1/63
wrongs and rights
what do laws identify
different behaviours and actions that are considered acceptable or unacceptable for individuals in the community
what can laws do
protect society and our safety, right to live free from discrimination, right to freedom of expression and movement
two main sources of law in Australia
statute law- parliament and common law- courts
statute law
law made by parliament, also known as Acts of parliament or legislation
bicameral parliament
parliament with two houses, two separate groups of people who together make laws
two houses in VIC parliament
Legislative assembly lower house and legislative council upper house
two houses in the commonwealth parliament
house of representatives and the senate
common law
laws made by judges through decisions made in cases
what are the three federal courts
high court, federal court and family court
main VIC courts
supreme court, county court and magistrates’ court
main role of courts
to resolve disputes
make laws as part of their determination of cases
remedy
any order made by a court designed to address a civil wrong or a breach, should provide a legal solution for the plaintiff for a breach of the civil law by the defendant
plaintiff
party who makes a legal claim against another party in court
damages
amount of money one party is ordered to pay to another party for loss or harm suffered, most common remedy
civil law
Area of law that defines rights and responsibilities of individuals, groups and organisations in society and regulates private disputes
Upholds rights by enabling a party who has suffered harm or loss bc of a breach of their rights to seek a remedy
Provides guidelines for acceptable behaviour- what’s right and wrong
Protects the rights of individuals
sue
take civil action against another person, claiming they infringed some legal right of the plaintiff
breach
breaking of or failure to fufill or comply with a duty or obligation
causation
direct relationship between one even and a second event, where event one was the reason event two happened
loss
economic or financial loss, property damage, personal injury, pain and suffering, loss of amenity
Limitation of actions
restriction on bringing a civil law claim after the allowed time
why is there a time limit in which a person can initiate a claim imposed
so disputes can be resolved efficiently and so that a defendent doesn’t have to be subjected to a claim a significant time after the alleged acts
Burden of proof
obligation of a party to prove a case, usually, rests with party who initiates the action.
standard of proof
degree or extent to which a case must be proven in court
civil disputes
a disagreement between two or more individuals or groups in which one individual or group makes a legal claim against another
aggrieved party
the person whose rights have been infringed and whom has suffered loss
class action
particular type of civil proceeding where seven or more people have claims against the same party
vicarious liability
when someone becomes responsible for the actions of another
situations in which person may be involved in wrongdoing
induced or encouraged it, aided abetted or produced wrongdoing and were in any way a party that conspired with others
accessorial liability
being involved in wrongdoing
duty of care
legal obligation to be cautious and careful, keeping other people in mind when doing anything that could cause harm to them
negligence
type of tort that involves a breach of a duty of care, causing loss or harm
to protect an individual’s rights to be safe from harm
tort
literally means wrong, something that interferes with a person’s legally produced interests
law of negligence also aims to do
establish legal principals when someone is owed a duty of care
allow parties to seek an appropriate remedy against those who breached duty of care
establish limitations for what remedies may be sought where there was a breach of conduct
when does someone owe a duty of care
risk of harm was foreseeable
risk was significant or insignificant
reasonable person in same circumstances would have taken precautions to eliminate risk
breach of duty of care
when a person doesn’t take all the care they should. Duty is breached when person fails to do what a reasonable person would have done
injury, loss or damage
physical, mental or damage to property, if it can be proved that they suffered injury, loss or damage even if it was minor
what’s a limitation period
time period within which a civil claim must be made
contributory negligence
defence that can be used by the defendant who alleges the plaintiff contributed to the harm caused by the defendant
defence 2- assumption of risk (volenti non fit injuria)
‘to a willing person injury is not done’ refers to a defence in which the defendant claims that the plaintiff accepted the damages of a known and understood risk, either expressly or by implication
waiver
when participating in a risky recreational activity, consumers sign a _____ stating that they accept responsibility for any injuries suffered while participating
compensatory damages
amount of money awarded to plaintiff for harm, injury or other losses suffered
special damages
damages to compensate for loss that can be accurately measured in monetary terms
general damages
damages to compensate for loss that cannot be accurately measured in monetary terms
aggravated damages
are awarded if defendant shows reckless disregard for plaintiffs’ feelings, court also looks at manner in which defendant infringed plaintiff’s rights
caps on damages
in VIC, ‘caps’ limit amount of damages that can be awarded for various damage types
defamation and what it seeks to do
tort that involves the action of damaging a person’s personal or professional reputation in the community through the communication of false and untrue statements or information
protect individuals against material or free speech that would harm their reputation
rights protected by defamation law
Right to be c reputation
right to have that reputation protected by placing limits on freedom of expression
right of people whose reputations have been harmed to seek affective and fair remedies
right to a quick and effective method of resolving a dispute in relation to defamation
elements required to establish liability for defamation
The statement is defamatory- not necessary to prove the defendant intended to hurt the plaintiff
The statement is untrue- plaintiff must prove defamatory statement is not true
The statement refers to the plaintiff- plaintiff was person referred to in the statement
The statement has been published by the defendant- done in private, if 3rd person reads/hears becomes defamatory
The publication caused, or is likely to cause serious harm-
Limitation of actions defamation
must be within one year of the publication of the defamatory statement
Defence one- Justification
When a statement is substantially true, like a minor detail was wrong, e.g., someone flashing a crowd of 60 people cannot claim defamation if the publication wrongly states exposure to a crowd of 64 people
Defences to a defamation claim
Justification
Contextual truth
Absolute Privilege
Publication of public document
fair report of proceedings of public concern
public interest
honest opinion
innocent dissemination
Defence two- Contextual truth
There are multiple parts of the story; the true parts are really bad and ruin your reputation but the false parts are harmless
er caused serious harm by biking into oncoming traffic intoxicated, but incorrectly states that they were not wearing a helmet
Absolute Privilege
Gives defendant complete immunity from being sued in certain situations, when they prove that the defamatory statements were published in the course of proceedings of parliamentary bodies
Defence four- Publication of public documents
if published statement was a fair copy of a public document, only if published for educational purposes
Defence five- Fair report of proceedings of public concern
defendant can argue the statement is a fair report of proceedings, and that the report was published for the publics information or educational purposes
e.g. Learned, professional, trade, sporting or recreational associations where membership or contractual issues are involved
Defence six- Public interest
aimed at protecting the publication of matters that concern an issue of public interest, defendant reasonably believed publication of matter was in public interest
factor to be considered: whether any other steps were taken to verify the information
Defence seven- Honest opinion
defendant may claim defamatory material is an expression of their honest opinion rather then a statement of fact
Defence eight- Innocent dissemination
protects people who may unknowingly distribute defamatory info, such as printing companies
didn’t know publication contained defamatory info
didn’t have an obligation to check for defamatory info
Injunction
remedy in the form of an order by a court to stop a person from doing something, often used to prevent further publication of defamatory material, or order them to print a retraction of the material
Impact on plaintiff if breach of defamation law
loss of reputation- loss of status
emotional impact of the defamatory material- may lead to mental distress and anxiety
loss of wages and livelihood- plaintiff may need to take time off of work bc of distress or anxiety
unemployment- person may lose business opportunities
Impact on defendant if breach of defamation
costs- occur when defendant has to defend a claim, pay plaintiff’s legal costs
need to sell assets- consequence of high damages, forced to sell to meet cost
public humiliation- consequence of the publicity of the claim, widely reported court proceedings