1/31
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a practice?
A practice is something people regularly do as part of everyday life or work. Practices are not just individual actions. They are shaped by shared meanings, materials and skills.
There are three main elements of a practice:
Meanings: The ideas, values, beliefs and symbols that give an activity meaning. For example, what an organization considers professional behaviour.
Materials: The physical objects, tools, technologies and spaces that people use when carrying out a practice. For example, computers, phones, uniforms or office spaces.
Skills: The knowledge and abilities people need to perform a practice. For example, communication, problem-solving or technical skills.
These three elements are connected. A practice only works when people bring together the right meanings, materials and skills. If one element changes, the practice itself can also change.
Practice theory
Practice theory looks at how people create and shape social life through their everyday activities. It focuses on what people actually do rather than only what they say, think or believe.
Practices are both created by society and help recreate society. For example, workplace routines are influenced by existing rules and expectations, but employees also reproduce or change those rules through their everyday actions.
An important concept is human agency, which means people's ability to make choices and influence or change the world around them. People are influenced by social structures, but they are not simply controlled by them.
Practice theory also emphasizes:
Embodiment: Our knowledge and social experiences become part of how we think, behave and use our bodies.
Materiality: Physical objects, technologies and spaces influence how people act.
Social structures: Existing rules, norms and expectations shape everyday practices.
When studying an organization, it is therefore important to understand what employees actually do in their daily work. Interviews can help, but observing their practices can also reveal things that people might not think to explain.
Connecting micro and macro levels: Coleman
Coleman's model helps explain how individual actions and larger social structures influence each other.
Macro-level conditions: Larger structures such as laws, policies, institutions and social norms influence what individuals can do.
Micro-level conditions: These are the situations and opportunities that individuals experience because of the larger structures around them.
Micro-level mechanisms: These describe how individuals act, make decisions and interact with others.
Micro-level outcomes: These are the results of individual actions.
Macro-level outcomes: When many individual actions come together, they can create larger social or organizational changes. This is called aggregation.
The important idea is that macro and micro levels are connected. Larger structures influence individual behaviour, but individual actions can also produce changes in larger structures.
For example, a government introduces a new policy (macro). Employees have to interpret and apply it in their daily work (micro). Their actions produce different results, which together influence how the policy works in practice (macro outcome).
Practice theory 1: Claude Lévi-Strauss – Structuralism
Structuralism is the idea that people's thoughts and actions are strongly shaped by the larger social and cultural structures they live in.
Lévi-Strauss argued that people do not always act as independently as they think. Their behaviour is influenced by existing cultural rules, traditions and ways of understanding the world.
Macro determines micro: Larger social structures influence individual thoughts and behaviour.
Human agency: People still have some ability to make choices, but their choices are limited by the structures around them.
Cultural norms: People often follow social rules without questioning them because they have become normal or taken for granted.
This can make people seem like what is sometimes called cultural dopes: people who follow cultural rules without being fully aware of how much those rules influence them.
Bricolage
Bricolage means creating something new by using whatever resources are already available.
Lévi-Strauss used the idea to describe how people solve problems by combining existing materials and knowledge rather than starting from scratch or following a perfect plan.
In organizations and entrepreneurship, bricolage means finding creative solutions despite limited resources.
For example, an organization might not have enough money to buy new equipment, so employees find new ways to use the materials and tools they already have.
The main idea is that people can still act creatively within existing social and material limitations.
Bricolage in environmental entrepreneurship
Environmental entrepreneurs use bricolage to create environmentally friendly products or services despite having limited resources. Instead of seeing a lack of resources as a reason to stop, they find new ways to use what is available.
There are several forms of bricolage:
Skills bricolage: Using personal experience, existing knowledge and self-taught skills to develop a business. This can also mean using interns or other people's abilities.
Network bricolage: Using existing relationships with friends, family, local people and other contacts to find support and resources.
Waste material bricolage: Turning waste into something useful or valuable by giving discarded materials a new purpose.
