PSC 249 International relations Final

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/37

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

38 Terms

1
New cards

What were the key facts for Bas v. Tingy

During the conflict between France and the U.S. in the early 1800’s the commander of an American public vessel (Tingy) argued that based on a 1799 statute that he should be entitled to a reward of ½ of the value of an American merchant ship he had recaptured from the french.

2
New cards

What was the statute of 1799 in Bas v Tingy? What was the argument that Bas (ship owner) made that he didn’t have to pay and the 1799 statute didn’t apply?

The 1799 act allowed for ⅛ salvage if retaken from an enemy within 24hrs and ½ if after 96hrs from the enemy. The ship owner argued that since congress had not declared War on france it was not considered an enemy of the state, therefore the statute did not apply. 

3
New cards

What was the question/issue before the court, the holding, reasoning, and the rule of law established in Bas. Tingy

Question: did the conflicts between the U.S. and France constitute a state of “war” or make France an “enemy” under the 1799 Act?

Holding: Ruled in favor of Tingy.

Reasoning: a partial limited war existed between the U.S. and France making France an enemy and entitled the commander to his ½ 

Rule of Law: war can be general/perfect (Congress formally declares it) or it can be limited/imperfect (specific actions authorized by Congress)

  • Congress possess the power to authorize a partial war without a full declaration of war

  • Countries can still be considered enemies of the state without a formal declaration of war


4
New cards

What were the key facts in Brown v. United States

Congress declared war on Great Britain and France (War or 1812) British merchants chartered a ship to carry pine timber, which was unloaded in Massachusetts shortly after the declaration of the War of 1812. The timber was later sold to an American citizen. The U.S. gov sought to condemn the timber as enemy property.

5
New cards

What was the issue, holding, reasoning, and rule of law established in Brown v. United States

Issue: Does Congress have to implicitly authorize the Executive Branch to confiscate enemy property (pine timber owned by a British citizen) located within the U.S.

Ruiling: Ruled against the U.S.

Reasoning: british-owned property found on land in the U.S. at the start of the war of 1812 could not be confiscated as enemy property without a specific legislative act from Congress authorizing it. In the constitution it grants Congress the right to “declare war, grant letters of marque and reprisal, and make rules concerning captures on land and water”

Rule of Law: a declaration of war foes not automatically confiscate enemy property within the U.S. and the power to do so only belongs to Congress


6
New cards

What were the key facts in Orlando v. Laird

During the Vietnam war, two enlistees in the army sues the secretary of defense and the secretary of the Army and certain commanding officers from enforcing orders telling the enlistees to report for transfer to Vietnam. Congress never made an official declaration of war, however they did authorize personnel deployment via a draft and passed the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution (gave the president Lyndon B Johnson broad authority to use conventional military force in Southeast Asia without a formal declaration of war. Congress had also allocated billions of dollars to carry out these operations in Southeast Asia. Congress had also just renewed the Military Selective Service Act with full knowledge that persons conscripted under that Act had been, and would continue to be sent to Vietnam

7
New cards

What was the question/issue, holding, reasoning, and rule of law established in Orlando v. Laird?

Question: Did the secretary of defense have the right to draft them under the Constitution AND does the constitution require an explicit declaration of war to authorize military operations or do collaborative legislative acts constitute valid congressional authorization

Holding: Yes, the secretary had the right.

Reasoning: he court held that there was an abundance of evidence of mutual participation between Congress and the Pres. by continuously funding military operations, renewing the draft laws right before this case, and the Golf of Tonkin Resolution and drafting manpower Congress implicitly authorized and ratified the Vietnam conflict

Rule of Law: Congress does not have to formally declare war to authorize military operations and funding. The constitution requires that congress mutually participates with the Executive when in prolonged military conflict, but this authorization does not require a strict declaration of war 


8
New cards

What were the key facts of Durand v. Hollins? And what was Hollin’s Argument?

In 1854 (during the gold rush) Captain George Hollins of the USS Cyane ordered the bombardment of Greytown, Nicaragua in response to the theft and destruction of American property and an attack on an American Minister. Durand was an American citizen living in Nicaragua at the time of the bombardment and destroyed his property

Hollin’s argument was that his actions were authorized by the Secretary of the Navy

9
New cards

What was the question, holding, reasoning, and key facts in Durand v. Hollins?

