1/169
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what two sectors are contentious between China and India
Aksai Chin in the west which is controlled by China
Area under the McMahon Line in the east which is controlled by India
Sino-Pakistan Agreement 1963
Pakistan cedes Shaksgam Valley to China
diminishes potential for conflict between the two countries and a basis for stronger ties
China uses the end of its boundary issues with Pakistan to portray border issues with India as being a result of Indian stubbornness
1948 War
Hari Singh’s accession to India in 1947 is the pretext for both sides to go to war
territorial dispute is the basis for ongoing conflict
India rejects plebiscite because of US aid to Pakistan
Jammu & Kashmir under India
Sheikh Abdullah is appointed by Nehru to lead the new government in May 1948
Article 370 detailed legal status of J&K in the new Indian Constitution
Rifts between Abdullah and Nehru emerge and Abdullah is arrested under a Kashmir Conspiracy Case. Jailed 1953-1964
India initiates a series of legal and political measures to integrate J&K into the Indian Union
Nehru begins to reconsider his inflexible stance on talks with Pakistan
Article 370
Declared J&K is limited to issues of defense, foreign affairs, and communications
separate constitution and a flag
Kashmir Conspiracy Case
Indian and Kashmiri authorities charge Abdullah, his lieutenant, and 22 others with conspiring with Pakistan to overthrow the state government with violence
Who succeeds Nehru
Nehru dies in 1964
Successor is Lal Bahadur Shastri
Lal Bahadur Shastri
lacks popularity, charisma, and resolve to settle Kashmir
Pakistan views him as weak
Pakistan’s views after the Sino-Indian War 1962
Pakistan does not want US’s disapproval so they do not exploit India’s weakness during the 1962 Sino-Indian War
Pakistan views the UN as unable or unwilling to apply pressure on India thanks to a Soviet veto
By 1955, the USSR begins supporting India not just with military aid but in the UN Security Council with diplomatic assistance
Pakistan fears India will use their loss against China in 1962 war as a pretext for many expansion of armed forces
Pakistan begins considering other ways to resolve the conflict
1965 War background
President Ayub Khan of Pakistan and his foreign minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto see a chance to act as India is expanding its military capabilities
Early 1965, Pakistan and India fight a minor conflict
Pakistan comes out on top as they are able to capture some territory
Shastri does not escalate in Kutch and Pakistan reads this as a sign India lacked resolve
1965 War
Pakistan launches Operation Gibraltar
covert military operation launched by Pakistan in Aug 1965 to infiltrate Indian administered J&K and sparked a local insurgency against Indian rule
Shastri authorizes troops to cross the ceasefire line (CFL) and they capture Haji Pir pass on 28 Aug
Pakistan launches Operation Grand Slam on 1 Sep
take the town of Akhoor, outnumbering Indian tanks 6-1
Shastri government escalated dramatically, opening a massive offensive in Punjab on 6 Sep
He wanted to relieve pressure in Kashmir and is successful because Pakistan is forced to redirect to Punjab in order to stop the Cambb offensive
India agrees to a UN ceasefire on 22 Sept following UNSC Resolution 211
Aftermath of the War
war ends but minor skirmishes continue
each side gained and lost significant chunks of territory along its shared border
peace talks restore the status quo to pre-Aug 5, both sides return capturing territory
both sides agree to 3 new terms
non-use of force
adherence to ceasefire on the CFL
non-interference in internal affairs
both sides lost about 3000 men and 200 tanks
Pakistan does not achieve their primary objective to “unfreeze’ the Kashmir problem without provoking a general war
takeaways from the war
Largest engagement of armored vehicles and tank battle since WWII
War shows Pakistan limits of US aid and support, leading Pakistan to get closer with China and Muslim countries
Pakistan claims victory, Ahub loses face and is replaced by Gen Yahya Khan in 1969; rise of Bhutto in Pakistan
Casler & Jost (2025)
Compares the quality of India’s foreign policy decision-making in its 1962 border war with China versus the 1965 border war with Pakistan
Argues that bureaucratic reconfigurations b/w these two wars improved the efficacy of signals sent by India’s leaders from 1962 to 1965
2 types of bureaucratic institutions:
closed —> coordination/agency problems → MORE noise → greater misunderstanding
Ex) 1962 Sino-Indian War
Diplomatic and defense decisions ran through separate committees
Military chiefs excluded from the foreign-affairs committee
Senior diplomats excluded from the defense committee
Nehru served as his own foreign minister which made limited use of formal advisory bodies
Nehru wanted to send a note to China saying he was interested in negotiations but the bureaucracy never transmitted the message. Beijing did not understand what Nehru was communicating
Open —> better coordination + monitoring → LESS noise → greater mutual understanding
