1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
democracy as a method
an arrangement in which leaders gain the power to decide through a competitive struggle for the peoples vote
Democracy according to Scmitter and Karl
system of governance in which rules are held accountable for their actions in the public realm by citizens, acting indirectly through the competition and cooperation of their elected representatives
what is accountability
answerability (rules must explain and justify they decisions in public), and consequences (citizens can sanction rules, above all by voting them out)
what accountability looks like at elections
power to remove a government
what accountability looks like between elections
free press, opposition parties questioning ministers, courts, and civil society lobbying and protesting
acting indirectly
in large states citizens choose representatives who decide on their behalf
acting in through competition
parties offer alternatives: real choices for citizens, and a reason for rulers to stay responsive
acting through cooperation
representatives compromise and build coalitions; citizens organize in parties, associations, and movements
Dahl’s procedural conditions for democracy
elected officials, free and fair elections, inclusive suffrage, right to run for office, freedom of expression, alternative sources of information, freedom of association
Schmitter’s and Karl’s additions to Dahl
elected officials can govern without being overridden by unelected actors such as military, the polity is self-governing and not controlled by an outside power
what democracy is not (necessarily)
more economically efficient, orderly, administratively efficient, stable
the democratic bargain
winners use power temporarily and don’t stop losers from competing and winning later; losers accept winners authority for now, for a fair chance to win later; citizens obey decisions as long as their basic rights are respected
bounded uncertainty
anyone might win, but the basic rules and rights are not at stake, so majors groups can afford to lose
democracy according to Dahl
an ideal system fully responsive to all its citizens. Not achievable
poliarchy
rule by the many. A real world approximation to democracy
two dimensions of democratization
public contestation, inclusiveness
four kinds of regime
competitive oligarchy, closed hegemony, polyarchy, inclusive hegemony
competitive oligarchy
High in contestation, low in inclusiveness. Real competition among a small elite
closed hegemony
low in contestation and inclusiveness. Few participate; no opposition allowed
polyarchy
high in contestation and inclusiveness. Wide participation and real competition
inclusive hegemony
low contestation, high inclusiveness. Mass participation; no real opposition
why polyarchy matters
liberties matter in themselves, political leaders change, more interests are represented, coercion becomes harder
democracy as as set of tension (Taylor)
freedom/equality, inclusion/exclusion, expertise/everyone, conflict/consensus
the appeal of consensus
radically inclusive, leaderless democracy, an alternative to a system seen as captured by the 1%
cost of consensus
slow meetings; a small minority could block; the most persistent dominated; few concrete demands
two sides of tension
democracy needs agreement but consensus has danger
agreements of democracy
shared rules, a sense of who we are, ability to decide, without it polarization and opponents as enemies
dangers of consensus
slow, lockable, dominated by the president; agreement can hide power; calls for civility can sideline dissent; progress often has been won through conflict
Taylot’s main idea
democracy needs both the freedom to disagree and the ability to decide and act together. Neither should swallow the other