Free Speech Final Quiz

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/52

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

53 Terms

1
New cards

Masses Publishing Co. v. Patten (Incitement and Advocacy)

The Postmaster refused to mail a socialist magazine under the Espionage Act for its antiwar content

Judge Learned Hand held that speech is unprotected only if it directly counsels or incites unlawful resistance, so harsh criticism of the war alone isn’t enough

The Direct Incitement Standard: Speech is protected unless it goes so far as to directly urge or counsel readers that it is their duty or legal interest to violate the law

2
New cards

Schenck v. United States (Incitement & Advocacy)

Schenck was convicted under the Espionage Act for mailing leaflets urging resistance to the draft. The Court upheld the conviction, announcing the “clear and present danger” test

The First Amendment does not protect speech that creates a "clear and present danger" of substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent

3
New cards

Abrams v. United States (Incitement & Advocacy)

Abrams threw leaflets criticizing U.S. intervention in Russia and calling for a strike of munitions workers

The Court upheld the convictions, but Holmes’s dissent developed the “marketplace of ideas” theory and a stricter reading of clear and present danger

The First Amendment does not protect speech that is designed to undermine the United States in war by fueling sedition and disorder.

The Espionage Act criminalized circulating anti-war and anti-intervention leaflets that intended to incite a general strike in munitions production during wartime

4
New cards

Brandenburg v. Ohio (Incitement & Advocacy)

A Klan leader was convicted under Ohio’s criminal syndicalism law for a rally speech that advocated violence in the abstract

The Court overruled Whitney and held that advocacy is protected unless it is directed at inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to produce it

5
New cards

Hess v. Indiana (Incitement & Advocacy)

An antiwar protester was arrested for saying “We’ll take the fucking street later” during a demonstration.

The Court reversed, holding the statement was protected because it advocated at most indefinite future action, was not directed at any person or group, and wasn’t likely to produce imminent disorder

The First Amendment protects advocacy of illegal action as long as it is not directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is not likely to incite or produce such action

6
New cards

Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

A Jehovah’s Witness called a city marshal a “God damned racketeer” and “damned Fascist” and was convicted under a state offensive-speech law.

The Court upheld the conviction, holding that “fighting words” that inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace are unprotected

7
New cards

Terminiello v. City of Chicago (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

A priest gave a provocative, inflammatory speech to an auditorium while a hostile crowd protested outside, and he was convicted of breach of the peace.

The Court reversed, holding that the ordinance was unconstitutional because speech may “invite dispute” and stir people to anger absent a clear and present danger

8
New cards

Feiner v. New York (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

Feiner gave a street speech criticizing officials that agitated a crowd, and police arrested him after he ignored requests to stop.

The Court upheld the conviction, holding that police may act to prevent imminent public disorder (a decision criticized as permitting a “heckler’s veto”) if there is reasonable ‘clear and present danger’ to cause a disturbance of the peace.

9
New cards

Beauharnais v. Illinois (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

Beauharnais distributed leaflets disparaging Black people and was convicted under a group libel law.

The Court upheld the statute 5–4, treating group libel like individual libel as unprotected (a holding widely seen as undermined by later cases).

The Fourteenth Amendment does not prevent states from punishing defamatory or provocative speech directed at specific racial or religious groups

10
New cards

Cohen v. California (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

Cohen was convicted of disturbing the peace for wearing a jacket reading “Fuck the Draft” in a courthouse.

The Court reversed, holding the words weren’t fighting words or obscenity, and that the government cannot ban offensive language to enforce “civility” because emotive content is part of the message.

11
New cards

Collin v. Smith (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

Skokie, home to many Holocaust survivors, passed ordinances to block a planned Nazi march.

The court struck them down, holding that the display of swastikas is protected symbolic speech and that offense or fear of a hostile audience doesn’t justify prior restraint

12
New cards

R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

R.A.V. was charged under a bias-motivated disorderly conduct ordinance for burning a cross on a Black family’s lawn.

The Court struck down the ordinance, holding that even within an unprotected category like fighting words, the government can’t discriminate based on viewpoint or the topics covered

The First Amendment does not permit a state to use content discrimination to achieve a compelling interest if it is not necessary to achieve that interest.

13
New cards

Virginia v. Black (Fighting Words, Hate Speech)

Defendants were convicted under a Virginia law banning cross burning done with intent to intimidate, which treated any burning as prima facie evidence of intent.

The Court held states may ban cross burning carried out with intent to intimidate (a true threat) but struck down the prima facie provision as unconstitutional.

14
New cards

New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (Defamation)

A Montgomery official sued the Times over a civil rights ad that contained minor factual errors.

