1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Book, Market or "Target" Weights
- The optimal capital structure is the mix of debt, preferred stock, and common equity that maximizes the stock's intrinsic value.
+ As we will see, the capital structure that maximizes the intrinsic value also minimizes the WACC.
- According to most financial theorists, it is better to use market values than book values.
+ In this case, as is generally true, the market value of the debt was fairly close to its book value; so, for simplicity, we show the same dollars of debt in both the book and market columns.
+ Also, stock prices are quite volatile; so, if we use market values, then the weights used to calculate the WACC will also be volatile.
+ As a result, most firms focus on a target debt ratio range as opposed to a single number.
- Generally, a firm's CFO considers the capital structures of the firms against which it benchmarks and performs an analysis
+ The greater the difference between the stock's book value and market value, the greater the difference between the alternative WACCs for the book value (set by the company's benchmarks), market value and target value.
Capital Structure Changes Over Time
- Firms' actual capital structures change over time, and for two quite different reasons:
+ Deliberate actions: If a firm is not currently at its target, it may deliberately raise new money in a manner that moves the actual structure toward the target.
+ Market actions: The firm could incur high profits or losses that lead to significant changes in book value equity as shown on its balance sheet and to a decline in its stock price.
- Similarly, although the book value of its debt would probably not change, interest rate changes due to changes in the general level of rates and/or changes in the firm's default risk could cause significant changes in its debt's market value.
+ Such changes in the market value of the debt and/or equity could result in large changes in its measured capital structure.
- If the actual debt ratio has surpassed the target, a firm can sell a large stock issue and use the proceeds to retire debt.
+ Or, if the stock price has increased and pushed the debt ratio below the target, it can issue bonds and use the proceeds to repurchase stock.
+ And, of course, a firm can gradually move toward its target through its annual financings to support its capital budget.
Business Risk
- We examined risk from the viewpoint of the corporation, and we considered how capital budgeting decisions affect the firm's riskiness.
- Business risk is the single most important determinant of capital structure, and it represents the amount of risk that is inherent in the firm's operations even if it uses no debt financing.
+ A commonly used measure of business risk is the standard deviation of the firm's return on invested capital, or ROIC
- ROIC measures the after-tax return that the company provides for all of its investors.
+ Because ROIC does not vary with changes in capital structure, the standard deviation of ROIC (σROIC) measures the underlying risk of the firm before considering the effects of debt financing, thereby providing a good measure of business risk.
- The more uncertainty there is about future EBIT and thus ROIC, the greater the company's business risk.
+ Bigbee uses no debt, so its stockholders currently face only business risk.
+ However, if it issues debt, its stockholders would face the existing business risk plus some additional financial risk.
+ Further, a firm's business risk can change over time.
Factors that Affect Business Risk
- Competition.
+ If a firm has a monopoly on a necessary product, it will have little risk from competition and thus have stable sales and sales prices.
+ However, monopolistic firms' prices are often regulated, and they may not be able to raise prices enough to cover rising costs.
+ Still, other things held constant, less competition lowers business risk.
- Demand variability.
+ The more stable the demand for a firm's products, other things held constant, the lower its business risk.
- Sales price variability.
+ Firms whose products are sold in volatile markets are exposed to more business risk than firms whose output prices are stable, other things held constant.
- Input cost variability.
+ Firms whose input costs are uncertain have higher business risk.
- Product obsolescence.
+ Firms in high-tech industries depend on a constant stream of new products.
+ The faster its products become obsolete, the greater a firm's business risk.
- Foreign risk exposure.
+ Firms that generate a high percentage of their earnings overseas are subject to earnings declines due to exchange rate fluctuations.
+ They are also exposed to political risk.
- Regulatory risk and legal exposure.
+ Firms that operate in highly regulated industries such as financial services and utilities are subject to changes in the regulatory environment that may have a profound effect on the company's current and future profitability.
+ Other companies face significant legal exposure that could damage the company if they are forced to pay large settlements.
- The extent to which costs are fixed: operating leverage.
+ If a high percentage of its costs are fixed and thus do not decline when demand falls, this increases the firm's business risk.
+ This factor is called operating leverage
Operating Leverage
- Business risk depends in part on the extent to which a firm builds fixed costs into its operations—if fixed costs are high, even a small change in sales can lead to a large change in ROIC (more business risk).
+ To a large extent, operating leverage is determined by technology.
+ Higher fixed costs are generally associated with more highly automated, capital-intensive firms and industries.
