P3: Opacity and the Right to an Explanation

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/8

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

9 Terms

1
New cards

What happened in Loomis v. Wisconsin? On what grounds did Loomis appeal his sentence?

Eric Loomis received a longer sentence based partly on a high risk score from the COMPAS algorithm. He appealed on due process grounds, arguing he could not review or challenge the reasoning behind COMPAS's trade-secret formula.

2
New cards

What are the three sources of opacity in machine learning (Burrell, 2015)?

The three sources are intentional corporate/state secrecy, technical illiteracy of non-experts, and algorithmic complexity from high-dimensional machine learning models.

3
New cards

What is the CURB-65 pneumonia model? Why do doctors use it despite knowing it oversimplifies risk?

CURB-65 is a simple 5-factor scoring system for pneumonia mortality. Doctors rely on it because it is fully interpretable and transparent, unlike complex black-box algorithms.

4
New cards

What can we know about black box models, and what can't we know? How does Google's retinal neural network illustrate this?

We can know a black box model's inputs, outputs, and accuracy, but not how it links inputs to outputs. For instance, Google's AI accurately predicts sex from retinal scans, but researchers don't know which visual features it relies on.

5
New cards

What is Cynthia Rudin's argument against black box models? What is CORELS, and what does her result not show?

Rudin argues simple interpretable models match black-box accuracy in high-stakes fields, demonstrating this with CORELS (a simple recidivism predictor as accurate as COMPAS). However, her result does not prove simple models will match black boxes in every domain.

6
New cards

What is the Right to an Explanation Objection to opaque risk tools?

The objection holds that opaque risk tools deny defendants their right to understand decisions affecting their freedom, making their use morally wrong even if it reduces crime.

7
New cards

What two conditions must be met for people to have a moral right to something? What examples illustrate each?

A moral right must protect a crucial human interest (e.g., the right to life) and must not impose an overly burdensome obligation on others (e.g., demanding free weekend childcare).

8
New cards

What is informed self-advocacy? What are its three components?

Informed self-advocacy is the ability to defend one's interests and navigate institutions effectively. Its components are representation, agency, and accountability.

9
New cards

What is Boonin's Opaque Jury Argument? Which premise of the explanation objection does it target?

Boonin argues that if defendants lack a right to explanations for secret jury verdicts, they also lack a right to explanations for sentencing, targeting the premise that such a right exists.