Chapter 12 - Preparing for Trials

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/4

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

5 Terms

1
New cards

Who Should Decide: Jury or Judge?

  • If the opposing party consents, defendants and plaintiffs can opt to have the verdict decided by a judge (i.e., a bench trial).

  • Preference for a bench trial or a jury trial involves thoughts of who will issue the most favorable ruling (Bornstein & Greene, 2017).

How Judges and Juries Compare

  • In only 19.5% of the criminal cases did the jury return a guilty verdict where the judge would have ruled not guilty, or vice versa (approximately 5% of cases resulted in a hung jury).

  • In discrepant decisions, the jury was more lenient than the judge.

  • Level of agreement between jury and judge was high in civil trials.

Determinants of Discrepancies

  • What accounts for the discrepancies between judge and jury?

  • Kalven and Zeisel attempted to answer these questions by delving more deeply into the judges’ reactions to the cases and comparing them to the juries’ verdicts.

A Critique of the Kalven and Zeisel Study

  • Judges were permitted to choose which trial or trials they reported.

  • 500 judges out of 3,500 judges provided responses to the survey.

  • The membership of juries has changed; they are more heterogeneous today than in the past (e.g., increased diversity).

  • As for causes of discrepancies between verdicts by the judge and jury, we have only the judge’s beliefs about the jurors’ feelings and sentiments.

Data on Judge/Jury Differences and Criminal Case Comparisons

  • Researchers at the National Center for State Courts, Eisenberg et al. (2005) collected data from jurors, judges, and attorneys in more than 350 trials in four jurisdictions.

  • The rate of jury/judge agreement was 70%, and when there was disagreement, juries were more lenient (compared to Kalven and Zeisel’s 75%). They were more likely to acquit when judges opted to convict.

  • Circumstances in which jurors were more likely than judges to return “not guilty” verdicts:

    • Jurors were more impressed than judges by the presence of a third party defense witness (someone other than the defendant).

    • Jurors were impressed by the absence of a prior criminal record.

    • Juries are also more lenient than judges in death penalty cases.

Updating Civil Case Comparisons

  • Clermont and Eisenberg (1992) examined plaintiff win rates in federal cases tried before either juries or judges from 1979 to 1989.

    • Differences emerged in products liability and medical malpractice cases only—plaintiffs had more success with judges (48% win rate) than with juries (28% win rate).

  • Researchers attributed the differences in civil cases to selection effects the selection of cases tried by juries differed from those tried by judges.

    • Defense lawyers tended to settle cases in which the plaintiff had a strong case, typically leaving juries to decide relatively weaker cases for the plaintiff—thus, they appear to make different decisions than judges.


2
New cards

Jury Selection Begins in the Community: Forming a Panel

  • Jury selection begins before potential jurors arrive at the courthouse, as officials assemble a panel (venire) of prospective jurors.

  • Jury selection must neither systematically eliminate nor underrepresent any subgroups of the population.

  • To encourage representativeness, U.S. Supreme Court cases since 1880 have forbidden systematic or intentional exclusion of religious, racial, and other cognizable groups from jury panels.

  • But as recently as 55 years ago, the composition of most venires was homogeneous, with middle-aged, well-educated White men generally overrepresented.

  • The U.S. Supreme Court and Congress established the requirement that the pool a jury is selected from must be a representative cross-section of the community. There are two reasons for this:

    • This would result in more heterogeneous juries. The courts assumed that this diversity would produce various benefits, such as the following:

      • Minority members might discourage majority members from expressing prejudice.

      • Heterogeneous juries would be better fact finders and problem finders.

    • Jury representativeness would give the appearance of legitimacy.

      • Juries should reflect the standards of the community. When certain components of the community are systematically excluded from jury service, the community is likely to reject both the legal process and its outcomes as invalid.

How do courts form the venire to make the jury representative?

  • Voter registration lists were used as the primary source for jury pool selection but underrepresent segments of the community.

  • Other sources such as lists of licensed drivers, persons receiving public assistance, and unemployed people have supplemented voter lists as a source of prospective jurors.

  • From those persons who are eligible for jury service, members of the venire are randomly selected and summoned to appear at the courthouse for jury service. 

    • But as many as half of qualified jurors ignore the jury summons, even though doing so constitutes a violation of law.