Question: was the Secretary of the Navy allowed to order a bombardment. And could Hollins be held personally responsible for the destruction of property

Ruiling: Ruled against Durand.

Reasoning: the Executive has the broad authority to conduct foreign affairs and has the authority to make orders when the lives/property of American citizens are at stake. 

Rule of Law: Congress doesn’t have to authorize the executive when it involves Americans lives and property are in danger abroad because one of the President’s constitutional obligations is to protect american citizens and their property abroad

10
New cards

What were the key facts of the Prize Cases?

  • During the Civil War, following the attack on Fort Sumter Pres. Lincoln proclaimed a blockade of the Southern ports in 1861

    • Union warships seized merchant vessels attempting to trade with the Confederacy 

    • Ship owners sued for the return of their property arguing that Lincoln lacked the constitutional authority to institute a blockade or seize ships as war “prizes” because Congress had not formally declared war

    • The owners of the ships wanted compensation for their ships being sized and sold in a prize court 


11
New cards

What was the question, holding, reasoning, and rule of law established in the Prize Cases?

Question: did the president have the right to institute a blockade of ports in possession of persons in armed rebellion against the Government on the principles of international law (and without a formal declaration of war)/Did a state of war exist that would justify a resort to these means of subduing the hostile force 

Holding: Ruled in favor of Lincoln

Reasoning: even thought the executive cannot initiate or declare war against a foreign nation, he is constitutionally empowered as Commander in Chief to resist sudden attacks and suppress an internal insurrection without waiting for congressional approval or a declaration of war. Lincoln had an obligation to act because the union and constitution were at risk

Rule of Law: established a major precedent for broad presidential authority to use military force during national emergencies and domestic crises (resist force by force)


12
New cards

What were the key facts in Reid v. Covert? What were the arguments for both sides/

Clarice Covert (civilian) and Dorothy Smith (civilian) both killed their husbands (air force sergeant and army officer) on bases abroad. Both women were tried by a court martial for the murdered under the UCMJ. Both women claimed they were insane at the time of the murder and were both sentenced to life in prison. They both filed for a writ of habeas corpus arguing that the constitution prohibited their trial by military authorities.

The Gov argued that it had the broad unlimited authority to subject civilian dependents of military personnel overseas to military trials and the UCMJ

13
New cards

what was the issue, holding, reasoning, and rule of law in Reid v. Covert

Issue: Did the government have the right to try these women under the UCMJ and court martial

Holding: ruled in favor of Covert (the wives) stating that they have to be tried in a civilian court

Reasoning: The governemnt does not have broad authority when acting abroad in relation to american citizens that violates their constiutional rights. These women were not military personnel, therefore they shouldn’t have been subjected to being tried in a military court. It also violated their constitutional rights to be tried by a jury of peers.

Rule of Law: When a U.S. civilian commits a capital crime (a crime punishable by death) outside the territorial jurisdiction of the U.S. retain their constitutional rights, especially the 5th ad 6th amendments which include the right to a jury trial and cannot be tried in military-courts martial during peacetime

14
New cards

What were the key facts Ex-Parte Milligan

During the Civil War, the U.S. general commanding a district of Indiana arrested Lambdin Milligan. Milligan (U.S.) citizen living in Indiana was accused of conspiracy against the government, giving aid and comfort to the rebels, initiating insurrection, disloyal practices, and violating the laws of war. He was tried before a military commission, which found Milligan guilty and sentenced. him to be hanged. Milligan petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus.

15
New cards

What was the issue, holding, reasoning, and rule of law established in Ex-Parte Milligan

Issue: did the executive have the right to try Milligan by military commission?

Holding: ruled in favor of Milligan

Reasoning: The courts in Indiana were open and functioning, therefore, the fed gov cannot issue military commissions to try civilians.

Rule of Law: If the courts are open then martial rule can never exist

16
New cards

What was the statement that Roosevelt issued 2 months after Pearl Harbor (Korematsu v. United States)

2 months after Pearl Harbor Pres. Roosevelt issued an order stating that the Secretary of War and the Military Commanders that he designates to perscribe military areas where any or all persons may be excluded and with usch respect to which the right of any person to enter, remain, or leave, shall be subject to wahtever restrictions the Secretary of War deems appropriate.

17
New cards

What were the key facts in Korematsu v. United states? What was Korematsu’s arguement?

