1/290
Looks like no tags are added yet.
MODULE: GOVERNMENTAL REGULATION (Consumer Protection, Competition, Environment)
Regulatory Risk
Risk that government (federal, provincial or municipal) takes legal action against a business that fails to follow statutes requiring it to operate a certain way. The enforcer is the government, not other businesses, clients or consumers.
Three main forms of regulatory risk
(1) Consumer protection / false advertising / deceptive marketing, (2) competition (monopoly) regulation, called anti-trust in the US, (3) environmental protection.
Examples of regulatory risk (slide examples)
Federal/BC environmental and climate rules (carbon taxes, pipeline approval process); City of Vancouver Airbnb rental restrictions; federal consumer protection rules on false claims about masks/PPE (quality, origin) or "Made in Canada" products.
Why businesses WANT laws (4 reasons)
(1) Laws give clarity and predictability, (2) everyone must operate under the same rules, (3) the cost of deregulation/no rules is often greater than having rules, (4) rules create opportunities for innovation, new products and ideas, and ways to outperform competitors.
How can environmental regulation promote economic development and innovation?
It forces/encourages new technologies and compliance methods, creates new products, services and markets (solar, battery, wind, recycling), and gives competitive advantage to businesses that comply and innovate.
Sale of Goods Act
Implies warranties and conditions into a sale contract, including product safety (e.g. implied warranty that a product is safe and will not cause harm).
Consumer protection legislation (what it does)
Prevents false advertising and deceptive marketing, addresses exclusion clauses used to override warranties, prevents unconscionable transactions, and mandates disclosure of important information (e.g. true cost of borrowing).
Online / electronic commerce rules
Newer consumer protection rules about spam, phishing and telemarketing.
Competition Act (purpose)
Consumer protection statute that prohibits price-fixing and collusion, misleading advertising and deceptive marketing (e.g. health product claims), and sets what facts must be disclosed.
Environmental regulations (purpose)
National and provincial rules that protect the public from pollution and other harms to the environment and our health.
Why is competition important / why do businesses want fair-competition laws?
Fair competition keeps markets open for new entrants, innovation and fair prices; businesses want laws because markets left alone may let dominant players shut out others.
3 business practices that interfere with competition
(1) Restraint of trade clauses in contracts (including employment contracts), (2) mergers and market domination through monopolies, (3) market manipulation through collusion (e.g. price-fixing).
How does the Competition Act prevent monopoly? (4 tools)
(1) Prohibits conspiracy among competitors (e.g. bid rigging), (2) prohibits abuse of a dominant position, (3) regulates certain mergers that create a dominant market position, (4) provides remedies. Uses criminal and civil penalties.
Bid rigging
Competing businesses agree to bid a certain price (a conspiracy to manipulate the market).
Abuse of a dominant position
Using a dominant market position anti-competitively, e.g. price fixing (gas stations all agreeing to sell at the same price).
Remedies under the Competition Act
Stop the anti-competitive practice, dissolve a merger, or hold the merged companies separate.
Why is "impact on the consumer" the focus of competition cases?
Competition law exists to protect consumers (prices, choice, quality) from the harm of reduced competition; it is not meant to punish a company simply for being big or successful.
Anti-trust
The US term for competition / monopoly regulation.
Facebook (Meta) & market dominance: key questions
What % of the market counts as "dominant"? Is dominance alone the issue (no, you also need ABUSE of the position)? Is it only a US issue because Facebook is US-registered (no, other jurisdictions like the EU have brought cases against Google and Facebook)? What risks do competition laws create for businesses?
Gas prices case: is matching a competitor's price price-fixing?
Slide question. Key issue: is there an AGREEMENT/collusion between competitors? General principle: independently raising prices to match a competitor is not automatically price-fixing; an agreement (formal or informal) to fix prices is. Evidence of agreement is the key.
Mobile phone market (Rogers, Telus, Bell): merger issues
Rogers would have to notify the Competition Bureau (government), which investigates market share and likely impact of the merger, including on consumer prices. Questions: type of merger, impact on whom, and whether current identical pricing is collusion (is there an agreement? formal?).
TREB v. Competition Bureau of Canada (2018)
Toronto Real Estate Board limited access to home sale data, preventing other companies from competing/entering the market. The Bureau found this violated the Competition Act (it was an abuse of a dominant position). Bureau focus: data availability must NOT block innovation, disruption and competition.
