1/70
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Do individuals often use more or less evidence in their decision making?
What are the best ways to answer our questions?
Meta-analyses, RCTs (experiments)
What are the worst ways to answer our questions?
Personal anecdotes, intuition
Comparing own practices against another entity's practices (usually successful) with the idea you can copy that and see the same results
Benchmarking
The primary issue with benchmarking - you can't generalize from 1 of experience of many because there is a low likelihood similar results will be produced due to other factors
N of 1 problem
Evidence gotten from systematic testing / experimentation
Empirical evidence
Human behavior is complex - can we predict it?
Yes (but it is hard)
Examines relationship between 2+ variables
Correlational research
What are the benefits of correlational research?
Easy to collect data, can study non-changeable variables
What are the drawbacks of correlational research?
Cannot identify causation
An external variable (Z) affects both variables (X and Y) measured in the correlational study
Third variable problem
When two variables are correlated without a causal connection (ex: ice cream sales and crime rates)
Spurious correlation
Manipulating one variable to see its effect on another variable
Experimental research (Randomized control trial, A/B test, experiment)
Each person in a study has an equal chance of ending up in experimental or control groups
Random assignment
What does it mean to manipulate a variable?
Intentionally change the independent variable to see its effect on the dependent variable
Researchers manipulate variables while “holding everything else constant.” Why do researchers do this?
They can single out variable they manipulated as the cause of the change
What are the benefits of experiments?
Establishes causality
What are the drawbacks of experiments?
Some variables are hard to manipulate, not always ethical
Analysis of all the studies ever done on a certain topic
Meta-analyses
Why are meta-analyses better than single experiments?
Replicability, generalizability, elimination individual bias
Ability to get same result across multiple trials, since it is always possible an effect happened by chance
Replicability
Measures how much findings can be applicable to broader situations, since it is always possible an effect only occurs in certain times
Generalizability
Use of different decision criteria for preferred and non-preferred conclusions
Motivated skepticism
In this study, subjects who wanted the strip to not change colors were satisfied when it didn't. However, subjects who did want it to change colors kept licking it when it didn't change and said the test was probably incorrect (motivated skepticism).
TAA enzyme study
Why is the TAA enzyme study relevant?
Demonstrates individual biases in experiment
What are the 6 standards of applying business knowledge (from the Evidence-Based Management reading)
Don't treat old ideas like new
Be suspicious of "breakthroughs"
Celebrate collective brilliance
Emphasize drawbacks and benefits
Individual stories aren't a valid research method
Have a neutral view before exploration
Aspects of a person's behavior that exhibit consistency across contexts (stable and enduring)
Personality
Generic personality statements that could apply to basically anyone
Barnum statements
People tend to believe feedback about their own personality no matter how generic that feedback is
Barnum effect
Lack of reliability, lack of validity (types vs. traits), lacks actual predictive value
Drawbacks of the MBTI
Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeabelness, Neuroticism
OCEAN (Big 5)
Why is OCEAN better than MBTI?
These 5 traits explain the most variance in personality
High = creative, curious
Low = conventional, concrete
Job performance = improved in jobs requiring flexibility and creativity
Openness
High = efficient, hardworking
Low = disorganized, late
Job performance = strongest correlation to improved performance (r = 0.15)
Conscientiousness
High = talkative, outgoing
Low = reserved, shy
Job performance = improved performance in people-oriented jobs
Extraversion
High = helpful, sefless
Low = critical, blunt
Job performance = improved performance in people-oriented jobs
Agreeableness
High = Anxious, worried
Low = Calm under pressure, stable
Job performance = NONE, but less satisfaction in job and in life
Neuroticism
Do people find jobs that suit their personality where they can thrive, do they earn more?
Yes (and they earn 15% more vs. those whose personalities don't match!)
Can you change your personality?
Yes (and major life events often induce gradual change)
What is the correlation of personality traits in a person over time?
0.4 to 0.6 (over 10-year span)
Unaware, unintentional, involuntary, effortless
Automatic processing (System 1)
Aware, intentional, voluntary, effortful
Controlled processing (System 2)
These 2 things are required for controlled processes to occur
Ability and motivation
Mental categorizations that we use to organize the world and make our thoughts more efficient
Schemas
What are the 3 benefits of schemas?
Interpret the world, what to focus on, efficient
What are the drawbacks of schemas?
They can distort our judgements (and persist even after proven wrong)
Actively seeking out info that confirms an already-held idea + avoiding info that disconfirms that idea
Confirmation bias
What happened when individuals with their own beliefs are exposed to mixed information?
Both sides believed more strongly in their original idea
Tendency for people to act in ways that enable the very thing they expect to happen
Self-fulfilling prophecy
Mental shortcuts or "rules” for quick decision-making
Heuristics
What is the difference between a schema and a heuristic?
Schemas are just categories (don’t need any input)
Heuristics are used in quick decisions (needs input, results in output)
Judgement based on how easy / quickly something came to mind (based on how easy it is to think of examples)
Availability heuristic
How the availability heuristic can occur, especially when there’s not enough info
Base rate neglect
Tendency to be influenced by the way problems are presented
Framing
People are more sensitive to losses than gains, and will take more risks in order to avoid / reduce a loss
Loss aversion
Overconsidering what has already been invested into something when making a decision
Sunk cost fallacy
Sticking with original plan because you’ve already gotten started, even though it’s not the best idea
Escalation of commitment
Tendency to use numbers you see (even unrelated ones) as a starting point for numeric estimates only
Anchoring heuristic
People’s tendency to view themselves as above average
Better than average effect
Tendency to overestimate how common a belief you have is shared by others
False consensus bias
Being overconfident you could have predicted something after it already happened
Hindsight bias (knew it all along effect)
It is hard to put ourselves in a position of not knowing something once we already learned it
Curse of knowledge
People often underestimate the amount of time it will take for them to complete a task
Planning fallacy
How can you avoid the planning fallacy?
Consider all the steps of a plan
Considering why a certain behavior occurred
Attribution
Thinking a behavior happened because of how a person inherently is
Internal attributions
Thinking a behavior happened because of the situation they’re in
External attributions
Over-attributing behaviors we see as internal causes
Fundamental attribution error (FAE)
Assuming a person is behaving a certain way because of how they internally are, ignoring the situational factors leading to that behavior
Quizmaster effect
In the Opinion Science podcast, what was the cab driver study?
On good money days, drivers would quit earlier (not making rational decisions)
In the Opinion Science podcast, what made Thaler, Kahneman, and Tversky (who came later) more successful compared to what Simon had done?
They explored why people wouldn’t always make the rational choice through experimentation