In persuance to the military order, the commanding general of the western command excluded japanese-americans from the west coast area and ordered them cerfewed and/or detaied in relocation centers. Korematsu was an american citizen of japanese decent that was convicted under this statute remaining in San Leandro California, a “military area” contrary to the Civilian Exclusion Order.

Korematsu argued that the government’s military order violated his 5th amendment right to due process and amounted to unconstitutional racial discrimination and that all danger of Japanese invasion of the West Coast had disappeared

18
New cards

Issue, holding, reasoning, and key facts in Korematsu v. United States

Issue: Can the government have the power to exclude an american citizen from these areas and exclude them and impose penalties

Holding: Ruled against Korematsu

Reasoning: Justice Hugo Black wrote that while any legal restrictions curtailing the civil rights of a single racial group are "suspect" and subject to the "most rigid scrutiny," wartime security imperatives justified the exclusion order as a matter of military necessity rather than racial prejudice (Basically that because it was a time of war and threats to national security they had the right to exclude certain citizens from areas)

19
New cards

Key Facts in Ex-Parte Endo

Endo was a U.S. citizen of japanese ancestry who was evicted from Sacramento CA in 1942 pursuant to the same military orders in Korematsu. She was relocated to a war relocation center where the loyal and disloyal evacuees, detain the disloyal ones and relocate the loyal ones. The government said that Endo was loyal, she proved she was loyal, but still wasn’t allowed to leave (arbitrary detention) on the basis that the area she wanted to return to was “hostile” towards Japanese American’s. Endo petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus because she was being unlawfully detained.

20
New cards

What was the issue, holding, reasoning, and legal issue established in Ex Parte Endo

Issue: Did the government have the right to detain Endo on the basis that the area she wanted to return to was “hostile” even though they said she was loyal and she proved she was loyal

Ruiling: Ruled in favor of Endo

Reasoning: neither the EO 9066 nor the War Relocation Authority possessed the statutory authority to detain citizens whom the government conceded were loyal to the U.S.

Rule of Law: The fed gov doesnt have the statutory authority to detain or continue to confine a loyal law-abiding citizen

21
New cards

What were the key facts in New York Times v. U.S.

  • The NY Times and Washington post obtained from Daniel Ellsberg, a former defense department official, portions of a secret defense department study known as the pentagon papers and began to publish them.

  • The president made a court injunction to stop the publishing of the papers

  • The papers analyzed in detail the formulation and execution of American diplomatic and military policy in Indochina. The executive (Nixon) sought to enjoin further publication of the PP on the grounds that publication would jeopardize national security, result in the death of americans, and prolong the vietnam war


22
New cards

What the issue, holding, reasoning, rule of law established in New York Times v. United States

Issue: Can the Executive prevent the publication of the Pentagon Papers?

Holding: No

Reasoning: violates the 1st amendment because the papers were not attained illegally, and the government failed to prove that the publication would cause a “grave and irreparable” danger to national security

Rule of Law: any gov. Attempt to block publication of information carries a heavy presumption of unconstitutionality and the gov bears a strict burden of proving that publication will result in direct, immediate, irreparable damage to national security

23
New cards

What is the historical context for Hamdi v. Rumsfeld?

Takes place post 9/11 after congress passed a joint resolution which authorized use of military force (AUMF). Following this, the U.S. armed forces were sent to Afghanistan where they engaged in combat with Al Qaeda and the Taliban.

24
New cards

What happened to Hamdi in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld?

During the conflict between Al Qaeda and the U.S., Hamdi (U.S. citizen) was taken into U.S. custody in Afghanistan. He was then sent to Guantanamo Bay and then moved to a navel brig in South Carolina. The U.S. gov maintained that he was an enemy combatant who could be held without trial essentially indefinitely (as long as the pres determines it necessary)

25
New cards

What did Hamdi’s father do on his behalf? And what was the gov’s response/argument?

  1. He filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus

  2. Gov said that Hamdi had traveled to Afghan in 2001 and affiliated himself with the Taliban military and surrendered to Northern Alliance forces while carrying a rifle


26
New cards

What was the question/issue (2), ruiling, reasoning, and key facts in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld?