Ex) 1965 India-Pakistan War
India takes serious institutional reforms after 1962:
Integrated foreign and defense policymaking through the Emergency Committee of the Cabinet (ECC)
Shastri strengthened the PM’s Secretariat and appointed separate foreign and defense ministers with regular access to him
Greater coordination: during the 1965 crisis, the ECC met almost daily; Shastri consulted widely across the foreign, defense, and home ministries and the military
Shastri successfully communicates that India is ready to negotiate and pursue a peaceful settlement and their bureaucracy transmitted this message coherently. So Pakistan's decision-makers accurately understood Shasri’s meaning
Background on Nepal
border two global powers that can influence domestic politics; China and India
Population around 30 million. Predominantly Hindu with Buddhist and Muslim minorities
2025 Proests
Massive youth-led anti-corruption movement in Nepal that began in Sep 2025
Leads to the resignation of PM KP Sharma Oli
Movement expands to encompass broader issues (governance, transparency, political accountability)
At least 76 deaths
Climate Vulnerability of Nepal
Home to Mount Everest and 8 of the world’s 10 highest peaks
Precipitating geological event in Aug 2026 leads to climate change destabilizing Himalayan slope
A massive chunk of ice fell off a glacier in the Langtang region, triggering high-speed flash floods
Over 1000 dead, 5000 missing
Shah Dynasty
Initially ruled Nepal as an absolute monarchy following its unification in 1768
Unification —> multi-decade campaign of military conquest and state-building to unite dozens of Himalayan kingdoms
Anglo-Nepalese War (1814-1816)
Finalizes Nepal’s international borders
British-Gorkha relationship begins with this war
1846 Rana Dynasty
Chhetri dynasty, seizes control through a violent political coup
Ranas reduce the Shah monarchs to figureheads, concentrating power in the hands of an all powerful PM who is always a Rana (hereditary role)
Ranas side with the British Raj in India as a strategic trade-off to keep their absolute power and prevent Nepal from being colonized toprolong their totalitarian rule
Gorkhas
named after a town in Nepal
Elite soldiers, native to Nepal and Nepali speaking ethno-cultural group
Ranas supply the British with a steady stream of Gorkha soldiers
Domiciled in both Nepal and India, seed by the British as a superior fighting force
British-Gorkha relationship begins with Anglo-Nepalese War
Tripartite Agreement
Britain, India, and Nepal Treaty in 1947
6/10 Gorkha regiments remained as part of Indian Army and 4/10 joined British Army
Around 32,000-35,000 Nepal soldiers served in the Indian Army at any given time
recruitment of Nepali Gorkhas into the Indian Army has been paused since 2022
Political awakening in Nepal
Rise of nationalism and the Congress in India coincides with political awakening in Nepal
Nepalese students and leaders in exile participate in struggle against the British and at home
Nepal National Congress (NC) formed in 1947 in India
end of the Ranas
King Tribhuvan supported efforts to weaken Rana rule and restore greater power to the monarchy
The Ranas viewed the king's support for political reform as a threat to their authority
When Ranas crack down, King Tribhuvan flees to the Indian Embassy and then New Delhi to take refuge
Nehru mediates Delhi agreement of 1951 allowing Tribhuvan to return and a new constitution and elections in 1959 to occur. NC wins with a 2/3 majority
Panchayat System
Tribhuvan’s son, King Mahendra, stages a coup in 1960 citing NC’s corruption and political instability because of divisions within NC
He dissolves the parliament and political parties
From 1960-1990, Nepal is ruled by the monarchy through a partyless Panchayat system
= limited, indirect election to village and district councils
Beginning of Communism in Nepal
Communism arrives late to Nepal because of historically low literacy and a policy of limiting external influence pursued by the Rana regime
As political dissent grows against the totalitarian Ranas by the early 1940s, communist literature makes it way into Nepali political discourse mostly by way of India (where the communist party of india started growing)
Communist Party of Nepal (CPN)
Founded in Apr. 1949 in Calcutta
Splits under the Panchayat system after 1960
Jhapa Revolt (1969-1971)
Communist revolt stemming from conflict b/w landowners and farmers in Nepal
CPN begins armed revolt inspired by Naxalites
Crushed by monarchy
United Left Front
Communist parties joined in Feb 1990 to form the United Left Front
Start of the People’s Movement with Nepali Congress for restoration of democracy
King Birendra agrees to new, democratic multi-party constitution although with the monarchy still place
Nepalese Civil War (1996-2006)
Nepal’s Maoist “People’s War”
Aim is to overthrow the Nepalese monarchy and build a republic
Insurgency gains momentum and spreads to all of Nepal
Maoist insurgency growing out of rural grievances and mountain terrain, while the state maintained tight grip on major urban centers
At its height, 6,000-10,000 guerillas, nearly 40,000 armed militia men and women
