breach of duty 4

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/17

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

18 Terms

1
New cards


what are the two thing to take into account when assessing if there has been a breach

how the D ought to have behaved and how they actually did behave- did they fall below the standard of care?

2
New cards

what is the key requirement for the D

that the D acts reasonably

3
New cards

how does the standard of care change in cases involving children

   the standard of care applied is scaled according to age so that it becomes that which can be ‘objectively expected of a child of that age’.

4
New cards

how does the standard of care change when it comes to professionals

The law requires that when dealing with people in the context of a calling or profession they do so with an appropriate level of competence

‘ a responsible body of medical opinion’

5
New cards

what is the Bolam test for

used to assess whether a professional—such as a doctor, barrister, or other specialist exercising a special skill—has breached their duty of care in a negligence claim

6
New cards

how would a professional not be found guilty of negligence

  acting in line with a respectable, accepted professional practice shields the defendant from a finding of breach.

7
New cards

when looking at duty of care, what are the types of things the courts will take into account

a) the likelihood of the injury (more likely= more liable

b) the more serious the injury (the more they have fallen below the duty of care)

c) did D take precautions against the risk?

8
New cards

describe the case of Nettleship v Weston 1971 and the outcome

D, a learner driver, crashed the car, injuring the driving instructor, C. The standard of care, is measured objectively by the skill to be expected of an experienced, skilled and careful driver. The learner driver may be doing his best, but his incompetent best is not good enough.

9
New cards

what is the rule in the case of Wilsher v Essex Health Authority

standard of care for a junior doctor is the same as any other doctor.

10
New cards

describe the case of Bolton v Stone and the outcome

    balls hit out of ground cricket only 6 times in 30 years. Claimant was hit in head. Was it negligent? No because the probability was so low. An ordinarily careful man does not take precautions against every foreseeable risk.

11
New cards

describe the case of The wagon mound and the outcome

D allowed oil to spill into harbour while refuelling, very small chance of fire but a fire happened- not liable as it was not reasonably forseeable

12
New cards

describe the case of Paris v stepney and the outcome

  D had one eye, not given goggles for work, he lost that one good eye. Goggles were obviously a necessary when a one eyes man was put to this kind of work.

13
New cards

describe the case of Latimer v AEC and the outcome

Ds factory was flooded, making floor slippery, spread sawdust on most of floor but left a bit out. They took the risk that someone might slip on that small part instead of closing factory until more sawdust was ordered. C slipped but court held that it was reasonable to keep factory open

14
New cards

describe the case of Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council and the outcome

   D owned a lake, notices read ‘dangerous water, no swimming’. Swimming was known to continue anyway, notices were ignored- C dove into shallow water and broke his neck. Held that D was not responsible.

15
New cards

describe the case of Mullin v Richards

C and D were both 15 year old school girls. They were playing with plastic rulers and a fragment of plastic entered C’s eye, causing her to lose all sight in that eye. Children should be held to a general standard of their age.

16
New cards

describe the case of Mansfield  v Weetabix and the outcome

D crashed his lorry into Cs shop as a result of a hypoglycemic state- did not know he was hypoglycaemic- not liable- he could not have reasonably foreseen as he did not know of his condition

17
New cards

describe the case of Dunnage v Randall

D was schizophrenic and set himself on fire, injuring C-  law does not care as he knew he had this condition and is able to move freely within society.

18
New cards

describe the case of Darnley v Croydon Health Services NHS Trust and the outcome

The claimant attended A&E after suffering a blow to the head. He had severe headaches which were getting worse. The receptionist informed him that there was a waiting time of four to five hours. In reality, the  hospital’s policy was that he would be seen in half an hour, at which point a triage nurse could better advise him (depending on his symptoms). After 19 minutes, the claimant left as he felt too ill to stay. He did not inform staff that he was leaving. The claimant later collapsed and suffered brain damage. He sued the hospital for negligence.

The receptionist had not acted as a reasonable A&E receptionist ought to have done, as she did not follow the known and established police.