The Court held that public officials can win a defamation suit only by proving “actual malice”: knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.

15
New cards

Gertz v. Robert Welch (Defamation)

A magazine falsely labeled a lawyer representing a victim’s family a communist, and he sued for libel.

The Court held that private figures need not prove actual malice for actual damages (states may set the fault standard but not strict liability), but presumed or punitive damages require actual malice

First Amendment does not require private individuals to meet the strict "actual malice" standard (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth) to win a defamation suit against a publisher or broadcaster

16
New cards

Time Inc. v. Firestone (Defamation)

Time misreported the grounds for the divorce of a prominent socialite, and she sued for defamation.

The Court held she was not a public figure because she hadn’t voluntarily injected herself into a public controversy, and that a divorce is not a public controversy.

17
New cards

Hustler Magazine v. Falwell (Defamation)

Hustler ran a parody ad portraying Jerry Falwell’s first sexual experience as incest with his mother, and he sued for emotional distress.

The Court held that public figures can’t recover for intentional infliction of emotional distress over parody unless it contains a false statement of fact made with actual malice.

18
New cards

McKee v. Cosby (Defamation)

McKee, who accused Bill Cosby of sexual assault, sued over a letter his lawyer wrote branding her a liar.

The First Circuit held she was a limited-purpose public figure who couldn’t show actual malice, and the Supreme Court denied cert, with Justice Thomas dissenting to urge reconsidering Sullivan.

Kathrine McKee was a limited-purpose public figure because she publicly accused actor Bill Cosby of sexual assault in a media interview

19
New cards

Berisha v. Lawson (Defamation)

Albania’s former president sued the author of a book that tied him to arms-trafficking.

Lower courts found he was a public figure who couldn’t prove actual malice.

The Court denied cert, with Justices Thomas and Gorsuch dissenting and questioning whether the actual malice standard should stand.

20
New cards

Dun & Bradstreet Inc. v. Greenmoss Builders (Defamation)

A credit agency falsely reported that a contractor was bankrupt, and the contractor sued for defamation.

The Court held that when speech involves a purely private concern, presumed and punitive damages are available without proof of actual malice.

21
New cards

Smith v. California (Commercial Speech)

A bookseller was convicted under a Los Angeles ordinance imposing strict liability for possessing obscene books.

The Court struck it down, holding that criminal liability for a distributor requires scienter (knowledge of the content), because otherwise booksellers would self-censor.

A state or municipality cannot penalize a bookstore proprietor for selling or stocking an obscene title unless the prosecution proves the seller had awareness of the book's character or obscene nature.

22
New cards

Cubby Inc. v. CompuServe Inc. (Commercial Speech)

A user sued CompuServe over defamatory statements in a third-party newsletter hosted on its forum.

The court held CompuServe was a mere distributor, not liable without knowledge or reason to know of the content, because it exercised no editorial control.

An online service provider acts as a distributor (like a public library, bookstore, or newsstand) rather than a publisher when it hosts third-party content without editorial control

23
New cards

Stratton Oakmont Inc. v. Prodigy Services (Commercial Speech)

A brokerage sued Prodigy over defamatory posts on its bulletin board.

The court held Prodigy was liable as a publisher because it moderated content and set guidelines, a result that prompted Congress to pass Section 230.

Because Prodigy made a choice to monitor and edit content, the court found it acted like a traditional newspaper publisher and was liable for defamatory third-party posts

24
New cards

Virginia State Pharmacy Board v. Virginia Citizens Consumer Council (Commercial Speech)

Virginia made it unprofessional conduct for pharmacists to advertise prescription drug prices, and consumers challenged the law.

The Court struck it down, holding that commercial speech is protected by the First Amendment because of consumers’ interest in the free flow of commercial information.

25
New cards

West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette ((Student/Academic Free Speech)

Jehovah’s Witness students were punished for refusing to salute the flag and recite the Pledge.

The Court overruled Gobitis, holding the government cannot compel students to salute the flag or affirm beliefs.

Public school officials cannot force students to express political, religious, or ideological beliefs by word or act
The First Amendment protects both the right to speak and the right not to speak, protecting symbolic expression and freedom of conscience

26
New cards

Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (Student/Academic Free Speech)

Students were suspended for wearing black armbands to protest the Vietnam War.

The Court held students don’t “shed their constitutional rights at the schoolhouse gate,” and schools may restrict speech only if it would materially and substantially disrupt school activities

First Amendment free speech protections extend to public school students.

27
New cards

Board of Education, Island Trees Union Free School District v. Pico (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A school board removed books it deemed “anti-American” and “filthy” from the school library, and students sued.

