1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Main Trade Policy Debate
Free trade vs. protectionism.
Virtuous Cycle of Free Trade
Free trade can promote economic ties, which can help promote peace.
TRIPS Patent Protection
Requires a minimum patent term of 20 years.
Major Regional Trade Agreements
NAFTA, Mercosur, and ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA).
Main Theme of Trade Law
Predictability. Trade law gives countries and businesses more certainty.
Tariff
A tax on imported goods.
Main Purposes of Tariffs
Raise revenue and protect domestic industries.
IEEPA Tariffs and why were they Trump’s Fav?
Broad tariffs imposed under emergency powers. They allowed major flexibility without the usual investigation process.
Section 122 tarrif? Whats the max percent? whats the time limit? what does its sunset provision mean?
Temporary tariffs used for serious international payment problems. max is 15%. max of 150 days. Sunset meaning The tariff automatically expires.
Section 232 Tariffs. What’s the process?
Tariffs based on national security concerns. Requires an investigation and can take a long time.
Section 301 tariffs? does it require an investigation? What is the principle around it?
Remedial tariffs responding to harmful foreign trade practices. Requires an investigation. The tariff should respond to the harm caused by the foreign practice
Section 338 tariff?
Tariffs responding to discriminatory treatment by foreign countries.
Tariff Dumping
Moving production to another country to avoid a high tariff.
TBT
Technical Barriers to Trade.
National Trade Estimate Report (NTE)
Identifies foreign barriers that affect U.S. trade.
Import Policy Barriers
Tariffs, customs restrictions, or licensing rules.
Technical Barriers
Restrictive standards, testing, or labeling requirements.
Sanitary Barriers
Health or safety rules that go beyond what is necessary or are not science based.
Intellectual Property Barriers
Problems involving patents, copyrights, or trade secrets.
Services Barriers
Restrictions on foreign participation or local presence requirements.
Investment Barriers
Rules that limit foreign access or require local content.
Subsidies
Government support that can give domestic firms an advantage.
Anti-Competitive Barriers
State Owned Enterprises
NMPPs
Non-Market Policies and Practices.
Labor Barriers
Trade concerns involving violations of labor or human rights.
Environmental Barriers
Weak environmental enforcement or environmental arbitrage.
Other NTE Barriers
Practices such as bribery and corruption.
TBT Agreement
Prevents technical rules from becoming unnecessary or disguised barriers to trade.
TBT Article 2.1
Focuses on technical regulations, like products, and discrimination.
Less Favorable Treatment
A rule changes competitive conditions to the detriment of imported products.
TBT Article 2.2
A technical rule should not restrict trade more than necessary to achieve a legitimate objective.
Legitimate Objectives Under TBT
Protection of humans, the environment, security, and similar interests.
Goldilocks Problem
A regulation must protect its objective without restricting trade more than necessary.
Conformity Assessment
A process used to determine whether a product meets required standards.
Mutual Recognition Agreement
Countries recognize certain conformity assessments performed by each other.
TBT Simulation 3 questions to ask in order
Is it a TBT?
Are they like products?
Is the measure excessive under Article 2.1 or 2.2?
Less Restrictive Alternative
An alternative that achieves the goal while restricting trade less.
Two Main GATT 1 Non-Discrimination rules
Most Favored Nation (MFN) and National Treatment (NT)
MFN
Prevents Discrimination among foreign trading partners.
National Treatment (NT)
Imported products should not receive worse internal treatment than comparable domestic products.
GATT Article III
Contains the National Treatment rule.
National Treatment Tax Example
If domestic steel has a 2% internal tax, comparable foreign steel should not face a higher internal tax.
MFN vs. National Treatment
MFN compares foreign countries to each other; NT compares imported products with domestic products.
De Jure Discrimination
Discrimination that appears directly in the law or rule.
De Facto Discrimination
A facially neutral rule that discriminates in practice.
Comparability
Products are similar enough to be meaningfully compared.
Why Comparability Matters
A discrimination claim needs a valid comparison between products.
Like Product
A product similar enough to another product to be compared under trade rules.
Like Product Factors
End uses, consumer tastes and habits, and the products' properties, nature, and quality.
Like Does Not Mean Identical
Products only need enough similarity to be meaningfully compared.
Intent Test
Looks at why a government adopted a trade measure.
Why Intent Is Controversial
A government's true purpose can be difficult to prove.
Effects Test
Asks whether a measure has a disparate impact on imports.
Regulatory Intent
Can be inferred by examining how a regulation was designed and how it works.
Elasticity of Substitution
Helps show how closely products compete with or substitute for each other.
De Jure Approach
Focuses on discrimination apparent from the face of the rule.
De Facto Approach
Looks at how a rule actually operates in practice.
WTO Precedent
Prior decisions can be considered, but WTO decisions do not operate as strict binding precedent.
Geographical Indication (GI)
A name or sign connecting a product's reputation or qualities to a geographic place.
GI Legal Issue
Whether a name represents a true geographic reputation or an ordinary brand or generic name.
SPS
Sanitary and Phytosanitary measures concerning food safety and animal or plant health. Measures should be science based and not disguised trade restrictions.
Protectionism
Government action that protects domestic producers from foreign competition.
Regulatory Trade Barrier
A regulation can raise the cost of foreign goods even without imposing a tariff.
Predictability
A central purpose of trade law because stable rules reduce uncertainty.