1/38
Looks like no tags are added yet.
AR elements of rape s128(2)
penetration of genitalia by a penis
One of the parties involved doesn’t consent
MR elements of rape s128(2)
The accused does not believe that the other party consents; or
If the accused does believe in the other party’s consent, there are no reasonable grounds for that belief
AR elements of unlawful sexual connection
Sexual connection (as defined in s 2)
One of the parties does not consent
MR elements of unlawful sexual connection
The accused does not believe that the other party consents; or
If the accused does believe in the other party’s consent, there are no reasonable grounds for that belief
R v Everson
Continuation is sufficient, so a party is entitled to withdraw consent at any point in time: here where he was told to get off her twice before he did so.
R v Ennever
Mere contact is enough
Mouth means the cavity, mere contact with the lips (part of the face) is not enough
R v Karotu
Genetalia includes surgically constructed or reconstructed organ analogous to naturally occurring male or female genitalia (whether the person concerned is male, female or of indeterminate sex).
The Queen v Annas
consent must be voluntary and deliberate, and not coerced. Consent must be a function of the person’s free will.
R v M - consent in fact - AR
The essence of true consent is that it is freely given by a rational and sober person so situated as to be able to form a rational opinion upon the matter to which [they] consent.”
R v Brewer
“Submission to an authority figure in a markedly unequal power relationship” does not imply consent. - she was a minor
W v R
Defendant’s criminal actions made it “inappropriate to describe what she did as voluntary choice”, her only other option was “enduring an intensely humiliating experience” of blackmail
Henry v R
Previous consent cannot amount to future consent
Christian v R s128(1)
consent cannot be inferred from a simple failure to protest or resist by the complainant - s128A
R v Herbert s128(2)
while subjective fear means they do not consent in fact, the defendant might not have the mens rea:
R v Nixon s128(3)
No reasonable belief in consent if activity occurs when someone is asleep
R v Isherwood s128(4)
Intoxication: even if the complainant has agreed to something they would not have otherwise, they may still consent in fact
R v Kim s128(4)
The detail of evidence does not need to be necessarily high, there need not be verification on the extent of the intoxication
Howard - UK s128(5)
If they cannot comprehend what the activity was, they cannot understand the sexual nature of the activity or if they cannot appreciate their right to refuse.
R v Papadimitropoulos - AU s128(6)
Mistake as to the person, not the status of them.
R v Richardson s128(6)
Does not extend to qualifications or attributes.
R v Williams s128(7)
There must be a mistake as to the nature of the act, not the effect it will have
R v Devonald - UK s128(7)
Case involved a young man doing sexual things online for someone who was proclaiming to do something else. This was found to be a mistake as to the nature and quality of the act
HIV status impacts consent - R v Lee IF TRANSMITTED
Knowledge of the serious risk associated with sex triggers a duty to disclose; however, taking precautions may mean the risk is not necessary.
HIV status impacts consent - Filitonga v R IF TRANSMITTED
Could potentially be risking GBH; however, medical advances may mean it is not risked.
HIV status impacts consent - R v Mwai IF NOT TRANSMITTED
It may be criminal nuisance under s 145 for a breach of s 156. However, the law is not settled here. KSB v ACC extended the duty only in civil cases.
KSB v ACC
Exposed to HIV but not infected - couldn’t get free counselling via ACC unless she was the victim of more serious crime
R v Campos
Conviction for rape on the basis that the D had removed a condom and ejaculated inside a woman who had made it clear that her consent to sex was conditional on condom use.
The queen v JR
The Court of Appeal rejected the notion that there is a third mens rea element in s 128 – knowledge of the complainant’s identity
R v Clarke
Reasonable grounds are not to be located in the circumstances as the accused thought they were.
Cf R v Sturm
“the reasonableness of any belief in consent has to be judged in terms of what an accused understands the factual situation to be.”
R v Can
Defendant’s age might be material
R v Aylwin - indecent assault test
• The accused assaulted the complainant by the deliberate (intentional) application of force to the person of the complainant; and
• The assault occurred in circumstances of indecency in the sense that it would be so regarded by right-thinking members of the community generally.
• The accused intended or appreciated those aspects of the assault, and the surrounding circumstances, which render it indecent
R v Nazif
the word ‘indecent’ is to take its ordinary meaning and it is for the jury to decide whether it amounts to indecency.
R v Dunn
Indecency must always be judged “in light of the time, place and circumstance”.
Peters v Police HC Whangarei
Contemporary norms in what is indecent need to be considered - kisses, pats, strokes can be friendly.
AR elements for indecent assault
Assault (intentionally applies force to the body of another or threatens to and has or causes the person threatened to have reasonable grounds to believe that he has the ability to affect his purpose. Force not consented to by the victim.)
Element of indecency - assault is one which right minded people would consider indecent
MR elements for indecent assault
Mens rea for assault (intent to touch or threaten to touch, along with knowledge that the victim does not consent.)
Intent to do something “indecent” (ie intent to do the behaviour in the context that the jury find to be indecent. It is not necessary that the accused knew that it was indecent or had a sexual motivation.)
R v Aylwin vs R v Armstrong
R v Aylwin: must have intended both assault and the indecency component.
R v Armstrong: must have recognised that his actions would be regarded as indecent by right-thinking members of the community.
Conflicting approaches, discuss both.