The Nepalese Army and Armed Police Force hit back. 17,000 deaths in a decade
Royal Massacre
1 June 2001 at the Naayanhiti Royal Palace in Nepal leaves 9 members of the Royal Family dead
Committed by a member of the family, the prince, whose family opposed him marrying someone. he kills himself after
Following the Royal Massacre, the government and the Maoist insurgents declared a ceasefire and held peace talks
Peace talks failed and the armed conflict returned
Seven Party Alliance (SPA) (2005)
King Gyanendra dismisses successive govts after 2002 citing failure to hold elections and/to bring rebels to the negotiating table, seizes direct control in 2005
SPA included the CPN-M (Communist Party of Nepal Maoist)
SPA builds pressure on Gyanendra to restore democracy including the House of Representatives
Arms dispatched from China despite ideological affinity with CPN-M
End of the Nepalese Civil War
Aug 2006, Maoist rebels agree to accept UN to monitor the peace process
Nov 2006, comprehensive peace accords signed b/w the government, SPA and Maoist rebels, formally ending the civil war
Aftermath of Nepalese Civil War
The monarchy officially abolished on May 28, 2008
Decision passed by Nepal’s 1st Constituent Assembly during its first sitting
Ends the 239 year old Shah dynasty and transitions the nation into a federal democratic republic
What 2 ideological fronts for organizing people/resistance makes the CPN-M successful
class (have vs have-nots) disenfranchises
poverty —> most people in a village have very little so they don’t have the resources to mobilize
inequality —> some people in a village have more than others, making them believe the system is unfair. more likely to mobilize
ethnic disenfranchisement
Many ethnic communities faced exclusion from political institutions and discrimination against their languages and cultures
Nepal, Bohara & Gawande (2011)
Examined 3,857 Nepalese villages and compared different levels of inequality and poverty with the number of people killed by Maoist rebels b/w 1996 to 2003
Found that long-standing inequality created grievances, meaning people have more of a reason to resent the existing system
Found that shared bonds like language and ethnicity among economically repressed people made collective action and mobilization easier
Language can partition society. Nepali language spoken in populous villages was associated with elites. Other linguistic communities feel excluded
Poverty alone (destitution constraint) makes it harder to rebel as they do not have the resources to participate
Education weakens the effect of inequality. Education provides people with greater opportunities and reducing reliance on rebellion
High prevalence of farming strengthens the effect of inequality
View from Beijing
Nepal’s political stability is an important consideration
Long border with Tibet could be the base for Tibetan exiles seeking to shake off Chinese rule
Relationship defined by 1960 Sino-Nepalese Treaty of Peace and Friendship
Nepal was the first neighboring country of China to conclude a border treaty with China
India’s role
India is Nepal’s largest trade partner and primary source of foreign direct investment (FDI)
Constitutes large share of Nepal’s total trade
Open 1,751 km border that spans at least 5 Indian states
Complex dynamic with India because of perceptions of uneven relationship
In 1962, Nepal allows India to station troops there
Siliguri Corridor
Very close to the borders of Bangladesh and Nepal
India is worried about China’s diplomacy with Bhutan
The monarchy of Sikkim's incorporation into India in 1975 slightly improved India's strategic position in the Himalayas and around the vulnerable Siliguri Corridor. Alleviates some of India’s worries about the northern states being cut off from the rest of the country
Mishra (2004)
Mishra is challenging the argument that poverty and economic marginalization alone explain why Nepal's Maoist insurgency began in certain regions
The Maoist insurgency was centered in mid-western Nepal, but this region was not the country's most impoverished or isolated. Mishra argues that if social and economic marginalization alone were the main cause of communist revolt, then areas like Karnali, Seri, and Mahakali would be more likely to experience the insurgency
This is because these areas had high levels of poverty, chronic food shortages, difficult mountain terrain, and more distance from the state centers. However, they were not the main epicenter for the rebellion so economic marginalization alone does not explain why the Maoist insurgency emerged there
Cross-border ties with India helped sustain its growth
India has had influence over Nepal’s politics since 1950, prioritizing its security and regional interests. Maoist leaders also reportedly operated from Indian territory, maintained links with Indian Maoist groups, and benefited from access to safe havens
After the 1962, Sino-Indian war, New Delhi ordered all antiroyal Nepali exiles in India to cease their activities to ensure the king’s absolute rule continued. Lasted for the next 30 years
What drives rebellion?