Marketing bricolage: Using customers, especially early customers, to promote new products and help create a market for environmentally friendly products.
The main idea is that creativity does not always require more resources. It often comes from using existing resources in different ways.
Effectuation vs. causation in entrepreneurship
Sarasvathy (2001) explains two different ways people approach decisions and develop new ideas: causation and effectuation.
Causation
Causation means starting with a clear goal and then finding the resources needed to achieve it. It is based on planning, prediction and choosing the best way to reach a specific result.
For example, someone wants to open a restaurant. They first decide what kind of restaurant they want, calculate the costs and then search for the money, employees and equipment needed.
Effectuation
Effectuation means starting with the resources you already have and using them to create possible new goals. Instead of planning everything in advance, people experiment, adapt and take advantage of opportunities as they appear.
For example, someone who enjoys cooking, has a small kitchen and knows many people might start selling homemade food. They see what is possible with the resources they already have and develop the business over time.
Causation and effectuation are not necessarily opposites. People can use both approaches depending on the situation. Causation is useful when goals and the future are relatively clear, while effectuation is useful when there is a lot of uncertainty.
Do-it-yourself: Standardized vs. local solutions
This example shows the difference between following an existing solution and creating something new based on a particular situation.
Standardized solution: Following instructions or an established method to solve a problem. For example, assembling IKEA furniture by following the instructions. The solution is already designed and can be used by many people.
Local solution: Creating a solution that fits a specific situation. It involves creativity, experimentation and using the resources available at that moment.
A standardized solution provides consistency, but it might not work in every situation. A local solution can be more flexible because it responds to the specific needs and conditions of the people involved.
This connects to bricolage and effectuation because both involve finding practical solutions instead of always relying on existing plans.
Practice theory 2: Pierre Bourdieu – Habitus
Bourdieu introduced the concept of habitus, which describes how social structures become part of the way people think, behave and understand the world.
People learn certain behaviours, values and expectations through their upbringing, education and social experiences. Over time, these become so familiar that they feel natural and automatic.
Micro embodies macro: Larger social structures become part of individuals through their experiences and everyday behaviour.
Taken-for-granted behaviour: People often follow social rules without consciously thinking about them.
Social and cultural capital: People's social backgrounds influence the knowledge, skills, relationships and behaviours they bring into different situations.
For example, university students might believe that the way they speak, dress or behave is simply their personal choice. However, many of these behaviours are influenced by the social groups and environments they have grown up in.
Habitus helps explain why people from different backgrounds may feel comfortable in some social environments but uncomfortable in others.
Field theory
Bourdieu's field theory explains how individuals and larger social structures influence each other.
A social field is a particular social environment where people interact and compete for resources, recognition and influence. Examples include education, politics, business and art.
Each field has its own rules, expectations and ideas about what is valuable.
People develop their habitus through their experiences in these fields. Their position in a field is influenced by the types of capital they possess, but their actions can also change their position over time.
For example, someone entering university might initially be unfamiliar with academic language and expectations. Through education and experience, they develop new knowledge and cultural capital, which allows them to participate more confidently.
The important idea is that social structures influence individuals, but individuals can also develop and change their position within those structures.
Blurring the boundaries between high culture and low culture
Bourdieu studied how social class influences people's cultural preferences and behaviour.
High culture traditionally refers to cultural activities associated with higher social status, such as opera, classical music and museums. These activities often involve formal behaviour and an expectation that people appreciate culture in a particular way.
Low culture traditionally refers to more popular forms of culture, such as festivals, popular music and entertainment. These activities are often more informal and encourage participation.
Bourdieu argued that people's cultural preferences are connected to their social background and cultural capital. What one group considers valuable or sophisticated may be different from what another group values.
The boundaries between high and low culture are not fixed. They can change over time as cultural practices and social expectations change.
Practice theory 3: Anthony Giddens – Structuration theory
Giddens developed structuration theory, which explains the ongoing relationship between social structures and human actions.