+ However, businesses that employ highly skilled workers who must be retained and paid even during recessions also have relatively high fixed costs, as do firms with high product development costs, because the amortization of development costs is a fixed cost.
- We can calculate the break-even quantity by recognizing that operating-breakeven occurs when earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) = 0
- The concept of operating leverage was originally developed for use in capital budgeting. Mutually exclusive projects that involve alternative production methods for a given product often have different degrees of operating leverage and thus different break-even points and different degrees of risk.
+ Still, once a corporation's operating leverage has been established, this factor exerts a major influence on its capital structure decision.
Financial Risk
- Financial risk is the additional risk placed on the common stockholders as a result of the decision to finance with debt (financial leverage). Conceptually, stockholders face a certain amount of risk that is inherent in the firm's operations—this is its business risk
+ If a firm uses debt (financial leverage), this concentrates the business risk on common stockholders.
+ The debtholders will receive a fixed payment, and it will come before the stockholders receive anything.
+ Also, if the firm goes bankrupt, the debtholders must be paid off before the stockholders receive anything.
- As we mentioned earlier, changes in debt will not affect ROIC, but it will affect the proportion of risk borne by the firm's stockholders.
+ More specifically, changes in the use of debt would cause changes in earnings per share (EPS) as well as changes in risk—both would affect the stock price.
+ The higher the percentage of debt in the capital structure, the riskier the debt and, for that reason, the higher the interest rate lenders would charge.
+ Risk, as measured by the coefficient of variation of EPS, rises continuously and at an increasing rate as debt is substituted for equity (the declining number of shares outstanding as debt is substituted for equity).
- Assumes that Bigbee uses no debt.
+ Because debt is zero, interest is also zero; hence net income is equal to EBIT(1 - T).
+ ROIC is calculated as EBIT(1 - T) divided by invested capital. Bigbee's invested capital, which equals equity because it has no debt.
+ Net income is then divided by the equity to calculate ROE.
+ Note that Bigbee will receive a tax credit if net income is negative (when demand is terrible or poor).
+ Finally, because there is no debt, the percentages calculated in the ROIC column are identical to those in the ROE column
- Assume that the situation if Bigbee decides to use 50% debt and 50% equity
+ Neither sales nor operating costs will be affected—the EBIT, the EBIT(1 - T), and the ROIC columns are the same, whether Bigbee has zero debt or 50% debt.
+ The interest expense must be paid regardless of the state of the economy—if it is not paid, the company will be forced into bankruptcy, and stockholders will be wiped out.
+ Note that when debt is added to the firm's capital structure, ROE and ROIC are no longer equal.
- Typically, using debt increases the expected rate of return for an investment.
+ However, debt also increases risk to the common stockholders.
+ It demonstrates that using financial leverage increases the expected ROE but that it also flattens out the probability distribution, increases the probability of a large loss, and thus increases the risk borne by stockholders
+ These examples make it clear that using leverage has both positive and negative effects: Higher leverage increases expected EPS, but it also increases risk.
Determining the Optimal Capital Structure
- The optimal capital structure is the one that maximizes the price of the firm's stock, and this generally calls for a Debt/Capital ratio that is lower than the one that maximizes expected EPS.
- We know that stock prices are positively related to expected earnings but negatively related to higher risk.
+ Therefore, to the extent that higher debt levels raise expected EPS, financial leverage works to increase the stock price.
+ However, higher debt levels also increase the firm's risk, which raises the cost of equity and works to reduce the stock price.
+ So even though increasing the Debt/Capital ratio from 40% to 50% raises EPS, in our example, the higher EPS is more than offset by the corresponding increase in risk.
WACC and Capital Structure Changes
- Managers should set as the target capital structure the debt-equity mix that maximizes the firm's stock price.
+ However, it is difficult to estimate how a given change in the capital structure will affect the stock price.
+ As it turns out, the capital structure that maximizes the stock price also minimizes the WACC; and at times, it is easier to predict how a capital structure change will affect the WACC than the stock price.
+ Therefore, many managers use the estimated relationship between capital structure and the WACC to guide their capital structure decisions.
+ Note that an increase in the Debt/Capital ratio increases the costs of both debt and equity
+ Bondholders recognize that if a firm has a higher Debt/ Capital ratio, this increases the risk of financial distress, which leads to higher interest rates.
The Hamada Equation
- Increasing the debt ratio increases the risk that bondholders face and thus the cost of debt.
