1/147
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Etymology of theology
theos (God) + logia (speech about/study of), Greek
St. Anselm’s take on theology
“faith seeking understanding”
Dr. A’s take on theology
Creative, second order reflection on faith in the “good news” of God becoming human/incarnate as Jesus
1st order
Christians living their lives, on the ground experience
2nd order
Academic reflection, work with the experiences of others
Catechesis
Greek for “instruction”, being taught the faith, for converts or children being introduced to Christianity, a reception of religious information
Religious studies
Broader study of various religious studies, no insider status assumed
Theodicy
An attempt to justify God’s goodness in light of other’s suffering and evil
Copeland’s problem with Christian attempts to offer theodicies
She disagrees with the idea of assigning reason to suffering. To look for a justification ignores our agency to try and improve social suffering. Copeland believes that theology must recognize a stand in solidarity with those suffer so as to end this suffering, particularly social suffering. We shouldn’t just accept suffering. Action should be done.
Social suffering
What social oppression exacts from human persons, as individuals and as groups
Social oppression
Intentional and unintentional, socio-culturally reproduced choices, decisions, and actions that unjustly and selectively inflict harm on human persons
Copeland’s view on Jesus’ crucifixion, especially in relation to the instances of social suffering that oppressed peoples experience
“theology must work out the relation between the murderous crucifixion of Jesus of Nazareth and the murderous crucifixion of countless poor, excluded, and despised children, women, and men” The suffering of Jesus is the same as suffering, and through devotion to Jesus we are obligated to do something to uplift those who suffer as he did
Belser’s themes when describing her relationship with the “sacred” and the Bible
“Sacred” as something larger than yourself, “a time you felt a sense of wonder, a time you felt connected”, not readings/catechesis but a deeper connection to something you can’t clearly explain. She has a more fluid theology open to different interpretations and possibilities, and believes that religion should make room for difference and inspire us to question ourselves and the religion (“I won’t claim something I believe is right and true simply because the Bible tells me so”)
Does Belser think the Bible is important? If so, in what way?
Yes, she believes it’s massive impact on society cannot be ignored, but it’s words on disability causes her to question it and reflect. This work is important to her
Why does Belser seem to value being Jewish?
Being Jewish gives Belser connection to heritage, connection to something spiritual, and the argument and interpretation of religion is meaningful to her. She remains connected to her religious tradition while actively questioning, criticizing, and transforming how it is interpreted.
Pentateuch
The first five books of the Old Testament (the Torah)
The Documentary Hypothesis
Leading theory about authorship of the Pentateuch, predominant from 18th to 20th century, hypothesizes that the Pentateuch was written by authors J, E, P, D, and R
J
The Yahwist (950 BCE?), YHWH (Yahweh) used as personal name for god, translation is “the LORD” or “the LORD god”
E
The Elohist (850 BCE?), “God” = Elohim
P
The Priestly Writer (600 BCE?), “God” = Elohim
D
The Deuteronomist (500 BCE?), wrote the Deuteronomy, possibly contemporary of the Redactor
R
The Redactor (600-500 BCE?), editor of previous works, possibly contemporary of the Deuteronomist
What we know about authorship of Genesis
No claims to authorship until the Greco-Roman period, then Moses was the agreed upon author. Documentary Hypothesis emerges in 1800’s and now J, E, and P are thought to be the main authors (class focus on J and P). Oral tradition, then written down. For a long time, nobody thought it was factually accurate.
Major differences between J’s and P’s creation accounts, especially characterization of God.
P’s account is orderly and moralistic (assigns values to everything from the start), God is very transcendent and out of reach), while J has an anthropomorphized God (walking around) with a more personal and direct relationship with humanity. J’s story contains the original sin and judgements
P’s creation account
Light and darkness
Sky
Earth, sea, and plants
Sun, moon, and stars
Sea and sky animals
Land animals and humanity
Rest
Very “orderly” God, “good” established from the start, God is very transcendent
J’s creation account
“Man” = ‘adham, none of the animals are suitable partners, “woman” gets created from “man’s” rib, serpent gets woman to eat forbidden fruit, man eats next, judgement rendered; banished from garden. God has a more personal relationship with humans, and is anthropomorphized
Biblical fundamentalism
Taking the Bible “literally”, with little to no attention to literary genre or critical pushback, views Bible as directly from God and inerrant (without error and entirely binding to current times)
Catholic view of reading the Bible
Started with Vatican II in the 1960’s, God inspired the writing of the Bible, and human authors used imaginations and biases. What regards human salvation is important, and literary genres matter
Salvation
Fullness of relationship with God, the Bible is telling a love story between God and humanity, a “salvation history”, where creation (good) > sin > God trying to mend > Jesus
Misogynistic interpretation of J’s creation account
