1/59
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Constitution
body of laws, rules and practices that sets out the way in which a state or society is organised
what is the magna carta?
1215
King John was a ruthless King. Abuse of royal powers and conflict with the Church.
Revolt led to the defeat of the monarchy and John was forces to sign the Magna Carter at Runnymede in berkshire
what are the key provisions of the magna carta?
first time since 1066 that power of monarch limited
- king could not raise tax without consent of people
- right to trial by jury guaranteed
- justice had to be free and fair
- nobles could select a committee of 25 to scrutinise the actions of the king
what is the bill of rights?
1689 - came about after the declaration of rights was modified and placed on statute book as bill of rights
key provisions:
- only parliament could pass or remove laws
- principle of free elections away from govt influence established
- judicial power of monarchy limited and court system not be abused by executive
- monarch could not ignore parliament by refusing to call it as parliaments would be held frequently
what is the declaration of rights?
a statement of the rights of the subject which also declared that the monarch could not act without the consent of parliament
why was the bill of rights a milestone in the development of the UK's constitution?
- removed royal interference in elections
- placed limits on royal prerogative
- established principles of rights or freedoms from govt
- established principle of parliamentary sovereignty
what were the problems with the bill of rights?
- monarch still held enormous powers over war, the peaceful running of the kingdom and foreign policy
- as a statue law it held no higher legal authority so could easily be repealed or replaced by a future parliament
what are acts of parliament?
laws that have been formally passed by parliament and given royal assent by the monarch
what is the act of settlement?
1701
established the several principles that had been suggested during the debates over the bill of rights
- judges could not be removed without consent of parliament
- monarch could not take England into war without consent of parliament
- monarch could not make decisions alone and had to consult the privy council (group that advised the monarch on the use of the royal prerogative)
After the act, anyone appointed to the cabinet had to resign their seat in the HoC and stand in a by-election (cont until 1918). Meant power of monarch and then PM, to appoint cabinet ministers was limited by the fear of losing a by-election
what was the first parliament act?
1911
to prevent the lords from ever again rejecting a proposal that had been in popular support in the democratically elected HOC, and to establish the primacy of the Commons through statue law rather than via a convention, PM Herbert Asquith introduced bill that would:
- give commons exclusive powers over money bills
- allow the lords to delay a bill for 2 years only
- reduce the duration of a parliament from 7 to 5 years
what was the second parliament act?
1949
- resulted from a conflict between Labour govt and Cons dominated HoL.
- to prevent lords from blocking the Iron and Steel act, Lab controlled govt attempted to pass new act which would reduce time which lords could delay a legislation from 2 years to 1 year, or two parliamentary sessions
- lords voted against act and after 2 year, commons invoked 1911 act to bypass lords and force through the legislation
OVERALL - the two acts marked the shift in power from the HoL to the Hoc.
Removal of the lords powers to veto primary legislation introduced in the commons.
Lord loss of power over money bills, and reduced time for delaying legislation made Lords weaker chamber
limited government
system in which the powers of government are subject to legal constraints as well as checks and balances w/i the political system
codified constitution
A single, authoritative document that sets out the laws, rules and principles by which a state is governed, and which protects the rights of citizens
status of a fundamental law and is superior to all other law
entrenched
used to determine whether actions of other key players are constitutional
e.g. US constitution of 1789
uncodified constitution
constitution where laws, rules and principles specifying how a state is to be governed is not gathered in a single document but instead in a variety of sources
no fundamental law and has status as regular statute
not entrenched so amended in way as ordinary law
limited judicial review as no single doc that senior judges can use.
entrenched
difficult to change ("dug in"), often requires supermajorities or a referendum
what is a Fundamental Law
law deliberately set above regular statute in terms of status and given a degree of protection against regular laws passed by the legislature
differences between codified and an uncodified constitution
codified:
- rules and principles in a single authoritative document: constitution
- status of fundamental law and superior to all other law
- entrenched, special procedures make it difficult to change
- courts use constitution to determine whether the actions of other key players are constitutional
uncodified:
- no single authoritative document, rules and principles found in number of sources unwritten and written
- same status as regular statute; no fundamental law
-limited judicial review as no single document to use.
