1/12
Vocabulary flashcards covering the components, statutory qualifying triggers, legal limits, and key case law related to the partial defence of loss of control.
Loss of Control (General Requirement)
The requirement that the defendant must experience a loss of control, which does not need to be sudden (Ahluwalia), while acts of revenge are not allowed and the defendant must actually lose control (R v Jewell (2014)).
Ahluwalia
Legal authority establishing that a loss of control does not need to be sudden.
R v Jewell (2014)
Case establishing that the defendant must actually lose control and that an act of revenge is not allowed.
S.55(3) Qualifying Trigger
A statutory qualifying trigger where the loss of control was caused by a fear of serious violence.
S.55(4) Qualifying Trigger
A statutory qualifying trigger caused by things done or said (or both) that constituted circumstances of extremely grave character and gave the defendant a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
Doughty (1986)
A case involving a crying baby used to demonstrate situations that are 'now out' under modern qualifying trigger rules.
S.55(5)
A statutory provision establishing that qualifying triggers can be a combination of both S.55(3) and S.55(4).
Justifiable Sense of Being Seriously Wronged
A two-part element under S.55(4) assessed by the court: having a 'justifiable sense' is evaluated objectively, whereas being 'seriously wronged' is evaluated subjectively.
Clinton, Parker, Evans (2012)
Case addressing the objective/subjective standards for being seriously wronged and ruling that sexual infidelity is excluded from qualifying triggers unless it is cumulative.
Sexual Infidelity Exclusion
A limitation on loss of control stating that sexual infidelity cannot constitute a qualifying trigger unless it is cumulative (Clinton; Dawes, Hatter, Bowyer (2013)).
Incitement Limitation
A restriction stating that a defendant cannot rely on loss of control if they intentionally incited the qualifying trigger under S.55(3) + (4) (Johnson; Dawes, Hatter, Bowyer (2013)).
Objective Tolerance Test
The requirement that a person of the defendant's age and sex, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint in the circumstances of the defendant, might have acted in the same or similar way.
R v Hill
Case establishing that a history of sexual abuse is relevant to the defendant's circumstances when applying the objective tolerance test.