Women are temptresses
Classic Christian interpretation of J’s creation account
Problem is pride (original sin)
Progressive Christian interpretation of J’s creation account
It’s about them not believing in their inherent goodness
Enlightenment interpretation of J’s creation account
It’s about throwing off shackles of religion and becoming mature
Biblical hermeneutics
The discipline of interpreting complicated texts (one thought process is worlds around the text)
Word behind the text
Background, author’s possible intentions
World of the text
What’s on the page, the beats of the narrative, and the poetic images
World in front of the text
What the text means for us today (and what it has meant to people in the past)
Etiological story
AKA etiology, story about the origins of something
Patriarchy etymology
“pater” (father) + “arche” (rule/law), Greek
Patriarchy Greco-Roman definition
The legal custom of oldest male in the household controlling everybody else
Patriarchy modern definition
Anything that prioritizes male domination and female submission
Feminist theology
Exploration of how Christian tradition can support the full liberation of women and all people, centers on the dismantling of the patriarchy
Key elements of patriarchal interpretations of J’s creation account (especially misogynistic stereotypes of women)
Adam was created first, woman created from rib of man, woman are the “helpers”, Eve ate the fruit first (seen as weakness, but then also she tempts Adam?), judgements can seem to push for subjugation of women (their suffering during childbirth is punishment for original sin)
Trible’s understanding of ‘adham versus ‘ishshah and ‘ish
‘adham refers to the androgynous being, which is later slit into “ish” and “ishshah”
Trible’s understanding of “ezer” + “neged” as “helper”
Helper more in the sense of a partner than an assistant, on the same power level (versus God or the animals) Neged = counterpart
Trible’s understanding of characterization of woman
Woman characterized as far less passive and more active the story, while man is more submissive and displays stereotypically feminine qualities (meekness, obedience, lack of courage)
Trible’s understanding of God’s judgements
The judgements describe what’s wrong with the world and what should be resisted rather than what God intended
Revelation
God’s communication with humanity about salvation, the “word of God”, things we never would have known/been able to reach through reason that is only known because God reveals it to humanity. Revelation is IN the Bible, but the Bible itself isn’t Revelation. Christians would argue that Jesus IS Revelation.
Covenant
The relationship God establishes with Israelites/Hebrews (and the rest of humanity, ultimately), important difference between Christianity and Judaism as Christians believe that the most radical expression of the covenant is incarnation.
Traditional Jewish approach to Bible
God gave Moses (God’s “secretary”) the Torah
Typical Jewish approach to Bible
Only a few places are really directly from God (e.g., prophets claim to be direct messengers from God), otherwise, human authors (ex: Song of Songs by Solomon and Proverbs by some unknown person), while Orthodox Judaism is different, many Jews are fine with findings of modern Biblical scholarship and still think God was involved in the writing somehow
Christian (Catholic) approach to Bible
Vatican II: God “inspired” the writing, specifically what pertains to salvation. Gives leeway to care about the Bible and acknowledge historical influences/biases. Church leadership mediates meaning of the Bible
Salvation
Fullness of life with God (also after death)
Incarnation
God becoming human as Jesus
Muslim view of Qur’an
Qur’an = Revelation (exact word of God), THE central text, written in Arabic, hieratic, dictated by Gabriel to Muhammed for 23 years (609/610 to 632), Muhammed is a scribe.
Muslim approach to Bible
The Bible has pieces that are revealed by God to various messengers. Jesus is viewed as a great prophet, but the Bible isn’t to be trusted as it has been corrupted by Jews and Christians
Hieratic
Lofty and beautiful writing style
Key characterization of Moses based on Exodus 1-4
He is Hebrew but raised as Egyptian royalty (biculturality), kills Egyptians who beat Hebrews, snitched on by Hebrews (doesn’t fully belong to either world, justice drives him to killing, which may appeal to God here), strong moral compass, care extends to daughters of Midian priest, reluctant to be God’s messenger, scared and flawed (not traditional hero archetype)
Exodus 1-14: How is God’s behavior possibly troubling? What is God like, what passages reveal what God is like?
God is very violent, killing civilians and animals that aren’t directly causing suffering to the Jewish people. Petty and vengeful, hardens Pharaoh’s heart towards the end
Exodus 1-14: How is God’s behavior possibly positive? What is God like, what passages reveal what God is like?
Committed to liberation of his people, hardening of Pharaoh’s heart might be excusable because the Pharaoh had already willingly hardened his own heart several times
Tetragrammaton
The four letter name of God: YHWH, often rendered as Yahweh, God reveals the tetragrammaton to Moses, which is significant!
What is Pharaoh like, and what passages reveal what Pharaoh is like?
Cruel and petty, refuses to let the Jewish people celebrate a three-day festival, instead makes them work harder (suggests that God wasn’t out of line because Pharaoh would never relent), hardens his OWN heart three times first even as Egypt begins to suffer
Events inspiring Exodus?
