1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
1st Argument for the intellectual sense/eye of the mind
Argument 1: Our awareness of the number 1 could not come from the bodily senses:
if we come to know one through the bodily senses, then something in the bodily senses would be one
but nothing in the bodily senses is (truly) one
for every material object we percieve can be divided into parts/has parts
and nothing that can be divided or has parts is truly one
Thus, we do not come to know one through the bodily senses
if we do not come to know one through the bodily senses we do not know any number that way
for every other number gets its name for how many times it contains one
thus, we do not come to knoe any number through the bodily senses
thus, we see them by some other sense
2nd Argument for the intellectual sense/eye of the mind
Argument 2: our knowledge about the order or structure of the number system could not come from the bodily senses
However far any number is from the beginning, its double is, in turn, that far after it. Ex: 1 is 1 step from 0, and its double (2) is 1 step from it; 2 is 2 steps from 0, and its double (4) is 2 steps from it
We see/know that the order is expressed in 1 is (necessary and) true for all numbers
If we know this through the bodily senses, we must perceive all numbers through those senses
But no one perceives all numbers through the bodily senses (for there are infinitely many of them!)
Thus, we do not know this through the bodily senses
either we see/know it through the bodily senses or through the mind/reason/and inner light
thus, we see it through the mind/reason/ and inner light
3rd Argument for the intellectual sense/eye of the mind
Argument3: Evodius made this argument right as the discussion of the topic began
Whatever is perceived by the bodily senses has come to be and is perishable
But the mathematical truths, such as 7+3=10, have not come to be and are imperishable
Thus, we don’t perceive mathematical truths by the bodily senses
4th Argument for the intellectual sense/eye of the mind
Argument 4: Augustine makes this argument in his Confessions; so it’s not in the book
The bodily senses report color, sound, scent, taste, and feel
Mathematical truths numbers have none of these
Thus, bodily senses don’t report mathematical truths
Descartes Brief Bio
mathematician, scientific thinker, philosopher, soldier
made algebraic geometry possible
sine law of refraction, empirical account of rainbow, naturalistic account of formation of Earth/planets, shaped modern physics
argued humankind is immaterial but directly related to the brain (mind-body problem), argued for existence of God
father was lawyer, mother died when giving birth
Jesuit college
obtained a law degree but never practiced; instead became a soldier
had a dream that told him to set out to reform all knowledge
daughter named Francine; the mother was his housekeeper
Corresponded with Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia
accepted invitation to become Queen Christina of Sweden’s tutor but died in 1650
Descartes taxonomy of beliefs
Sensory beliefs:
Beliefs about the sensory world OR beliefs based on sensory input
Type 1: beliefs about the state of the world/whats happening in the sensory world. Ex: “I am sitting next to the fire.”
Type 2: beliefs about what exists in the sensory world. Ex: there are hands, there is shape, etc.
Non-sensory beliefs:
Beliefs not about the sensory world. Not based on sensory input.
Mathematical beliefs: arithmetic, geometiric
The Dream Argument
It is possible that I am dreaming
If 1, then I can’t be certain about my type one sensory beliefs
Thus, I can’t be certain about my type 1 sensory beliefs (only type 1 sensory beliefs are susceptible to doubt using the dream argument) (type 2 sensory beliefs/mathematical/nonsenory beliefs are not susceptible to the dream argument)
The Decieving God Argument
It is possible there is a supremely powerful and clever God who has directed his entire effort at deceiving you, by causing sensory images in me that correspond to nothing outside of me and by constructing me to have a strong intuition that certain mathematical beliefs are true but are, in fact, false.
if 1, then I can’t be certain about type 1 sensory beliefs, or even mathematical beliefs
Thus, I can’t be certain of T1 sensory beliefs, or my mathematical beliefs
The Argument that “I exist” can be known with certainty
The very act of trying to doubt that I exist proves that I exist
If 1, then it is possible to prove that I exist
Thus, “I exist” is undoubtable
The Argument that the only thing I can be certain about is that “I am a thinking thing.”
