1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
exclusion clauses
clause that seeks to exclude or restrict the liability of a party who is in breach of contract
two types of exclusion clause
exclusion clause
limitation clause
exclusion clause
total exemption of liability
limitation clause
restricts the amount of liability a party can have
3 rules for a clause to bind the parties
clause must be incorporated into the contract
as a matter of construction, it extends to the loss in question - it covers the loss
the exclusion is allowed by legislation
three methods of incorporation
signature
reasonable notice
previous dealings
incorporation by signature rule
presumption that the contract is read therefore signature shows agreement to the terms
key case
LāEstrange v F Graucob Ltd
LāEstrange v F Graucob Ltd
C was bound by the exclusion clause as by signing the contract it was assumed she had read the terms
exceptions
misrepresentation
Non Est Factum
misrepresentation - case and principle
Curtis v chemical cleaning and dyeing co - exclusion clause misrepresented as only damage to beads to sequins not all damage
clause is not deemed legally enforceable where the drafting party misrepresents the effect of a clause to the other party
Non Est Factum
where the party is unable to understand a document due to ādefective education, illness or innate incapacityā
Saunders v anglia building societyĀ [
Saunders v anglia building societyĀ [
D signed a document with broken glasses - argued she did not know what she signing - held that non est factum was not available as it was due to her own carelessness
recent development - Tilden rent a car v clean dining
Party seeking to rely on onerous terms should take reasonable measures to draw such terms to the attention of the other partyĀ
incorporation by notice rule
The party seeking to rely on the clause must take reasonable steps to bring the terms to the other party's attention before or at the time the contract is made
incorporation by notice key case
Parker v South Eastern Railway
P left a bag in cloakroom in railway station and paid 2p - received ticket that said see back - reverse side contained a clause limiting companyās liability for lost items to Ā£10 - bag was lost and worth more than Ā£10- P did not read the ticket ā Held that D took reasonable steps on the ticket to bring conditions to attention and Pās failure to read did not affect thisĀ Ā
Reasonable steps must be taken to draw the existence of the clause to the attention of the other party
three key questions to consider for reasonable notice
notice must be contained in a contractual document
notice must be given before or at the time of contracting
the notice must be sufficiently prominent
notice must be contained in a contractual document
a document that a reasonable person would expect to contain terms and conditions
key case
Chapelton v Barry - when hiring a deckchair they received a ticket - ticket was treated as a receipt rather than a document with terms and conditions - exclusion clause was not incorporated into the contract - reasonable person would not expect it to contain contractual terms
notice must be given at or before the time of contracting - key case
Olley v Marlborough Court Ltd - exclusion clause was given in notice in the room, after the contract was formed at the reception desk - clause excluding liability was given too late
notice must be sufficiently prominent - key case
Interfoto picture library Ltd v Stiletto Visual Programmes [1989]
I supplied to S -delivery note contained term imposing a substantial daily holding fee if not returned promptly - term was particularly onerous and had not been sufficiently brought to S attention - court refused to enforce
Denning LJ in Spurling Ltd v Bradshaw [1956]
āMore unreasonable a clause is, the greater notice which must be givenā
incorporation of previous dealings rule
where parties have dealt with each other in the past, their previous dealings may be sufficiently consistent and regular for the clause to be incorporated
key case
Spurling v Bradshaw -
S sent a document containing exclusion clause - B challenged because the document arrived too late - considering previous dealings court concluded that the clause could be incorporated because in previous transactions it had appeared
Principle: a term may be incorporated through a consistent previous course of dealing, even where notice on the current occasion would otherwise be too late
2 rules about previous dealings
consistent and regular previous dealings incorporate the terms and conditions
previous dealings must be consistent and frequent
holler v rambler motors
H used services of R 3/4 times over 5 yearsĀ - normally signed an exclusion clauseĀ form - fire at garage destroyed the car but H hadnāt signed the form - held the 3/4 times over 5 years werenāt consistent and regular enough to automatically incorporate the clause
McCutcheon v MacBrayne
car sank on ferry - on this occasion the exclusion form hadnāt been signed - court found dealings were not frequent enough to to incorporate the clause
construction
where the court interprets the wording of the clause to determine whether it covers the loss or liability
do exclusion clauses or limitation clauses have a more lenient approach
limitation clauses
what case established this
Ailsa Craig Fishing Co Ltd v Malvern Fishing Co Ltd (1983)
main rule in construction
Contra Proferentem Rule
Contra Proferentem Rule
ambiguity or uncertainty is interpreted against the party seeking the rely on the clause
key case
Houghton v Trafalgar Insurance
insurance policy excluded the insurers liability where an āexcessive loadā was being carried - phrase excessive load did not apply to passengers in the car - should have used precise wording to exclude liability for excessive passengers
negligence v strict contractual liability
negligence = failure to meet the legally required standard of care
strict liability = failure to perform a contractual obligation even when exercising reasonable care
key case
Canada Steam Ship v R
established a three stage test for whether the clause will cover negligence
the clause must make express reference to negligence
no express reference to negligence, but the words are wide enough to cover negligence (contra proferentem)
can the party in breach be liable on some other ground other than negligence
what legislation to use for a contract between a trader and consumer
consumer rights act 2015
what legislation to use for a contract between a business and business
UCTA 1977
what legislation to use for a contract between a consumer and a consumer
depends, UCTA may be relevant
UCTA - negligence relevant sections
s.2(1) - personal injury and death can not be excluded
s.2(2) - everything else may be able to be excluded if passes test of reasonableness
s.11 - defines reasonableness test
schedule 2 - advice on whether reasonable
UCTA - strict liability relevant cases
s.6 - sale of goods and hire
s.7 supply of goods
consumer rights act s.65(1)
death or personal injury can not be excluded
consumer rights act s.62
everything else subject to fairness test
consumer rights act s.62(4)
unfairness definition = imbalance of power to the detriment of the consumer
consumer rights act s.57(1)
negligence from a service can not be excluded