Weak state capacity
Rebel opportunity
Natural resources, forest cover, mountainous terrain
Mishra (2004) Conflicting Evidence
Does Mishra (2004) necessarily establish direct Indian state sponsorship?
External connections did help sustain the rebellion even if original grievances were domestic. However, Maoists opposed India and their influence over Nepal (40-point demands), so why did their leaders operate from Indian territory?
Maoists submitted 40-point demands to the Nepali government in 1996
Top 3 related to India
Remove all unequal stipulations and agreements from the 1950 India-Nepal Treaty of Peace and Friendship
Admit the anti-nationalist hydroelectric water agreements be nullified
Nepal-India border should be systematically controlled and vehicles with Indian number plates should not be allowed free entry
Naxalite-Maoist insurgency
Term Naxal comes from then village Naxalbari in West Bengal where the Naxalbari uprising of 1967 occurred
Those engaged in the insurgency are called Naxals/Naxalite
Insurgency begins in 1967 following the split within the Communist Party of India
One branch that breaks off is the CPI (Marxist-Leninist) in West Bengal
Driving force → tribal and rural areas of India remote and under-developed; insurgents demanded improved land rights and more jobs for agricultural laborers
The movement attracted lower-castes, indigenous tribals (adivasis), with a focus on students/youth
The targets are tribal police, government workers, and security officials
Armed wing of Naxalites is the People’s Liberation Guerilla Army (PLGA) that was established between 6,500 and 9,500 cadres in 2013
What drives Naxalites rebellion?
After Indian independence, industry/mining caused displacement of 84 million advisais most subsistence farmers/landless
India’s economic liberalization in the 1990s will instigate a rush for mineral resources leading to the displacement of even more tribes and land confiscation
Red Corridor
In 2007, it’s estimated that Naxalites were active across half of India’s 29 states (40% of India’s geography)
Two coal-rich, remote, forested hilly clusters in tribal, underdeveloped parts of India
North: tri-junction area of Jharkhand-Bihar West Bengal
South: Andhra Pradesh-Chhattisgarh-Odisha region
Counterinsurgency Response
Operation Steeplechase
Launched in 1971 under Indira Gandhi
Hundreds of Naxalites killed and 20,000+ imprisoned
Operation Green Hunt
Launched by the Congress Party in 2009
Deployed 80,000 paramilitary personnel and 10-armed IAF (indian air force) helicopters
Successes of the counterinsurgency response
March 2026, Union Home Minister Amit Shah declared India free of Naxalism which was in line with a deadline he announced in August 2024
what is the two puzzles argument
Some areas like Western Ghats on India’s western coast have similar topography, low reach of state, socioeconomically exploited lower castes and tribes, but no Maoist insurgency
Others areas like Bihar, Andhra Pradesh with no tribals will see Maoist mobilization
Veghese & Teitelbaum (2019)
Examined 589 Indian districts provinces (both provinces and princely states) and found that the likelihood and intensity of Naxalite violence was substantially higher in areas with greater British influence
Authors propose 3 mechanisms linking contemporary Naxalite violence to colonialism: Land Inequality, classification systems, elite capture and bureaucratization
Land Ineuqality
British introduced and institutionalized the zamindari or "Permanent Settlement” system starting in 1793 which granted property rights to Zamindars, those who had formerly just been revenue agents under the Mughal Empire, in the hopes of incentivizing them to make productive investments in their estates
This turned peasants into tenants vulnerable to eviction and dispossession and resulted in land being heavily concentrated in the hands of landlords throughout north India
In 1947, all the land was owned by less than 5% of the population
British colonial rule fundamentally altered advisai land rights by declaring themselves conservator of forest lands in which tribes had lived without interference for generations
Huge swaths of forest were suddenly placed in reserve, especially areas that had rich forest produce or mineral wealth
Indian Forest Act of 1878 → influx of Forest Department officials, immigrants, moneylenders, and commercial firms
Classification systems
British rigidified social inequalities by systematically categorizing and ranking caste and tribal communities