Unlike the idea that society completely determines how people behave, Giddens argues that people both follow and reproduce social structures through their everyday actions.
Structures enable action: Rules and resources make certain actions possible.
Structures constrain action: Rules and expectations can also limit what people are able to do.
Agency: People have the ability to act, make choices and influence existing structures.
Duality of structure: Structures influence people's actions, but people also reproduce or change those structures through their actions.
For example, an organization has rules about how employees should communicate. Employees follow these rules in their daily work, which keeps the existing system going. However, if employees begin communicating differently, they may gradually change the organization's usual practices.
This means that structures and actions continuously influence each other. Social structures are not completely fixed because people recreate them through everyday practices
The Third Way
The Third Way was a political approach that tried to modernize traditional social democracy by combining social goals with some market-based ideas.
It emphasized active citizenship, individual responsibility, social investment and adapting to globalization.
Its connection to Giddens is that it reflects the idea that individuals should have the ability to act and take responsibility, while institutions should provide the support and opportunities that make this possible.
The main connection is the idea of moving beyond a simple choice between state control and individual freedom. Society needs both supportive structures and active individuals.
Practice theory 4: Bruno Latour – Actor-Network Theory (ANT)
Latour developed Actor-Network Theory, which looks at how social life is created through relationships between different actors.
ANT argues that we should not only focus on human beings when explaining how things happen. Non-human things, such as technologies, objects and tools, can also influence what people do.
Actors: Anything that makes a difference to a situation can be considered an actor.
Actants: A term often used in ANT for both human and non-human participants in a network.
Networks: Different actors are connected through relationships, and their interactions shape what happens.
Agency: The ability to make a difference or influence an outcome is not limited to humans.
For example, when employees work together using digital technology, their actions are influenced by colleagues, computers, software, communication systems and organizational rules. All these elements help shape the way the work is performed.
ANT challenges the idea that society can be explained only through individuals or larger social structures. Instead, it focuses on the relationships between actors.
Sociomateriality – Wanda Orlikowski
Orlikowski developed the idea of sociomateriality, which explains that social life and material objects cannot always be separated.
People's actions are shaped by the technologies, tools and physical environments they use. At the same time, people give these materials meaning through how they use them.
For example, a smartphone is not just a physical object. It changes how people communicate, organize their work and interact with others. The way people use the phone also influences what the technology means in their everyday lives.
The main idea is that social and material elements are connected and should be understood together.
Difference between ANT and sociomateriality: ANT focuses on networks of relationships between human and non-human actors. Sociomateriality focuses on how the social and material are inseparably connected in everyday practices.
Actor-Network Theory: Basic assumptions
ANT has several important assumptions:
Anything that makes a difference to a situation can be considered an actor, including people, objects and technology.
Non-human actors must be included when explaining how social situations and organizational practices work.
The social world is not something separate that exists on its own. It is created through relationships between different actors.
Actors influence each other through their relationships, and these relationships can also change the actors themselves.
For example, introducing a new computer system into an organization does not simply add a new tool. It can change employees' responsibilities, communication, routines and relationships.
This shows that organizational practices are shaped by networks of both human and non-human actors.
Practice-based approach
A practice-based approach sees social and organizational life as something that is continuously created and recreated through everyday activities.
Instead of only studying formal rules, strategies or organizational structures, it looks at what people actually do in practice.
It highlights four important things:
Everyday activities: Organizations are created through the daily actions and interactions of people.
Human agency: People can influence and change the practices they are part of.
Materiality: Objects, technologies and physical spaces influence how practices happen.
Power and politics: Practices are not neutral. Some people have more influence than others, and different interests can shape how work is done.
The main idea is that organizations are not just structures or plans. They are continuously created through what people do every day.
Communities of Practice (CoP) – Lave and Wenger
Communities of Practice are groups of people who share an interest, profession or activity and learn from each other through regular interaction.
People develop knowledge by participating in a shared practice rather than only learning from books or formal teaching.