A plurality held that boards may not remove library books simply to suppress ideas they dislike, and remanded for trial on the board’s motive.

28
New cards

Bethel School District No. 403 v. Fraser (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A student was disciplined for delivering a sexually suggestive speech at a school assembly.

The Court held that schools may punish lewd, vulgar, or plainly offensive speech without violating the First Amendment.

29
New cards

Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A principal removed articles on teen pregnancy and divorce from a student newspaper produced in a journalism class.

The Court held that schools may exercise editorial control over school-sponsored speech if the action is reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns.

The First Amendment does not prevent educators from exercising editorial control over the style and content of student speech in school-sponsored expressive activities

30
New cards

Morse v. Frederick (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A student was suspended for unfurling a “BONG HiTS 4 JESUS” banner at a school-supervised event.

The Court held that schools may restrict student speech reasonably viewed as promoting illegal drug use.

31
New cards

Mahanoy Area School District v. B.L. (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A cheerleader was suspended from the team for a profane Snapchat post, made off campus, criticizing the team.

The Court held the school violated her First Amendment rights, since schools have diminished but not zero authority over off-campus speech, and here the interest in regulating it was insufficient.

32
New cards

Sweezy v. New Hampshire (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A professor was held in contempt for refusing to answer the state attorney general’s questions about a lecture and his political associations.

The Court reversed (plurality), emphasizing academic freedom and that the inquiry intruded on his rights, with a concurrence resting on due process

Reversed the contempt conviction of Paul Sweezy, holding that compelling a university professor to answer questions about a lecture and his political associations violated Fourteenth Amendment due process because the state's legislative mandate lacked clear and explicit authorization for such an inquiry

33
New cards

Keyishian v. Board of Regents (Student/Academic Free Speech)

New York required faculty to certify they weren’t Communists and barred “treasonable or seditious” speech.

The Court struck the laws down as vague and overbroad, declaring that academic freedom is “a special concern of the First Amendment.

34
New cards

Healy v. James (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A state college denied recognition to a Students for a Democratic Society chapter because of its perceived affiliation with a disruptive national organization.

The Court held the denial violated the students’ associational rights, because the college failed to show the group would disrupt campus or reject its rules.

35
New cards

Papish v. Board of Curators of the University of Missouri (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A graduate student was expelled for distributing an underground newspaper with a vulgar cartoon and headline.

The Court held the expulsion violated the First Amendment, as public universities can’t punish speech merely because it is offensive or indecent.

36
New cards

Doe v. University of Michigan (Student/Academic Free Speech)

Michigan’s policy prohibiting speech that stigmatized students based on race, sex, or other traits was challenged by a graduate student.

The court struck the policy down as overbroad and vague, holding that a university can’t prohibit speech simply because it is offensive or demeaning

The University of Michigan's campus anti-harassment policy was unconstitutionally overbroad and vague in violation of the First Amendment

37
New cards

Christian Legal Society v. Martinez (Student/Academic Free Speech)

A law school denied recognition to a Christian student group that excluded members based on religion and sexual orientation, citing its nondiscrimination “all-comers” policy.

The Court upheld the policy as a reasonable, viewpoint-neutral condition on a limited public forum

A public college or university may condition official student organization recognition, funding, and campus access on compliance with a viewpoint-neutral, "all-comers" policy requiring groups to accept any student as a member or leader, regardless of their status or beliefs.

38
New cards

Schneider v. New Jersey (Town of Irvington) (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Several cities banned leafleting on streets to prevent litter, and activists were convicted.

The Court struck the ordinances down, holding that preventing litter doesn’t justify banning handbill distribution in public streets.

An anti-littering law may not infringe the First Amendment rights of people trying to circulate information or opinions.

39
New cards

United States v. O’Brien (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

O’Brien burned his draft card at an antiwar protest and was convicted under a law criminalizing destruction of draft certificates.

The Court upheld the conviction, establishing intermediate scrutiny for laws that incidentally burden expressive conduct but serve an important interest unrelated to suppressing speech.

Chief Justice Earl Warren formulated a four-part test to determine when a government regulation of mixed speech-and-conduct (symbolic speech) is permissible:

  1. Constitutional Power: The regulation is within the constitutional power of the government. [1]

  2. Substantial/Important Interest: It furthers an important or substantial governmental interest (in this case, ensuring the smooth, efficient administration of the draft and raising armies). [1, 2]

  3. Content-Neutral: The governmental interest is unrelated to the suppression of free expression (the law banned destroying draft cards to protect the card-issuing and tracking system, not to silence anti-war messages). [1, 2]

  4. Narrowly Tailored (Incidental Restriction): The incidental restriction on First Amendment freedoms is no greater than is essential to the furtherance of that interest


40
New cards

Wooley v. Maynard (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

A Jehovah’s Witness covered the “Live Free or Die” motto on his New Hampshire license plate and was prosecuted.