Consumer protection: purpose
Federal and provincial laws that protect consumers against false or deceptive claims about products or services, including online claims and sales.
Consumer protection statutes (list)
Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act (BC), Competition Act (Canada), Consumer Packaging and Labelling Act, Textile Labelling Act, Hazardous Products Act, Food and Drugs Act, Sale of Goods Act, anti-spam legislation.
Consumer protection: 5 areas
(1) Advertising and marketing, (2) product safety (minimum quality/safety standards), (3) Sale of Goods Act implied warranties, (4) information disclosure (cost of borrowing, product origin, food ingredients), (5) electronic commerce (identity theft, privacy, spam, phishing, telemarketing, data misuse unless consented to in Terms of Use).
What makes advertising "misleading or deceptive"?
A statement about a MATERIAL fact. Deceptive is judged OBJECTIVELY (not subjectively). Defence: due diligence (reasonable care). Can be on packaging or any marketing incl. online, by seller, employee or other agents. Can lead to criminal OR civil penalties.
Misleading advertising: examples list
Unsupported performance claims; multilevel marketing/pyramid selling; bargain claims about regular price (MSRP); selling at higher price than advertised / bait-and-switch; incorrect origin labelling ("Made in" vs "assembled in"); misleading prizes and contests; failure to disclose origin, food ingredients, credit/borrowing rates or safety issues (recalls).
Bait-and-switch
Advertising a low price when only 1 (or very few) are available at that price, then selling something else/at a higher price.
"Made in" vs "assembled in"
Origin labelling must be accurate and properly disclosed; a product assembled in Canada is not necessarily "Made in Canada".
Volkswagen emissions case
VW advertised diesel cars as "clean" and "environmentally friendly" but was found by regulators to be cheating emissions tests. Fines for false advertising plus over $60 million in the US for violating the Clean Air Act.
Dannon Activia case
Claimed "special bacterial ingredients" "clinically and scientifically proven" to boost immunity and regulate digestion, sold at 30% more. A customer challenged it; Dannon couldn't prove the claims and was fined $45 million.
Damage to a business from misleading claims beyond fines
Reputational harm, loss of consumer trust, lawsuits, and loss of sales (slide asks: unethical? bad business? should consumers be more skeptical?).
Online marketing/spam rules (summary)
Business must have consent to send marketing email, identify itself in the email, provide an "unsubscribe" mechanism. Failure: ISPs can cancel service and fines apply.
Disclosure in online/social media promotion
Must disclose known risks of the product AND promoters must indicate if they get a financial benefit from promoting it.
Kardashian / Diclegis case
Kim Kardashian promoted morning sickness drug Diclegis (made by Quebec company Duchesnay) on social media without mentioning side effects, risk warnings, or that she was paid. Violated disclosure rules. US FDA (like Health Canada) forced her to take the ad down; she was not fined.
Discussion: key issue in Kardashian case
Whether it is obvious it's an ad, and whether promotion + payment without disclosure is the violation. Questions: should celebrities disclose payment? What if they never used the product?
Natural Health Product Regulations
Require product licensing, evidence of safety and efficacy, labelling and disclosure, adverse reaction reporting, following human clinical trial rules, disclosing warnings and recalls.
Health Canada / NNHPD
Governmental regulatory body strengthening regulation of natural health products; created the Natural and Non-Prescription Health Products Directorate (NNHPD).
Cold-FX case
Sued in a consumer class action for claiming short-term relief from the common cold with no scientific evidence to support the claim.
CASL
Canadian Anti-Spam Legislation: updates to the Competition Act, CRTC Act and PIPEDA addressing online marketing.
CASL: spam and consent
Cannot send a commercial electronic message (CEM) without EXPRESS consent (cannot rely on implied consent) AND must provide a no-cost way to unsubscribe.
CASL penalties
Damages up to $200 per non-compliant CEM, max $1 million per day; CEOs, officers and directors can be held PERSONALLY liable.
CASL defence
Only defence is due diligence (drafting and implementing CASL policies, procedures and training).
Consumer remedies and penalties (4)
(1) Right to rescind a contract (cooling-off period), (2) right to refuse unsolicited goods (don't have to pay), (3) criminal penalties for some offences (price-fixing, agreements to restrict competition), (4) civil penalties and damages.
