1/49
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a service supply chain (Ellram, Tate & Billington, 2004)?
The management of information, processes, capacity, service performance, and funds from the earliest supplier to the ultimate customer.
Why do service supply chains matter?
The services sector covers every industry other than agriculture, manufacturing, and mining, and its share of GDP, employment, and outsourcing keeps growing.
What is the basic logic of a service supply chain?
Suppliers provide labor, technology, and goods. The provider’s capacity (staff, facilities, systems) cannot be stored. The customer is both consumer and co-producer. Demand cannot be inventoried, quality is experienced during delivery, and production and consumption happen at the same time.
What is co-production?
The customer takes part in producing the service by supplying themselves, their belongings, or their information.
What is the “inventory” in a service supply chain?
The provider’s capacity and the customer’s readiness.
What is the hub-and-spoke model in services?
A central provider (hub) linked to many suppliers and customers (spokes), instead of a linear chain. Service chains are short, information-intense, and extremely time-sensitive.
What does IHIP stand for?
Intangibility, heterogeneity, inseparability, perishability: the four characteristics that separate services from manufacturing.
What is intangibility, and what does it mean for the supply chain?
A service can’t be seen, tasted, or touched before purchase. Quality is hard to judge up front, so branding and “tangibilizing” the service matter.
What is heterogeneity, and what does it mean for the supply chain?
Quality varies by who delivers, when, and where. Standardization is hard, so it needs training and quality-control systems.
What is inseparability, and what does it mean for the supply chain?
The service is produced and consumed at the same time. There is no central production, so the chain must decentralize to the customer.
What is perishability, and what does it mean for the supply chain?
Unused capacity is lost forever. There is no inventory buffer, so real-time supply-demand matching is the core challenge.
What is the key point of the IHIP framework?
Each characteristic removes a lever that goods supply chains rely on: inspection, standardization, central production, or inventory.
What does Schmenner’s service process matrix show?
It plots labor intensity (low to high) against interaction and customization (low to high). This gives four service types, each with its own supply chain implication.
What is a service factory?
Low labor intensity, low interaction (airlines, trucking, hotels, resorts). Expensive fixed capacity, so scheduling and yield management decide profit.
What is a service shop?
Low labor intensity, high interaction and customization (hospitals, auto repair). Capacity plus customization, so appointments and flexible routing matter.
What is a mass service?
High labor intensity, low interaction (retailing, wholesaling, schools). Labor is the capacity, so staff scheduling and standard training matter.
What is a professional service?
High labor intensity, high interaction (doctors, lawyers, accountants, architects). People are the product, so talent pipeline and knowledge management matter.
What is the trend in Schmenner’s matrix?
Self-service and automation push many services toward the service-factory corner: cheaper, but less personal.
What does the Unified Services Theory (Sampson, 2006) say?
With services, customers act as suppliers for all service processes.
What do customers supply in a service?
Themselves (haircut, surgery), their belongings (car repair, dry cleaning), and their information (tax prep, consulting). The output then returns to the customer.
What is the defining trait of a service according to UST, and what does it mean for the chain?
Customer inputs, not intangibility. So the chain is bidirectional, with information and materials flowing both ways throughout the process, not just at the end.
What is a Process Chain Network (PCN) diagram?
A diagram showing where value is co-created and where efficiency can be gained through “surrogate” interaction. It splits steps into independent (provider alone), surrogate, direct (face-to-face), surrogate, and independent (customer alone).
What is direct interaction in a PCN?
Face-to-face interaction between provider and customer (a physical exam, a live consulting session). It has the highest customization.
What is surrogate interaction?
One party acts on the other’s resources without a face-to-face meeting: an ATM, a kiosk, a chef cooking your order.
What is independent activity in a PCN?
Steps done by the provider alone (pre-chopping vegetables, back-office processing) or by the customer alone (gathering documents at home). More efficiency, less customization.
What is the strategic shift in a PCN?
Moving steps from direct to surrogate interaction (online check-in, self-service kiosks) often raises efficiency and customer control while cutting provider labor cost.
What is the Services Supply Chain Model (Ellram et al., 2004)?
A model built for services with five participants (supplier, purchasing, internal users/stakeholders, finance, ultimate customer) linked by six flows, under one continuous information flow.
What are the six flows in the services supply chain model?