what is statute law as a source of the constitution
law created by parliament.
acts of parliament have to be approved by the HoC, HoL and monarch before placed in statue books and have force of law.
however not all act have constitutional significance as not all have bearing on fundamental relationship b/w the state and the people or between institutions that make up th e state. e.g. 1991 dangerous dogs act.
however, statute law is the supreme source of constitution because parliament is sovereign.
what is common law as a source of the constitution
law derived from general customs or traditions and the decision of judges.
judicial review to clarify or establish a legal position where statute law is unclear or absent.
but parliamentary sovereignty means that govt of day can overturn such common law by acts of parliament. therefore cannot claim govt actions as unconstitutional only unlawful.
what is the royal prerogative as a source of the constitution (in common law sec)
discretionary powers of the crown that are exercised by gov ministers in monarchs name
-appoint ministers and choose PM
- give royal assent to legislation
- declare war and negotiate treaties
what are conventions as a source of the constitution
established norms of political behaviour, rooted in past experience rather than the law, considered to be binding.
written source of the constitution.
usage over time that gives them their authority e.g. the monarch by convention must give their assent to Acts of Parliament. only time this was refused in 1707 with Queen Anne refusing Scottish militias bill
new conventions can be established, even though some may fall into disuse over time e.g. gordon brown announced UK would not declare war without a parliamentary vote.
what are authoritative works as a source of the constitution
handful of long established legal and political texts that have come to be accepted as reference points to know "who can do what" under the UK constitution
have persuasive authority
help identify, interpret and understand values in constitution
e.g. A.V Dicey's 'An introduction to the study of the law of the constitution' (1885) focus on parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law. system of a responsible cannot in a parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarch
what is the European Union law as a source of our constitution
following European communities act 1972, UK became member of EEC on 1st jan 1973, EEC--> EC--> EU, and judgements of the European court of justice have all become part of the British constitution - due to 1958 treaty of Rome incorporated into UK law at the time of our joining of the EEC
European law takes precedent over UK law.
what is Parliamentary Sovereignty
doctrine that parliament has absolute legal authority within the state. Has legislative supremacy.
parliament is the supreme law making body constructed around:
- parliament can legislate subject of choosing
- legislation cannot be overturned by any higher authority
- no parliament can bind successors.
HOWEVER
e.g. under European committees act 1973, parliament effectively agreed to make itself subservient to European law
- also general elections transferring a degree of legislative power to the people
what is devolution
process by which a central government delegates power to another (lower) tier of government while retaining ultimate sovereignty.
what is the rule of law
legal theory + relationship between the state and the individual is governed by law --> protects one from arbitrary state action
A.V Dicey:
- no one can be punished without trial
- no one is above the law and are all subject to the same justice
- general principles of constitution such as personal freedoms result from judges-made common law, rather than from parliamentary statue or executive order.
hold everyone accountable
everyone equal under law
laws passed by parliament must be interpreted and applied by independent judiciary, free from political interference.
essential feature of a liberal democracy
what is a unitary state
highly centralised state whose political power is focused at the centre - central govt has ultimate authority over subnational institutions.
centre dominates the political, economic and cultural life of the state.
high degree of administrative standardisation as all areas of state are governed in the same way
what is a union state
whose component parts have come together through treaty or union of crowns
high degree of administrative standardisation but components retain some pre-union features e.g. separate legal systems
political power conc at centre, but component nations have some degree of autonomy through devolution
what is a federal state
constitution divides decision making authority between national (federal) and regional (state) tiers of govt
all tiers protected by the const, one cannot abolish another.
regions in the state have distinctive political and cultural identity.
What is a constitutional monarchy?
A political system in which the monarch is the formal head of state but the monarch's legal powers are exercised by government ministers
what is a cabinet government
a.v. dicey, the uk political system was a cabinet govt in the mid 19th century
A system of government in which executive power is vested in a cabinet, whose members exercise collective responsibility, rather than a single office
prime-ministerial government
argued to have replaced the cabinet govt.
