1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Federalism
Power is divided between a central government and smaller units
Different penalties between state and federal
States and National government get power from people
Unitary System
Vote for national elections
National government will tell regional and locals what to do
Same penalties for federal and state
Ex: Japan & France
Confederate government
State controls what national does.
How many governments in America?
90,106 governments!
1 US Government
50 State
3031 County
19,519 Municipal
16,360 Town
38,266 Special District
12,880 Independent School Districts
TX: has 5,343 local governments
Good things about Federalism
Diverse policies for a diverse population (unique states)
Minimizes policy conflict (interstate compacts: agreement between 2+ parties; keeps national government from addressing smaller issues; gets people ideas across local levels)
Closer to people (gets people more involved)
Healthy dispersion of power creates more opportunities for participation
Policy innovation at state level (state laboratories, laws tried in states are later implemented in national law)
State and local levels good training ground
Privileges and immunities clause (protects people from different states)
Concerns about Federalism
No national standards can create inequities
Dispersion of power can allow groups to protect interests which may be undemocratic and contrary to national trends
Low visibility and information flow about local governments (we don’t know much about our local government that impacts our daily lives)
Bad competition between states (diversity)
How to divide power?
National Powers
State Powers
Concurrent Powers
Denied Powers
National Power
Obligation to protect state from invasion and violence
Coin money, conduct foreign relations, regulate commerce, provide an army and navy, declare war, establish courts inferior to Supreme Court, establish post offices, make laws necessary and proper to carry out these powers, admit new states
Supremacy Clause
Judges in every state must obey US Constitution
State Power
Reservation Clause = 10th Amendment
Unique to US system
If the powers aren’t in the Constitution or not prohibited by the Constitution, the states/people get them
How much power do these states have?
legislate public health, safety, and morals of their citizens, state criminal laws, set time/place/manner of elections, ratify amendments to federal 3 2021 © Shannon Bow O’Brien Constitution, exert powers not delegated to national government or prohibited to the states, establish local governments, regulate commerce within a states, regulate voting
Concurrent Power
Given to both national and state governments
Include: tax, borrow money, make and enforce laws, charter banks, spend money for general welfare, take private property for public purposes with just compensation Denied Powers
AKA POWERS WE DONT GIVE TO ANYBODY
Bill of Attainer (prevents people from saying anything is illegal and the person goes straight to jail; no jail without proper trial)
Ex Post Facto laws (Out of the fact; previous legal activity becomes illegal and then preventing having penalty)
Powers Denied Just to the State Governments
Can’t deal with foreign countries, coin money, can’t prevent contracts from being fulfilled, side deals with other states without Congress
Powers Denied Just to the National Government
Can’t play favorites w/ states, can’t regulate commerce differently in states
Development of Federalism
Marshall Court
McCulloch v. Maryland (making Judiciary equal in all 3 branches)
Establish Judicial Review (the judiciary looks at things decided by national and state government and decides its constitutionally)
Nullification (Civil War; states do not have to obey unconstitutional laws and gets to decide constitutionally of national laws)
Preemption (if state wants to do something not in conflict w/ national laws but its still to the scale of national attention, the national government might step in to interfere)
The Civil War Amendments
Power of the federal government expands to make the states adhere to new national standards
13th: abolished slavery
15th: former male slaves given the right to vote
14th: Applied to states; Incorporation doctrine, Equal protection clause for citizens, remedial legislation comes from section 5 of this 14th amendment
national laws can address discriminatory state laws against slaves/former slaves
Double citizen: national citizen & state citizen; right to vote in both
Types of Federalism
Dual (layer cake)
Each level of power remains supreme in its own jurisdiction (national and state are distinct)
State centered view
Dred Scott decision (1857) - slave viewed as property
Dual federal ended in 1930s
Cooperative/Shared (marble cake)
Solutions for state/local problems are directed and sometimes funded by both national and state governments.
Administration of programs characterized by shared power and shared responsibility and shared blame if they fail. No clear division of power.
Picket Fence (modified “organized” cooperative)
Ex: federal cannot build homes so they provide money to states to build homes
Why should the federal government spend money cooperatively?
National money to pay for national problems and set minimal standards
Spillover effect (event causes unintended side effects for others that are not directly involved)
The national government supports state and local governments with revenue (helps equalize resources)
Programs might be managed better by state and local agencies (attack national problems but minimize growth of federal agencies)
Cutthroat Competition & Race to the Bottom
Competitive Federalism:
Good side: states compete to attract business
Bad side: Cutthroat and race to bottom (when states lower things to attract people)
How does federal give out money?
Categorical Grants (strings attached) •
Medicaid is biggest
Program Grants
Narrow like categorical grants but limited to time periods for a specific issue
Block Grants (few or no strings attached)
What was New Federalism?
Revenue Sharing (national gives state/local money)
Formula Grant – Money allocated in a predetermined manner
Unfunded mandates?
When national tells state to do something unfunded but they will get penalized if they don’t do it.
Coercive Federalism
Categorical grants
Drinking age
Federal Highway Money = states needs to raise drinking age to 21 to prevent young deaths
Louisiana refused to raise drinking age so federal didn’t give them money