Issue: 1.  does the Executive have the authority to detain citizens who qualify as “enemy combatants." 2. can the executive hold Hamdi in indefinite detention without formal charges or a meaningful opportunity to challenge that classification unconstitutional

Ruiling: Yes to both questions

Reasoning: Although of the AUMF joint resolution that congress passed that authorized the President to use “all necessary and appropriate force” against “nations, organizations, or persons” associated with 9/11, it did not give the executive absolute unreviewable authority to detain citizens

Rule: The Court held that a U.S. citizen detained as an enemy combatant has the right to a meaningful opportunity to contest the factual basis of their detention before a neutral decision maker.

27
New cards

What were the key facts in Al-Aulaqi v. Obama? And what was the argument?

Al-Aulaqi was a dual U.S.-Yemeni citizen who was living in Yemen. The US Treasury Department designated Anwar Al-Aulaqui as a specially designated global terrorist due to his alleged operational role in Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) and had called for jihad attacks on the U.S. The plaintiff (Al-Aulaui’s father) filed suit against the President, secretary of defense, and the director of the CIA.

Al-Aulaqi’s father argued that his son was placed on an approved gov “kill list” and would use lethal force against his son without charge, trial, or convisction and doing so would violate the constitution and international law

28
New cards

What did Al-Aulaqi'‘s father want? (4 things) in Al-aulaqi v.Obama

He sought declaratory and injunctive relief

  1. Declaration would state that outside of armed conflict the Constitution prohibits defendants from carrying out the targeted killing of U.S. citizens except for instances where they present a concrete, specific, and imminent threat to life or physical safety. 

  2. declaration stating that outside of armed conflict, "treaty and customary international law" prohibit the targeted killing of all individuals - regardless of their citizenship - except in those same, limited circumstances.

  3. Preliminary injunction prohibiting defendants from internationally killing Anwar Al-Aulaqi unless he “presents a concrete…..threat to life”

  4. Injunction ordering defendants to disclose the criteria that the U.S. uses to determine whether a U.S. citizen will be targeted for killing


29
New cards

What were the problems with this case? (not the issue)

  1. Judicial approval is required when the U.S. decides to target a citizen overseas for electronic surveillance, but judicial scrutiny is prohibited when the U.S. decides to target the killing of a citizen

  2. Can a citizen vindicate his constitutional rights while also engaging and planning for an orginazation that has already carried out terrorist attacks and evaded law enforcement

  3. Can an assiassination of a U.S. citizen be ordered without first affording them any form of judicial process whatsoever based on the assertion that he is a dangerous member of a terrorist organization

  4. How is the judicial branch supposed to make decisions that require the knowledge and information that only the executive has 

  5. When would it ever make sense to disclose in advance to the target of contemplated military action and the precise standards under which it will take that military action

  6. How does the evolving AQAP relate to core Al Qaeda for purposes of assessing the legality of targeting AQAP under the 9/18/2001 AUMF


30
New cards

What was the issue, holding, reasoning, and rule of law established in Al-Aulqui v. Obama?

Issue: Is a lawsuit seeking to enjoin the Executive Branch from carrying out the targeted killing of a U.S. citizen abroad, filed by the citizen's father, justiciable in federal court? And is the plaintiff the proper person to bring the constitutional and statuatory challanges he claims.

Ruiling: ruiled to dismiss the case

Reasoning: because the plaintiff lacks standing to sue because he failed to provide an adequate explanation for his son’s inability to appear on his own behalf and the Court does not hold that the Executive possesses "unreviewable authority to order the assassination of any American whom he labels an enemy of the state." aka nonjusticiable

Rule of Law: A lawsuit challenging the Executive Branch's authority to conduct a targeted killing of a U.S. citizen abroad who is an alleged operational leader of a terrorist organization presents a non-justiciable political question. A relative cannot establish 'next friend' or 'third-party' standing to bring such a claim where the citizen has not been rendered inaccessible to the courts by government action and has expressed disdain for the U.S. legal system.


31
New cards

What was the neutrality controversy?

France was an ally and helped the u.s gain independence. The French Revolution breaks out and the president (george washington) issued a proclamation that stated that the U.S. will remain neutral. This including the prohibition of arms sales to any party involved, provide aid, harboring war ships for repair/protection, or allowing citizens to fight for either side. He also said that international law is u.s. law, so anyone caught breaking these rules is liable to be prosecuted.

32
New cards
33
New cards
34
New cards
35
New cards
36
New cards
37
New cards
38
New cards