1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ice Free Corridor
gap between the cordilleran and laurentide ice sheets
glacial maximums = cold = closed corridor (25 kya), low sea levels
interstadial periods = warming period = open corridor (100-65 kya and 30-35 kya), high sea levels
Bering land bridge = closed when sea levels are high, cannot walk across, opened when sea levels are low
50 m below sea level for bering land to open
Yana RHS
warmer climate, land bridge is open, high sea levels (33-31 kya)
IFC closed
31-14.5 — cold w/brief warming periods, land bridge open
14.5-14 — warming period, swan point, land bridge open
IFC open
13.9-12.8 — warm w/100 year cold snaps, nenana complex, land bridge is decreasing, low sea levels
12.8-11.7 — cold, denali complex, land bridge is closed (submerged as holocene approached)
Glacial lakes
dangerous to cross
no fish to catch (no food)
lakes were draining
Direct evidence of the use of IFC
timing of when Clovis was present
timing of when ice sheets were retreating
people were living in beringia and an opening between ice sheets appeared at the end of the pleistocene
Animal movements in the corridor
food
bison genetics = IFC was shut from 23-13.5 kya (no bison present)
gene flow for top predators (humans, bears, lions) between 29-14 kya show there was no food/prey
Fladmark’s initial reasons for positing the coastal migration route
inhospitable, no one would be able to live in the IFC due to weather conditions
water craft technology was known at this point (50 kya)
no sites of appropriate age in the IFC
could explain language diversity on the west coast of north america and spread south along coast
What the coastal migration can explain
early sites in the americas
might never have been shut which allows for genetic models to work
language diversity
Assumptions of the Coastal Migration Hypothesis
watercraft would be necessary, assumed because water would have been too cold to swim in
viable plant and animal refugia, needed to support travelers along the coast (assumed due to the need for food)
Watercraft in other areas
indonesia = homo erectus made hops across marine straights 700-1000 kya
homo sapiens traveling to australia (island)
after 50 kya, modern humans crossed salt water gaps of 100km
25-30 kya people in Japan were sailing into colder waters to get obsidian
pesse canoe from holland (10-9.5 kya)
dufona canoe in nigeria (8000 years old)
boats found in azerbaijan from 12 kya
Refugia
isolated areas where plant and animal communities survive due to special circumstances
pollen dating reflected plant growth
animals could live off of plant live, humans could live off of animals
Current evidence for the coastal migration route
parts of western vancouver island are interpreted to be ice free for the last 18.5 kya
outer coastal sites included open shrub vegetation from 17.5-16 kya
interior valleys on vancouver island included fir/pine woodland by 14.2 kya
several millennia of late pleistocene human settlement was possible on vancouver island
sedimentary ancient DNA
habitable refugia to be occupied in southern coast
isostatic
changes in ground level rising or falling due to pressure from ice (some evidence of first occupations lies very high in elevation)
eustatic
changes in sea level due to amount of ice in the water (more ice = lower sea levels) (some evidence of first occupations is under water)
Pre-clovis candidates
calico hills
cerutti mastodon site
calico hills
location = shores of lake manix, drained around 18 kya
founded by ruth simpson, louis leakey, jeffery goodman
consists of stone artifacts from a deposit under 100 kya soil column
uranium-thorium dates of 200-150 kya on carbonates encrusted on artifacts
problems:
artifacts = natural
no consistent technological pattern
artifacts are made of locally available stone which easily flakes naturally
no human remains or fauna
cerutti mastodon site
holen et al. 2017
intentionally broken mastodon bones and human baattered cobbles
hammer and anvil present (evidence of bone breaking)
130,700 BP
rocks could have been moved to the site naturally
no left over waste material of making stone tools
broken bones from bulldozer in 1970
no human remains
published in nature
land bridge was closed
too old (neanderthals and denisovans)
Burden of Proof Caveats
are paleoenvironmental studies consistent with ages assigned to the site
are there human remains that are reliably dated older than 13.5 kya
is there a definable cultural complex that is demonstrably different than clovis
Potential pre clovis sites
Big Eddy
Cactus Hill
Meadowcroft Rockshelter
Cooper’s Ferry
Big Eddy Site
founders: Neil Lopinot and Jack Ray
southeast missouri, 1990’s
clovis points found
stone anvil below clovis layer (pre clovis occupation)
no disturbance in stratigraphy; lower layers = 14.5-13.8 kya
not distinct from clovis site
no human remains — new human line made up
Cactus Hill Site
Excavated in 1990s
upper layer w/clovis points (13-12.8 kya)
layer under clovis layer w/bifacial points (18-20 kya)
“pre clovis” blades
sand dune site due to wind born sand deposits
biface tradition = mix of solutrean and clovis
no human remains
Meadowcroft Rockshelter
excavated by James Adovasio in 1970s
dry cave
blades and bifaces = miller site
plant and animal remains
fluted projectile points
pre clovis occupation (16-19 kya)
early dates dismissed due to coal contamination (did not meet paleoenvironmental consistency)
deposit lacks fauna that was expected for that age
cooper’s ferry
located on salmon river in idaho
early occupation associated with soil layer
