1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the two sources of law governing lawyers?
Model Rules of Professional Conduct and
Restatement of the Law Governing Lawyers
What can a lawyer do if they are unsure about appropriate professional obligations?
ask a local, state, or national bar association for an ethics opinion
call an ethics hotline
(neither is binding but persuasive to a court deciding whether to discipline)
What are the three roles of lawyers?
as instruments,
as directors, and
as translators
In re Application of Converse
commission correctly determined Converse possessed a moral character inconsistent with one dedicated to the peaceful and reasoned settlement of disputes
“more consistent with someone who wishes to go outside the field of law and settle disputes by mounting personal attacks and portraying himself as the victim and his opponent as the aggressor”
what is the discipline process for lawyers?
similar to trial
use rules of civil procedure and evidence
require clear and convincing evidence
provide for adjudication by judges or other lawyers rather than a jury
how do individual jurisdictions differ in their discipline of lawyers?
many jurisdictions have additional protections beyond professional discipline
how does discipline of lawyers differ between smaller and larger firms?
small firms are subject to discipline more often than larger firms because…
large firms have institutionalized proceudres to prevent violations
possible sanctions for lawyer misconduct
disbarment
temporary suspension
public reprimand
private admonition
restitution
requirement to take continuing legal education
requirement to retake bar exam (all or part)
Matter of Giulani
“speech by an attorney is subject to greater regulation than speech by others”
I suspect that the fact that Giuliani made his various statements repeatedly, his words as well as his conduct were ripe for sanctioning through the lawyer disciplinary process to prevent harm to the public.”
underscores the significance of the allegation of “fraud”
in court proceedings
representing clients inside or outside court
more broadly by “engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation”
When do lawyer-client duties attach
most only attach after the client has requested the lawyer to render legal services and the lawyer has agreed
some duties, such as confidentiality, attach when the lawyer agrees to consider whether the relationship should be established
taking on a client actgivates fiduciary obligations designed to keep lawyers focused on the client’s goals and interests
is payment required to establish the lawyer-client relationship?
no
Togstad
Courts allow juries to find implied client-lawyer relationships when a trier of fact determines a person reasonably relied on a lawyer’s legal advice or lawyer’s failure to clearly decline a legal representation
in what situations should a lawyer clarify their intent not to give legal advice or induce reliance?
public speeches
advertising
initial consultation
on law firm websites
advising family members or friends
What duties are owed to prospective clients
might not always become full-fledged but are owed confidentiality
What duties are owed to former clients?
Fiduciary duties (MR 1.9)
Continuing duty of confidentiality
Togstad Letters
non-engagement letters
sent to clarify misunderstandings to those who contact a lawyer or inquire about obtaining legal services but do not explicitly retain
lawyers also routinely send engagement letters to explicitly acknowledge a client-lawyer relationship
disengagement letters
what is the difference between non-engagement and disengagement letters
non-engagement letters: sent to clarify misunderstanding to those who contact a lawyer or inquire about obtaining legal services but do not explicitly retain
disengagement letters: sent when lawyers completely withdraw from a client matter
possible solutions to the access to justice problem
publicly fund legal service programs
pro bono lawyer or student work
deregulation
unbundling legal services and offering them a la carte
Problem 3-4: Should Martyn & Fox take on the representation of a financially strapped couple who have just been served with a notice of foreclosure on their home? An indigent person seeking to expunge a crime standing in the way of getting a decent job?
Depends on the client’s need and the legal system’s need for such representation and whether Martyn & Fox recognizes those needs, if they exist. Both illustrate MR 6.1, which admonishes lawyers to offer free or reduced fee services to persons of “limited means.”