1/51
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Phylogenetics
Study of ancestor-descendent relations to construct phylogenies.
Phylogenies- Hypotheses of ancestor descendent relationships. Can be based on morphology, physiology, molecular data.
Phylogenetic trees: graphical summaries of phylogeny
Phylogenetic characters
Attributes that can provide insights into evolutionary history. Molecular: Nucleotide positions.
Plesiomorphy
Ancestral character state
Apomorphy
Character state derived from the ancestral state.
Synapomorphy: apomorphy shared by two or more taxa from a common ancestor. Identify monophyletic groups.
Autapomorphy: Uniquely derived apomorphy.
Monophyletic
A group that contains all descendents of a common ancestor. Also known as clades.
Non-monophyletic
Cases that aren’t monophyletic. Includes:
Paraphyletic: Group with some but not all descendants of a common ancestor. Can be missing or have extra members.
Ex: Reptiles- didn’t used to include birds. Nowadays does include birds to be monophyletic as sauropsida.
Polyphyletic: Groups of taxa that have been grouped by homoplasies (like vultures).
Homoplasy
Shared characters that developed independently. Occurs by:
Parallel Evolution: Same features developed from the same ancestral condition, in separate populations. Ex: Three spine stickleback. Diverged by positive assortative mating and assortative mating. Marine ancestors moved into different lakes- each lake produced the same two species.
Convergent evolution: Independent evolution of the same feature from different ancestral conditions. Ex: Vultures- polyphyletic group between old world (birds of prey) and new world (related to storks).
Secondary loss: Reversal to the ancestral condition.
Analogy: Ex: fins of a whale vs sharks
Parsimony
Simple explanation are preferred over more complicated ones. Less evolutionary steps are more parsimonious.
Constructing Trees with Parsimony
Use synapomorphies to identify monophyletic groups. Avoid homoplasies.
Outgroups: Not part of group of interest, but not too distantly related (plesiomorphy).
Use parsimony to identify monophyletic groups.
Assess confidence in phylogenetic trees
Bootstrap method: Generate new data sets from the original sets (commonly 1000 sets) and compute number of times groupings appear in a tree.
Taxonomic Groups
Can be:
Monophyletic, Paraphyletic, Polyphyletic.
Cladistics- use of parsimony to construct relationships.
Cladistic taxonomy: evolutionary taxonomy.
Carl Woese
Three monophyletic domains of Eukarya, Bacteria, Archaea. Favored over Whittaker’s Five Kingdoms.
Biogeographies
Explanations for why some organisms are found in some regions than others. Can be used to trace lineages with continental drift/new islands.
Coevolution
Evolutionary changes in one species drives changes in other species. Can result in co-speciation.
Adaptation
Trait that increases fitness relative to individuals that don’t have it. Mutation and selection, but process may be hindered/aided with drift and migration.
Testing Adaptation hypotheses
Oxpeckers and Ticks:
Experiment- Cattle- control where birds were chased off, group with birds.
Number of ticks did not have statistically significant changes with or without the presence of oxpeckers.
Wounds and Earwax: Presence of oxpeckers increased the changes in wounds cattle had, and kept earwax levels constant. Conclusion: oxpeckers drink blood and eat earwax from cattle.
Studies for adaptations
Differences between populations are not always adaptations
Not every trait is adaptive
Not every adaptation is perfect
Experimental Approach for adaptation studies.
Ex: Jumping spiders and Tephritid fly.
Waving and wing markings of the fly: Hypotheses-
-Flies don’t mimic jumping spiders
-Flies mimic jumping spiders to deter other predators
-Flies mimic jumping spiders to deter jumping spiders
Results- flies were stalked and killed by jumping spiders if they couldn’t wave their wings or if they had no wing markings.
Observational studies of adaptations.
Ex: Garter snakes
Do Garter snakes choose adaptive choices when looking for a place to stay?
- Medium rocks: if rocks are preferred, do they choose random rocks or medium rocks (optimal hiding spot for favorite temperatures).