India’s first scientific census placed thousands of diverse jatis (endogamous birth groups) into a 4-tired structure
British instituted the Criminal Tribes Act in 1871 that pertained to certain tribes with a history of criminal behavior but they just criminalized every member of a “criminal tribe” even if they never committed a crime
These tribes could not travel freely and were jailed for not reporting movements
Elite Capture & Bureaucratization
Creation of an upper-caste dominated bureaucracy that cemented these inequalities through administrative practice
Fostered district of India’s law enforcement and legal institutions among low-caste and tribal groups
Constructed the Indian Civil Service, the Imperial Police, and the Imperial Forest Department
Naxals characterized the Indian government as a semi-colonial state dominated by comprador bourgeoisie
2 strategies to measure colonial influence
Provinces → count the number of years a territory was governed directly by the British
Princely states → number of guns in British salutes, proxy for how much colonial administrators intervened in a princely territory
British administration in India was prone to sign treaties of indirect rule in border districts because of budget constraints and foreign threat perceptions to frontier districts
Mukherjee (2018)
Areas under both British rule and direct land revenue systems (ryotwari tenure) had higher levels of development and lower levels of interethnic and land inequalities
Maoists did not succeed here because…
Increased bureaucratic capacity and tax capacity of the state led to more accurate measures of land yields and a less exploitative system for the peasants or ryots
Zamindari system on the other hand was in areas of lower bureaucratic capacity, and hence less public goods distribution
Ryotwari System
Colonial officers did not rely on intermediaries like landlords to collect the land taxes/revenue on their behalf like the Zamindari system. Instead, they up their own bureaucratic/administrative network of officials (native and British) employed by the colonial state to go and measure land value and agricultural yields and to collect land revenue directly from the villages or from peasants
Increased bureaucratic capacity and tax capacity of the state led to more accurate measures of land yields and a less exploitative system for the peasants or ryots
Zamindari system had lower bureaucratic capacity, and hence less public goods distribution
Democracy and Revolution in Nepal vs. India. Why do some communist or revolutionary movements launch rebellions even after democracy has been introduced and left-wing parties have gained political power?
Nepal → CPN-M in 1996: case of communist faction turning against post-democratication governments including elected communists
India → Naxalites, 1967: case of Maoist radicals revolting against newly-elected, leftist-dominated state government
South Asia → category of internally-divided leftist movements that face “incorporation windows” and the choice between co-optation and rebellion against democratic involvement / “bourgeoise freedoms”
surprising as democracies should in theory be what the insurgency groups want but they ended up still revolting against the democracies
India’s Creation Dilemma: how to build a strong, unified country out of a highly diverse population while avoiding the divisions that weaken it
India’s status as a great power linked to its size and regional ambitions
Large population and economic potential
British 200 year rule was attributed to a lack of internal cohesion
Some believe internal divisions between regions, religions, ethnic groups, and political authorities in India made it easier for Britain to control
Concerned that a divided India could make it vulnerable to external powers
Partition itself seen as a clumsy British retreat
External security considerations and federalist tensions created urgency to keep territory within the Union
Worried about too much fragmentation weakening the country
A Hijacking Above Kathmandu
December 24, 1999
Indian Airlines Flight IC-814 takes off from Kathmandu, Nepal for New Delhi, India
179 passengers on board; midway it is hijacked, and rerouted to Kandahar, in Afghanistan
Week-long standoff between Indian negotiators and the 5 hijackers
India will release 3 imprisoned militants in exchange for the hostages
Who were the hijackers
Hijackers (and the prisoners whose release was sought) were part of the Harkat-ul-Mujahideen (HuM)
HuM traces its roots to networks of Islamist fighters who had been mobilized during the Soviet-Afghan War (1979-1989)