Cooling-off period
The right to rescind (change your mind about) a contract within a set time.
Why create environmental and climate laws? (problems)
Environmental harm (visible or not: oil spills, air pollution, climate change); business operations have environmental and health impact; community consensus is needed for projects; harm doesn't respect national borders; profitability and sustainability seen as mutually exclusive.
Who should pay for pollution and environmental degradation?
Slide debate: business? communities? taxpayers?
Why do some businesses want environmental laws?
Clear and equal rules, predictability, level playing field, opportunities to innovate and gain competitive advantage, reputation.
Shareholders vs environmental investment
Shareholders may resist spending that cuts profit; SRI (socially responsible investing) is investing that considers social/environmental impact; environmental laws also create opportunities for innovation.
Sustainability
Slide question: balancing economic growth with environmental protection so development continues without long-term environmental harm; implications for business strategy, reputation, investors.
Types of environmental law
Canadian (federal) + provincial + local/municipal + international agreements (with overlap between them) + common law.
Who is at risk of environmental liability?
Businesses and corporations (sometimes personally), landlords, banks and lenders: whoever is "responsible," including negligent parties.
Key national environmental laws
Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA), Impact Assessment Act, Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act, Clean Fuel Regulations, Clean Electricity Regulations, Oil and Gas Methane Regulations, Passenger Automobile and Light Truck GHG Emissions Regulations, Fisheries Act, Species at Risk Act, Sustainable Development Act.
Key BC environmental laws
Environmental Management Act, Environmental Assessment Act, Water Sustainability Act, Greenhouse Gas Industrial Reporting and Control Act, Climate Change Accountability Act, Low Carbon Fuels Act, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act.
Legislation vs regulations
Legislation = statutes (Acts) passed by a legislature. Regulations = more detailed rules made under the authority of a statute (by government/ministers). (Slide poses this as a question; this is the general definition.)
Environmental common law (tort)
Creates liability when a polluting substance from a business harms property or causes injury. Examples: negligence, riparian rights, nuisance, trespass, strict liability, Rylands v Fletcher.
Rylands v Fletcher
A reservoir was improperly built and overflowed, damaging another property. Even with no intention to harm, the act of polluting/escape was enough for liability (strict liability).
Environmental permits
Required before certain activities such as mining, fishing, forestry, certain land uses.
Environmental and Social Impact Assessments
Process a business must complete to evaluate risk and obtain approval from government (and communities) before a project can start.
Duty to Consult
Law obligating business to consult communities potentially impacted by a proposed activity (pipeline, mine). It is the obligation to HEAR concerns but does NOT give communities a project "veto".
Reputational risk, CSR and social licence
Businesses want to appear socially responsible (CSR) and must consult stakeholders (e.g. communities) to earn a "social licence to operate," even when not legally required (otherwise more reputational harm and costs).
Why is social licence challenging?
Community support can be hard to get, e.g. Indigenous communities where support may differ within the community.
Shareholder pressure on environmental risk
Investors can respond negatively if environmental risk is not managed (divestment campaigns against oil and gas companies; see ClientEarth v Shell).
Insurance and environmental risk
Insurers evaluate environmental/climate risk and whether a business manages it; this affects the cost (and availability) of insurance.
CEPA: purpose
Prevent and respond to pollution to promote environmental and human health alongside economic development, particularly sustainable development.
CEPA: what it does
Research, set standards/guidelines/codes of conduct, monitoring, inspection, prohibited substances, enforcement, remediation, penalties, whistleblower protection.
CEPA: government powers
Inspection powers, examining records and computers, requiring environmental assessments.
CEPA: business obligations
Duty to report an environmental problem or hazard, create a pollution prevention plan, exercise due diligence.
CEPA: penalties and remedies
Criminal penalties; company officials can be personally liable unless they show due diligence; individuals can seek damages from business.
Impact assessment (CIAA) purpose
Projects that may harm the environment must undergo impact assessment to identify and mitigate environmental and social impact, including hearings and consultation with affected communities. Laws: federal impact assessment legislation + provincial rules.
Challenges with impact assessment
How to assess environmental and social impact, how to mitigate, and the costs of harm and mitigation.
