The Problem of Evil: Historical and Modern Arguments

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/15

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards detailing key thinkers, concepts, arguments, and publications concerning the Problem of Evil, spanning ancient formulations to modern debates between theists and atheists.

16 Terms

1
New cards

The Book of Job

A biblical text dating to circa the 6th century BCE containing one of the earliest recorded treatments of the Problem of Evil.

2
New cards

Epicurus

A 4th-century BCE Greek philosopher recognized for presenting early classical arguments regarding the Problem of Evil.

3
New cards

Boethius

A 6th-century CE Italian philosopher who addressed the Problem of Evil in works including The Consolation of Philosophy.

4
New cards

David Hume

An 18th-century CE Scottish historian and philosopher who formulated influential arguments on the Problem of Evil in works such as Dialogues concerning Natural Religion.

5
New cards

Gottfried Leibniz

A 17th-century German polymath and theist who argued that our world is the best world God could have created and that the mixture of evil produces the greatest possible good.

6
New cards

Leibnizian Optimism

The theological and philosophical view that our world is the best of all possible worlds God could have created, and that eliminating any specific evil would necessitate even greater evils.

7
New cards

Candide (1759)

A satirical novel by Voltaire that ridicules Leibnizian optimism, defining optimism as 'the obstinacy of maintaining that everything is best when it is worst!'

8
New cards

Voltaire

An 18th-century deist philosopher and satirist who ridiculed Leibniz's optimism in Candide and argued that those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.

9
New cards

Bertrand Russell

A 20th-century British mathematician, philosopher, and atheist who argued that an omnipotent, good creator who foresaw all pain and misery is fully responsible for all evil.

10
New cards

Russellian Pessimism

The philosophical position holding that an omnipotent God who foresaw worldly misery prior to creation is morally responsible for all suffering, just as a parent knowingly begetting a homicidal maniac would share responsibility for their crimes.

11
New cards

Natural Evil (Russell's critique)

Suffering caused by natural phenomena, such as overflowing rivers or erupting volcanoes, which Russell points out cannot be attributed to human sin.

12
New cards

Richard Swinburne

A 21st-century British Christian apologist (b. 1934) who proposes that suffering is permitted by God to give humanity the opportunity to cultivate virtues and form a holy character.

13
New cards

Swinburne’s Theodicy

The theodicy proposing that God permits suffering to provide individuals and society the necessary opportunities to exercise courage, patience, sympathy, and generosity.

14
New cards

Richard Dawkins

A 21st-century British evolutionary biologist (b. 1941) and atheist who strongly criticizes Swinburne's theodicy and argues that unquestioned faith is an evil.

15
New cards

Dawkins’ Criticism of Swinburne

The position that reconciling the horrific suffering, abuse, and death of innocent children with the mere opportunity for other people to show virtue is 'a grotesque piece of reasoning.'

16
New cards

Dawkins’ View on Faith

The stance that faith is an evil because it requires no justification and brooks no argument, conditioning children into potentially lethal agents for future conflicts.