Kandahar
In the 1990s, Afghanistan is under Taliban control
Kandahar is in southern Afghanistan and its partially dry
De facto political headquarters of the Taliban located here
Background on Afghanistan
Landlocked, multi-ethnic country
Under Taliban control for a second time
Population of 45 million; median age 17
Capital is Kabul
One of the poorest, most war-torn countries in the world
Durannis Empire
Among the largest tribes of Afghan Pashtuns
Extends Afghanistan’s borders to India in the 1760s
Emergence of a geographical identity
They will have a lot of civil war problems. Decline starts in 1793 between the sons of Timur Shah Durrani
Dost Mohammad Khan
Barakzai sub-tribe
Usurps Kabul in 1826
Dost Mohammad reunites most of Afghanistan by the time of his death in 1863. Credited with laying foundations of first modern Afghan state
Why do the British invade Afghanistan
British are concerned over Russian advances in Central Asia and over Russia’s growing influence in West Asia and in Persia (culminates in 2 Afghan wars)
Invade to protect Indian Empire from the expansion of the Russian Empire and to install compliant rulers during a geopolitical rivalry
First Anglo-Afghan War
British attempt to restore Afg.’s status as a vassal state
1839-42
Following British defeat, Dost Mohammad reunites most of Afghanistan by the time of his death in 1863. Credited with laying foundations of first modern Afghan state
Sher Ali
Son of Dost Muhammad Khan
Leader during Second Afghan war
Second Anglo-Afghan War
1878-80
Stemming from Sher Ali’s refusal to accept a British diplomatic mission
Abdur Rahman Khan
Nephew of Dost Muhammad
Reestablishes government writ
Granted assistance in arms and money, but must align his foreign policy with the British
The Durand Line
border between Pakistan and Afghanistan. agreed to by Abdur Rahman Khan and Sir Henry Durand, British soldier and colonial administrator, in 1893
Both British and Russians are looking to establish clear boundaries
Line cuts through Pashtun villages, continuing cause of conflict between Afghanistan and Pakistan
In 1947, Pakistan inherits 1893 agreement from British India
Afghans say the Durand ethnic division had been imposed on them under coercion/duress/diktat
In 1947, Puhstuns favored autonomy
In 1949, Pak-Afghan ties deteriorate. PAF (pakistan air force) bombs Afghan village in response to cross border fire
Third Anglo-Afghan War
Armed conflict b/w UK and Afghanistan, Following the assassination of Habibullah Khan.
Launched by Amanullah Khan with an attack India
Treaty of Rawalpindi Aug. 1919 ends the war. British relinquish control over Afghanistan’s foreign affairs in 1919
Amanullah Khan
successor of Habibullah Khan
he regains control of Afghanistan’s foreign policy after launching the third Anglo-Afghan War with an attack India
Amanullah proclaims Kingdom of Afghanistan in 1926 (lasts until 1973)
Nadir Shah
Amanullah Khan’s Minister of War, reinstates kingdom following temporary 10- month interruption by conservative rebellio
Continues Amanullah’s reforms
Zahir Shah
Nadir Shah’s son
Rule commences in 1933 (1933-73)
Afghanistan is admitted to UN in 1946; in 1947 is sole UN member to vote against Pakistan’s entry
Daoud Khan
Zahir Shah’s cousin
Strained relations with the King
Served as PM from 1953-63
1973 coup d'état where he abolishes the monarchy and sets up a republic with himself as President
approves new constitution with a presidential one-party state. concentrates power in the executive
suppresses opposition but assures continuity of religious, cultural heritage (to refute allegations of communist takeover)
Republic of Afghanistan (1973-78)
By 1978 Daoud has achieved little progress
Afghan economy and living standards stagnating
Single-party constitution alienates political supporters
People’s Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA)
Communist minority party established in 1967
Daoud had executed 1973 coup with their help
Socialist leaning, backed by Soviets, split between hardline Khalq (masses) vs. moderate Parcham (flag) who advocate for more gradual change
Ideology of both geared towards Islamic socialism
Initially PDPA had been rewarded with important roles in Daoud’s govt, but factionalism sharpens
Saur Revolution (27-30 April 1978)
Tensions heighten in Apr. 1978 after left-wing intellectual and Parcham member Mir Akbar Khyber is killed. People believe the government is responsible for his murder
Mir Akbar Khyber’s funeral prompts PDPA protests, Daoud cracks down