+ More debt also raises the risk borne by stockholders, which raises the cost of equity, rs. It is harder to quantify leverage's effects on the cost of equity, but a theoretical formula can help measure the effect.
- To begin, recall that a stock's beta is the relevant measure of risk for a diversified investor.
+ Moreover, beta increases with financial leverage.
- Here bL is the firm's current beta, which we now assume is based on the existence of some financial leverage, and bU is the firm's beta if the firm were debt-free, or unlevered.
+ If the firm were debt-free, its beta would depend entirely on its business risk and thus would be a measure of the firm's "basic business risk."
+ D/E is the measure of financial leverage as used in the Hamada equation, and T is the corporate tax rate.
- Now recall the CAPM version of the cost of equity
+ Note that beta is the only variable in the equity cost equation that is under management's control
+ The other two variables are determined by market forces that are beyond the firm's control but bL is determined by the firm's operating decisions, which as we saw earlier, affect its basic business risk, and by its capital structure decisions as reflected in its debt (or D/E) ratio.
- The beta used in CAPM model is bL
Capital Structure Theory
- Business risk is an important determinant of the optimal capital structure.
+ Moreover, firms in different industries have different business risks.
+ So we would expect capital structures to vary considerably across industries, and this is the case.
+ In addition, capital structures vary among firms within a given industry, which is a bit harder to explain.
+ What factors can explain these differences?
- Modern capital structure theory of Professors Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller (MM) proved, under a restrictive set of assumptions, that a firm's value should be unaffected by its capital structure.
+ Put another way, MM's results suggest that it does not matter how a firm finance its operations—hence, that capital structure is irrelevant.
+ However, the assumptions upon which MM's study was based are not realistic, so their results are questionable.
- Here is a partial listing of their assumptions: (1) There are no brokerage costs, (2) there are no taxes, (3) there are no bankruptcy costs, (4) investors can borrow at the same rate as corporations, (5) all investors have the same information as management about the firm's future investment opportunities and (6) EBIT is not affected by the use of debt.
- Despite the fact that some of these assumptions are unrealistic, MM's irrelevance result is extremely important.
+ By indicating the conditions under which capital structure is irrelevant, MM provided clues about what is required to make capital structure relevant and, therefore, to affect a firm's value.
The effect of taxes
- MM published a follow-up in 1963 that relaxed the assumption of no corporate taxes.
+ They recognized that the Tax Code allows corporations to deduct interest payments as an expense, but dividend payments to stockholders are not deductible - There are tax benefits associated with debt financing as they pay less tax after paying interest.
+ This differential treatment encourages corporations to use debt in their capital structures.
+ Indeed, MM demonstrated that if all their other assumptions hold, this differential treatment leads to an optimal capital structure of 100% debt.
- On balance, returns on common stocks are taxed at lower effective rates than returns on debt because this tax can be deferred until the stock is sold and the gain realized.
+ Additionally, if a stock is held until the owner dies, no capital gains tax must be paid
- As a result, Miller argued that investors are willing to accept relatively low before-tax returns on stocks as compared to the before-tax returns on bonds.
- As Miller pointed out, (1) the deductibility of interest favors the use of debt financing, but (2) the more favorable tax treatment of income from stocks lowers the required rates of return on stocks and thus favors the use of equity.
+ It is difficult to specify the net effect of these two factors.
+ However, most observers believe that interest deductibility has a stronger effect and hence that our tax system favors the corporate use of debt.
+ Still, that effect is certainly reduced by the lower taxes on stock income.
The Effect of Potential Bankruptcy
- MM's irrelevance results also depend on the assumption that firms don't go bankrupt and hence that bankruptcy costs are irrelevant. However, in practice, bankruptcy exists, and it can be quite costly.
+ Firms in bankruptcy have high legal and accounting expenses, and they have a hard time retaining customers, suppliers, and employees.
+ Moreover, bankruptcy often forces a firm to liquidate assets for less than they would be worth if the firm continued to operate.
- Note too that the threat of bankruptcy, not just bankruptcy per se, brings about other problems, if they become concerned about the firm's future
- Bankruptcy-related problems are likely to increase the more debt a firm has in its capital structure.
+ Therefore, bankruptcy costs discourage firms from pushing their use of debt to excessive levels.
+ Note too that bankruptcy-related costs have two components: (1) the probability of their occurrence and (2) the costs that will be incurred if financial distress arises.