There are three main characteristics:
Domain: The shared area of knowledge or interest that brings people together.
Community: The relationships between members that allow them to communicate, exchange experiences and support each other.
Practice: The shared activities, knowledge, skills and methods that members develop together.
Situated learning
Situated learning means learning through participation in real activities and situations. People learn by observing others, trying things themselves and gradually becoming more experienced.
Lave and Wenger also use the idea of legitimate peripheral participation. This describes how newcomers begin with smaller or simpler tasks and gradually become more involved in the community as they gain knowledge and experience.
For example, a new social worker might first observe experienced colleagues, then take on smaller responsibilities and eventually become confident enough to handle more complex situations independently.
Communities of Practice are useful in organizations because they allow people to share knowledge that might otherwise remain separated between individuals or departments.
They can also help organizations improve their practices because employees learn from each other's experiences rather than relying only on formal instructions.
Reflection-in-action – Yanow and Tsoukas (2009)
Yanow and Tsoukas (2009) build on Donald Schön's work and explain how professionals think and learn while carrying out their everyday activities.
They distinguish between two forms of reflection.
Reflection-in-action and Reflection-on-action
Reflection-in-action
Reflection-in-action means thinking and reflecting while doing something. It happens when people notice something unexpected, try to understand the situation and adjust their actions in the moment.
For example, a social worker might notice that a client is uncomfortable during a conversation. The social worker changes their approach or asks different questions instead of continuing with the original plan.
The authors emphasize that this does not always involve stopping to think carefully. Much of it happens naturally through experience, interaction and responding to the situation
Reflection-on-action
Reflection-on-action means thinking back on something after it has happened. People look at what they did, why they acted in a particular way and what they could do differently next time.
For example, after meeting a client, a social worker might think about how the conversation went and whether another approach would have been more helpful
Surprise and improvisation
Yanow and Tsoukas emphasize that surprise is important because it can make people question their usual way of doing things.
When something unexpected happens, people may realize that their assumptions or usual methods do not fit the situation. They then have to make sense of what is happening and respond differently.
This often involves improvisation, which means adapting and finding a solution without having a complete plan in advance.
The main argument is that professional knowledge is not only about following rules or remembering theories. It also involves being able to respond to real situations, use experience and adjust actions as things happen.
Theory-laden observation: Seeing as – Wittgenstein
Theory-laden observation means that the way we observe and understand something is influenced by our existing knowledge, experiences, beliefs and assumptions.
We do not simply see the world exactly as it is. We interpret what we see based on what we already know and what we expect to find.
Wittgenstein's idea of seeing as helps explain this. The same thing can be understood in different ways depending on the perspective we use.
For example, a manager might see an employee arriving late as lazy or unmotivated. Another manager might understand the same behaviour as a sign that the employee is struggling with their workload.
The situation is the same, but the interpretation is different.
This is important in organizational research because researchers must be aware that their own assumptions influence what they notice, how they interpret situations and what conclusions they make.
Positionality
Positionality refers to the position a researcher has in relation to the people and situation being studied. It includes their background, experiences, values and social position.
For example, a researcher who has previously worked in social work may notice certain things when studying social workers that another researcher might overlook.
Reflexivity
Reflexivity means examining your own assumptions, beliefs, decisions and actions during the research process.
It involves questioning how your personal background and position influence the way you collect information, interpret observations and present your findings.
A useful way to remember the difference is:
Positionality: Who am I, and what influences the way I understand the world?
Reflexivity: How do these influences affect the way I conduct and interpret my research?
Reflexivity helps researchers avoid treating their own interpretations as objective facts.
Weick's Sensemaking Theory
Sensemaking is the process through which people try to understand situations, especially when something unexpected, confusing or uncertain happens.
Karl Weick argues that people create explanations to make sense of what is happening around them. These explanations help them decide how to act.
Sensemaking is particularly important in organizations because employees often have to make decisions without having complete information.
