1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Cognition
all the mental faculties that allow an animal to store, process, and act on information from the environment
humans are not the only animals with a mind
animals engage in “playful teasing” like siblings
use tools to generate solutions to problems (showing cognition)
Fairness in animals
want equal reward for equal behavior
ex: monkey gives rock and gets grape, other monkey does same and is upset when he gets a cucumber instead of a grape
Monkey behavior mirroring human behavior
seek high-value, nutrient rich foods, and want tools to access those foods
mom wants to crack nuts, but son is using only available tools (rocks) so the mom grooms the son
mom expects son to groom in response, he does, and she sees opportunity to steal his tools
mom’s possible cognition: deception, manipulation, distraction; could’ve been incidental - just saw that the tools were available so took them
Why study animals’ minds? to understand animals
Curiosity: they’re cool, find out how clever they are
Ethics: do other animals have consciousness or moral status
Psychological and Behavioral Biology: which cognitive mechanisms support complex behavior, like alliance building or navigation
Evolution: how does cognition evolve
Conservation: how does cognition influence adaptability ~ flexibility and ability to find solutions for novel issues (like current environmental degradation)
Why study animals’ minds? to understand humans
Psychology and Anthropology: what makes us unique
Human Evolution: how did our psychology evolve
Psychology and Philosophy: how does the mind represent the world around it? what is the role of language and culture in human cognition
Comparison of Species Intelligence
cannot determine which species is smarter, because intelligence is not a linear spectrum as was once thought
comparing a dolphin to a monkey is like comparing a hammer to a screw driver
The Cognitive Approach
rejects old linear spectrum of intelligence
focuses on variety of factors: navigation, memory, social learning, inhibitory control, etc.
not seek to determine “smartness” but the unique cognitive profile of each species
animals
animals tend to be cognitively advanced at the things they need for survival, which are favored in reproduction/evolution
How do we Study Animal Minds: Experimental Psychology
core tenet
all behavior can be explained/potentially explained by multiple psychological mechanisms
just because behavior of two species (or even people) looks identical, it does not mean the behaviors are controlled by the same psychological/cognitive mechanisms
observations: generate hypotheses
experiments: test hypotheses, controlling for alternatives
Clever Hans
horse that could “do math”
could only perform when others were present, not when he was just hearing the instructions
actually just picking up on external social cues (like a sigh of relief or excitement when he did tapped number)
can solve this misperception by making a researcher blind to the hypothesis, so their behavior can’t influence the results (even subconsciously)
Anthropomorphism
George Romanes
attributing human qualities to non-human entities - can make you think animals are more human like if they look more like humans
Morgan’s Canon
if there’s a simple explanation for an outcome, you cannot favor a more complex explanation until the simpler one is ruled out
simple is the default, and complexities can only be considered if simple phenomena are first rejected
How do we Study Animal Minds: Ecological Validity
central tenet
testing animals on tasks that mimic the problems they would naturally face in the wild - problems their cognition evolved to solve
helps work against “performance v. competence"
animals may lack cognition that a task questions
lack ancillary mechanism like memory or self-control
lack ability to perceive stimuli (imperceptible color or vision difficulty)
not understand what they have to do
not be motivated to solve the task
Feats of Animal Cognition
Clark’s nutcrackers recover nuts from 6,000 locations even after 6 month delay
can do so because adapted that ability in order to survive - birds with better memory reproduced better
smarter than humans as far as memory goes
Border Collie: incredibly large semantic memory capacity - remember hundreds of labels and verbal commands
Chaser the dog know names of all her toys, and can use deduction to place label on new objects - similar to children learning language
Evolutionary Divergence
each type of primate diverged and adapted to new species at different point in time
orangutan (before human) trait expected to be seen in humans
if human has trait that orangutan doesn’t have, it would’ve likely adapted during the point of divergence
Theory of Mind
ability to infer others’ unobservable mental states, ie mind-reading/mental state attribution
motivational mental states: goals, desires, emotions
goal to communicate
Epistemic mental states: perception, knowledge, beliefs
failure to understand how things look from other’s perspective (three mountains task for kids)
False Belief Understanding
monkeys displayed understanding that others have false beliefs, that are different from their own understanding of a situation (item under box, person leaves, item changes boxes, which box the person looks under determines the monkey’s looking time)
Sally Anne Task
shows differing results among kids regarding false beliefs
some kids don’t display theory of mind, some do
could be because performance v. competence