1/46
Subject Matter Jurisdiction
A court’s authority to decide a claim
State Law Claims
Created by state legislation or state common law (examples: breach of contract, negligence)
Federal Law Claims
Created by federal law (examples: securities fraud, workplace discrimination)
State Courts
General Jurisdiction (can hear all claims & non-exclusive federal claims)
Federal Courts
Limited Jurisdiction (can hear federal law claims & certain state claims under diversity jurisdiction)
Exclusive Jurisdiction
Only federal courts can hear the claim
Concurrent Jurisdiction
Either state or federal courts can hear the claim
Default Jurisdiction
State court hears the claim because federal jurisdiction is unavailable
State courts cannot hear federal claims if they fall under CAPS
Copyright, Antitrust, Patent, Securities
Requirements for Diversity Jurisdiction
(1) Complete Diversity and (2) Amount in Controversy
Diversity Jurisdiction
Allows a plaintiff to bring a state law claim in federal court if requirements are met.
Complete Diversity
No plaintiff can be a citizen of the same state as any defendant
Amount in Controversy (AIC)
Must be greater than $75,000
Citizenship - Natural Person
State of domicile
Citizenship - Corporation
State(s) of incorporation AND principal place of business
Citizenship - Partnership
Every state where each partner is a citzen
When Citizenship is Determined
At the commencement of the lawsuit
Changing Citizenship - Natural Person
Physical presence in the new state + intent to stay
Aggregation Rules: One Plaintiff vs. One Defendant
Can aggregate all claims, even if unrelated claims
Aggregation Rules: One Plaintiff vs. Multiple Defendants
Cannot combine separate claims
Aggregation Rules: Multiple Plaintiffs vs. One Defendant
Cannot combine individual claims
Alienage Jurisdiction
Between a citizen of a state and citizens or subjects of a foreign state
Requirements for Alienage Jurisdiction
(1) State citizen on one side (2) Non-LPRA on the other side (3) Amount in Controversy
Lawful Permanent Resident Alien
LPRA - no alienage jurisdiction when an LPRA is domiciled in the same state as the other party.
Adding Aliens
Once complete diversity exists between state citizens, aliens can be added on either/both sides.
Both Aliens
Federal courts cannot hear state law claims when both plaintiff and defendant are aliens (state courts can)
Federal Question Jurisdiction
Based on cases arising under the Constitution, Laws, or Treaties of the United States
Requirements for Federal Question Jurisdiction
(1) Well Pleaded Complaint (2) Centrality (3) Substantiality
Well-Pleaded Complaint Rule
The federal issue must appear in the plaintiff’s properly pleaded claim.
Federal Question Jurisdiction cannot be based on:
(1) a defense the defendant expects to raise (2) federal counterclaim asserted by the defendant (3) passing reference to federal law that is not important to the plaintiff’s claim
Declaratory Judment Action
Asks the court to declare the parties’ rights
Centrality
The federal issue must be central to the plaintiff’s state law claim (the federal law creates the cause of action)
Four-Part Test [Centrality]
(1) Necessarily Raised (2) Actually Disputed (3) Substantial (4) Federal-State Balance
Substantiality
A state law claim containing a federal issue should be dismissed for this only when the federal issue is (1) implausible or (2) otherwise devoid of merit
Removal
Procedure that allows the defendant to move a case from state court to federal court.
Bases for Removal
(1) Diversity (2) Alienage (3) Federal QuestionP
Procedure for Removal
(1) File Notice of Removal (2) Observe the Deadline (3) Notify Parties & State Court (4) Address Consent
Case Removable from Beginning
30 days after receipt or service of initial pleading
Case Becomes Removable Later
30 days after receiving amended pleading, motion, order or other paper establishing removabilityM
Multiple Defendants with Removal
Each defendant has its own 30-day removal period
Forum Defendant Rule
When diversity is the sole basis for SMJ, a defendant who is a citizen of the forum state cannot remove
Snap Removal
Defendant removes a diversity case before the forum defendant has been served
One-Year Rule
Diversity and alienage cases cannot be removed more than one year after commencement
Voluntary Removal Rule
plaintiff dismisses nondiverse defendant - remaining defendant may be able to remove if the case become removable
Involuntary Removal Rule
Court dismisses nondiverse defendant - removal not permitted on the basis alone
Remand
plaintiff returning a removed case back to state court
Remand Requirements
(1) Federal court lacks subject matter jurisdiction (2) there is a procedural defect in removal