+ A firm whose earnings are relatively volatile, all else equal, faces a greater chance of bankruptcy and thus should use less debt than a more stable firm.
+ This is consistent with our earlier point that firms with high operating leverage (and thus greater business risk) should limit their use of financial leverage.
Trade-Off Theory
- The preceding arguments led to the development of what is called "the trade-off theory of leverage."
+ This theory states that firms trade off the tax benefits of debt financing against problems caused by potential bankruptcy.
- The fact that interest paid is a deductible expense makes debt less expensive than common or preferred stock.
+ In effect, the government pays part of the cost of debt—or to put it another way, debt provides tax shelter benefits.
+ As a result, using more debt reduces taxes and thus allows more of the firm's operating income (EBIT) to flow through to investors.
+ This factor, on which MM focused, tends to raise the stock's price.
+ Indeed, under the assumptions of MM's original paper, the stock price would be maximized at 100% debt.
- In the real world, firms have target debt ratios that call for less than 100% debt to limit the adverse effects of potential bankruptcy.
- There is some threshold level of debt, labeled D1
+ Beyond D1, however, bankruptcy-related costs become increasingly important and they begin to offset the tax benefits of debt
+ In the range of D1 and D2, bankruptcy-related costs reduce but do not completely offset the tax benefits of debts, so the firm's stock price continues to rise (but at a decreasing rate) as its debt ratio increases.
+ However, beyond D2, bankruptcy-related costs exceed the tax benefits, so from this point on, increasing the debt ratio lowers the stock price
+ Therefore, D2 is the optimal capital structure, the one where the stock price is maximized
+ Of course, D1 and D2 vary from firm to firm depending on business risk and bankruptcy costs, and they can change for a given firm over time.
- Another disturbing aspect of capital structure theory is the fact that many large, successful firms use far less debt than the theory suggests.
+ This point led to the development of signaling theory
Signaling Theory
- MM assumed that everyone—investors and managers alike—has the same information about a firm's prospects. This is called symmetric information.
+ However, in fact, managers often have better information than outside investors.
+ This is called asymmetric information, and it has an important effect on the optimal capital structure.
- Therefore, we would expect a firm with very favorable prospects to avoid selling stock and instead raise any required new capital by using new debt, even if this moved its debt ratio beyond the target level.
+ If it sells stock, when profits from the new product start flowing in, the price of the stock will rise sharply, and purchasers of the new stock will make a bonanza.
+ The current stockholders (including the managers) also will do well, but not as well as they would have done if the company had not sold stock before the price increased.
+ In that case, they would not have had to share the benefits of the new product with the new stockholders.
- Therefore, a firm with unfavorable prospects would want to finance with stock, which would mean bringing in new investors to share the losses.
+ Firm will want to sell stock so that some of the adverse consequences will be borne by new investors.
- The conclusion from all this is that firms with extremely bright prospects prefer not to finance through new stock offerings, whereas firms with poor prospects do like to finance with outside equity.
- In a nutshell, the announcement of a stock offering is generally taken as a signal that the firm's prospects as seen by its management are not bright.
+ This, in turn, suggests that when a firm announces a new stock offering, more often than not, the price of its stock will decline.
+ Issuing stock emits a negative signal and thus tends to depress the stock price; so even if the company's prospects are bright, a firm should, in normal times, maintain a reserve borrowing capacity that can be used in the event that some especially good investment opportunity comes along.
+ This means that firms should, in normal times, use more equity and less debt than is suggested by the tax benefit/bankruptcy cost trade-off model.
Using Debt Financing to Constrain Managers
- Conflicts of interest may arise if managers and shareholders have different objectives.
+ Such conflicts are particularly likely when the firm has more cash than is needed to support its core operations.
+ Managers often use excess cash to finance their pet projects or for perquisites, all of which may do little to benefit stock prices.
+ By contrast, managers with more limited free cash flow are less able to make wasteful expenditures.
- Firms can reduce excess cash flow in a variety of ways.
+ One way is to funnel some of it back to shareholders through higher dividends or stock repurchases.
+ Another alternative is to tilt the target capital structure toward more debt in the hope that higher debt service requirements will force managers to become more disciplined.
+ If debt is not serviced as required, the firm will be forced into bankruptcy, in which case its managers would lose their jobs.
- A leveraged buyout (LBO) is a good way to reduce excess cash flow.
+ In an LBO, debt is used to finance the purchase of a high percentage of the company's shares.
