Philosophy of Mind: Descartes, Searle, Ryle, and Nagel

0.0(0)
Studied by 1 person
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/5

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

6 Terms

1
New cards

1) Descartes discusses a piece of wax. a. What point is he trying to illustrate, and what view is he arguing for? b. What view is he arguing against? c. Present the wax argument in your own words. (There is a slide on this in the PowerPoint presentation.) d. After discussing the wax, Descartes draws an analogy involving the people he sees on the street. What is the analogy here? (Present it in your own words.) What point is he making with it?

a) Descartes is trying to argue the point that not all of our knowledge comes from our five senses; some comes from our intellect. Descartes believes that consciousness/the mind is separate from the body.

b) Descartes is arguing against the view that your mind is a physical thing. He would argue that you cannot understand all of the complex workings of the mind by just looking at the brain itself; the brain is a non-physical thing. He would say that some fundamental things can be gathered from our senses, but we also know some things a priori.

c) Descartes' wax argument is the following view: All the wax's sensible properties could change, and so all of the information our senses provide could be different. Yet we could still know that it is an extended physical object. Therefore, our knowledge of what the wax is (i.e., an extended physical object) does not come from our senses.

d) The analogy Descartes uses is to explain that we might think that we are "seeing" people on the street, but really we are just seeing the coats, pants, and hats that they are wearing. It is our intellect, and not our sense of sight, that judges that there are actually people under all of that clothing moving on the street.

2
New cards

2) a. What does strong AI claim about the mind that Searle rejects? b. What is Searle's objection to strong AI? (State his argument against strong AI, and in so doing you will have shown why the Chinese Room is a problem for philosophers like Dennett.) c. How does Dennett respond to Searle? d. How might Searle reply to Dennett's reply? e.What argument might Dennett give in response to Searle's arguments?

a) Strong AI claims that if a computer can pass the Turing Test, then it has consciousness, a mind, and intentionality. It is, in effect, human because it acts intelligently and acts as a human. In denying strong AI, Searle denies that just because you act like a human, you are human.

b) Searle claims that simply behaving intelligently is not the same as having a mind. A machine can behave intelligently without being conscious at all. For example, computers play chess very well. Maybe someday they will also write philosophy papers. But the mere fact that they behave intelligently doesn't mean that they understand what they are doing. They will not necessarily have intentionality, i.e., the power to represent, to think about something.

c) Dennett would say that there is nothing more to being a human than acting like a human in all the relevant circumstances. A computer could act just as I do. If a computer acted just as I do, then the computer would have the same sorts of thoughts as I have. Therefore, there is no way for me to know that I am not a computer. Apparently, computers can think.

d) Searle would respond by saying that the speed of the response does not matter concerning understanding. As long as you get the answer, it is fine. Slowly reaching an answer does not determine the depth of one's understanding.

e) Dennett might respond to Searle by arguing that the Chinese Room is too simple to represent how an actual intelligent computer would function. He believes that a real computer would require many complex systems working together to process information and respond quickly, unlike the Chinese Room. Dennett argues that a system complex enough to demonstrate genuine intelligence should not automatically be considered incapable of understanding or consciousness.

3
New cards

3) a. What, according to Ryle, is the fundamental error made by the official doctrine? b. Why is it a category mistake (according to Ryle) to say that Hubert (from Dennett's story "Where am I?") doesn't have a mind or understand anything? How is this an example of the fundamental error of the official doctrine? c. What is the inverted spectrum? d. Why, according to Ryle, do we make a category mistake when we try to describe the inverted spectrum? Please explain the category mistake.

a) Ryle would argue that, according to the Official Doctrine, there are two kinds of events: mental events (recorded in first-person omniscient narratives) and physical events (recorded in scientific journals). There are interactions between mental events and physical events. But the interactions cannot be either mental or physical events and are recorded neither in first-person omniscient narratives nor in scientific journals. Therefore, the Official doctrine's view of interaction makes no sense.

b) Hubert is not the right sort of thing that could have a mind. This is an example of the fundamental error of applying a characteristic to the wrong thing.

c) The inverted spectrum is a thought experiment suggesting that two people can share the same color vocabulary and responses while simultaneously experiencing a completely different color sensation.

d) The inverted spectrum illustrates this fundamental category mistake: two people could see the color blue as two completely different colors, but since they have always been taught it is blue, that is what it is for them. Ryle would say that since a color is not a physical object, blue could not be seen to be blue. However, you would be able to disagree that the color of the sky could be seen differently by different people.