1280-1250 BCE
1250-1200 BCE
Occupation of the land of Israel
1000-922 BCE
United monarchy with First Temple, King Solomon & King David
922 BCE
United monarchy falls due to infighting and fighting with neighbors of Israel
922-721 BCE
Kingdom of Israel/The Northern Kingdom/The North, capital = Samaria
721 BCE
The fall of the North to the Assyrians
922-587 BCE
Kingdom of Judah/The Southern Kingdom/The South, capital = Jerusalem, when language of “Jews” emerged
587 BCE
Fall of the South to Babylonians, temple destroyed
587-539 BCE
Babylonian Exile, Jews get taken to Babylon
539 BCE
Persians conquer Babylonians, Jews return to Judah
539 BCE - 70 CE
“Second Temple Period”, “post-exile”
64 BCE - 476 CE
Romans
70 CE
Romans destroy the Second Temple
Who is Amos?
Herder and farmer (tends fruit trees) from the Southern Kingdom (Judah)
Where does Amos prophesize?
The Northern Kingdom
Major features of Amos’ words as a prophet
Critique of human rights abuses of many different groups, criticizes performative faith without action against injustice, God’s covenant partners (Israel and Judah) can’t do whatever they want, they are also held to ethical standards (important that God cares about injustice against ALL groups)
With whom is God angry?
Damascus, Edom, Gaza, Ammonites, Tyre, Moab, Judah, and Israel
Why is God angry with Damascus?
“threshed Gilead”, destroyed crops (war crime)
Why is God angry with Edom?
Violence against Judah, breaking of treaty implied
Why is God angry with Gaza?
Exiled entire communities, slave trafficking, vulnerable people used for profit
Why is God angry with the Ammonites?
Killing of civilians, senseless graphic violence
Why is God angry with Tyre?
“Delivered entire communities over to Edom”, slave trafficking
Why is God angry with Moab?
Desecration of an important corpse
Why is God angry with Judah?
Vaguer critique of Judah for somehow being unfaithful (important as Amos is criticizing his own community)
Why is God angry with Israel?
Exploitation of the poor (huge gap between wealthy landowners and the poor farmers of Judah, Amos’ identity is relevant here), insincere religious activites, sexual violence implied
What is the relationship between acting ethically toward others and worshipping God (via intentionally “religious” activities such as attending festivals, going to the Temple, etc.)?
To God, acting ethically towards others = worshipping God. God HATES religious activities from people who do not pursue justice and instead actively benefit from systems of oppression. Drinking wine in the temple offends God because the wine is bought using wealth extracted from the poor
How exactly does King argue that working to end Jim Crow segregation is a matter of theological concern?
Segregation is not just a political issue, it is theological because it directly contradicts Christian ideals of justice, love, and community (segregation is morally WRONG and ruins Black lives)
The myth of time
The idea that social progress will happen naturally. King argues against this, some things need to be done NOW and you have to push against the status quo to achieve justice. African Americans have been waiting far too long already, and the myth of time undermines their continued suffering
The white moderate
Whites who claim they support equality yet prioritize the idea of social order over justice.” They know segregation is wrong but don’t DO anything about it, bystanders in the face of injustice because they fear “disorder” (which King argues is necessary in the pursuit of justice)
Extremism
Meant to be an insult, King takes it as a compliment. Argues that many good people were considered extremists (Amos referenced as an extremist in the pursuit of justice), the right kind of extremism is necessary to catalyze change
Violence and who is identified as violent
Civil rights activists are portrayed as violent for nonviolent protests, while segregation and white supremacists (KKK) are violent yet receive less attention
Law and order vs justice
Just because something is the law doesn’t mean it is just. Sometimes it is necessary to break the law when the law itself is unjust. King mentions Nazi Germany, while the Nazi’s followed the law, the law itself was morally wrong
Tanakh (TNK)
Jewish scripture:
T: Torah - law/instruction
N: Neri’im - prophets
K: Khetuvim - writings
Catholic Old Testament length vs other scriptures
Less than Greek Orthodox Bible but more than Jewish scripture and Protestant Old Testament
Catholic Old Testament contents
Pentateuch
Historical books - SOME of the prophets and writings
Wisdom books - some of the writings, contains “apocryphal” (“hidden things”) deuterocanonical (“second canon”) books
Prophets - positioned last to be prophesying about Jesus in New Testament
What important information do we glean from Job 1–2? Specifically, what is the exact wager, and is Job actually “innocent,” as he maintains?
Wager is to take away Job’s blessings and see if he will lose faith in God. Wager 1 – Satan argues that Job only worships God because he is fortunate and prosperous. God permits Satan to destroy Job’s wealth, etc. but not harm him. Wager 2 – Satan argues that Job will lose faith if he loses his physical health. God allows Satan to harm Job’s body but not kill him. Job IS innocent according to the Bible, his suffering is a result of the wager, not any wrongdoing of his own
Who is Satan in this book (Job), and what does he do?
“Frenemies” with God, here to test Job and throw things into chaos
Does Job curse God? What exactly is the nature of Job’s response to his suffering(especially once his friends start talking to him)? What exactly is he complaining about? What does he want?
Job does NOT curse God (cursing is very explicit language) but is complaining and angry with God (he curses his existence). Job wants recognition for his suffering and an explanation because he knows he didn’t do anything to deserve his suffering. He wants affirmation and the ability to express his pain.