+ As noted, high debt payments after the LBO force managers to conserve cash by eliminating unnecessary expenditures.
- Of course, increasing debt and reducing free cash flow has its downside: It increases the risk of bankruptcy.
+ Higher debt forces managers to be more careful with shareholders' money, but even well-run firms can face bankruptcy (get stabbed) if some event beyond their control occurs.
+ To complete the analogy, the capital structure decision comes down to deciding how big a dagger stockholders should use to keep managers in line.
Pecking Order Hypothesis
- Yet another factor that may influence capital structures is the idea that managers have a preferred pecking order when it comes to raising capital and that this pecking order affects capital structure decisions.
+ We know that firms often finance in the following order: Their first source of funds is accounts payable and accruals.
+ Retained earnings generated during the current year would be the next source.
+ Then, if the amount of retained earnings is not sufficient to cover capital requirements, firms issue debt.
+ Finally, and only as a last resort, they issue new common stock.
- First, no flotation costs are incurred to raise capital as spontaneous credit or retained earnings, and costs are relatively low when issuing new debt.
+ However, flotation costs for new stock issues are quite high, and the existence of asymmetric information/ signaling effects makes it even more undesirable to finance with new common stock.
+ So, the pecking order theory is logical, and it can influence a firm's capital structure, although there is still some debate about its relative importance.
Windows of Opportunity
- If a company's stock is selling for a price different than its intrinsic value, the company's managers can adjust the firm's capital structure to take advantage of this mispricing.
+ When a company's stock is overvalued (trading for more than its intrinsic value), its managers can take the opportunity to issue new equity at a time when its market value is relatively high.
+ Likewise, managers may choose to repurchase stock when the firm's stock is undervalued.
Financial flexibility
1/ Asset structure.
- Many companies also take their desired cash holdings into account when setting their target capital structure.
+ Holding other factors constant, firms that have more cash or other assets that are suitable as security for loans tend to use debt relatively heavily.
+ For this reason, some analysts also evaluate an alternative measure, net debt, which subtracts cash and equivalent securities from the company's total debt
2/ Control
- If management currently has voting control (more than 50% of the stock) but is not in a position to buy any more stock, it may choose debt for new financings.
+ On the other hand, management may decide to use equity if the firm's financial situation is so weak that the use of debt might subject it to serious risk of default.
+ If the firm goes into default, managers will probably lose their jobs.
+ However, if too little debt is used, management runs the risk of a takeover.
+ Thus, control considerations can lead to the use of debt or equity because the type of capital that best protects management varies from situation to situation.
3/ Management attitudes.
- Some managers tend to be relatively conservative and thus use less debt than an average firm in the industry, whereas aggressive managers use a relatively high percentage of debt in their quest for higher profits.
4/ Lender and rating agency attitudes.
- Regardless of a manager's analysis of the proper leverage factors for his or her firm, the attitudes of lenders and rating agencies frequently influence financial structure decisions.
5/ The firm's internal condition.
- A firm's own internal condition can also have a bearing on its target capital structure.
- The times-interest-earned (TIE) ratio gives an indication of how vulnerable the company is to financial distress. This ratio depends on three factors: (1) the percentage of debt, (2) the interest rate on the debt, and (3) the company's profitability.
+ Generally, low-leveraged companies have financed heavily with debt, have lower coverage ratios.
- Combining these thoughts gives rise to the goal of maintaining financial flexibility, which from an operational viewpoint means maintaining adequate "reserve borrowing capacity."
+ Determining the "adequate" reserve is based on judgment
Finding the Optimal Capital Structure
- The firm's optimal capital structure can be determined two ways:
+ Maximises stock price
+ Minimises WACC
1/ Estimate the cost of debt at different debt levels
- As debt ↑ -> default risk ↑ -> cost of debt ↑
2/ Estimate EPS at different debt levels
- EPS = [(EBIT - rd)(1 - T)] / Shares outstanding
- As debt ↑ -> EPS ↑ up to a certain extent and then start to fall
3/ Estimate rs = rRF + (rM - rRF)bL at different debt levels
- As debt ↑ -> financial risk ↑ -> bL ↑ -> rs ↑
- Hamada Equation: bL = bU [1 + (1 - T)(D/E)]
4/ Estimate P0= EPS/rs at different debt levels
5/ Optimal capital structure is the debt level that maximises stock price
- Optimal capital structure is the debt level that minimises WACC.