surface was 16,560 to 15,280 years old
stemmed points associated with western stem point tradition points develope after clovis (13,100-8400 cal. BP)
WSP = 13-12.5 kya
dates not clearly associated with artifacts
pits could have been dug
similar WSP found in sites that date post clovis
features have ambiguous boundaries
Clovis Technology
fluted bifacial points
spurred endscraper
ivory shaft straightener (used to heat up and bend wood)
ivory and bone rods
gravers (etching)
crescents (catching waterfowl)
Western Stemmed Point Tradition
crude
paisley cave, OR
cooper’s ferry, ID
very different from clovis points
found in great basin, from socal to rocky mountains
projectile points with stems and constricting bases
coeval or older than clovis (13.7-12.5 kya)
Debra Friedkin site
Texas, buttermilk creek
rich in water
clear clovis occupation and potential preclovis
stratigraphy is in good condition
dates w/OSL because of lack of carbon (13.5-15.5)
40 late stage biface fradments found, 12 are projectile points
not clovis points, probably pre clovis
no fluting
hard to criticize this site
Paisley cave
high desert of central oregon, northern great basin
human coprolites w/human DNA in them
human DNA is unique enough to discern from other DNA
coprolites dated back to 14.4 cal BP, 1000 years before clovis
4 WSP were recovered from early deposits
accepted as preclovis
human DNA was found
DNA can move through sediments through water and urine, not from coprolites
but pretty undeniable
Page Ladsen
Aucilla river, florida
9m underwater in a sink hole
1983-1997 investigations brought out butchered mastadon bones associated with 8 stone tools (14.4 kya) — challenged because dates were too old
2012-2014: excavated using underwater methods, human made preclovis artifacts present
nothing stylistic = preclovis
Beringia Standstill Hypothesis: Scenario I
ANE and AEE populations interacted in Lake Baikal
Ancestral native americans settled on western shores of the Bering sea
first people would have moved to exploit the swampy tundra where they adapted to marine enviornments
Beringia Standstill Hypothesis: Scenario II
Steppe tundra was a refugia for people (hunted megafauna)
cold temperatures of LGM enhanced carrying capacity
likely been occupied by paleosiberians, not ancient american ancestors
not a route to southern americas @ the time
White Sands, NM
human footprints found in mud and clay and alongside them were mammoth footprints
water plant seeds (Ruppi cirrhosa) produced dates: 23-21 kya
20 discrete stratigraphic horizons and sedimentary packages containing multiple foot print bearing horizons
152 human footprints (children, adolescents, adults)
tells us people were in north america before 23 kya
space between footprints tell us how fast they were walking
shorter people from foot sizing
dragging travois
used IFC to travel
when did clovis appear in north america
13,050-12,750 cal. BP
Blackwater Draw
oldest water well in the americas
used to be a watering hole used by extinct megafauna
1936 = 2 mammoths with stone spear points and other tools
clovis first model
became preferred model
challenging it became heresy
Solutrean Hypothesis
Americas were settled by people out of Europe using solutrean technology
used watercraft to make their way across north atlantic and into north america
23-17 LGM
Evidence of the Solutrean Hypothesis
methods used to make solutrean stone tools were the same as clovis
overshot flaking technique
too similar to clovis, must have been intersection
Problems with Solutrean Hypothesis
overshot flaking could be a by product of some other technique
only so many ways to flake stone tools (coincidence)
several thousand years of discontinuity between solutrean and clovis
contradicting radio metric data
no evidence of a marine adaptation that would have supported the journey
genetic modeling cannot find genetic connection between populations
Harm of Solutrean Hypothesis
can be used to disenfranchise indigenous americans from claims to north america and promotes racist agendas
Beringian Microblade tradition
small wedge shaped cores common and used for microblades
Dyuktai culture and blade technology
northeast siberia
16,000-11,000 BP
bifacial knives, choppers, burins, microblades, wedge shaped microblade cores
fauna = mammoth, bison, horse, musk ox, birds, fish
Ushki site
13.5-12 kya
nicolai dikov (1961-1990)
ted goebel (2000s)
series of 5 sites = strata can be cross correlated between the sites based on volcanic ash layers
lowermost layer = VII
Component VII
13.5-12.8 kya
Tundra flora
burned bone for fuel
stemmed points
human buriel pit
poorly preserved bones
881 beads + 26 chipped chakedony points
figure 8 shaped dual chamber dueling w/small pits/hearths
red ochre, 3 stone pendants
Component VI
12.7 kya BP
dyuktai like wedge shaped core and microblade technology
microblades have connections with alaskan complexes
nonmicroblade component stratigraphically before
stemmed points may relate to western stemmed points found along western US
Berelekh
13-11 kya BP
N. Grigoriev in 1947; V. Pitulko in 2009
mammoth cemetery
8800 bones and 2kg of hair
steppe bison, reindeer, ptarmigan
burned bone for fuel
50 legit artifacts
4 drilled flat pebbles
no relation to dyuktai culture
Swan Point — Eastern Beringia
oldest accepted site in EB
initial occupation 14,440-13,550 BP
clear evidence of man made stone tools with extinct fauna
discovered in 1990s
charles holmes
connection to siberia = dyuktai tradition was used in SP
microblade and burin tech (primary)
biface and blade tech (secondary)