1/48
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Clean Air Act (CAA) - basics
Oldest regulatory environmental statute (1970); amended in 1977 and 1990
Cost:benefit of the 1990 CAA amendments by 2020
About $65 billion in costs vs. about $2 trillion in benefits, mostly from preventing premature deaths from PM2.5
Recent trend in PM2.5
Uptick since 2015-16; wildfires are reversing progress
6 criteria pollutants
CO, lead, SO2, NOx, O3 (ozone), PM2.5/PM10
Criteria pollutants - defining features
Adverse effects on public health and welfare; come from numerous, diverse sources
Hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) - examples
Benzene, vinyl chloride (regulated under Section 112)
Residual pollutants (on neither list)
Pollutants like GHGs; hard to regulate because they aren't on the criteria or HAP lists
Two types of sources regulated by the CAA
Stationary (e.g., factories) and mobile (e.g., highways/vehicles)
NAAQS
National Ambient Air Quality Standards; set by EPA for each criteria pollutant (primary and secondary)
NAAQS level requirement
Must protect public health with an adequate margin of safety
NAAQS review schedule
EPA reviews every 5 years and revises as appropriate; it doesn't always revise, so a revision is a big deal
CAA Section 108
EPA lists criteria pollutants and prepares criteria documents
AQCR
Air Quality Control Region; EPA determines attainment/non-attainment status for each NAAQS in each one
SIP
State Implementation Plan; shows how a state will achieve NAAQS attainment in each AQCR (gives states flexibility); EPA approves or rejects
What a SIP contains
Emissions inventory, projected future emissions, allocation of needed reductions, quantified emission limits, timetables, monitoring/enforcement approaches, non-attainment and PSD measures
FIP
Federal Implementation Plan; EPA can issue one if a SIP is inadequate; often stricter than the SIP would have been
Whitman v. American Trucking
When setting or revising NAAQS, EPA cannot consider costs (though cost is always in the background)
Non-Attainment program (1977) - applies to
AQCRs that are out of attainment for 1 or more NAAQS
LAER
Lowest Achievable Emissions Reduction; strictest standard; for NEW/MODIFIED sources in non-attainment areas
RACT
Reasonably Available Control Technology; for EXISTING sources in non-attainment areas; least strict, can be very relaxed (grandfathering issue)
PSD
Prevention of Significant Deterioration; applies to AQCRs that are IN attainment; also covers other regulated pollutants like GHGs; uses increments for specific areas
BACT
Best Available Control Technology; for new/modified sources under PSD; in between LAER and RACT
Why does PSD have no controls on existing sources?
They're already in attainment
Strictness ranking of source standards
LAER (strictest) > BACT > RACT (least strict)
LAER/BACT - permit writer role
Permit writer has discretion and the standard can be negotiated
NSR
New Source Review; pre-construction review and permitting for new/modified MAJOR stationary sources under PSD and non-attainment
PSD major source threshold
100 tons or more of a listed pollutant, or 250 tons or more of a pollutant subject to regulation under the CAA
Non-attainment major source thresholds
Vary by degree of non-attainment (criteria pollutants)
Section 111(b)
New Source Performance Standards: requires BSER (Best System of Emissions Reduction) for new/modified sources, category by category; sets the floor for BACT; applies to any air pollutant
Section 111(d)
Requires EPA to regulate EXISTING sources in a category for pollutants that are neither criteria nor hazardous; basis of the Clean Power Plan
Original Section 112 (pre-1990)
Health-based approach requiring an 'ample margin of safety'; unworkable (EPA regulated only 7 HAPs)
1990 overhaul of Section 112
Technology-based approach; Congress listed 189 HAPs for EPA to regulate
MACT
Maximum Achievable Control Technology; required for HAP emissions from major sources (different for existing vs. new)
Residual risk assessment
After MACT, EPA assesses carcinogenic HAPs and requires additional controls if cancer risk exceeds 1 in a million
Title II programs (mobile sources)
1) Tailpipe standards (Sec. 202), 2) Fuels and fuel additives (Sec. 211), 3) Alternative vehicles
Section 202
Tailpipe emission standards for NEW mobile sources; triggered if emissions endanger public health and welfare; EPA has discretion on method but must regulate once it makes an endangerment finding
Section 211
Regulates fuels and fuel additives (e.g., ethyl lead)
Section 209 (California waiver)
Lets CA request a preemption waiver to adopt stricter new-motor-vehicle emissions standards; other states can follow CA's standard (done for GHGs)
CA programs for stubborn air pollution
CA ARB and regional AQCRs (e.g., South Coast) have developed innovative state and regional programs
CA GHG policy portfolio
Statewide targets through 2050; Sec. 209 waiver, renewable portfolio, new-vehicle emissions standards, low carbon fuels program, cap-and-trade
Why are GHGs hard to regulate under the CAA?
CO2 isn't on the criteria pollutant list; too many sources, international scope, no direct health impact
Massachusetts v. EPA (2007) - claim
MA sued EPA for failing to regulate GHGs under Sec. 202 (tailpipe emissions -> climate change -> sea-level rise -> coastline destruction)
Massachusetts v. EPA - EPA's argument
It lacked authority to regulate GHGs under Sec. 202 because they aren't an 'air pollutant' by definition
Massachusetts v. EPA - holding
5-4: GHGs are air pollutants; EPA has a statutory obligation and must make an endangerment finding
Massachusetts v. EPA - dissent
Whether to regulate is up to EPA's discretion (Chevron deference)
Aftermath of Massachusetts v. EPA
Obama EPA made the endangerment finding, issued tailpipe standards, then used Sec. 111(d) to create the Clean Power Plan
West Virginia v. EPA (2022)
Struck down the Clean Power Plan using the major questions doctrine; EPA overextended its reach
Major questions doctrine
If Congress wanted to shut down the coal industry (or another major sector), it would have said so explicitly
Context for West Virginia v. EPA
Coal was already declining due to the rise of natural gas/fracking