From experiment: Snakes choose medium rocks preferentially at night.
Comparative approaches to adaptations
Evaluate the strength of hypotheses by testing for patterns among species/lineages. Correlations among traits, or traits relating to environment. Require knowledge of organisms considered.
Ex: Bat testes- why are some bigger than others?
Hypotheses: sperm competition- bats in larger groups evolve larger testes for their body size. Variety of species tested.
- Found correlation for testes mass according to group size. However: As each plot point was a different species of bat, species ABC may have descended from a common ancestor with smaller testes vs. DEF species.
- Grouped into two points- one for each possible common ancestor. Weak evidence.
Felsenstein’s method:
When species diverge, do species that evolve larger group sizes have larger testes?
Plot all sister species and measure ‘slope’ of group size and testes sizes between pairs.
Left point at origin + leave the right point: scatterplot created for phylogenetically independent contrasts.
Each point = divergence of a species from common ancestor.
As species diverged to have larger group sizes, they also evolved larger testes.
Phylogenetically Independent contrasts
Method of evaluating cross-species correlations among traits. See Felsenstein’s method in comparative approaches.
Phenotypic Plasticity
Genetically identical individuals can have different phenotypes in different environmental conditions. Environmental Variation.
Evolution of phenotypic plasticity
Ex: Water Flea
- Parthenogenesis makes them good for testing plasticity as they make genetically identical clones.
Phototactic behavior: On average they avoid light somewhat. When water fleas are exposed to fish, they avoid light more- less phototaxic behavior.
When exposed to fish over generations, water fleas avoid light even more around fish. Thus, plasticity evolved.
Trade-offs
Compromise between one character and another that is unavoidable. Prevents simultaneous optimization of two characters or aspects of one.
Ex: Begonia involucrata
Hypotheses:
- the more closely female flowers resemble males, the more bees visit (Stabilizing selection)
- the more closely female flowers resemble the most successful males, the more bees visit (directional selection)
More pollinators approach larger female flowers, but the trade-off is that there are less flowers per inflorescence. Female flowers are usually no bigger than males.
Constraints
Factor that stunts the rate of adaptive evolution or prevents optimization of a trait.
Physiological constraint:
Ex: Fuschia excorticata
5.5 days after opening, they are green. They become red afterwards for five days. When they become red- almost nothing pollinates. Why not drop flowers immediately after to signal that there’s no nectar instead of turning red (more metabolic stress)?
Time is needed for pollen tubes to grow after germination for sperm to transfer to the ovary.
Genetic Constraint:
Ex: Phytophagous beetle
Hypotheses: Most host shifts are genetically impossible, or all host shifts are genetically impossible
Constraint- not enough genetic variation for evolutionary change of hosts.
Ecological constraint:
Ex: Dove lice
Dove lice on body feathers don’t change hosts- they don’t get much opportunity to change to other hosts. Less dispersal means they can’t easily change hosts.
Hominidae
Family of Great Apes.
Includes Humans, Chimpanzees, and Bonobos as closely related species.
Also includes Gorillas, Orangutans.
Hyalobatidae family (Gibbons) are closely related to Hominidae.
Fission/Fusion Societies
Size and composition of groups (Bonobos, Chimpanzees, Orangutans, Humans) change over time.
Fusion: merging of various groups (ex: sleeping together as one group)
Fission: splitting of a group into various groups (ex: foraging in small groups in the day)
Bonobo social structure
Peace-loving society. Strong social bonds between females, sometimes female and male bonds.
Status within a group depends on the mother’s hierarchy.
Mother and son stay closely bonded throughout their lives.
Chimpanzee social structure
The strongest bonds are between males to hunt and protect territory. Females live in overlapping areas in the territory but don’t have strong bonds to others.
Gibbon social structure
Monogamous, egalitarian (equal) relationships in pairs that each maintain a small territory.
Human social structure
Males unite for cooperative ventures, Females also bond with those of the same sex. Monogamy, Polygamy, and Polyandry have been observed.