Capacity management, demand management, customer relationship management, supplier relationship management, service delivery management, and cash flow management.
What is the central challenge in service supply chains?
Capacity is the inventory, so matching supply and demand in real time is the central challenge.
What are the demand-side levers for matching capacity and demand?
Differential pricing (shift demand from peak to off-peak), appointment systems, reservation systems, and complementary services (occupy customers while they wait).
What are the supply-side levers for matching capacity and demand?
Cross-training, part-time or gig staff, customer participation (self-checkout), and shared capacity (e.g. airline code-sharing).
What is yield management?
Getting the right capacity to the right customer at the right price and time. Essential where fixed costs are high and capacity perishes (airlines, hotels).
What is the difference between chase and level demand?
Chase: change capacity to follow demand (flexible workforce). Level: smooth demand to fit steady capacity (reservations, queuing). Self-service shifts the coping cost to the customer.
What are the four design decisions in service supply chains?
Make vs buy (cost efficiency vs control), centralize vs decentralize (scale and consistency vs responsiveness), chase vs level demand, and high-touch vs automated (chatbots, RPA, but depersonalization can reduce perceived value).
What is Business Process Outsourcing (BPO)?
Outsourcing internal functions to specialist firms, a tendency that has grown with the services sector.
What are common BPO targets?
IT, HR, customer service, and auditing.
What is the strategic question of BPO?
Does handing a function to a specialist free the firm to focus on its core value, or does it just relocate a problem the firm doesn’t understand well enough to specify?
Why is service outsourcing harder to control than manufacturing outsourcing?
Manufacturing outsourcing has decades of precedent. Service outsourcing is newer and structurally harder to control (Ellram et al., 2004).
What are the four risks of BPO?
1. Vague agreements.
2. Hard-to-specify services.
3. Moral hazard.
4. No procurement involvement.
How do manufacturing and services differ in outsourcing contracts?
Expectations: precise specs vs vague SLAs.
Quality: measurable vs subjective.
Demand: forecast-based vs varies with project scope.
Cost: pre-negotiated per unit vs changing scope.
Verification: physical evidence vs internal sign-off.
Payment: receipts matched to purchase orders vs bills without tangible evidence.
Which principle answers each BPO risk?
Vague agreements: install business controls (e.g. audit turnaround per contractor).
Hard-to-specify services: revisit the division of labor (keep in-house what you can’t specify).
Moral hazard: align incentives or make them explicit (pay on on-time departure, not hours billed).
No procurement involvement: increase visibility and strength of services SCM (central procurement co-signs every contract).
What is an SLA?
What is an SLA? | A service level agreement: the contract part that defines the service, how it is measured, and what happens if it falls short.
What is moral hazard?
One party takes risks or acts opportunistically because the other bears the cost, e.g. a supplier inflating billable work.
How is SCOR adapted to measure service supply chains?
Its performance dimensions are kept:
reliability (SLA adherence, on-time delivery)
responsiveness (response time, wait time, turnaround), agility (capacity-flex ratio, ramp-up time)
costs (cost per service unit, overhead ratio)
asset efficiency (utilization rate, idle capacity %).
SCOR’s process names (Make, Deliver, Return) don’t fit services, but its performance attributes are process-neutral.
What is the Triple-A framework (Lee, 2004)?
Agility (respond quickly to short-term demand or supply changes)
adaptability (adjust supply chain design as markets evolve long-term)
alignment (align incentives across all partners).
What are the four disruption types in service supply chains?
Demand shocks (COVID healthcare surge, hotel collapse)
capacity failures (staff illness, system outages, strikes)
partner failures (an outsourced call center goes bankrupt)
digital disruption (platforms disintermediate the traditional chain)
What are the five resilience levers?
Redundancy (backup capacity, multi-sourcing)
flexibility (cross-trained staff, modular processes)
visibility (real-time monitoring across tiers)
collaboration (joint planning with partners and customers)
digital buffers (virtual capacity: cloud, gig platforms)
What is SCOR?
The Supply Chain Operations Reference model: Plan, Source, Make, Deliver, Return, linked to metrics.
What is the GSCF framework?
The Global Supply Chain Forum framework: business processes managed across firms, including the return flow.
What is the H-P model?
Hewlett-Packard’s supply chain model: managing uncertainty with inventory, capacity, and flexibility.