1/45
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the independent variable?
The varibale that is changed or controlled in an experiment
What is the dependent variable?
The variable being tested and measured in an experiment
What is a controlled variable?
A variable that is kept constant in an experiment
These are kept the same so that only the independent variable affects the results which makes the experiment valid
What is an aim and a hypothesis?
Aim: The main purpose of a practical investigation
Hypothesis: A prediction of the outcome of a practical investigation based on accurate scientific knowledge
What is primary data?
Data cllected from the investigator from first-hand sources
e.g You measure the heights of plants in your own experiment.
What is secondary data?
Data collected from another person, not the investigator, which is relevant to the scientific investigation
e.g. You use plant growth data from a scientific journal or website
What is raw data?
Measurements or observations of the dependent variable
e.g Recording each plant’s height every day in a table
What is qualitative data?
Data that tends to be non-numerical and is subjective
e.g. Hair colour, choice of clothing, describing leaf colour or health
What is quantitative data?
Data expressed as a number
e.g. concentrations of solutions, temperature, height
How do qualitative and quantitative data differ?
Qualitative: Data that tends to be non-numerical and is subjective
e.g. Hair colour, choice of clothing
Quantitative: Data expressed as a number
e.g. concentrations of solutions, temperature
What is the definition of accuracy?
How close the experimental data is to the true value
e.g. The true mass is 10.0 g and a scale reads 10.1 g, so the reading is accurate
Improved by calibrating equipment and reducing systematic errors
What is the definition of precision?
How close a set of data values are to each other
Precise results are not always accurate
Example: three readings of 12.1 mL, 12.2 mL and 12.1 mL are precise
If the true value is 15 mL, they are precise but not accurate
How do accuracy and precision differ in a scientific investigation?
Accuracy: How close the experimental data is to the true value
Precision: How close a set of data values are to each other
What is the definition of repeatability?
A measure of achieving the same set of data if the experiment was repeated under the same conditions
What is the definition of reproducibility?
A measure of achieving the same set of data if the experiment was repeated with a different experimenter in a different laboratory
How do repeatability and reproducibility differ in a scientific investigation?
Repeatibility: A measure of achieving the same set of data if the experiment was repeated under the same conditions
e.g. You measure catalase activity three times in one lesson and get similar results
Reproducibility: A measure of achieving the same set of data if the experiment was repeated with a different experimenter in a different laboratory
e.g. Another class runs your experiment and gets similar results
What is the true value in a scientific investigation and why can it not be known exactly?
The value that accurately represents the measurement had the experiment been conducted perfectly
It can never be known exactly because every measurement has some uncertaint
e.g Your exact height might be 165.2371… cm, but a tape measure only shows 165 cm. Your exact height is the true value, and it can never be measured perfectly
What is the definition of validity?
A measure of whether the experiment tests what it claims to test
Valid when: Control group, all other variables controlled (only IV acting)
The conclusion must be supported by the data
e.g. Testing temperature on enzyme activity is invalid if pH is not kept constant (should be controlled)
How is validity different from accuracy, precision and repeatability?
Validity: A measure of whether rthe experiment tests what it claims to test. It’s about the design of the experiment
Accuracy: How close the experimental data is to the true value. It’s about the measurements
Precision: How close a set of data values are to each other
Repeatability: A measure of achieving the same set ofd data if the experiment was repeated under the same conditions
An experiment can be accurate, precise and repeatable, but still not valid if the design is flawed
What is the definition of a random error? How do they affect results?
An error that reduces data’s precision due to an unknown and unpredictable error in the experiment
Random error causes unpredictable variation between readings, affecting precision
It can be reduced by repeating trials and calculating an average
e.g. Slight differences in reading a measuring cylinder each time
What is the definition of a systematic error? How do they affect results?
An error that reduces the accuracy of the data by causing the reading to differ from the true value
Systematic error shifts all results in the same direction by a similar amount, affecting accuracy, not precision
It cannot be reduced by repeating trials
Fixed by calibrating equipment or improving the method
e.g. A scale that always reads 0.5 g too high
How do random and systematic errors differ?
Random: An error that reduces the precision of the data due to an unknown and unpredictable error in the experimental process that is uncertain
Systematic: An error that reduces the accuracy of the data by causing the reading to differ from the true value
What is the definition of an outlier?
Any value that sits outside of the data set
What are the 5 ethical principles?
Integrity
Justice
Beneficience
Non Maleficence
Respect
How does integrity apply to a bioethical issue?
Defintion: Committment to searching for knowledge and being honest in the approach
e.g. Researchers publish all their clinical trial results, including the ones where the drug did not work
How does justice apply to a bioethical issue?