Doubting is a form of thinking
If doubting is a form of thinking, then any time someone tries to doubt they are a thinking thing, it proves they are a thinking thing,
If trying to doubt one is a thinking thing proves it, it’s impossible to doubt “I am a thinking thing.”
Thus, it is impossible to doubt “I am a thinking thing.”
The argument for the nonphysicality of the “I”
I can be known to exist with certainty
Physical things can’t be known to exist with certainty
Thus, I am not a physical thing
Descartes taxonomy of ideas
Innate ideas: ideas that are in your head (born with them). Ex: truth
adventitious/sensory ideas: ideas that are caused by something outside of you. Ex: sound someone else makes
Ideas created by me (imagining): ideas created by me (imagining). Ex: mermaids
Descartes theory of God
God is a supremely/infinitly perfect being.
Descartes theory of God
Either my idea of god is innate, adventitious, or produced by me.
If adventitious, then something in the sensory world is perfect
but there isn’t
so, it’s not adventitious
if it is made by me, I can add/subtract something from it
but i can do neither
so, its not made by me
so, the idea of god is innate
Descartes 1st Theory for God
The cause of my idea must be at least as perfect as the idea represents its object as being
My idea of god represents god as innately perfect
so, the idea of god represents god as innately perfect
if something innately perfect exists, then it is god
thus, god exists
Descartes 2nd theory of God: ontillogical argument
god is a supremely perfect being (a being with all perfections or great-making features)
Existence is a perfection
god has existence
Thus, god exists
Descartes argument that the mind is external to corporeal objects exist
(Argument from natural inclination:
I was created by god with an inclination to believe that mind external, corporeal objects, cause various sensations in me (and correspond to those sensations)
thus, if such objects did not exist, god would be a deciever
but god is not a deciever
thus, there must be mind external corporeal objects
Descartes argument that God cannot be a deciever
(Argument from Imperfection):
Deception is an imperfection (it’s a form of maliciousness and so not a great making feature)
So, if God were a deceiver, he would not be supremely perfect
but, god is a supremely perfect being
Thus, god is not a deceiver
Descartes 2nd arguent that one’s mind is distinct from one’s body
i. Conceivability argument:
it’s conceivable that one’s mind exists without one’s body
so, it’s possible that one’s mind exists without one’s body
if its possible that x exists without y, then x and y are distinct things (and x can exist without y)
Thus, one’s mind is distinct from one’s body (and can exist without it)
ii. Divisibility argument:
Corporeal things are divisible
minds are not divisible
Thus, minds are not corporeal things
Argument for 2:
It is impossible to conceive of a mind having parts
if 1, minds can’t have parts
if minds can’t have parts, they aren’t divisible
thus, minds are not divisible
Aristotles brief bio
plato’s Aristotle’s teacher
studied at Plato’s academy for 20-ish years
Founded his own school called the Lyceum
More technical/cold/scientific than Plato/Socrates
books on physics, biology, psychology, meteorology, etc. —> 1st to codify logic
teachers at Lyceum were Peripatetics
not very physically vigorous
was well to do/aristocratic
teacher to Alexander the Great
supposedly he wrote beautiful dialogues, but none exist today
was Macedonian (like Alexander)
Aristotle’s Theory of the Supreme Human Good
Happiness is the Supreme Human Good
Argument that Happiness is the Supreme Human Good
x is the SHG if and only if:
a. x is aimed at by everything that we do (universal aim condition)
b. x is desired in itself and
c. x is never desired for the sake of something else
d. x is such that (i) when isolated, it makes life worth living and (ii) lacking in nothing/complete (self-sufficiency condition)
Happiness meets conditions a-d and nothing else does
thus, happiness is the supreme human good
Aristotle’s critiques of different conceptions of Happiness in Different Types of Life:
Type of Person: most vulgar
Type of Life: life of enjoyment
View of Happiness: happiness = pleasure
Problems: this life and the concept of happiness involved are fit only for grazing animals, not for rational agents
Type of Person: more refined persons, active disposition
Type of Life: political life
View of Happiness: A. Happiness= Honor B. Happiness = virtue
Problems: happiness is something of our own; our having it doesn’t depend on others, but being honored does so depend. If happiness = virtue, then someone can be happy when he is asleep or suffering terrible misfortune. This is absurd. Further a virtuous person being tortured would be happy on this view.