Gorilla social structure
Polygamy. Single male maintains a territory for his family, with several females. Strong bonds between male and females.
Orangutan social structure
Solitary. One male has a range in which several females live within their own ranges.
Human Sperm Competition
Masturbation may be a way to increase sperm fitness without sacrificing sperm count retained by females (sperm count is unchanged). Sperm count in ejaculates were reduced, however.
- Pairs that spend less proportion of time together (high risk of sperm competition) tended to have increased insemination
- Larger females tended to retain more sperm
Obligate Parthenogenesis
Entire eukaryote species are female, which reproduce asexually by making identical clones of themselves.
Ex: Mourning Geckos
Cyclical Parthenogenesis
Eukaryote populations are mostly females that make clones throughout the year. Specific breeding seasons when males appear for sexual reproduction.
Ex: Aphids
Facultative Parthenogenesis
Eukaryote populations have males and females, but females can conduct parthenogenesis to make clones if needed.
Ex: Komodo Dragons
Hermaphrodites (Androgyne)
Organisms that have both male and female gonads- can undergo self-fertilization (selfing). Strongest form of inbreeding (less genetic diversity); still sexual reproduction due to production of gametes by meiosis.
Meiosis with/without Recombination: 4 gamete types with recombination (sexual) instead of 2 gamete types without (asexual).
Sex: destroys old combinations to make new ones. There will always be one combination that is favorable.
Why sex exists
Maynard Smith’s Null model: Female reproductive mode doesn’t affect the number of offspring or their survival.
- Asexual reproduction in theory would be much more beneficial as reproductive output and rate are faster. Females can just keep cloning themselves, without needing to find a mate. Two organisms are needed instead of one: extra resources needed.
Experiment: C. elegans → Can be hermaphrodites (female), or male. Males and females can cross for 50% genders, females can produce more females. Male persistence in a population requires them to fertilize more eggs than their own frequency, or to increase offspring fitness.
3 strains: One purely hermaphroditic, one purely sexual, one control. Given a stressful environment, and given a stressful environment with mutagen introduction: Outcrossing increased fitness with mutagen exposure. Controls accumulated deleterious mutations and became less fit.
Linkage disequilibrium
Genes close together on a chromosome: linked. Do not segregate independently but inherited as a single unit.
Linkage disequilibrium: genotypes at two different linked loci are not randomly associated with one another. Less genetic diversity.
Recombination: breaks up linked genes and reduces linkage disequilibrium.
Muller’s Ratchet
Obligate asexual organisms accumulate deleterious mutations, decreasing fitness.
Genetic load: total number of deleterious mutations and fitness changes as a result in the average population. Eventually rises until extinction.
Ex: sexual stickbugs had less nonsynonymous to synonymous mutations than asexual stickbugs. asexual bugs tended to have more deleterious mutations causing them to produce proteins different from the original.
- Ancient asexual organisms are rare
Red Queen Hypothesis
Species must continuously evolve in response to changes in other organisms. Failure to do so results in extinction. Adaptation to new metas in short.
Ex:
Pathogens must evolve with their host, and vice versa to keep up with one another.
C. Elegans- outcrossing rate increases tremendously with coevolution.
Snail Potamopyrus antipodarum: Higher frequency of males in parasite-infected snail populations
Advantages of asexual reproduction
Strong colonization abilities- entire population can be founded by one individual. Propagate much faster when an environment is favored.
Sexual Dimorphism
Phenotypic differences between males and females. Related to sexual selection- differential reproductive successes from different abilities to find a mate.
Ex: Great Frigate birds, humans, Greater kudu, giant scale insects, etc.
Parental Investment
Energy, time, resources devoted to mating, gestating, and caring for offspring. Increases offspring fitness. Greater for females- eggs are expensive, sperm are cheap.
Various species: log Female gamete production rate is higher per log gram of mass. Three times more energy for daily metabolism. Daily sperm: 4/1000 daily metabolism to produce.