Definiton: The fair and equal consideration of all factors
e.g. A new genetic therapy should be available to everyone who needs it, not only wealthy families
How does beneficence apply to a bioethical issue?
The commitment to maximising benefits and minimising risks and harms
e.g. Gene therapy is used to treat a serious inherited disease, greatly improving the patient's quality of life
How does non-maleficence apply to a bioethical issue?
Avoiding causing harm or decreasing the amount of harm inflicted
e.g. A clinical trial is stopped early because participants are having serious side effects
How does respect apply to a bioethical issue?
Considering the value of living things and the ability for living things to make their own decision
e.g. A patient is fully informed and gives consent before having a genetic test
Why is a control group needed in an experiment?
A control group is not exposed to the independent variable
It gives a baseline to compare results against (ensures validity)
e.g. To test whether fertiliser helps plants grow, one group of plants gets fertiliser and a control group gets none. Comparing the two shows whether the fertiliser made a difference.
What are the three ethical approaches?
Consequences-based
Duty/rules-based
Virtues-based
How does the consequences-based approach decide what is right?
Definition: Maximising positive outcomes whilst minimsing negative ones
Ask: Which action produces the most good and the least harm?
Think: Results, outcomes, benefits vs harms
Watch out: It can justify harming a minority if the majority benefits
e.g Testing a new drug on a small group is justified because it could save millions of lives
How does the duty/rules-based approach decide what is right?
Definition: People have a responsibility to act in a particular way
Ask: Which action is morally right, regardless of the consequences?
Think: Rules, duties, rights, obligations
Watch out: Rules can conflict or seem too rigid in unusual situations
e.g A doctor refuses to share a patient's genetic test results without consent, even if it would help their relatives
How does the virtues-based approach decide what is right?
Definition: Judging actions by the character of the person doing them, a good action is what a virtuous person would do
Ask: Which action would a good person choose?
Think: Character, integrity, compassion, judgement
Watch out: Whose idea of a “good person” counts? It can be subjective
e.g A scientist honestly reports that their experiment failed, even though it may cost them funding
Who are stakeholders in ethical issues?
Individuals or groups who can affect, or be affected by, an ethical issue or decision
How do you identify stakeholders in an ethical issue?
Definition: Individuals or groups who can affect, or be affected by, an ethical issue or decision
Ask: Who is affected, directly or indirectly?
Ask: Who has influence through power, money, votes or expertise?
Ask: Whose voice is missing, such as animals, the environment or future generations?
Who are common stakeholders in a bioethical issue?
Patients and families
Researchers and clinicians
Companies and funders
Governments and regulators
Communities and society
Animals and the environment
Future generations
What are the four factors that shape a bioethical decision?
Social
Economic
Legal
Political
Definition: The values, beliefs, culture, public opinion and community impact
Ask: Do many people see it as "playing God"?
e.g. Some religious groups oppose embryo research because they believe an embryo is already a human life, so destroying it is wrong
Definition: The costs, funding, profits, jobs and who can afford access
Ask: Can only wealthy families afford it?
e.g. A gene therapy costing millions of dollars per patient is only accessible to a few people
Definition: The laws, regulations and guidelines in force now
Ask: What is currently allowed in Australia?
e.g. Making heritable changes to human embryos is illegal in Australia under the Prohibition of Human Cloning for Reproduction Act 2002
Definition: The Government priorities, funding decisions, policy change and public pressure
Ask: Would a government fund it or change the law?
e.g. Public pressure leads the government to fund a new treatment through Medicare
Legal: What the rules are now
Political: How and why governments decide to change, fund or enforce the rules
e.g. A law banning embryo editing is legal. A government debating whether to change that law is political.
How do you analyse a bioethical issue? What are the 5 steps?
Define: What is the science? What is the dilemma?
Stakeholders: Who is affected? Who has influence?
Factors: How do social, economic, legal and political factors shape it?
Approaches and concepts: What would each approach say? Which concepts matter most?
Decide and justify: What is your position, and why is it better than the alternatives?
How do you write a strong evaluation? What are 4 points to consider?
Weigh both sides.
Use key terms.
Use evidence from the case.
Use "because…" to justify every point.
What are characteristics of an effective bioethical anaylsis?
Considering multiple perspectives of stakeholders (such as scientific, community, environmental, and economic)
Using clear reasoning to identifiy risks, benefits, and long-term consequences
Considering long-term and unintended consequences, such as risks of ecosystem disruption or ongoing intervention needs to maintain the new population
Using evidence-based reasoning, relying on scientific data, evidence, and well-supported arguments