1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Culture and social sciences
-Social sciences disconnected the dyad culture - transformations from the idea of humanization and considered it as a varied character of a multi-faceted humanity within or without the frame of an evolutionary framework
-Culture is a semeiotic structure / environment
Imaginaries
Images and meanings that enact social forces
Truths
Truths that give orientation to practices
Values
Beliefs that give orientation to practices
Identities
Beliefs that shape self-perceptions and communities
Culture in the frame of evolution (Edward Burnett Tylor)
Culture or civilization, taken in its wide ethnographic sense is that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society
Culture in the frame of relativism (Franz Baas)
-Culture may be defined as the totality of the mental and physical reactions and activities that characterizes the behavior of individuals composing a social group collectively and individually in relations to their natural environment, other groups, members of the group and themselfs
-It also includes the products of these activities and their role in the life of the groups
-The mere enumerations of these various aspects of life does not constitute culture, it is more for its elements are not independent and they have a structure
Culture moving toward structuralism (Margaret Mead)
-Culture means the whole complex of traditional behavior which has been developed by the human race and is successively learned by each generation
-A culture is less precise, it can mean the forms of traditional behavior which are characteristics of a given society or of a group of societies or of a certain race, or area, or period of time
Culture in the frame of structuralism (Bennet, Martin, Mercer, and Woollacott)
-Structuralism views experience not as the ground of culture but as its effect, the product of ways in which inindividuals are transformed into thinking, feeling, and perceiving subjects of different kind
-In extreme structuralist formulations, the orders of culture have been conceived as so many machines for producing and regulating the orders of subjectivity
-Determination of the imaginary orders which regulate the consciousness of human subjects for the structuralist the diverse form of human agency, the form in which people think, feel, and act out their lives, are the product of cultural determinations
Culture in the frame of semeiosis (Clifford Geerz)
-Culture denotes an historically transmitted pattern of meanings embodied in symbols, as system of inherited conceptions expressed in symbolic forms, and develop their knowledge about and attitudes toward life
-The concept of culture is a semiotic one, culture is the webs of significance and the analysis of it is not an experimental science in search of law but an interpretative science in search of meaning
Totalitarianism as a cultural case
-The idea that every human being has to be extracted, the more you are happy, the more you are open to be used
-It is not Hitler, Putin, etc.
The quality of culture
-This is a political issue
-Who decides?
-Is it a legitimate issue? --> if you don't like a band, but others pay a lot of money to go see them, then is it quality even though you don't like it?
-Is it socially bounded?
-Is it intrinsic to specific objects?
The necessity of culture according to Artaud
-"Never before, when it is life itself that is in question, has there been so much talk of civilization and culture and there is a parallel between this generalized collapse of life at the root of demoralization and our concern for a culture" (written just before ww2)
-The world is hungry and not concerned with culture, the attempt to orient toward culture thoughts turned only toward hunger is a purely artifical expedient
-What is most important is not so much to defend a culture whose existence has never kept a man from going hungry, as to extract from what is called culture, ideas whose compelling force is identical with that of hunger
-We must insist upon the idea of culture-in-action, of culture growing within us like a new organ, a sort of second breath
The power of words (Gualtieri)
-The oath is a strange place in language
-It is a point where language becomes solemn: forces are gathered around a word that wants to become effective, and which is planted, with the will to remain unperturbed, stronger than life, and its events, stronger than fate
-It wants to become destinity itself
The ethical question of culture
-"You can teach only what you are" (Daumal)
-Parrhesia: All-telling/to say everything --> you say what you are, who you are, without being subjective but testifying what is true for you, then quality becomes how we develop it and shape it (Pinter)
Misunderstanding
-Misunderstanding is a structural character of social relationships and social communication --> everyone misunderstands eachother all the time
-The illusion of an easy and direct access to information conceal the transformative importance of mediation (mediating does not transfer the meaning but transform the meaning)
Decorum
As a specific quality and state of integrity in the making of culture, as a social therapy through freedom --> it is something inside you which tells you I have to do this or I shouldn't do this
Controlling the impulse, resonnance, reverberation process (Bachelard)
-In the reverberation step, you can choose freedom or coercion --> will you speak your own thoughts or what has been taught to you/what people around you do
-Propaganda makers can control this process, where the goal is to have everyone think the same and do the same --> coercion
-Controlling the impulse works mostly through tailoring the medium towards your goal, like screaming about the danger of something creates imaginaries in the heads of those who hear it, even though it might not be true (like screaming about immigrants) --> people might stop listening to other evidence
--> totalitarian risk --> risk of losing our freedom --> however, we can change it, we can refuse to believe it as we have agency
Marcel Duchamp on resonance
-In art for all, it is understood that everyone is free to look at works of art and try to feel what I call 'aesthetic resonance'
-This implies that art cannot be understood through the intellect, but is perceived through an emotion that bears some analogies to religious faith or sexual attraction
-The victim of aesthetic resonance finds themselves in a position comparable to that of a man in love or a believer who automatically silences the demands of his ego and submits to a pleasant and mysterious constraint
-In exercising their taste, they assume an authoritarian attitude, the same person when touched by aesthetic revelation enters an almost ecstatic state of mind and becomes humble and receptive