1/26
Looks like no tags are added yet.
primary level of care
common health problems that account for 80-90% of visits to a physician/other caregiver (ie; diabetes, arthritis, hypertension, sore throats, depression, etc) including preventative measures (ie; vaccines and mammograms)
ie; colds, physicals, ear infections
secondary level of care
problems that require more specialized clinical expertise (ie; hospital care for a patient with acute renal failure)
OB/GYN, Ent, surgery, cancer treatment
tertiary level of care
management of rare disorders and complex medical issues (ie; pituitary tumors and congenital malformations)
organ transplant
MOST expensive of levels of care
regionalized model
highly structured; flow of patients across levels occurs in orderly, regulated fashion
base = primary care, organization works upward as needed
GPs practice exclusively at primary care level (distinct physician -> distance tiers)
Relies on resources coordinated in a geographic region -> emphasizes population-oriented framework for health planning
regionalization
organization and coordination of all health resources and service within a defined area
dispersed model
more fluid; allows patients to go where they wish, tertiary expertise is emphasized
primary care is spread among specialists, total supply of generalists
A system where hospitals and specialists are distributed across many locations with less centralized organization
why disperesed model has grown in the US
biomedical model
financial incentives
Hill Burton Hospital Construction Act, 1946
Professionalism
biomedical model
Flexner 1906 report - medical training reformed with an emphasis on academically oriented training, technology and basic science, specialist training
financial incentives
Federal involvement in health care financing
Blue Shield → reimbursement for procedures; fees for routing procedures remained high (after initial effort and time requirement for “new” procedure) despite physician time and skill needed for procedures declining (increased disparity in income between PCPs and specialists)
Insurance benefits first offered by Blue Cross covered hospital costs but not physician visits and other outpatient services
federal involvement in health care financing (financial incentives for why dispersed model has grown in US)
Medicare/Medicaid paid more for procedures; perpetuated private insurance tradition of higher payment for procedurally oriented specialists than for generalists
Medicare further encouraged specialization through its policy of extra payments to hospitals to cover costs associated with residency training
hill burton hospital construction act, 1946
hospital expansion; allocated billions of dollars between 1946-1971 for expansion of hospital capacity rather than development of ambulatory services
professionalism
physicians have been sovereign, AMA has supported physician independence
System has been weighted toward hospital and specialty care
arguments FOR dispersed model
pluralism enable providers and facilities to be more available
Americans value choice of providers
Access to specialists and technology
arguments AGAINST dispersed model
lacks coordination
Quality of care CAN be maintained with use of fewer resources: research shows comparable outcome for patients treated by general practitioners and nurse practitioners
Not consistent with health needs of the majority of the population - “common disorders commonly occur and rare ones rarely occur”
Ie: URI, skin disorders, emotional disorders, preventative care needs
Costly: research shows that generalists, in contrast to specialists, practice a less resource-intensive style of medicine
Costs are lower for patients treated by generalists vs specialists after controlling for severity of illness
why supply of US generalist physicians is a problem
there is a relative shortage of generalist physicians compared to specialists
due to less emphasis on primary care, higher healthcare costs, and reduced access to preventative care
history of HMOs
traditional FFS -> 1900-1950s -> development of HMOs
traditional FFS
physicians in solo/small group practices, NOT hospital employees; controlled hospital admissions
1900-1950s
development of multi-specialty group practices, prepaid group practices (basis for HMOs), and community health centers
community health centers
have helped to improve care of low-income ambulatory patients
generate income by billing patients and Medicare/Medicaid; over 28 million people served in 2018
development of HMOs
pre-paid group practices; Kaiser one of the first; several variations of HMOs developed
vertical integration
consolidates all levels of care, staff, and facilities under one organizational ownership
vertical integration benefits
improved continuity of care, better care coordination, greater financial stability, more convenient access to services, stronger negotiating power, allows flexibility
first generation HMOs
Kaiser Permanent Model
a vertical integration model
Does NOT cover entire population, but responsible for delivering all services to a population of enrollees
Physician group practice provides care to members under capitated plan
Enables a more population-based model of health
Kaiser Permanent Model
a large, integrated health system consisting of three interlocking administrative units: 1) kaiser foundation health plan, 2) Kaiser Foundation hospitals, 3) Permanente Medical Groups
also horizontally integrated -> has allowed Kaiser to regionalize tertiary care services at a select number of specialized centers
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan
performs the functions of health insurer
Kaiser Hospitals
in a region, operate under common ownership and management rather than as autonomous facilities
Permanente Medical Groups
the physician organizations that provide medical services to Kaiser members under a capitated contract with the Health Plan; have greater proportion of PCPS than overall US workforce, incorporating NPs and PAs into primary care team