1/30
crime & mental disorder
learning disability
•person with global impairment in intelligence that also impacts on functioning
•Arises during developmental period (in brain) and persists across lifespan
•1.5 million people in UK (80% mild or moderate)
•At increased risk of also having behavioural problems, neurological disorders & physical disabilities.
•Also: other neurodevelopmental disorders beyond general LD - specific learning difficulties eg. dyslexia & wider neurodivergence eg. autism spectrum, ADHD.
Different categories of LD according to IQ:
•50-69 (Mild)
•35-49 (Moderate)
•20-34 (Severe)
•Less than 20 (Profound)
why are links between LD & crime not clear: (Lindsay, 2002)
olot of people in long term care – no opportunity to offend.
oExcused responsibility due to labelling effect. Offence not reported.
oFiltering & diversion within CJS at every stage
LD & crime
•Higher proportion of mild-to-borderline LD in CJS
•Relative prevalence of sexual offending & arson (
•Majority of offences committed by LD offenders are less serious offences cf. gen pop
Drugs as predictor of crime
•Drug abuse significant predictor of general recidivism & violent recidivism
•Recidivists had more problems alcohol & drugs cf. non recidivists
•Odds ratio recidivism x 1.87 those reporting drug problems
•Those using drugs 4 weeks prior to custody had reoffending rate 62% cf. 30% who never used
•Lots of supporting correlational evidence – but direct causal links?
Fetishism
reliance on a non-living object/non-erotic body part as a stimulus for sexual arousal.
Exhibitionism
recurrent or persistent tendency to intentionally expose genitalia to non-consenting people.
Voyeurism
recurrent or persistent tendency to look at people naked, disrobing or engaging in sexual behaviour without consent.
Sadism/Masochism
preference for sexual activity that involves infliction of pain or humiliation (non-consensual/dysfunctional)
Paedophilia
sexual preference for prepubescent children
Neuroses
(~ 15% gen. pop)
–Emotional imbalance leading to distress
–Insight remains
–Eg. Anxiety, Depression, Phobias, Obsessive-Compulsive, PTSD
–Can usually be dealt with by GP (primary healthcare team in prison)
Psychoses
< 1% gen. pop.
–Distorted perceptions and irrational behaviour
–Thoughts/emotions so impaired that lose contact with reality/no insight
–Eg. Schizophrenia, Schizoaffective disorder, Bipolar disorder
–Often req a specific MH setting (forensic hospital for offenders)
Gender Differences in Prisoner Mental Health
•40% of women prisoners admitted to having received help for MH problems in the last year before imprisonment (double the proportion of male prisoners)
•26% of men and as many as 59% of women qualify as having a MI upon remand reception into prison
•26% of newly sentenced prisoners report symptoms of anxiety and depression
→ 49% of females
→ 23% of males
items in schizophrenia diagnosis in DSM-5
Delusions.
2. Hallucinations.
3. Disorganized speech (e.g. freq derailment or incoherence).
4. Grossly disorganized or catatonic behaviour.
5. Negative symptoms (i.e. diminished emotional expression or avolition).
At least 2 of the 5 symptoms must be present for at least 1 month. 1 of the 2 symptoms must be delusions, hallucinations, or disorganised speech
derailment
progression of speech that jumps around from one topic to another, the topics being only indirectly related or apparently unrelated.
catatonic behaviour
stupor, mutism, negativism, motor rigidity
avolition
reduced motivation to initiate activities
Before a PD diagnosis is made, a person must demonstrate signif & enduring difficulties in at least which 2 of 4 areas? (DSM)
•Distorted thinking patterns
•Problematic emotional responses
•Over- or under-regulated impulse control
•Interpersonal difficulties
In order to be diagnosed with a specific PD, a person must meet the minimum no. of criteria established for that disorder.
3 P’s of PD: (HMPPS/NHS, 2020)
–Problematic
•must have a signif -ve impact (impaired functioning/triggers distress in self/others).
– Persistent
•must have persisted over an extended period of time (since adolescence/early adulthood - not applicable to children).
– Pervading
•must be clinically signif (impairs no. of diff areas of daily functioning).
PDs & the research as far as gen pop is concerned…
•PDs are assoc w/ signif increased rates of mortality, substance use, unemployment, homelessness, relationship difficulties and self-harm
•PDs freq occur with other PDs and MI:
–people meeting criteria for 1 PD met the criteria for an average of 1.9 diff types of PD
–Comorbidity of PD and substance use disorders is common in clinical practice
DSM-5 PD clusters
A= Odd, eccentric
B= Dramatic/emotional/erratic
C= Anxious/fearful
DSM-5 PD cluster B
B= Dramatic/emotional/erratic
particularly linked to crime
Narcissistic- grandiosity
•Borderline- unstable emotions/relationships
•Histrionic- attention-seeking
•Antisocial- disregard rules/others (of special forensic interest)
Risk factors of ASPD (Farrington, 2005)
•Early impulsivity
•Low intelligence
•Poor parental supervision
•Harsh and erratic discipline
•Maltreatment by parents
•Parental conflict
•Lone mother
•Disrupted families
•Large families
•Low economic status
•Low commitment at school
•Poor educational attainment
•Antisocial parents
•Delinquent peers
(like a summary of causes of crime from previous lecture)
DSM- 5 criteria for ASPD
•Disregard for and violation of others' rights since age 15:
•Failure to obey laws and norms by engaging in behavior which results in criminal arrest, or would warrant criminal arrest
•Lying, deception, and manipulation, for profit or self-amusement
•Impulsive behavior
•Irritability and aggression, manifested as freq assaults others, or engages in fighting
•Blatantly disregards safety of self and others,
•A pattern of irresponsibility
•Lack of remorse for actions
(basically definition of crime)
Psychopathy: PCL-R→ interpersonal
•Glib with superficial charm
•Grandiose view of self worth
•Pathological Liar
•Cons and manipulates people
Psychopathy: PCL-R→ affective
•Remorseless/Guiltless
•Emotionally shallow
•Lacking in empathy and callous
•Denies responsibility for harmful things he/she does
Psychopathy: PCL-R→ Lifestyle
•Stimulation need and easily bored
•Impulsivity
•Irresponsibility
•Few realistic long-term goals
•Exploitive or parasitic lifestyle
Psychopathy: PCL-R→ antisocial
•Lacks good behavioural control
•Versatile in range of crimes committed
•Behaviour problems early in life
•Delinquency as juvenile
Early release from prison revoked
Psychopathy & crime
•Psychopathic offenders more likely to commit crimes generally
–PCLR >30, x3 recidivism (anything over 30 considered psychopath, PCLR scored out of 40)
•Start offending younger age, wider variety of offences
•Persistent offenders
–80% re-offend in 3 years cf. 25% non-psychopathic offenders
Psychopathic offenders- violence
•Commit greater proportion of violent crimes
–x4 violent recidivism
–x3 instrumental violence
–Hostile/reactive violence
–Revenge rather than self-defence
–Victims usually strangers
•Life-course persistent
–High rate of violence even after 40 yrs. old
•Sexual Offences
–Child molesters 10-15%, rapists 40-50% are psychopaths. Most mixed offenders. Sadistic rape (likely psychopaths)
–Sexual homicide
Link: Mental Disorder and Crime→ 3 research approaches
•Crime among MD
Small minority of MDs, but higher rates
•MD among offenders
Strong links incarceration
•MD as predictor offending
MI small relative contribution, especially schiz, more so psychopathy/ASPD & substance use