Pipeline case: legal questions
If an approved pipeline spills: who is responsible, who sues whom, how does the company show due diligence, what if poorly engineered pipes, what if an earthquake? Is consultation required or just PR? What if one group objects? How measure damages (undrinkable water, destroyed fisheries, climate change)?
Pipeline approval (case facts)
Enbridge (to US), Kinder Morgan (to Burnaby), TransCanada (south to US and east): cannot build without government approval and consultation.
Reputation management and CSR
Environmental harm prevention is costly and consultation takes time, but the reputational cost of environmental disasters is huge (see BP oil rig disaster).
Climate change laws: purpose
Balance sustainable economic growth with policies that reduce human impact on climate; promote clean energy (clean electricity, methane regulations for oil and gas).
Carbon tax vs cap and trade
Provinces set carbon tax and trading rules. Cap and trade: pollution is given a price and traded in markets so carbon emissions are priced by supply and demand.
Net Zero Emissions Accountability Act
Does NOT impose a carbon price on individual plants/businesses; requires national targets, emissions reduction plans and progress reports.
Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act + Output-Based Pricing System
Creates an industrial pricing system (separate from consumer pricing).
International climate rules
International initiatives (e.g. Paris Convention) become Canadian law.
Net zero vs carbon neutral / greenwashing
Slide issue: net zero claims affect reputation and marketing; misleading environmental claims are "greenwashing" (also a misleading advertising risk).
Climate legal risks
Businesses and governments increasingly sued for failing to meet climate rules (City of Victoria v Shell and other oil and gas companies; ClientEarth v Shell).
Beyond borders: international operations
Must comply with rules where you operate (US, EU), which may be MORE stringent (e.g. EU rules on GMO foods, food safety, ingredient/origin disclosure).
Nevsun case (Supreme Court of Canada)
Canadian businesses can be held legally responsible IN Canada for conduct outside Canada (may include international environmental obligations).
Absence of environmental rules abroad
Some countries have few or unenforced rules; Canadian businesses may see it as an opportunity (lower cost) or a risk (reputation, Nevsun-type liability).
Opportunities and innovation from environmental law
Compliance innovation (many ways to comply = competitive advantage), BAT, new products/services/markets.
Best Available Technology (BAT)
Many environmental laws require BAT but do NOT specify the technology; the goal is hitting the environmental target any number of ways.
Plastic bag laws: how do they create opportunities?
New markets for reusable bags and alternative materials, recycling technologies and packaging innovation.
Environmental risk management strategy (4 steps)
(1) Identify laws and obligations (all levels of government, impact assessment, consultation), (2) evaluate compliance and whether you're using opportunities, (3) evaluate costs of compliance vs financial/reputational harm of an accident (investors, insurance), (4) evaluate benefits of environmental/CSR reputation.
Oil and gas pipeline consortium case
Energy companies consider merging/collaborating to build pipelines to new markets after US tariffs; claim net-zero alignment; use brand ambassadors (Ryan Reynolds) and influencers to build social licence. Raises competition, false advertising/greenwashing, environmental law, consultation, and shareholder-disclosure issues.
Legal risk management framework (3 steps)
Identification (what laws apply?), Evaluation (costs of compliance vs non-compliance, feasibility, future laws), Strategy (non-compliance, partial compliance, or comply and innovate; consultation, social licence, SRI/ESG, insurance, contracts, corporations/limited liability).
Pipeline case: competition issues
Does the merger create a dominant market position? Abuse of dominance? Consumer impact?
Pipeline case: advertising issues
Net zero claims: objective or subjective? Misleading or false? What can be said? Disclosure and transparency including online, and influencer disclosure.
Compliance strategies (3)
Non-compliance (accept the risk/cost), partial compliance, or comply and innovate.
ESG / SRI
ESG = environmental, social, governance factors; SRI = socially responsible investing. Opportunities for businesses that perform well on them.
Triple bottom line
Value measured on three fronts: profit, people (social) and planet (environment).
ClientEarth v Shell (directors' duty)
See Business Types module: shareholders sued Shell directors personally for failing to address material climate risk.
MODULE: TYPES OF BUSINESS AND ELECTRONIC BUSINESS RISKS
Why do businesses need rules on types of business?
Clarity on liability, governance, raising money and obligations; different structures balance personal risk, flexibility and cost.