4
New cards

4) Dennett might use his short story "Where am I?" to argue for his view that computers are people too. a. Present Dennett's argument. b. How would Descartes respond to Dennett's argument? c. How would Searle respond to Dennett's argument?

a) Dennett would use his story to argue the following: It is possible that a computer could act just like I act. If a computer acted just like I do, then the computer would have the same sorts of thoughts as I would have. Therefore, there is no way for me to know that I am not a computer. Apparently, computers can think.

b) Descartes would disagree with Dennett, saying that computers cannot be people, too. Descartes believes that people have a non-physical mind that is responsible for intelligent behavior. It cannot be replicated by looking at it or studying it. If a replica were made, it would not have the same comprehension as a person.

c) Searle would claim that simply behaving intelligently is not the same as having a mind. A computer, or an object, can behave intelligently without being conscious at all. It has the ability to behave, not understand. He would also say that someday computers will be able to act like people; however, not at the current moment.

5
New cards

5) According to Descartes, there is no way for a computer to pass the Turing test. a. What does this mean and why does Descartes believe this? b. How would Ryle criticize Descartes' answer that you have just given (i.e. in response to part a. of this question). Please give an argument against Descartes's view. For example, you might want to use the slide that has the title "Ryle's argument against the Official Doctrine".

a) The Turing Test is when a computer passes if we can chat with it online, ask it any questions we want, and cannot tell it is a computer. Its answers seem human to us. Descartes says that thinking is a private event and that only a non-physical mind can be a human, and only humans can pass the Turing Test. Computers won't pass the Turing Test because they aren't nonphysical minds.

b) Ryle would argue against the Official Doctrine that, according to the Official doctrine: There are two kinds of events, mental events (which are recorded in first-person omniscient narratives) and physical events (which are recorded in scientific journals). There are interactions between mental events and physical events. But the interactions cannot be either mental or physical events and are recorded neither in first-person omniscient narratives nor in scientific journals. Therefore, the Official doctrine's view of interaction makes no sense. Ryle would argue that Descartes is making a category error in classifying the mind and the body as two different things of the same kind. For Ryle, the mind and the body are two different kinds of things.

6
New cards

6) a. Why, according to Thomas Nagel, is the problem of consciousness unique? What makes it fundamentally different from and harder than the problem of explaining genes, water, and electricity? b. What (according to Nagel) is wrong with saying that the debate about what it is like to be a bat has no practical purpose and is therefore meaningless? In answering part b, please explain the point that Nagel is making when he says, "in contemplating the bats we are in much the same position that intelligent bats or Martians would occupy if they tried to form a conception of what it was like to be us."

a) Nagel would argue the following about the problem of consciousness being unique: We can distinguish objectively what a thing is from how it appears to us given our subjective perspective. For everything but consciousness, the more objective our understanding of a thing, the better our understanding of its real nature. For example, to know water as H2O is to know more of its real nature than to know that it is wet. With consciousness, the more we move away from our subjective experience of it, the less we understand it.

b) Nagel disagrees with the idea that discussing what it is like to be a bat is meaningless simply because it has no practical purpose. He believes understanding consciousness and subjectivity is important. When Nagel compares humans trying to understand bats, or Martians trying to understand humans, he is explaining that we experience the world differently. We can try to understand behavior and physical characteristics; we cannot fully experience the world from either's perspective. Therefore, the question is still meaningful even if it cannot be answered.