Asymmetric limits on reproductive potential
Females: Usually have greater parental investment- success limited by the eggs they can produce and rear. 90% mammals: males don’t provide investment. Usually have weak sexual selection- can be choosier, selective.
Males: can produce infinite amount of sperm. Success limited by the amount of mates they can obtain. Usually have strong sexual selection- competitive. Combat, sperm competition, infanticide.
Ex:
Newts- females: offspring numbers not affected by number of mates.
Males: offspring numbers affected by number of mates (statistically significant).
Pipefish: more male parental investment. Offspring numbers not affected as much by the number of mates.
Females- more offspring with more mates.
Intersexual Selection
Male-Male competition:
- Combat → Marine Iguanas: morphological traits favored that increase combat power- tactics, size, armor, etc.
males that copulate are larger than the optimal size for survival. As the number of males decrease, the number of copulations increase.
→ Dawson’s Burrowing bees- males spawncamp newborn females and fight to the death until only the last remain. Sometimes females are killed in the process.
- Sneakers → Coho Salmon: Males fight for spots closer to females that are nesting (Hooknoses). Others (Jacks) hide somewhere nearby and rush to spawn on the eggs laid when the time is right. Success betwee hooknoses vs. jacks depends on environment and genetics.
- Side-blotched lizards: three male strategies- large territories with many females, small territories with few females, and sneaking into other territories. Small territories work best against sneakers, but large territories outcompete small territories.
- Sperm competition: To outcompete other sperm, males can produce larger ejaculates, prolong copulation, inserting copulatory plugs, or remove sperm left by other males.
- Infanticide: Male lions may go to other prides to try and take over. Success: kill previous males’ cubs to mate with nursing females (dont mate when nursing). Females may defend their cubs but might get killed in the process.
Intrasexual selection
Female Choice: When males can’t monopolize females or resources for them, males advertise for mates to choose.
Red-collared widowbirds: dimorphic during dimorphic season. Males gain three times more mates with longer tails, but those with shorter tails expend less energy.
Gray Tree Frogs: Females prefer longer calling males, and can differentiate longer calls from multiple short ones.
Male Zebra fish: mutant red fish are favored by females. Traits selected can be arbritrary at first and could be neutral in terms of viability.
Spotted Cucumber beetles: Fast-stroking males are favored by females, but fast-stroking presents no extra viability. It only gets more mates, and offspring are fast-stroking too.
Bruce Effect
In Gelada Baboons:
Groups of few males, many females up to 12, offspring. Males take over: infants killed.
Pregnant females: May spontaneous terminate pregnancy to avoid raising ‘doomed offspring’. Called the Bruce Effect
Modelling female choice and runaway selection
A null model: Arbritrary female choice- any detectable traits in males can increase sexual selection, and don’t need to increase viability selection.
Assortative mating for extreme displays and preference for it can lead to genetic correlation.
→ Evolution equilibrium reached when population mean display and preference match. Selection for display or preference leads to correlated response in the other.
Runaway Selection: When a population moves off the equilibrium line between display and preference, the population may never return → male traits that are maladaptive for viability selection.
Reasons females are picky for mates
Better genes: Offspring of Gray Tree Frogs with longer calls are more fit on average
Pre-existing sensory bias: Water mites can imitate prey vibrations to increase likelihood of mating with a female.
Resistance to parasites: Barn Swallows can be infected by blood-sucking mites, leading to shorter tails, less nestling growth. Females prefer males with longer, more symmetric tails- offspring with more mite resistance.
Better resources: Hanging Fly males can provide food, parental care, etc. Females can distinguish between good/bad providers.
→ Larger nuptial gifts (prey provided) means longer copulation time. Sexual cannibalism in black widows, mantises, are an example of this at an extreme.
Polygny, Polyandry
Polygny: Multiple female mates from one male. Results from strong sexual selection for males.
Polyandry: multiple male mates from one female. Results from strong sexual selection for females.