Type of Person:?
Type of Life: contemplative life (philisophical)
View of Happiness:?
Problems: He says we’ll consider this more later
Type of Person:?
Type of Life: life of making money
View of Happiness: happiness = wealth
Problems: wealth cannot be happiness because happiness is valued in itself, but wealth isn’t. Not final good.
The Function Argument
Humans in roles have functions (carpenters, leatherworkers, etc.)
Parts of humans have functions (eyes, hands, feet, etc.)
So, (from 1 & 2) there is probably a human function (i.e., humans, qua humans, probably have a function)
the function of any x is the distinctive activity of x
the distinctive activity of humans is rational activity (both theoretical and practial/action oriented types.)
So, (from 4 & 5) the function of humans is rational activity
the highest good for any x is x performing it’s function well
thus, (from 6 & 7) the highest food for human beings is performing rational activity well
but happiness = the highest human good
thus, (from 8 & 9) happiness is performing rational activity well
Aristotle’s division of the Soul
Rational Part
Underlies our ability to think, e.g., to make judgements and draw inferences
Limited to humans
Intellectual virtues concern this part of the soul
Nonrational part:
A. Appetitive
source of impulses, emotions, desires
distributed to plants and animals
participants with reason that is— it can obey or disobey reason
virtues of character/moral virtues concern this part
B. Nutritive
cause of nutrition and growth
most widely distributed
does not participate with reason
no share in human excellence or virtue
Aristotle’s Division of the Virtues
Intellectual Virtues
A. theoretical/philiophical wisdom
Wisdom about facts of reality/the world (science)
comes about through instruction
B. Practical Wisdom
Wisdom about how to achieve results you want in the world
Moral Virtues
come about through habit or practice
state of character, intermediate states between two extremes
temperence, justice, courage
Aristotle’s Argument that virtues and vices are not by nature
What arises by nature cannot be changed by habit or practice
But a person can come to possess a virtue (or vice) that he once lacked
therefor, the moral virtues do not arise in us by nature
Thus, “we are adapted by nature to receive this and do so by habit.”
Aristotle’s division of character states and theoretical account of virtues and vices generally
vices: states of character that dispose one to feel or act deficiently
virtues: states of character that dispose one to feel or act neither excessively or deficiently, but in an intermediate kind of way
Aristotle’s taxonomy of states of character
dispositions to feel and act deficiently
dispositions to feel and act excessively
a. constitute the moral vices
b. these are blameworthy
c. bring possessors into a bad condition
d. forms of failure
e. are easy to attain bc theres many ways to fail
dispositions to feel and act in an intermediate way
a. constitute the moral virtues
b. these are praiseworthy
c. bring their possessors into good condition
d. are forms of success
e. hard to attain: 1. one way to succeed 2. hard to find/determine the intermediate
Table of Moral Virtues and Vices
Sphere of Action, excessive, intermediate, and deficient
fear, cowardice, courage, rashness/carelessness
pleasure/pain, licentiousness/self ignorance, temperance, insensibility
spending with respect to small sums, prodigality, liberality, meanness
spending with respect to large sums, vulgarity/tastelessness, magnificence, stinginess
self-worth, vanity, proper pride, undue humility
setting goals, hot-tempered, patience/good temper, lack of spirit/overmild
self-expression, boastfulness, truthfulness, hypermodesty
feelings with respect to the wealth of others, envy, righteous indignation, spite
conversation, bafoonery, witness, boorishness
social conduct, slavishness/suckpidness, friendliness, contensiousness
dealing with others, ?, justice, ?