Retrospective: People often look back at events to understand what has happened.
Social: Sensemaking happens through conversations and interactions with others.
Ongoing: People's understanding is continuously changing as new information appears.
Plausibility: People often look for explanations that make sense rather than explanations that are necessarily completely accurate.
Enactment: People influence the situations they are trying to understand through their own actions. Enactment is particularly important. It means that people do not simply react to an existing environment. Their actions also help create the environment they later try to understand. For example, employees might believe that a new policy is difficult to implement. Their reactions and actions can make the implementation more difficult, which then reinforces their original belief.
The story of the soldiers and the wrong map
Weick uses a story about soldiers who become lost in the Alps during a snowstorm. They find a map, use it to regain their confidence and eventually find their way back.
Later, they discover that the map was actually of the Pyrenees, not the Alps.
The story illustrates that having an explanation or reference point can help people act, even when that explanation is not completely accurate.
The map gave the soldiers a way to understand their situation and move forward.
The important point is that sensemaking helps people create order when they feel lost or uncertain. Sometimes taking action and developing an explanation is more useful than waiting until everything is completely clear.
"How do I know what I think until I see what I say?"
This is one of Weick's famous ideas about sensemaking.
It means that people sometimes discover what they think by explaining a situation to themselves or to others.
For example, imagine that a CEO suddenly visits a department where they rarely go. An employee might assume that the CEO is there to discuss a reorganization. This explanation seems reasonable, so the employee accepts it and continues working.
Later, the employee hears that there has been a serious accident at the workplace. They now reinterpret the CEO's visit and create a new explanation.
The example shows that people continuously develop and change their understanding as new information becomes available.
Sensemaking and organizational change
Sensemaking is important during organizational change because employees need to understand what is happening, why things are changing and what the changes mean for their work.
If employees interpret a new policy differently, they may put it into practice in different ways. Therefore, organizational change is not only about introducing new rules. It is also about how people understand and respond to those rules.
Negotiation Space Model: Frontstage and Backstage
The Negotiation Space Model explains how people develop and negotiate solutions by moving between discussions and practical work.
It distinguishes between frontstage and backstage activities
Frontstage
The frontstage is where people communicate, discuss problems and share ideas with others. Objects, such as documents, models, diagrams and prototypes, can be used to make ideas visible and help people discuss different possibilities. For example, employees might present a new organizational plan to colleagues and discuss what should be changed.
Backstage
The backstage is where people work behind the scenes to develop, test and modify ideas. They might create prototypes, experiment with different solutions or make changes based on feedback from others. For example, employees might take feedback from a meeting and work together to develop a better version of the organizational plan.
Objects as negotiation tools
Objects play an important role because they help people communicate ideas that might otherwise be difficult to explain. For example, a prototype allows people to see and discuss a possible solution instead of only talking about it.
The process moves between frontstage and backstage:
People identify problems and discuss their concerns.
Ideas and objects are shared to make the problems easier to understand.
People work behind the scenes to develop or modify possible solutions.
New versions are presented and discussed.
The process continues until people develop a solution they can agree on.
The main idea is that solutions are not always created in one meeting or by one person. They develop through ongoing discussions, experimentation and cooperation.
Reflective Practice
Reflective practice is the ability to think critically about your own actions and experiences in order to learn and improve your future work. It is especially important for professionals because every situation is different. Reflecting helps people understand what worked, what did not work and how they could respond differently next time.
A common reflection model uses six stages:
Description: What happened? Describe the situation.
Feelings: What were you thinking and feeling at the time?
Evaluation: What went well and what did not go well?
Analysis: Why did the situation happen? What can you learn from it?
Conclusion: What could you have done differently?
Action plan: If the situation happens again, what will you do?
For example, a social worker might reflect on a difficult conversation with a client. They can examine how they reacted, whether their approach was helpful and what they could change in future conversations. Reflective practice supports continuous learning because professionals do not simply repeat the same actions. They use their experiences to improve their future practices.