1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Actus reus
a voluntary act or omission
that causes
a social harm
When does a person have a legal duty to act?
special status relationship
contractual obligation
creates the risk of harm
voluntary assumption of care- assumed care and did not allow anyone else to help the victim
statutory duty
Mens Rea
the guilty mind
Intent: Conscious object or Knowledge to a virtual certainty
Conscious object: did the defendant have the conscious object or purpose to cause a certain result (result crime; conscious objective to commit a crime) or to engage in certain prohibited conduct (conduct crimes) or
Knowledge to a virtual certainty: did the defendant know to a virtual certainty that their actions would cause the prohibited social harm (result crimes) or know to a virtual certainty that they were engaging in the prohibited conduct (conduct crimes)
Proving intent: direct evidence
rare, but is confessions, prior statements, testimony
Proving intent: circumstantial evidence
jurors can make inferences about a defendants mental state even if the defendant is disclaiming it.
natural and probable consequences: can infer if the natural and probable consequence of a voluntary act or omission is to produce the prohibited result
deadly weapon rule: for result crimes dealing with death or bodily harm, if a deadly weapon is directed at a vital part of the human body, jurors can infer the intent to kill or intent to cause serious bodily harm
proving knowledge
the defendant was aware of a material fact or correctly believed that the material fact exists
actual: positive knowledge
constructive: willful blindness
defendant subjectively believed in the high probability of the existence of a material fact and
took deliberate actions to avoid learning the facts
Strict Liability
punishes people for the acts or omissions alone, NO MENS REA REQUIRED
Morrisette factors for determining strict liability
New Crime
public welfare offenses (malum prohibitum)
the statute is aimed at protecting public health, safety, and welfare as opposed to infractions against specific people
vs. malum in se: moral wrongdoing
public welfare crimes often punish omissions stemming from a statutory duty
penalties: carry light/nonserious penalties
stigma: the perception of moral wrongdoing attached to a conviction is relatively low
specific intent
when the required mental state applies to some further act or additional consequence beyond the mental state required in concurrence with the voluntary act or omission
EX: burglary
case in chief defenses for specific intent crimes
voluntary intoxication- negates mens rea
mistake of fact- can negate mens rea
general intent
the required mental state applies only to the voluntary act or omission that causes a social harm
EX: battery
causation
only for results crimes
the prosecution must prove causation for results crimes and not conduct crimes
step 1 to prove causation
is the defendant an actual BUT FOR cause of the social harm? but for the defendants voluntary act or omission, the social harm would not have occurred