3
New cards

Jury Selection Continues in the Courtroom: The Voir Dire Process

  • In an effort to determine if prospective jurors are prejudiced, the judge and/or attorneys question prospective jurors in a procedure called voir dire.  

  • The following are all matters left to judges’ discretion:

    • Who asks the questions

    • What questions are asked

    • How they are phrased

    • How long the questioning goes on

    • Whether the questions are posed to individual jurors or to a group

  • A limited form of voir dire involves yes-or-no questions asked by the judge and answered by the group, not individuals.

    • Yes-or-no questions offer little insight into jurors’ beliefs and attitudes.

      • Implicit biases—beliefs borne of experiences and attitudes that predispose us to think in a certain way and of which we are unaware—make it difficult for jurors to accurately know their own predilections.

      • Another important psychological dynamic, termed the social desirability effect, is also a factor at this stage. Most people want to present themselves in a positive, socially desirable way.

      • Extended voir dire in which the judge and attorneys ask open ended questions and question jurors individually has advantages in uncovering biases.


4
New cards

Challenges for Cause

  • Technically, attorneys do not select a jury; rather, the judge gives them the opportunity to challenge, and effectively dismiss, a number of potential jurors from the jury.

  • There are two mechanisms—challenges for cause and peremptory challenges—by which panelists are excluded from serving on a jury. 

  • In theory, because attorneys strive to exclude those jurors who seem unfavorable to their client, the challenges made by each side should tend to balance out, and both extremes should be eliminated, leaving a jury composed of people who are less biased and more open minded.

  • In any trial, attorneys can claim that particular jurors should be excluded because they are inflexibly biased or prejudiced or because they have a relationship to the parties or the issues that creates an appearance of bias. 

    • These exclusions are known as challenges for cause. 

    • For example, a relative or business associate of a defendant would be challenged, or excused, for cause. 

    • Additionally, the judge may excuse a panelist for cause if the prospective juror is unfit to serve. 

  • In criminal cases, judges often inquire about whether prospective jurors have been crime victims and may excuse those who say that their own victimization experiences would affect their ability to be fair jurors. 

  • In cases where the prosecution seeks the death penalty, prospective jurorswhose strong opposition to the death penalty might make it difficult for them to be impartial are also dismissed for cause.

  • In theory, each side has an unlimited number of challenges for cause. In reality, few prospective jurors are excused for reasons of bias. In a survey of New Mexico courts over a three-year period, only about 1 of every 20 jurors was dismissed for cause (Hans & Vidmar, 1986).

  • As jury selection proceeds, each side may also exclude a designated number of prospective jurors “without a reason stated, without inquiry, and without being subject to the court’s control” (Swain v. Alabama, 1965). This procedure is known as a peremptory challenge. Most states and the federal courts allow six or more peremptory challenges per side, and some allow more than that in serious felony cases.


5
New cards

Peremptory Challenges: No Exclusion of Race or Gender

  • Peremptory challenges have multiple purposes. 

    • First, they allow attorneys to dismiss potential jurors whom they believe will be unsympathetic to their client, for whatever reason.

    • The peremptory challenge has a second, largely symbolic function: When the parties in a lawsuit play a role in selecting the people who decide the outcome, they may be more satisfied with that outcome (Saks, 1997). 

    • The third function of peremptory challenges is to allow the attorney to begin to indoctrinate prospective jurors and influence those who ultimately will make up the jury. 

  • The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that peremptory challenges may not be based solely on a juror’s race or gender. 

  • The decision regarding race was triggered by the case of James Batson, a Black man convicted of second-degree burglary by an all-White jury. 

  • During voir dire, the prosecutor used four of six peremptory challenges to dismiss all the Black persons from the venire. 

  • In Batson v. Kentucky, decided in 1986, the Court held that James Batson was denied his Fourteenth Amendment right to equal protection by the prosecution’s dismissal of Black members of the panel. 

  • The Court clarified that decision in Powers v. Ohio (1991) when it ruled that basing peremptory challenges on race harms not just defendants, but wrongly excluded jurors as well.

  • And the following year, the Court held defense counsel to the same standard as prosecutors, effectively prohibiting race-based challenges for both sides (Georgia v. McCollum, 1992). 

  • In the Batson case, the Supreme Court developed a procedure for determining whether a peremptory challenge was race-based.

  • Psychological research on social judgments can explain why we are adept at generating false but plausible explanations of unseemly behavior.