1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Can MCS be designed using a one size fits all approach?
No! As their design is contingent upon various situational factors and these factors are interrelated and interact with each other to affect organisational outcomes.
What are the key contingent factors?
Environmental uncertainty
Technology
Organisational strategy
Organisational structure
Multinationality/ national culture
What is environmental uncertainty?
A broad set of factors making it difficult or impossible to predict the future ( e.g. political/ economic climate and technological pace).
What impact does a high environmental uncertainty have on action controls?
Difficult to use due to unpredictability, requires direct supervision, face to face meetings and intensive reaction reviews.
What impact does having a high environmental uncertainty have on result controls?
Challenging because employees struggle to forecast outcomes or set appropriate targets.
It often creates high information asymmetry, budgetary slack and forces employees to bear uncontrollable risks.
What are the 3 dimensions that make up technology?
Interdependencies
Task uncertainty
Complexity
How should the MCs be designed if there is low complexity/task uncertainty/complexity?
Formal MCS
High budget use and low budgetary slack
infrequent interactions
Narrow scope information
How should the MCs be designed if there is high complexity/task uncertainty/complexity?
formal MCS
frequent interactions
Broad scope information
What sort of MCs should large,decentralized structured firms have??
Show strong emphasis on formal MCS
Formal communication channels
Active budget participation
What sort of MCs should decentralised, uncertain firms have?
More complex integration
Direct contact between managers
Temporary task forces
Liaison roles
What is corporate strategy?
It is about where organisations compete.
Related diversification
Unrelated diversification
What is related diversification?
Exploits core business synergies, requiring elaborate planning/budgeting systems, transfer pricing, and bonuses linked to higher-level entities
Exploit economies of scope
What is unrelated diversification?
Pursue a portfolio of distinct businesses with high information asymmetry
Exploit internal capital market benefits
Relies heavily on financial result controls and financial targets due to high information asymmetry
What is business strategy?
It is about how an organisation competes. Balances innovation with efficiency
Cost leadership
Differentiation
What are Hofstede’s 4 cultural dimensions and do they directly influence MCS design?
Individualism: Favours individual rewards and performance evaluations over group structures
Power distance: High power distance accepts greater centralisation, less participation and greater supervisory subjectivity
Uncertainty Avoidance: Lowers the use of subjective performance evaluations
Masculinity: Favours relative performance evaluations and hard performance metrics
In highly uncertain environments is a centralised or decentralised structure preferred?
Decentralisation is preferred!! This is because local managers and operational units are closer to the ground and possess the specialised real time knowledge needed to respond quickly to changes.
Decentralisation alone isn’t enough! Integration is needed
Why is integration needed alongside decentralisation in uncertain environments?
Decentralisation creates separate decision making hubs so organisations must use complex integration mechanisms such as liaison roles, temporary task forces, frequent contact between managers and subordinates.
This is to ensure alignment and coordination between different teams and organisational goals