A system of government in which the prime minister is the dominant actor and is able to bypass the cabinet
strengths of the UK constitution: Ad
adaptability:
has evolved in face of changed circumstances
reforms introduced where clear case for change enabling constitution to adapt w.o need to supermajorities or approval of a referendum
- why Tory's view constitution as organic rather than an artificial creation
strengths of the UK constitution: SG
strong govt:
traditional constitution provides for a strong and effective govt.
doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty dictates legislature holds supreme authority. govt able to implement most of objectives as cabinet is party based and governing party generally exercises sig control over legislative process in HoC through its majority.
strengths of the UK constitution: Ac
accountability:
govt accountable to parliament that scrutinises activities and wider electorate.
in general election under a two-party system, voters choose between alt govt.
unpopular govt pay price at the polls.
weaknesses of the UK constitution: O&U
outdated and undemocratic:
key elements of common law, notably the royal prerogative date back to medieval time - like HoL throwback to pre democratic era - hard to justify hereditary principle in a liberal democratic state
weaknesses of the UK constitution: CoP
concentration of power:
power conc dangerously at the centre and few safeguards against exercise of state power
parliamentary sovereignty and absence of cod constitution means that key points of the rule of law not protected
govt with strong majority can force through legislation which weakens other institutions - lord hailsham referring it to an 'elected dictatorship'
weaknesses of the UK constitution: LoC
lack of clarity:
not always immediately clear where govt has acted unconstitutionally
parliament controlled by govt of day and is final arbiter of constitution.
govt can use control to pass new Act that overturn unfavourable rulings in courts
right of citizens poorly entrenched, hard for citizens to engage with the system.
new labour constitutional reform 1997-2010 : R
rights:
HRA 1998 enshrined most of the provisions of the ECHR in UK law:
e.g. - right to life, liberty, fair trial etc....
all bills introduced at west ministers are reviewed by lawyers to make sure they are HRA compliant.
govt forced a derogation from article 5 of the ECHR (right to liberty and security) in the wake of 0/11 in order to allow the detention of foreign nationals suspected of terrorist activities.
new labour and constitutional reform; D
Devolution:
- scottish parliament with primary legislative and tax raising powers
- NI assembly with primary legilsative powers
- welsh Assembly with secondary legislative powers
- directly elected mayor of london and london assembly
- elected mayors in some english authorities
what is the West Lothian question?
why should Scottish MPs be able to vote on English matters, when English MPs cannot vote on matters devolved to the Scottish parliament?
new labour constitutional reform 1997-2010: R
Rights
HRA 1998 incorporates the European convention on HR into UK law. Right protected by convention include:
- right to life
- right to liberty and personal security
- right to fair trial
- right to marry and start family
- freedom of thought and expression
- freedom from discrimination
new labour constitutional reform 1997-2010: PR
Parliamentary reform:
- HoL Act 1999: abolished the right of a but 92 hereditary peers to sit and vote In the upper house.
- lords compromised of mainly life peers and no political majority.
- yet labour govt made little process with 2nd stage to settle final composition and powers of the reformed HoL.
- division b/w HoC and HoL on how reform should progress.
- HoL favoured appointed model, HoC favoured partially/elected
- chairs of select committees to be elected by backbenchers
- BBBC determine business of the HoC for 1 day each week.
- e-petitons from the public
what did the FT Parliament's act 2011 do?
established pattern of fixed general elections every 5 years starting in 2015.
remove ability of PM to call an election at a politically advantageous time
what did the Scotland act 2012 do?
gave scottish government the power to vary income tax up or down by 10p In the £ and devolved further power to the Scottish government, including in the area of regulation of controlled drugs. Allowed the scottish government to borrow up to £2.2bn per annum
what did the House of Lords reform act 2014 do?
aimed at halting the increase in the number of the those eligible to sit and vote in the HoL, by going existing peers the right to retire or resign their seats.
Peers can be removed s a result of a serious criminal offence or non-attendance.
54 peers had resigned under this act by 2016 and 4 removed as a result of non-attendance.
what did the Wales act 2014 do?