The Court held the state cannot force citizens to display an ideological message on their private property.

41
New cards

Perry Education Association v. Perry Local Educators' Association (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

A school district gave the incumbent union access to teacher mailboxes but denied it to a rival union.

The Court upheld the exclusion, establishing the public-forum categories and holding that in a nonpublic forum the government may restrict access with reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rules.

42
New cards

Rust v. Sullivan (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Title X regulations barred federally funded family planning clinics from counseling or referring patients for abortion.

The Court upheld the rules, holding the government may fund one viewpoint and not another without violating the First Amendment.

43
New cards

Rosenberger v. Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

The university refused to pay printing costs for a Christian student magazine while funding other student publications.

The Court held this was impermissible viewpoint discrimination in a limited public forum.

44
New cards

Legal Services Corporation v. Velazquez (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Congress barred federally funded legal aid lawyers from challenging existing welfare laws.

The Court struck down the restriction, holding it distorted the role of attorneys and the judicial system, and was viewpoint-based, in a way that differed from the program in Rust.

Congress violated the First Amendment by prohibiting Legal Services Corporation (LSC)-funded organizations from representing indigent clients in efforts to amend or challenge existing welfare laws

45
New cards

Rumsfeld v. Forum for Academic and Institutional Rights (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

The Solomon Amendment conditioned federal funds on law schools giving military recruiters equal access, and schools objected over the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy.

The Court unanimously held it constitutional, holding that it regulates conduct, not speech, and doesn’t compel speech or violate associational rights.

46
New cards

Pleasant Grove City, Utah v. Summum (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

A city accepted a Ten Commandments monument but refused a religious group’s monument for its park.

The Court held that permanent monuments in a public park are government speech, so the Free Speech Clause doesn’t require the city to accept others

47
New cards

Walker v. Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Texas rejected a specialty license plate design featuring a Confederate flag.

The Court held that specialty license plate designs are government speech, so Texas may refuse them without violating the First Amendment.

48
New cards

Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Students collected petition signatures at a private shopping center, which tried to eject them under its property rights.

The Court held that California could require the mall to permit the activity under its state constitution without violating the owner’s property or free speech rights

49
New cards

Pacific Gas & Electric Co. v. Public Utilities Commission (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

California required a utility to include a consumer group’s newsletter in its billing envelopes.

A plurality held this violated the First Amendment because it forced the utility to associate with and respond to views it disagreed with.

The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) violated the utility's First Amendment rights by forcing it to carry third-party newsletter content in its monthly billing envelopes

The First Amendment protects a corporation's right to speak as well as its right not to be compelled to house, circulate, or associate with messages it finds objectionable or does not wish to endorse

50
New cards

Roberts v. United States Jaycees (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

A state's compelling interest in eradicating sex discrimination justifies applying public accommodations laws to require a large, unselective membership organization to admit women as full voting members, and that doing so does not unconstitutionally abridge freedom of expressive association or speech

While the First Amendment protects the right of individuals to associate for the purpose of engaging in protected speech or religious activities, the Court found that the Jaycees lacked the intimate or selective characteristics required for high constitutional protection. [1, 2]

51
New cards

Hurley v. Irish-American Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual Group of Boston (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Demonstration organizers do not need to allow anyone who wishes to participate, especially members of groups whose purposes they do not support.

State public accommodations laws cannot compel private parade organizers to include a contingent expressing a message the organizers oppose, as this violates First Amendment speaker autonomy.

52
New cards

Boy Scouts of America v. Dale (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

Applying New Jersey’s public accommodations law to force the Boy Scouts of America to admit an openly gay assistant scoutmaster (James Dale) violated the organization’s **First Amendment right of freedom of expressive association.

Private organizations have a constitutional right to choose their own members and leaders. Forcing the group to accept a member whose presence contradicts its values is unconstitutional if that person's presence significantly affects the group's ability to advocate its public or private viewpoints.

53
New cards

303 Creative LLC v. Elenis (Compelled/Gov. Speech)

The First Amendment's Free Speech Clause prohibits Colorado from enforcing its public accommodations law (the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, or CADA) to compel a website designer to create custom wedding websites that express messages inconsistent with her religious beliefs

The government cannot force an individual to speak or convey artistic, expressive messages that violate their conscience, establishing that custom wedding websites represent "pure, protected speech" rather than ordinary commercial goods

The Court concluded that the state's interest in ensuring equal access to goods and services in the commercial market does not permit it to override an individual's First Amendment right against compelled expression