1/33
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Pith and substance analysis
Used to determine which level of government has authority over a certain matter
Goal is to determine what the most basic purpose and effect of the law is, and then to determine the appropriate jurisdiction based on those characteristics
Interjurisdictional immunity (re Canadian Western Bank case)
Doctrine to protect exclusivity, within flexible federalism
Used to insulate the activities of one level of government from another
Flexible federalism
Allowing s. 91 and s.92 legislation to coexist, so long as the legislation does not encroach on the other jurisdiction’s core set of responsibilities
Federal paramountcy
When provincial law conflicts with a federal law, it will be rendered inoperative to the extent of the conflict
BNA Act (1867) s. 55
Refers to the process of granting Royal Assent to federal bills passed by the Canadian Parliament
BNA Act (1867) s. 56
Gives the British government the power to "disallow" (veto) any federal law passed by the Canadian Parliament within two years of the British Secretary of State receiving an authentic copy of the act
BNA Act (1867) s. 90
Extends several federal parliamentary powers and procedures down to the provincial level, including the appropriation and tax bills, and federal disallowance powers (feds can strike down provincial laws)
BNA Act (1867) s. 91
Powers of Parliament (key powers for this class):
The Public Debt and Property.
The Regulation of Trade and Commerce.
The raising of Money by any Mode or System of Taxation.
The borrowing of Money on the Public Credit.
Currency and Coinage.
Banking, Incorporation of Banks, and the Issue of Paper Money.
Savings Banks.
Bankruptcy and Insolvency.
Indians, and Lands reserved for the Indians.
BNA Act (1867) s. 92
Exclusive powers of provincial legislatures:
Direct Taxation within the Province in order to the raising of a Revenue for Provincial Purposes.
The borrowing of Money on the sole Credit of the Province.
The Management and Sale of the Public Lands belonging to the Province and of the Timber and Wood thereon.
Municipal Institutions in the Province.
Property and Civil Rights in the Province.
Generally all Matters of a merely local or private Nature in the Province.
BNA Act (1867) s. 93
Gives provinces exclusive power to make laws relating to education, while establishing constitutional protections for minority denominational and separate schools
BNA Act (1867) s. 94
Allows the federal government to create uniform laws regarding property, civil rights, and court procedures in ON, NS, NB, but not QC
BNA Act (1867) s. 95
Establishes concurrent legislative powers between the feds and provinces over two specific domains:
Agriculture
Immigration
Intra-vires
When a law is within the proper jurisdictional scope (e.g. feds pass a law regarding trade)
Ultra-vires
When a law is outside the proper jurisdictional scope (e.g. provinces pass a law regarding military spending)
Vertical tax competition
Occurs when a government acts to unilaterally increase its share of a tax base that is constitutionally assigned to multiple levels of government
5 competitive techniques in vertical tax competition (Gillis, 2025)
First occupancy
Two-step offers (national change in taxation, transfers to subnationals)
Nonconsenual tax relief (e.g. OMA and changes to physician corporate tax)
Litigation (constitutional or about the tax itself)
Political action
5 regulatory approaches to minimize vertical tax competition (Gillis, 2025)
Anti-discrimination rules (e.g. federal uniform taxation rules)
Supremacy rules (e.g. Canadian paramountcy doctrine)
The principle of federal loyalty
Constitutional caps and floors (maximum tax cap and/or minimum tax on national and subnational tax shares)
Constraints on conditional grants
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 91(1A)
The public debt and property
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 91(3)
The raising of money by any mode of system of taxation
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 91(4)
The borrowing of money on the public credit
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 92(2)
Direct taxation within the province in order to the raising of a revenue for provincial purposes
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 92(3)
The borrowing of money on the sole credit of the province
Constitution Act, 1867 ss. 92A(4)
Grants provincial legislatures the power to raise money through taxation regarding natural resources and electrical energy
Constitution Act, 1982 s.36
The government of Canada and the provinces are committed to:
a) promoting equal opportunities for the well-being of Canadians
b) furthering economic development to reduce disparity in opportunities
c) providing essential public services of reasonable quality to all Canadians
Parliament and the government of Canada are committed to the principle of making equalization payments to ensure that provincial governments have sufficient revenues to provide reasonbly comparable levels of public services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation
Horizontal fiscal imbalance
A fiscal imbalance across sub-national units (provinces)
Fiscal capacity
How much a province can raise at “x” tax rate by taxing “y” goods
Vertical fiscal imbalance
Fiscal imbalance between sub-nationals and federal government