- UK's response to the Silk Common's recommendation on further devolution to Wales.
- transferred control to one smaller taxes to devolved institutions in Wales
- also changed name from Welsh Assembly government to the Welsh government.
what did the Wales act 2017 do?
gave the welsh assembly tax raising powers, further cementing the primary legislative authority that devolved institutions in Wales had been granted in the wake of the 2011 Welsh referendum
what is the Barnett formula?
The funding mechanism devised in 1978 by Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Labour MP Joel Barnett. Translates changes in public spending in England into equivalent changes in the block grants for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, calculated on the basis of population. Resulted in higher public spending per person than England.
what is EVEL?
English votes for English laws (EVEL) is a set of procedures of the House of Commons of the Parliament of the United Kingdom whereby legislation which affects only England requires the support of a majority of MPs representing English constituencies
system used for the first time in January 2016
arguments for a codified constitution
-logical conclusion of recent constitutional reforms
- would provide greater clarity on what is constitutional
- would be an authoritative reference point for the courts
- sets limits on the powers of the state and its institutions
-provides greater protection for the rights of citizens
- informs citizens about the values and workings of the political system
arguments against a codified constitution
- pragmatic adaptation has worked well and is preferable
- no agreed process for establishing a constitution
- no elite consensus on what a codified constitution should include
- it would be rigid and difficult to amend
- it would give judges, who are unaccountable, greater political power
- there is no great popular demand and other issues are more important
how can we encourage active participation and engagement - aims for constitutional reform
- simplifying voter registration
- lowering the voter registration to 16: 2014 Scottish referendum they could vote but not in 2016 EU referendum
- making wider use of e-democracy e.g. online petitions
- opening up candidate selection
how can we deliver fair representation? - aims for constitutional reform
- electoral reform: no tangible process to change FPTP electoral system to EVEL
how can we provide good governance and restore trust - aims for constitutional reform
- completing reform of Lords - second stage promised in 1997 whereby 2nd chamber would become at least partially elected, not close to completion
- modernising the commons: some effort to regulate lobbying and reform party funding, but little mvt to restore confidence in politics
- enhancing local democracy: devolved institutions have seen powers extended, but not enjoyed renaissance envisaged by electoral commission.
what are civil rights?
granted to citizens within a state
relate to social and political reforms e.g. equality and privacy
also define relationship between citizens and state e.g. right to vote
what are human rights
said to be inalienable or fundamental to every human being e.g. right to life and freedom from torture
what are the ongoing debates to the extent of rights in the UK
restrictions to basic rights e.g. freedom of speech and freedom of association, and the growth in accusations of 'authoritarianism; as an increasing number of regulation and laws are seen to curtail former freedoms
detention - sometimes indefinite - of vulnerable individuals and groups e.g. asylum seekers and other undocumented migrants in the name of security
restrictions in the rights to a trial by jury with many more crimes being tried at magistrates' level rather than in jury-based crown courts
an ever-greater number of restrictive tools, including ASBOs, PSBOs and Community Protection Notices (CPN), imposed by local councils and other law enforcement agencies
one way rights have been protected? JR
judicial review: checking actions of the govt.
Harder in the UK compared to USA, as the codified constitution means easy to check whether actions are constitutional.
UK: judges cannot overturn acts of parl but can decide on lawfulness of actions carried out under delegated legislation.
Judges can decide whether ministers are acting beyond their power - doctrine of ultra vires
E.g. successful judicial reviewL November 2013 when court of appeal upheld a legal challenged by 5 disabled people over decision to abolish independent living allowance
BUT controversial because means that unelected judges are making policy. Costly process and most reviews end up siding with govt.
second way rights are protected?
use of the HRA
judges can challenge cases on bases of HR
E.G. 2005: ban on prisoners voting declared unlawful.
courts can issue a declaration of incompatibility, forcing parl to revise legislation or set aside provision of HRA (derogation).
It has strengthened way judges can uphold civil liberties, increased public rights education, made govt ministers take rights more into account
BUT HRA not fully entrenched. Cannot overturn act of parl and not binding on parliament. (parl Can amend/overturn aspects)