Resentment against Daoud at all-time high. PDPA officials alone identified w/some social, economic reform
Daoud’s regime ends on 28 Apr. 1978 (shot dead along with his family) when military units loyal to Khalq storm Presidential Palace
Hafizullah Amin
Organizes Khalqi military officers
Second President of the Democratic Republic of Afghanistan
Background to Afghan-USSR Relations
Afghanistan has been military, economic aid recipient of the U.S.S.R. since 1940s
Economic assistance and aid had been provided as early as 1919, shortly after the Russian Revolution and when the regime was facing the Russian Civil War
1950s Soviet had an interest in energy exploration and started importing Afghan gas from 1968 onwards
US-Pakistan 1950s defense cooperation pulls Afghanistan closer to India and the USSR
When Daoud seizes power in 1973 to establish first Afghan republic, most of his army officers are Soviet trained
Daoud’s relationship with Pakistan is complicated
Moscow does not want to challenge Pakistan directly unless relations with other Muslim countries deteriorates, relies on Daoud as a proxy
Daoud pauses Pashtunistan policy after Bhutto/Pakistan ISI start supporting anti-Daoud factions in 1975, prompting relations with Moscow to deteriorate
Soviet Shadow
Despite his socialist views, relations between Kabul, Moscow had begun to plumnet during Daoud’s rule
U.S.S.R. wary of Daoud’s outreach to the U.S. and to Pakistan; Daoud has also brought about little change
Daoud’s suppression of pol. opposition alienates Soviet-backed PDPA, an important ally in the 1973 coup
Soviets help heal the rift between Khalqs and Parchams in 1977 w. formal agreement on unity
Outcome of Saur Revolution
Daoud overthrown and killed by the same civilian and military officials who helped him seize power in 1973
Coup strategically planned (e.g., day before Friday, use of tanks, air force to breach Presidential Guard)
Hafizullah Amin renames country Democratic Republic of Afghanistan under Nur Taraki; DRA will last from 1978-1992, first under Taraki, then Amin, then finally Karmal
Democratic Republic of Afghanistan
First leader is Nur Taraki
Saur Revolution brings PDPA to power (specifically the Khalqi)
5 December 1978, Treaty of Friendship signed between the Soviet Union and Afghanistan
Khalqi rule is repressive (to neutralize competitors)
Radical social reforms (land and marriage reforms, but also enforced policy of de-Islamization alongside the promotion of socialism). All very badly received
Rifts b/w Khalq and Parcham resurface, Karmal is (for all purposes) exiled to E. Bloc
Rifts emerge within Khalq too between Taraki and Amin. Amin has Taraki killed in Sept. 1979
Why is Amin more unpopular than Taraki (and to the Soviets)
Due to harshness of reforms (aimed at eliminating feudalism) and heavy-handedness, Amin proves unpopular in both Afghanistan and the Soviet Union
Soviets worry that Khalqi plans to transform Afghanistan will not work as the Afghan society deeply conservative
Khalq state executes between 10,000 and 27,000 and up to 100,000 disappeared
Large parts of the country erupt in open rebellion, made worse by disintegration of Afghan Army (from 110k men to 25k in just two years)
Red Army Intervention (December 1979)
Amin repeatedly requests support against mujahideen (“those engaged in jihad”) throughout 1979
Soviets deeply conflicted, even as they send helicopters and ammunition because Amin’s credibility eroded. KGB assessments of Amin’s policies were that they caused destabilization and led to the Taraki assassination
Moscow is also deeply concerned about radical Islam spreading to Central Asia. They believe the US & Pakistan sponsoring insurgency
Fall 1979, Moscow envisions in a short intervention to replace radical Khalqi Amin with the moderate Parchami Babrak Karmal to stabilize Afghanistan
Operation Storm 333 (27 Dec 1979)
Marks start of Soviet-Afghan War that will rage on for 10 years
Assault on Tajbeg Palace and Amin is killed by the Afghan Revolutionary Central Committee
Next day the Soviet military command takes to Radio Kabul to declare U.S.S.R.’s compliance with the 1978 Treaty
Committee elects Babrak Kamal as head of government
1947, A TALE OF TWO WINGS
Partition creates West Pakistan and East Pakistan
Partition of Bengal in 1947
Largest province in British India
Population of roughly 62 million (per 1941 British Raj census)
Roughly 55% Muslim, 42% Hindu
Capital city of Calcutta (which until 1911 was also the capital of British India)
United Bengal Plan, April 1947
