Difference Feminism and Poststructuralism

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/9

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

10 Terms

1
New cards

How does 'difference feminism' differ from earlier feminist perspectives regarding women's experiences of oppression?

→ Unlike earlier feminist perspectives which assume that all women share a similar situation and similar experience of oppression, 'difference feminists' do not see women as a single homogeneous group.

→ They argue that middle-class and working-class women, White and Black women, and lesbian and heterosexual women have very different experiences of patriarchy, capitalism, racism, homophobia, and so on.

2
New cards

What is meant by 'false universality' in feminist theory, and how does the example of the family illustrate this?

→ Difference feminism argues that feminist theory has claimed a 'false universality' for itself by claiming to be about all women, when in reality it was only about the experiences of White, Western, heterosexual, middle-class women.

→ For example, by seeing the family only as a source of oppression, White feminists have neglected Black women's experience of racial oppression, whereas many Black feminists view the Black family positively as a source of resistance against racism.

→ This criticism raises two important issues: the problem of essentialism, and the relationship of feminism to the Enlightenment project.

3
New cards

What is 'essentialism' as applied to gender, and why do difference feminists criticise liberal, Marxist, and radical feminists as essentialist?

→ As applied to gender, essentialism is the idea that all women share the same fundamental 'essence', meaning all women are essentially the same and all share the same experiences of oppression.

→ Difference feminists argue that liberal, Marxist, and radical feminists are essentialist because they see all women as the same.

→ As a result, they fail to reflect the diversity of women's experiences and exclude other women and their problems.

→ For example, some difference feminists argue that the preoccupation of Western feminism with sexuality is irrelevant to women in poorer countries, where access to clean water and primary healthcare are far more pressing problems.

4
New cards

What is poststructuralist feminism concerned with, and how do discourses create power over others according to thinkers such as Judith Butler?

→ Poststructuralist feminists such as Judith Butler (Butler and Scott, 1992) offer an alternative approach concerned with discourses and power/knowledge.

→ Discourses are ways of seeing, thinking, or speaking about something, and the world is made up of many, often competing, discourses, such as religious, scientific, medical, and artistic discourses.

→ By enabling its users to define others in certain ways, a discourse gives power over those it defines; knowledge is power, specifically the power to define or 'constitute' the identities of others.

→ For example, by defining childbirth as a medical condition and healthy women as patients, medical discourse empowers doctors and disempowers women.

5
New cards

How does Judith Butler apply poststructuralist ideas about discourse and power/knowledge to critique the Enlightenment project and existing feminist theories?

→ Poststructuralists argue that the Enlightenment project, with its emphasis on reason, humanity, and progress, is a discourse acting as a form of power/knowledge that legitimated domination by Western, White, middle-class males while excluding women and other oppressed groups despite claiming universal applicability.

→ Similarly, Butler argues that the White, Western, middle-class women who dominate the feminist movement have falsely claimed to represent 'universal womanhood'.

→ She concludes that feminists are wrong to believe they can adapt the Enlightenment project to include all women, because women are not a single entity who all share the same 'essence'.

6
New cards

Why does poststructuralism reject a fixed essence of 'womanhood' across different times and cultures?

→ For poststructuralism, there is no fixed essence of what it is to be a woman because identities are constituted through discourses, and there are many different discourses across different times and cultures.

→ Consequently, there can be no fixed entity called 'womanhood' that is the same everywhere.

→ For example, womanhood in some parts of the world is constituted partly by religious discourse, whereas in the West it is constituted to a greater extent by the discourses of advertising and the media.

7
New cards

What advantages does Judith Butler argue poststructuralism offers for feminism?

→ It enables feminists to (analyse) different discourses, such as medicine, sexuality, advertising, art, religion, science, and pornography, to reveal the power/knowledge by which they define and subordinate women (as seen in the medicalisation of childbirth).

→ Because different discourses produce different forms of oppression, identities, and experiences for women, each discourse provokes its own distinct form of resistance and struggle with its own aims and demands.

→ By rejecting essentialism and stressing the diversity of discourses, poststructuralism recognises and legitimates the diversity of women's lives and struggles rather than prioritising some and excluding others.

8
New cards

What is the main strength of poststructuralist feminism, and how does Sylvia Walby (1992) criticise its emphasis on difference?

→ Poststructuralist feminism seems to offer a theoretical basis for recognising the diversity of women's experiences and struggles.

→ However, Sylvia Walby (1992) agrees that there are differences among women, yet argues that there are also important similarities because they are all faced with patriarchy (for example, compared with men, women face a greater risk of low pay, domestic violence, and sexual assault).

→ Similarly, celebrating difference may have the effect of dividing women into an infinite number of sub-groups, thereby weakening feminism as a movement for change.

9
New cards

How does Lynne Segal (1999) criticise poststructuralist feminism regarding discourses and objective social structures?

→ Lynne Segal (1999) criticises poststructuralist feminism for abandoning any notion of real, objective social structures.

→ She argues that oppression is not just the result of discourses, but is about real inequality.

→ Feminists should therefore continue to focus on the struggle for equality of wealth and income.

10
New cards