1/25
Comprehensive question-and-answer flashcards covering Lecture 1 on Theories of Punishment and Émile Durkheim's sociology of law, social solidarity, and penal evolution.
Which academic developments in the 1960s prompted the sociological study of punishment?
Labelling perspectives (examining who has power), radical critiques of the criminal justice system (exploring how and why policies are in place), and studying punishment as a 'social phenomenon' reflecting deeper values.
What central moral question concerning punishment is raised in the lecture notes?
Regarding the deliberate infliction of suffering on fellow humans: is causing more harm the right approach, or do we restore justice by doing something more positive?
What four symbolic messages and deeper meanings can punishment convey?
The severity of the crime,
Ultimate power,
Respect or disgust for the offender
Religious beliefs.
What historical examples of public torture and corporal punishment are cited in the notes?
The stocks and pillory, public hanging in mediaeval England, the beheading of the Duke of Northumberland in 1553, and public flogging.
How did the 'civilisation of punishment' and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights transform penal methods?
They led to punishments becoming more psychological and private rather than purely physical public spectacles.
Which modern penal practices are noted to question whether society is genuinely 'civilised'?
Wormwood Scrubs, cell time, electronic tags, speed cameras (auto justice), the electric chair at Kentucky State Penitentiary, sanitized killing via lethal injection, public shaming, and the chain gang.
What historical and social context influenced Émile Durkheim's sociological work?
France between the 1880s and 1910s, characterized by industrialisation, urbanisation, and secularisation, prompting the question of what holds society together when religion and tradition weaken.
How does Durkheim define 'social facts'?
Ways of feeling, thinking, and behaving that exist outside the individual and exert influence over them.
What is 'functionalism' in sociology?
Explaining a social institution or phenomenon by looking at what it does for society as a whole.
How is 'social solidarity' defined in Durkheim's framework?
The bonds that hold society together.
What is the 'collective conscience' according to Durkheim, and what example is given?
The shared set of beliefs and values that members of society hold in common, such as the shared belief that harming children is wrong.
Why does Durkheim state that crime is 'normal'?
Because it is completely impossible for any society to be free of it.
Why is crime considered 'necessary' and 'useful' in Durkheimian theory?
It is bound to the basic conditions of social life, and these conditions are indispensable to the normal evolution of morality and law.
If crime is not cured by punishment, what does Durkheim identify as the true nature and object of punishment?
Punishment is a passionate reaction emanating from society—a work of vengeance and expiation—intended to maintain social cohesion by sustaining the common consciousness in all its vigour.
According to Durkheim, who is punishment primarily intended to affect?
Punishment is intended to have its effect on honest people, rather than solely reforming the offender.
What are the key characteristics of simple societies in relation to punishment and law?
Little division of labour, mechanical social solidarity based on sameness and strongly held sacred norms, repressive law, and harsh punishments such as torture and execution.
What are the key characteristics of complex modern societies in relation to punishment and law?
A significant division of labour, organic social solidarity based on interdependence and individualist norms, restitutive law focusing on compensation, fines, and reparation, and more lenient punishment.
Does repressive law disappear in modern developed societies according to Durkheim?
No, repressive law remains at work in developed societies even as restitutive law becomes more prominent.
How do contemporary criminal court practices reflect Durkheim's theories of ritual and tradition?
Criminal courts retain drama, rituals, symbols, dress, and archaic language that mimic church ceremonies, demonstrating the continued sacred and expressive character of the law.
What modern case study is used to illustrate the continued role of emotion in justice?
The Soham Murder Trial (2003), involving two girls murdered by their school minder (who was later attacked/killed).
What is 'punitive display' in the context of law and order politics?
A political contest among parties using emotive language and harsh penal rhetoric, often driven by populist politicians and sensationalist press to publicly reaffirm the severity and importance of the law.
What is the historical critique of Durkheim's account of punishment?
It provides simple snapshots without explaining the transition between societal stages, and simple societies were often less repressive than his model suggests.
What is the 'selectivity' critique of Durkheim's model of punishment?
His model fits horrific, highly emotive crimes well, but fails to explain how everyday, mundane offences processed through the same court systems generate little collective drama or passion.
What power-based critique challenges Durkheim's concept of the 'collective conscience'?
Critics ask 'whose values?' are represented, noting that Durkheim ignores power structures, conflicting interests, and competing social groups who shape the criminal law.
How does the issue of the death penalty challenge functionalist views on punishment and solidarity?
Rather than unifying society, punishment can be deeply divisive and polarizing, as seen in widespread public division over capital punishment.
What are Émile Durkheim's key lasting contributions to the sociology of punishment?
Demonstrating that punishment reflects and shapes societal values, highlighting the enduring expressive and emotional functions of justice, explaining how law and order are used in populist politics, and framing penal rituals as a form of secular religion.