Bengal provincial Muslim League leader H.S. Suhrawardy proposed a plan to create an independent Bengal state that would remain unpartitioned
Partition of Bengal
Suhrawardy realized that if Bengal was partitioned, it would be economically disastrous for the eastern half (East Bengal)
All coal mines, industrial plants, all but two jute mills, and Calcutta (industrial/commercial hub and largest port) would go to the western (overwhelmingly Hindu) half
Viceroy Mountbatten cabled the British government with a partition plan that made an exception for Bengal. It was to be the only province that would be allowed to remain independent should it so chose to
In a cabinet meeting that month PM Attlee said he hoped that Bengal would remain united
Who supported United Bengal and who oppossed
Jinnah did not support a United Bengal. Did not understand its use without Calcutta
Bengal Muslim League was very divided. Independent Bengal would undercut the logic of the two-nation theory which ran counter to the logic of Partition
Within the provincial Muslim League, much of the split would be along linguistic lines
Urdu-speaking Bengals wanted to be part of a union with Pakistan
Bengali-speaking Muslims were fine with an independent Bengal
Congress opposes the plan
Nehru, Patel see it as a ploy by Suhrawardy to keep industrial west (including Calcutta) under League control
1905 Bengal Partition
British under Viceroy Lord Curzon partitioned Bengal for administrative purposes. He severed the largely Muslim east from the largely Hindu west
Calcutta was the capital of British Raj and the 4th largest city in the British Empire. it was also the nerve center of the Indian independence movement
Partitioned because Bengal was too large and complex for any single administration to govern. East Bengal is isolated, neglected, poorly connected. Needed an administrator
By splitting Bengal into a Hindu majority west and Muslim majority east, British could fracture a unified political resistance
Backlash from 1905 Bengal Partition
Partition provokes lots of anger from Congress, triggering radical nationalism. It is seen as a deliberate attempt to divide Bengal on religious grounds
Hindus of West Bengal are upset because the division made them a minority in a province that incorporated Bihar and Orissa
decision is reversed in 1911 by King George at the Delhi Durbar. capital is then shifted to New Delhi to provide the British colonial government with a stronger base
Partition reversal upsets Muslim constituents whose interests are subjugated, unlikely to be protected in a reunited province
Aftermath of 1947 Bengal Partition
Incomplete population changes relative to Punjab. Less violence
migration across Bengal estimated at 3.3 million
2.6 million Hindus move west to West Bengal
0.7 million Muslims move east to East Pakistan
Logistical Difficulties of Partition (West and East Pakistan)
To reach Karachi, a citizen in east Pakistan would have to fly 1,000 miles or travel 3,000 miles by sea
Growing Grievances in West/East Pakistan
Social, political, and economic inequality
Political power concentrated in the West
Bengali speaking population of East Pakistan resented Urdu’s status as the national language. Riots begins as early as 1952 which exacerbates cultural differences
Even though Bengalis made up 54% of the population, they were only 5% of officer corps in the army with barely any commanding positions. 66% of US aid was spent in West Pakistan
One Unit Scheme
Controversial. 1954
Creates two provinces; one in the east and one in the west
purpose to streamline development and prevent East from having political sway
Lahore would be provincial capital of West Pakistan (until 1954, when it would shift to Rawalpindi)
1965 India-Pakistan War Effect on the Wings
The war exacerbates eastern wing’s frustrations. they only have 1 infantry division, 15 combat aircrafts, virtually no tank support in East to thwart potential Indian retaliations during the conflict
Political Aftermath of the 1965 War
Rise of Bhutto’s political popularity
Tashkent Agreement proves costly for Ayub, who is overthrown in March 1969 coup. It shattered the domestic wartime narrative of victory and triggered a major political rebellion
East Pakistan-based Awami League, led by Sheikh Mujib. He has a different outlook on Kashmir (thousands of miles away so disconnected)
Following Ayub’s overthrow, Yahya commits to holding free and fair elections by 1970. starts negotiations with Bhutto and Mujib about restoration of democratic rule also ends One Unit Scheme. but too little too late