1/5
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Effective Altruism
use most effective and evidence-based strategies to benefit others
charitable giving is a large impact
personal preference is by emotional appeal instead of effectiveness
motivation obstacles: less effective charities because of emotional appeal. want to donate effectively but don’t know how. perceived subjectivity of giving.
identifiable victim effect: one named person > statistics
effective altruism movement: variation in effectiveness per dollar
“drop in the bucket” fallacy: pseudoinefficacy that tiny amount of donation doesn’t make a difference because look at proportion not amount of lives saved
effective altruism movement
charities vary enormously in value per dollar
WHAT charity matters more than how much you give
motivational influences on effective altruism
don’t care about cost-effectiveness because charities are personal appeal
don’t feel responsible or accountable for the effects of donations because they’re nonobligatory/supererogatory (unless sole helpers then they feel more obliged to be effective)
narrow affective motivation: giving driven by empathy/sympathy for victims = warm glow for providing good (personal connection/loyalty, narrow moral circle of social/biological/temporal, scope neglect of psychophysical numbing/statistics)
priority aversion: effective causes are large (many affected), neglected (little support), and tractable (achievable progress) so prioritizing seems unfair = split donations which has less impact
character/reputation benefit: dependent on if you give not how much, deliberation is less positive than just giving for empathy
epistemic influences on effective altruism
want to help effectively but don’t know how
avoid high admin costs so they think it is less effective but its the opposite = perverse incentives to cut overhead (motivational too because overhead reduces warm glow)
quantifiability skepticism: don’t think effectiveness can be measured and compared across causes but within is okay. Quality-Adjusted Life Years and Well-Being Years measure health interventions or compare charities across causes for cost-effectiveness analysis)
innumeracy: expects value and how much each donation can do
pseudinefficacy: “drop in the bucket”
underestimating variance in effectiveness
overestimate local appealing disaster-relief charities
Interventions to encourage effective altruism
information - epistemic: tell which re effective
defaults - motivational: effective option = default
incentives - motivational: matching funds/tax deductions
units - scope neglect
splitting - motivational: split with favorite and highly effective
philosophical reasoning: narrow moral circle
norm change - reputation/motivational: make effectiveness and public pledges the norm
affective altruism/narrow affective motivation
relating to feelings and emotions instead of evidence