatized, or have trouble remembering details
negative of traditional investigate interview
can lead witnesses toward certain answers, influence memory, or cause important info to be missed due to direct questions, interruptions, and assumptions
cognitive interview (ci)
designed to help witnesses remember as much accurate info as possible
encourages witnesses to mentally recreate the event and report everything they remember
factors affecting child witnesses
age, memory development, language skills, ability to understand questions, vulnerability to leading questions and suggestions from adults
NICHD protocol
method designed to help children provide accurate info about events by using open-ended questions and encouraging children to describe what happened
avoids leaiding/suggestive questions
factors affecting older adult witnesses
age-related memory changes, attention, hearing, vision, stress, and unfamiliar interview environment(s)
factors affecting witnesses w intellectual and developmental disabilities
differences in communication, memory, understanding, and suggestibility
use simple language, clear questions, and allow for extra time for responses
physical interview context
environment where interview takes place
lighting, noise, temp, privacy, seating, and distractions can affect witness comfort and memory
information-gathering approach
collecting accurate info from suspect rather than forcing a confession
accusatorial approach
assumes suspect is guilty and uses confrontation and questioning techniques to obtain a confession
REID tehcnique
suspect-interviewing method using confrontation, psychological pressure, and persuasion to obtain confession
can increase risk of false confession, especially if suspect is vulnerable
often begins by assuming suspect is guilty
PEACE technique
interviewing method focused on gathering info rather than confession
emphasizes open-ended questions, active listening, and evaluating evidence
meant to reduce pressure and encourage accurate accounts
false confessions
when someone admits to committing a crime they did not commit
false confessions: risk factors
age (younger = more vulnerable), intellectual disabilities, mental health, sleep deprivation, interrogation pressure, and suggestibility
SUE technique (strategic use of evidence)
strategically presenting evidence to suspect to spot inconsistencies between evidence and statement
allows investigators to note suspect’s response to what investigator knows
SUE technique: phases
pre-interview: collect evidence and prepare questions
initial questioning: ask suspect for statement prior to revealing evidence
evidence presentation: slowly show evidence and observe suspect’s response
evaluation: compare suspect’s statements with available evidence and identify inconsistencies
the role of eyewitness
person who saw event and provides info about what they saw/experienced
able to help investigators identify suspects and reconstruct crimes
eyewitness importance
can play major role in investigations and trials
are not always reliable/accurate, even when someone is confident
eyewitness research
examines why eyewitnesses sometimes make mistakes and what affects memory accuracy
process of remembering
encoding: taking in info when event happens
storage: keeping that info in memory over time
retrieval: bringing the info back when asked to remember it
factors that influence eyewitnesses: estimator variables
factors that affect memory accuracy but cannot be controlled by justice system
ex. lighting, distance, stress, weapon presence, viewing time, age
factors that influence eyewitnesses: system variables
factors that the justice system can control to improve eyewitness accuracy
ex. lineups, questions asked, presentation of identification procedures
official guidance: testimony
guidelines for how eyewitness evidence should be collected and presented in court
goal: help jurors understand that memory can be inaccurate and that confidence does not equal accuracy
official guidance: identification
guidelines for how police should conduct identification, such as lineups
procedures should avoid influencing witnesses toward a particular suspect
theories of deception: mental process theories
explain lying by examining the mental effort involved in creating and maintaining a false story
theories of deception: strategic models
explain how ppl decide when, why, and how to lie based on situation
theories of deception: social psychologiacal theories
explain how social situations, relationships, emotions, and social expectations influence lying
lie-catchers’ performance
refers to how accurately ppl can determine whether someone is lying or not
misconceptions about deceptive behavior
incorrect belief that liars always avoid eye contact, fidget, look nervous, or stumble over words
truthful ppl can also display this
realism in deception detection studies
examines whether deception experiments accurately represent real-life situations
statement validity assessment (SVA)
method used to evaluate whether someone’s statement is likely to be based on an actual experience
examines content and quality of a person’s statement rather than just their behavior
often used during children statements in abuse investigations
reality monitoring (RM)
technique that examines differences between memories of real experiences and imagined events
real memories tend to contain more sensory details, contextual info, and descriptions
psycho-physiological detection of deception
methods that measure physical responses from the body to try to determine whether someone is lying
ex. heart rate, breathing, blood pressure, and sweating
control question test (CQT)
polygraph that compares a person’s physical reactions to different types of questions
compares responses to relevant questions about crime with responses to broader control questions
assumes that deceptive individuals may react more strongly to questions about the crime
validity of the CQT
debated; physical reaction do not equal some is lying
concealed info test (CIT)
designed to determine whether someone recognizes info about crime that only someone familiar with event would know
compares responses to crime-related details with responses to similar but irrelevant details
validity of CIT
useful for detecting whether someone recognizes concealed info
BUT recognized info does not prove someone committed the crime
countermeasures
actions someone takes to try to manipulate or interfere with results of a deception detection test
strategic interviewing to elicit and enhance cues to deception
designed to make it easier to identify inconsistencies between truthful and deceptive accounts
cognitive load approach
technique that increases the mental effort required during interview
idea that lying may require more mental effort than telling the truth
interviewers may ask unexpected questions or ask someone to explain events in reverse order
verifiability approach
asks interviewees to provide details that can be independently checked
truthful individuals may be able to provide details that investigators can verify